Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say Lidl and Aldi are not cheaper or better quality than other supermarkets?

133 replies

WeetabixTowels · 04/08/2023 12:27

A Lidl has opened near me and so many people have said how good it is and how much cheaper it is to shop there. So I thought I’d give it a go.

I meal plan over 2 weeks and we generally eat the same things. So I went with my usual list - and spent £20 more than I do in Asda!

This was yesterday, and we ate chicken last night which was very gristly and then today I made the kids bacon sandwiches for breakfast - I had to bin the bacon as it was so fatty and shrivelled and grey it was revolting.

Comparing my receipt, I saw that

  • The only things that were cheaper than Asda were bakery items and biscuits/treats - but I don’t tend to buy a lot of either so made no massive difference
  • Fruit and veg were more expensive in Lidl
  • Meats were a little more expensive in Lidl
  • Frozen stuff was a lot more expensive and smaller quantities too so it won’t all last as long. We always have a movie and pizza night on Saturdays and I spent £3 per pizza whereas in Asda I can easily find them for £1.50 or cheaper
  • Cupboard things like olives are more expensive in Lidl
  • Toilet roll is cheaper in Lidl but honestly I wouldn’t buy it again, it’s like wiping my arse with a cheese grater

Now I will say that I bought 2 things I can’t get in Asda that were to die for and I would 100% make a trip to Lidl again for these - pickled garlic cloves and the Towergate digestives 🤤 amazing!

But have I done something wrong? I have officially failed at Lidl and I have no idea why 😂 was chatting to my cousin about this last night and she said the same happened in Aldi to her!

OP posts:
wutheringkites · 04/08/2023 14:58

We do most of our shopping in Sainsbury’s. If you have a nectar card and are flexible about what you buy to maximise offers then I find them good value.

Quality of produce has taken an absolute nose dive in the past year though. I'm buying more and more fruit and veg at M&S

ObiKenobi · 04/08/2023 14:56

I shop in several supermarkets to get the best quality & value for money product. You constantly need to look around as everyone has their offers.

maddiemookins16mum · 04/08/2023 14:55

I now shop at Aldi. Just out of curiosity/boredom (and because DH was watching a Marvel film), I did a like for like ‘dummy shop’ at Tesco.
Aldi was £14 cheaper and I got more weight on the chicken thighs.

KatherineSwynford1403 · 04/08/2023 14:53

WeetabixTowels · 04/08/2023 13:31

I think the pickled garlic cloves were from a ‘foreign’ range (also bought some plantain thingmabobs) so I would go back for the odd thing - even though the queues seem to take about half an hour!

The thing with stuff like this is that it gets discontinued and it is so annoying.

SM4713 · 04/08/2023 14:52

Out of interest OP- how do you eat picked garlic? Just whole as a snack, on a cheese platter or some other way? I've always seen them in the jar and wondered what you do with them 🤔

If you have lidl app, and spent £250 in a month, the next shop is 10% off. I'm sure you end up spending much more though!

In both lidl/aldi/asda- you always need to check the dates. Too many times I've come home to find the item is best before the following day. I do like the lidl, grassfed beef though. Even the rump is tender and tasty.

ScribblingPixie · 04/08/2023 14:50

Aldi and Lidl used to be much cheaper than their competitors a few years ago but it's a much more mixed picture now. I'm lucky to be able to walk to five supermarkets and pick up from all - there isn't one where I'd buy everything.

Reugny · 04/08/2023 14:50

riotlady · 04/08/2023 14:39

Weekly shop in Lidl usually works out about £20 cheaper than Morrisons for me, find everything good quality except the meat (bakery stuff especially is lush)

Morrisons is damn expensive.

My nearest supermarket is now Lidl, followed in distance order by Asda, Sainsburys, M&S, Waitrose, Aldi, Tescos and Morrisons. Both Asda and Sainsburys sell niche products that the other ones don't tend to sell all the time. So depending what I'm buying I go to Lidl, Asda or Sainsburys.

Though with Sainsburys I have a tendency to drive to one further away simply so I can look at the clothes and homeware.

The problem with Lidl is their middle aisle - looks at latest pot plant.

megletthesecond · 04/08/2023 14:47

Yanbu. The fruit and veg in our aldi and lidl is awful. Yet again I forgot and bought some salad leaves. They were off 2 days before the best before date. I can't even take them back as it's not worth my time for £1.

OneMoreCookieMonster · 04/08/2023 14:43

I do a family shop every week plus tops at sainsburys. I think they are the best value and quality available. I get it delivered and pay something ridiculous like 40 quid a year for it. Such amazing value by the time you factor parking and petrol in. I spend approx £120 or less weekly for a family of four one being baby (nappies and formula) this includes my top up. We eat very healthy meals and don't buy alot of junk.

I get toilet roll, paper towel, fem hygiene products, laundry stuff, bleach, fairy washing up liquid, coffee, maple syrup and jams/spreads and any cans from Costco.

Have noticed cleaning products are getting stupidly expensive.

I occasionally get bits from m&s and waitrose. Find they can both be very good value but certain items are better quality and value. Depends if I'm hosting a dinner or if it's a special occasion.

