Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say Lidl and Aldi are not cheaper or better quality than other supermarkets?

133 replies

WeetabixTowels · 04/08/2023 12:27

A Lidl has opened near me and so many people have said how good it is and how much cheaper it is to shop there. So I thought I’d give it a go.

I meal plan over 2 weeks and we generally eat the same things. So I went with my usual list - and spent £20 more than I do in Asda!

This was yesterday, and we ate chicken last night which was very gristly and then today I made the kids bacon sandwiches for breakfast - I had to bin the bacon as it was so fatty and shrivelled and grey it was revolting.

Comparing my receipt, I saw that

  • The only things that were cheaper than Asda were bakery items and biscuits/treats - but I don’t tend to buy a lot of either so made no massive difference
  • Fruit and veg were more expensive in Lidl
  • Meats were a little more expensive in Lidl
  • Frozen stuff was a lot more expensive and smaller quantities too so it won’t all last as long. We always have a movie and pizza night on Saturdays and I spent £3 per pizza whereas in Asda I can easily find them for £1.50 or cheaper
  • Cupboard things like olives are more expensive in Lidl
  • Toilet roll is cheaper in Lidl but honestly I wouldn’t buy it again, it’s like wiping my arse with a cheese grater

Now I will say that I bought 2 things I can’t get in Asda that were to die for and I would 100% make a trip to Lidl again for these - pickled garlic cloves and the Towergate digestives 🤤 amazing!

But have I done something wrong? I have officially failed at Lidl and I have no idea why 😂 was chatting to my cousin about this last night and she said the same happened in Aldi to her!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ScribblingPixie · 05/08/2023 14:27

When you say M&S and Waitrose are on a par, do you actually mean budget wise, as they cost a fortune compared to anywhere else?

Have you seen the M&S value range - I think they might call it Remarksable? Chicken, eggs, bananas, broccoli, sardines in olive oil - basic stuff like that but good quality, at very good prices. It's worth checking out.

SheerLucks · 05/08/2023 09:25

I was a lifelong Waitrose shopper until I recently started trying Tescos, and have now been shopping in Lidl for three weeks.

I'm seriously impressed - their cereals, dishwasher tabs, cold meats and hummus are better than Waitrose IMO, and their fruit and veg, bread and cheese are almost as good.

Things not so good or just not available are pesto, anchovies, chorizo, breadsticks and coffee pods.

But the cost savings!! I used to spend about £130 in Waitrose and about £110 in Tesco's. In Lidl it's never more than about £75. It's a no brainier to me.

Inmydreams88 · 05/08/2023 00:00

I sometimes do a dummy shop and put my weekly shop into Aldi, Asda, Sainsbury’s and Tesco online and it’s always cheaper in Aldi.

I used to buy a lot of branded stuff but have switched to the Aldi version of nearly everything now, washing up liquid, hand soap, shampoo, cleaning spray, beans, pickle, tuna, toilet roll, soup. The only thing I have to buy branded is Heinz ketchup and Almond Breeze Almond milk. I really wish I liked the Aldi almond milk.

I think the fruit and veg is fine. I usually only buy enough fresh stuff for a few days and then go back for a top up midweek.

I’ll admit it’s not as well presented as somewhere like M&S but Aldi is the cheapest for us. Maybe the quality isn’t quite as good but it’s not that different that I’d be willing to pay 20p-£2 more per item. A blueberry is a blueberry at the end of the day and they both taste the same on my porridge in the morning.

Genuinely curious to see how people are saying M&S could be cheaper 👀

WhiteFire · 04/08/2023 22:58

My main shop is Sainsbury's, I've had a delivery pass for years and it is also the most convenient for popping into on my way home from work.

I am, however, a 'supermarket whore'. I prefer Aldi over Lidl and there are a few things we specifically get from Aldi. I will use Farmfoods, Iceland, Tesco, Asda, Morrisons , Home Bargains and even Ocado. The latter does incredibly good deals and if you aren't buying Quail eggs and suchlike it can be a perfectly reasonable shop.

