Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say Lidl and Aldi are not cheaper or better quality than other supermarkets?

133 replies

WeetabixTowels · 04/08/2023 12:27

A Lidl has opened near me and so many people have said how good it is and how much cheaper it is to shop there. So I thought I’d give it a go.

I meal plan over 2 weeks and we generally eat the same things. So I went with my usual list - and spent £20 more than I do in Asda!

This was yesterday, and we ate chicken last night which was very gristly and then today I made the kids bacon sandwiches for breakfast - I had to bin the bacon as it was so fatty and shrivelled and grey it was revolting.

Comparing my receipt, I saw that

  • The only things that were cheaper than Asda were bakery items and biscuits/treats - but I don’t tend to buy a lot of either so made no massive difference
  • Fruit and veg were more expensive in Lidl
  • Meats were a little more expensive in Lidl
  • Frozen stuff was a lot more expensive and smaller quantities too so it won’t all last as long. We always have a movie and pizza night on Saturdays and I spent £3 per pizza whereas in Asda I can easily find them for £1.50 or cheaper
  • Cupboard things like olives are more expensive in Lidl
  • Toilet roll is cheaper in Lidl but honestly I wouldn’t buy it again, it’s like wiping my arse with a cheese grater

Now I will say that I bought 2 things I can’t get in Asda that were to die for and I would 100% make a trip to Lidl again for these - pickled garlic cloves and the Towergate digestives 🤤 amazing!

But have I done something wrong? I have officially failed at Lidl and I have no idea why 😂 was chatting to my cousin about this last night and she said the same happened in Aldi to her!

OP posts:
Cincinnatus · 04/08/2023 13:40

They might be cheaper but the quality is🤢

christmastreefarm · 04/08/2023 13:40

I have Sainsbury’s lidl and Iceland in walking distance and Aldi Morrisons Asda and Tesco a short drive.

I get 70% sainsburys. I get a few bits from lidl but find I cannot do a full shop and veg doesn't always last.

Iceland I find can be cheap for some frozen stuff but alot is takeaway stuff and expensive now. Fresh food is very expensive I think generally there.

Asda is good for a fortnightly cupboard shop. Again don't always think their meat is the best.

EhrlicheFrau · 04/08/2023 13:40

WeetabixTowels · 04/08/2023 13:31

I think the pickled garlic cloves were from a ‘foreign’ range (also bought some plantain thingmabobs) so I would go back for the odd thing - even though the queues seem to take about half an hour!

If it's not working for you as a main shop then maybe just check the leaflets online and pop in when there are specific things you want, unless of course it's really out of the way (we have a Lidl next to our other main supermarket in the bigger town, so it's not too much hassle to do both on the same shop). I have heard others say that Lidl and Aldi, while still a little cheaper overall on an average shop, aren't as comparatively cheap as they were. If we had an Asda or Sainsburys within 20 miles or so I'd definitely use those, as it is it would be a long and expensive journey. I routinely used Adsa where I lived before, and Sainsburys every now and then.

WeetabixTowels · 04/08/2023 13:31

I think the pickled garlic cloves were from a ‘foreign’ range (also bought some plantain thingmabobs) so I would go back for the odd thing - even though the queues seem to take about half an hour!

OP posts:
EhrlicheFrau · 04/08/2023 13:29

We have limited choice where I live - Lidl used to be a lot cheaper, now it's not that much cheaper (and probably a less pleasant overall shopping experience). I do like when they get some of the 'foreign' ranges in though, for something a bit different.

WeetabixTowels · 04/08/2023 12:34

@Grannyknowsbest Sainsbury’s is especially cheap if you use the shop and scan and have a Nectar card as there are loads of personalised offers. The Sainsburys own brand stuff is good quality too

OP posts:
User63847484848 · 04/08/2023 12:33

That’s interesting
my choice is between sainsburys and Lidl and I find Lidl much cheaper for things I buy like bags of nuts, own brand crisps, cereal etc. haven’t closely compared veg but think it’s cheaper at Lidl.

Grannyknowsbest · 04/08/2023 12:31

I find Sainsbury's the cheapest supermarket for quality and Value with M&S coming second.. it amazes me how many people think these two are expensive.. we have every supermarket there is in my city..so been to them all.
It's false economy if you don't like the food and end up throwing it away.