BarnacleBeasley · 04/08/2023 14:40

I wouldn't use Aldi for a main shop, but it's good for things like wine (not the cheapest ones, but if you are spending, say, £5-7 a bottle, you'll get better quality than for the same money at other supermarkets. Their knock-off toiletries are often also good (you can tell what brand they're copying from the packaging design). I like their whole coffee beans - packets are smaller so not as much cheaper as they look, but still good. And their knock-off fancy muesli is better than the Dorset Cereals 'really nutty' one because it really is mostly nuts and not padded out with dates like the branded one. I'd also go in when they have merino wool thermals in the middle aisle. So basically, not great for a cheaper 'normal' shop, but if you are planning to buy posh stuff it can be cheaper from there.

riotlady · 04/08/2023 14:39

Weekly shop in Lidl usually works out about £20 cheaper than Morrisons for me, find everything good quality except the meat (bakery stuff especially is lush)

fullbloom87 · 04/08/2023 14:36

Grannyknowsbest · 04/08/2023 12:31

I find Sainsbury's the cheapest supermarket for quality and Value with M&S coming second.. it amazes me how many people think these two are expensive.. we have every supermarket there is in my city..so been to them all.
It's false economy if you don't like the food and end up throwing it away.

Sainsburys is incredibly expensive to shop for a family. Aldis have the nicest meat. Sainsburys gammon and pork was inedible. And to do a weeks shopping for a family at m&s you'd have to remortgage.

ClaraBourne · 04/08/2023 14:35

There used to be a website called MySuoermarket where you filled your trolley at the supermarket of your choice and it showed you how much it was elsewhere. Asda was always cheapest and Waitrose the most expensive.

It closed down and nothing had taken its place - unless somebody knows of anything,

We use Sainsbury's as there are certain things we really like we can't get elsewhere.

SistersNotCisters · 04/08/2023 14:35

My bestie is an Aldi fanatic. And I mean fanatic as in she will try and convert everyone from Tesco, Asda etc to shopping at Aldi. Staying at her house last week and I felt like I was in a sci-Fi episode where the characters are in an alternative Earth. Everything almost exactly the same but different. Nutella was Nutoka yet in the exact same packaging. Head and shoulders, Colgate, butter, jars and everything else was a mocked up named brand copy. And she insisted that it all tasted the same.

It didn't. Especially the Nescafe Azera rip off that didn't even come close.

She was most put out when all three of my kids picked their usual name stuff out on her blind taste tests 😂 and they struggled to eat (but did out of politeness) other things that were just horrible, like gristly meat, overly fatty bacon etc.

I shopped at Aldi a number of times but lost money. The fresh veg and fruit wilted and rotted quickly. The costs are pretty much the same and some of the Aldi alternatives weren't edible and got binned. And we had to do a Tesco top up for all the things we couldn't get at Aldi so it was pointless.

Bloody love that Middle Aisle of madness though.

tryingtodobetter1 · 04/08/2023 14:34

In my experience we spend less at aldi than at Sainsburys and get way more for our money as well. I have found the quality to be better than I expected as whenever I read these types of threads I see comments on how the quality is awful. We do go shopping at least twice a week though so aren't generally looking for things to have a long shelf life which would be a consideration for others.

TheDogsMother · 04/08/2023 14:33

I go to Lidl every couple of months for kidney/cannelini beans, chick peas, olives, cornichons, roasted red peppers, dried pasta, cleaning stuff. These things are definitely cheaper than the other supermarkets. Then I do a weekly online shop with Sainsburys.

Ylvamoon · 04/08/2023 14:31

I get my staples (pasta, rice & tinned stuff) from lidl.

We do like the odd thing from the bakery- love the low GI rolls & french stick!
But I agree, prices have gone up so much now that it's hardly any difference to other supermarkets.

I never buy any supermarket meat. To much water, to much fat and minimum animal standards.

APurpleSquirrel · 04/08/2023 14:30

I shop mostly is Aldi & Sainsbury's, with extras bits from Waitrose & M&S, occasionally Asda.
Aldi has definitely got more expensive, but if you're careful with what you buy, a lot of it is very good (tinned goods, deli meats, cheese, cleaning products etc).
A Lidl has just opened in our town & I thought I'd give it a try but found it didn't have half the choice of Aldi, let alone other supermarkets, so I'll only go in there for emergencies now.
Sainsbury's has got a bit better price-wise recently with their Aldi price match & Nectar prices.
However, we tend to buy all our meat from the local butcher's.

Begonne · 04/08/2023 14:29

Lidl and Aldi used to be substantially cheaper than the other supermarkets. It took a while for them to respond and drop their prices a bit. And I’m the meantime Aldi and Lidl got notions and started upping their game with posher sounding things to draw in the curious middle classes.

We’re overdue a new entrant in the supermarket wars to freshen up the competition.

unfor · 04/08/2023 14:27

This is interesting as I find Aldi much cheaper and the fruit and veg really good. I do tend to look for the British-grown stuff, perhaps that makes a difference? We rarely eat meat, but the cheese is very good quality and I like their frozen/smoked fish.

GigiAnnna · 04/08/2023 14:21

I find Lidl and Aldi a lot cheaper than most supermarkets and the quality is usually good but the meat can be a bit hit and miss. I got chicken thighs in Lidl the other week and they were absolutely disgusting. So I buy my meat from Asda, but overall I do save a lot on my bigger weekly shops from Aldi and Lidl.

Hufflepods · 04/08/2023 14:19

It’s an Aldi and an Asda near us, I find them comparable in pricing and then Tesco slightly higher so we do Ocado/M&S. It is more expensive but I find it’s less of a difference now vs a few years ago and the slight increase is worth it as the quality is so much better.

IMustDoMoreExercise · 04/08/2023 14:18

I like Tesco food and veg especially their broccoli and baby plum tomatoes.

AutumnalPumpkin · 04/08/2023 14:17

I used to regularly shop at Aldi and always found lidl was much more expensive.
I now only use Tesco, and find that it is much cheaper than ASDA but a family member that always uses ASDA thinks Tesco is much more expensive.
I think it massively depends on what you buy

unihornandrainhoes · 04/08/2023 14:17

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.