The vast majority of my shop is branded, which is why I shop all over. I'm not particularly time rich but I can go to the majority of shops on my way home from work (albeit going slightly out of my way to do so)

Whippetlovely · 04/08/2023 22:37

Went to lidyl the other day and felt the same , the prices weren’t much different and as other posters have said the fruit never lasts,the toilet roll is cheap but is thin and is a false economy. I get asda delivery’s as they usually do next day slots but their fruit doesn’t last long either. If I actually go out to the shops I prefer Sainsbury’s their food is nicer and they do have decent offers. I also like to look in the clothes section as they’re clothes aren’t bad and often have good sales on.

Arrgghhdecisions · 04/08/2023 22:10

SheerLucks · 04/08/2023 22:01

When you say M&S and Waitrose are on a par, do you actually mean budget wise, as they cost a fortune compared to anywhere else?

M&S and Waitrose own brand stuff is incredibly competitive price wise. They just stock more "upmarket" things than some other supermarkets.
Tins and dried goods are so cheap in both!

Arrgghhdecisions · 04/08/2023 22:09

Yanbu

I ventured to Aldi last weekend in a bid to reduce my food spend. Spent about 20 quid more than I would at asds, and still had to go to asda for stuff I couldn't get. Also agree poorer quality. Which when they were charging pennies, was passable. But not now.
The only thing I will go for is nappies as they are the best non branded. But that's it, and tbh I'd rather spend the extra 3 quid on pampers and not have to deal with the chaos that is Aldi 🤣

SheerLucks · 04/08/2023 22:01

cocksstrideintheevening · 04/08/2023 13:42

The quality is shit and it's not cheaper anymore, maybe five years ago it was. M&S and waitrose are on par if you shop wisely,.

When you say M&S and Waitrose are on a par, do you actually mean budget wise, as they cost a fortune compared to anywhere else?

TimeFlysWhenYoureHavingRum · 04/08/2023 21:23

Also everything is going up due to global inflation - which is also worse in the UK due to Brexit.

TimeFlysWhenYoureHavingRum · 04/08/2023 21:19

Aldi and Lidl used to be significantly cheaper (before brexit) due to their buying power and free trade. Brexit has imposed new costs on their buisiness model so now they are obviouly the same as other UK retailers (bar a few ever changing loss leaders). It was all explained before the referendumb in 2016 but people voted for it.

Luxell934 · 04/08/2023 20:06

We usually shop at Aldi, but I have been noticing that Asda's Just essentials range is often cheaper than Aldi. We have been picking up lots of the Asda just essential stuff recently and can recommend lots of it (haven't tried the meat though) Flour, runny honey, blueberries, strawberries, pasta, rice, soup, chickpeas, chopped tomatoes, raspberries, kiwis, yogurts, chocolate mousses, peppers, pears, greek yogurt, garlic bread, grapes, orange juice and tortilla chips. All cheaper than Aldi and the quality is good in my opinion for the price.

For example

A tin of Chickpeas 400g
Aldi 55p
Asda just essentials 50p
Sainsburys 55p

Tomato Soup 400g
Asda Just essentials 57p (tastes like Heinz, my Husband didn't notice the difference)
Sainsburys 75p
Aldi 67p

Chocolate moussue 6x 60g
Aldi £1.09
Asda just essentials 86p
Sainsburys £1.09

Fresh Blueberries 125g
Asda Just essentials 99p
Aldi £1.59
Sainsburys £1.59

Fat free greek style yogurt 500g
Asda Just essentials 85p
Aldi 85p
Sainsburys £1.10

Penne pasta 500g
Asda Just esstenitals 41p
Aldi 41p
Sainsburys 75p

Hollyisblue · 04/08/2023 18:34

We use Iceland or the CoOp quite frequently. They are in walking distance. Or it's Sainsbugs for us. Aldi is near Screwfix so go there for variety.

Tlolljs · 04/08/2023 18:24

I honestly think it depends on your local store too. My local Lidl is awful dirty, fruit and veg really poor quality. Yet the one near my dil is so much better.
I find Morrisons very expensive, Asda ok. I’m a Sainsbury’s fan, have been for twenty odd years. Not the cheapest but definitely best quality.

stayathomer · 04/08/2023 18:22

Oh sorry forgot cooking oil- so much cheaper in lidl and Aldi!!!

stayathomer · 04/08/2023 18:20

I’d find Aldi much cheaper than Lidl, both much cheaper than other places especially for things like yoghurts, cereals, biscuits, cakes etc but we’ve had very bad luck with milk and meat and I don’t like the taste of a lot of their fruit. Interesting the voting is so against both!!!

