Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I have a right to know if my ex has a girlfriend!

182 replies

Laughro · 04/08/2023 10:37

To preface, my ex is extremely awkward, and always has been. He still holds a huge grudge about me splitting up with him 6 years ago, and is very combative towards me. Despite me trying to have a civil relationship with him and co-parent DS (8) as best I can, he takes every opportunity to express his bitterness, be rude to me and generally make life difficult. I've moved on with a new DP, successful business and a new baby on the way, while he is still in the same position he was 6 years ago, which he constantly weaponises and expects sympathy for. He constantly brings up the past in conversations and things that happened years ago. This extends to him always attempting to avoid and do as little of his parental responsibilities as possible, including never having our DS overnight since we split up.

Due to his behaviour, he does not have a great relationship with DS. He only sees DS every other weekend and sporadically in the holidays, but never overnight at his own place. He doesn't have a suitable place to have DS because he has lived in house shares with random people since we split up. On his weekends, DS and him do the same routine, and often end up spending hours sat in his car as my ex does not want to spend the money on day trips and again, doesn't have a suitable home environment to take DS. He's also very strict with DS, and doesn't understand his struggles with ASD and ADHD (despite me explaining them) so he constantly tells him to 'make eye contact and look at him' and belittles him for not being able to listen and follow instructions well. All in all, DS doesn't like his dad, expresses this often and says every weekend that he doesn't want to see him.

Last night, ex-DP announced he would be having DS overnight from October as he would be moving out of his house share and in with a friend. I asked who this friend was, and he said it was a woman called 'Anna'. I know of Anna, he met her on Tinder and had previously told me about dating her. I asked if that meant Anna was his girlfriend, to which he went on a texting rant about how I have no right to know if it is romantic or not, and I have double standards as I have introduced DS to ex partners, and essentially he did what he always does which is bring up things from years ago. I told him that I don't care who he is dating, all I care about are things that impact on DS, and as DS has never met Anna before, actually it is pertinent information if ex-DP is moving in with his girlfriend that DS has never met or heard about and they are expecting to launch DS straight into overnight stays with them both. I told him it's inappropriate for DS to be staying overnight frequently with someone he has never met, doesn't know, has never heard about and yes it makes a difference whether they are romantically involved or not (only from the perspective of DS, who I know will be confused and uncomfortable in this situation). I do not feel comfortable with DS staying overnight, given these circumstances, and the attitude of my ex-DP.

This morning I've had a huge text message paragraph about how unreasonable I am, being incredibly rude to me, and again bringing up things from years ago. AIBU to think I have a right to know this sort of information, in these circumstances, and my ex-DP is just once again being an idiot?

OP posts:
PoshPineapple · 04/08/2023 13:17

@x2boys

You know children have a right to see both parents ?
Its not up.to.the Op to let or not let her Ex see their son.

Who said anything about barring contact with him? If one of my DC was spending hours shut in a car with his Dad, thoroughly miserable and making noises about not wanting to go beforehand, I'd address that issue before worrying about anything else. How is that an appropriate day out for an 8 year old??

Rewis · 04/08/2023 13:14

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 04/08/2023 12:39

Some will be totally fine with 4yo sleeping in livignroom and some won't.

Oh come off it, no decent parent would be happy for their child to be sleeping on the sofa in the living room of a house shared with unrelated adults.

Well there are several pages of people claiming that op is stopping son from spending time with dad due to not allowing over nights. I feel like that's enough evidence to conclude that some would be ok with it 🤷🏼‍♀️

Moving12 · 04/08/2023 13:13

Moving12 · 04/08/2023 13:12

I get that OP and I’m not saying you’re wrong but you need to look at this objectively.

In the space of 2 YEARS, you have introduced a new man into your son’s life, moved in together & had a new baby; not just got pregnant but actually given birth -all in 2 years. That’s lightning fast from your son’s perspective so you’re not really in a position to judge your ex on doing things fast.

It is completely irrelevant to your son if you knew your partner for a year before introducing him. The point is how quickly your son’s life has changed in the space of the last 2 years.

Like I said, there is so much wrong with your ex & how he treats your son that I can’t believe the speed of his relationship is what you’re focusing on.

Sorry I re-read that your new baby is on the way & has not arrived yet but my point still stands.

Moving12 · 04/08/2023 13:12

Laughro · 04/08/2023 12:42

@Moving12 When I said ex-partners, I meant one ex-partner and my current DP. Ex-partner was introduced 5 years ago, then current DP was introduced 2 years ago (not including the year we had been together before the introduction. So my ex is referring to two people, one of which is pretty historic and we never had overnights or lived together. He only brings this up to be combative with me.

I get that OP and I’m not saying you’re wrong but you need to look at this objectively.

In the space of 2 YEARS, you have introduced a new man into your son’s life, moved in together & had a new baby; not just got pregnant but actually given birth -all in 2 years. That’s lightning fast from your son’s perspective so you’re not really in a position to judge your ex on doing things fast.

It is completely irrelevant to your son if you knew your partner for a year before introducing him. The point is how quickly your son’s life has changed in the space of the last 2 years.

Like I said, there is so much wrong with your ex & how he treats your son that I can’t believe the speed of his relationship is what you’re focusing on.

Royalbloo · 04/08/2023 13:07

Personally, and you can do whatever you'd like to do, I'd forget about the whole thing and see how he behaves/ what your son's experience is and then judge the impact on him.

I've had to come to the realisation that I cannot control anything my ex does and he isn't reasonable enough to even speak to me properly but when he f**ks stuff up (which he does occasionally) I hold him to account for that and get his to address the pact of whatever he has done with my DD. It's difficult but the only way for me.