WhatADrabCarpet · 04/08/2023 18:13

We use Lidl rarely now due to poor quality meat ( grey, gristly mince and water plumped chicken) and only go there to buy Formil, continental meats and low GI bread.

Their fruit and veg just doesn't last but Tesco's fruit and veg is ropey anyway.

Aldi and Lidl's range of herbs and spices is limited as well as store cupboard ingredients.

magnolia1997 · 04/08/2023 18:11

I don't usually go to Lidl but popped into one recently.

I only needed a couple of things and they were good and much cheaper than expected:

Tinned tuna for the cats (no complaints from them).
Own brand fabric softener - really pleased with it and will buy again.

Those little Portugese tarts from the bakery which were lush.

LizzieSiddal · 04/08/2023 18:11

I decided to try a new Lidl which opened near us. At first I was really impressed re price however I find the quality of fresh stuff awful. Fruit and veg may be cheaper but don’t last as long. I always buy organic meat and again the price was amazing, However when I opened it it looked disgusting, I nearly threw it away but thought that was wasteful, so cooked it but it was horrible, slimy and rubbery.
I’ve gone back to Waitrose where, you get great quality and if you watch what you put in your trolly, doesn’t have to be really expensive.
I do go to Lidl for mixed nuts and seeds, and olive oil, which are great.

WeetabixTowels · 04/08/2023 18:11

Thesearmsofmine · 04/08/2023 18:07

I spend about £100 a week on a family of 5 in Sainsburys. I think it just depends what you buy as to which supermarket will be cheapest for your family.

That’s my budget too for a family of four, and I’ve never had a problem meeting it in Asda our Sainsburys

OP posts:
TheReverendBeeb · 04/08/2023 18:09

I find the opposite - Aldi and Lidl always work out cheaper for us, but I don't buy meat or fish. Must be lucky because the veg I get is usually v tasty and lasts just as well as other supermarkets.

I am plant based and find them a lot cheaper for nuts, and soya milk as pp said. Also Aldi chickpeas are so plump and tasty - even prefer them to Napolina and are about 50p per tin.

Lidl now have their own organic tofu which is good. I find Sainsbury and Tesco better for vegan processed stuff, but tend to avoid it if I can.

Oh and most importantly Lidl chocolate is delicious.

Fizbosshoes · 04/08/2023 18:09

We recently went to Aldi and found the overall bill a lot cheaper than tesco (even with a clubcard) but I don't meal plan so can't say I bought exactly the same. However I was with DH which means I normally spend more and there was more alcohol in the trolley 🤣

Thesearmsofmine · 04/08/2023 18:07

Rathouse · 04/08/2023 17:53

How much do you spend on a food shop each week in Sainsburys? How many people? I find it the most expensive supermarket ever. Things like cheese and sausages are expensive from Sainsburys I find and just overall.

I spend about £100 a week on a family of 5 in Sainsburys. I think it just depends what you buy as to which supermarket will be cheapest for your family.

WeetabixTowels · 04/08/2023 18:07

Me and OH are big TGI Fridays fans (despite not having one nearby) and when I found out they were stocking TGI Fridays frozen food in Iceland I was so excited. I went down and spent, no joke, £24 on TGI Friday bits.

I can quite assure you the food in no way resembled the equivalent at TGI’s and I have held a grudge against Iceland since 🤣

OP posts:
ScallyWaggyWoo · 04/08/2023 18:03

Honestly you couldn’t pay me to shop there.

choices are shit
fruit / veg goes off really quickly
everyone in there bloody rude IME

i don’t think it’s much cheaper either. Just full of spurious rubbish I wouldn’t usually get.

Mrsfussypants1 · 04/08/2023 18:03

In my town we've got Asda, Sainsburys, Aldi, M&S and Iceland, and they are all within walkimg distance There's only Dh and I at home now and we don't do a big shop but I pick up bits from all but Iceland. I have my best buys/bargains that I pick up from each one. Meat and fruit/veg sainsburys. Steak, bread, Nordpak, loo roll Aldi etc.

Swipe left for the next trending thread