BalletBob · 04/08/2023 13:06

I think you need to take a step back and reassess the whole situation. It seems like you’re focusing on entirely the wrong things.

Based on what you’ve written here, I’d be stopping contact and going to court. Your son is being abused by his father and this doesn’t seem to massively factor in your concerns. Being punished for having ASD and being forced to make eye contact, or berated for not doing so etc is appalling and will be hugely damaging your child. Making him sit in the car for hours because he has no safe place to take him - this isn’t OK. There’s an awful lot wrong here and the new girlfriend is the very least of it. The reason people are making the assumption that there’s some desire on your part to control your ex’s love life is because you have looked past an awful lot of damaging behaviour but are now concerned when there’s another woman on the scene.

I do agree with others that your own lifestyle will also have had a significant impact on your son. He is so, so young but has had at least 3 of your boyfriends introduced into his life and now a baby on the way. He hasn’t so far experienced a truly stable home life with either of his parents. With the added challenges he faces due to his ASD, his childhood this far must have been extremely difficult for him. It doesn’t sound like anyone is really putting his needs front and centre, and really trying to view his life through his eyes.

User1800 · 04/08/2023 13:04

Not sure what the right answer is tbh but I really feel for you and your predicament, you love your son and have to, by law, share him with someone who you don’t think will be thoughtful enough around your son, stuff of nightmares really 😐

Fupoffyagrasshole · 04/08/2023 13:04

none of your business tbh

Laughro · 04/08/2023 12:58

@MumblesParty 3 years in total I have been with DP. DS was made aware from around 6 months of us meeting that I had a boyfriend, so he certainly wasn't blindsided one random day. This progressed to meeting DP after I'd known him a year, we then moved in with one another a year after that, and recently found out we're expecting - it has been another year on from moving in together. I don't think that's an unreasonably fast timeline.

OP posts:
jay55 · 04/08/2023 12:57

I don't suppose Anna is too thrilled she's going to be sharing her home with a young boy she doesn't know either.

You'll have to manage your sons expectations the best you can. Knowing you're dealing with a total dickhead who can't see beyond his own nose.

Royalbloo · 04/08/2023 12:56

It's not your relationship to foster.

Laughro · 04/08/2023 12:54

To everyone questioning why I allow contact and why I don't just stop DS from seeing ex-DP, I have been down this road many, many times. I always try my best to foster a good relationship between the two of them and help ex-dp to understand DS's neurodiversity. It's impossible when you are dealing with someone who is totally unreasonable, ignorant, arrogant and yes, abusive.

I have explored the legal route before, and been told, in no uncertain terms, that I would be judged as stopping my ex-DP from having contact and it must be DS who expresses that he no longer wants to see him when he reaches an age where he is able to advocate properly for himself (around age 11). DS sadly does express quite often that he doesn't want to see him, and that he doesn't enjoy his time with him, but I'm helpless to do anything. It's not as simple as just stopping contact altogether.

OP posts:
MumblesParty · 04/08/2023 12:53

Laughro · 04/08/2023 12:42

@Moving12 When I said ex-partners, I meant one ex-partner and my current DP. Ex-partner was introduced 5 years ago, then current DP was introduced 2 years ago (not including the year we had been together before the introduction. So my ex is referring to two people, one of which is pretty historic and we never had overnights or lived together. He only brings this up to be combative with me.

So in the space of 5 years (starting just a year after you and DS’s Dad split up) , your DS has met 2 of your partners. And in the space of 2 years, one of these partners has gone from being a new face to being resident. And there’s a sibling on the way.
That seems a lot to adjust to for your DS. So yes, I do think there’s a bit of a double standard here.
I think it’s reasonable for you to know a bit about Anna, and what her involvement will be with your son, but ultimately this change seems like a good thing. Your son will be able to stay overnight, which should improve their relationship. And Anna might be a lovely addition to his life.

horseyhorsey17 · 04/08/2023 12:52

Sorry you're getting a load of grief about this - which is probably to do with the way your post is phrased, 'I have a right' just sounds quite confrontational.

I'd want to know who my child was staying with and whether that was likely to be an ongoing situation too. I don't think that's unreasonable at all.

However as the child of divorced parents who also spent a lot of time sitting in cars (while my dad cried about us not being close but was also too tight to pay for us to do anything), one of the things I became used to was being introduced to a different girlfriend roughly every four access visits or so. Eventually he married one but for some reason, he could never do those access visits on his own. Having a random woman there all the time was slightly better than the crying thing, anyway!

Laughro · 04/08/2023 12:49

@Pontiouspilate Very unfortunately, not. He has form for being able to put on a show of being a charming, lovely man who is down on his luck... Until the facade finally falls off.

OP posts:
Pontiouspilate · 04/08/2023 12:45

Did you know he was such a monumental cunt before you had a child with him?

ReleasetheCrackHen · 04/08/2023 12:43

pikkumyy77 · 04/08/2023 11:56

Why are people so hard of reading? The OP ‘s ex has form for ignoring his child’s needs and abusing child (the car sitting/hectoring) and for having poor judgment w/r/t potential harm from housemates and randoms. Asking who Anna is is a perfectly reasonable attempt to figure out what relationship this new random person has to ex so OP can figure out whether child is safe with them. Is she landlady? Roomate? Stranger? Gf? With an ex as unreliable and thoughtless as this guy Id want to know.

Are you joking? We already know that DS(8) is definitely not safe because his own father is abusive. It shouldn’t have to be two adults vs a small child before OP decides to protect her DS.

Laughro · 04/08/2023 12:42

@Moving12 When I said ex-partners, I meant one ex-partner and my current DP. Ex-partner was introduced 5 years ago, then current DP was introduced 2 years ago (not including the year we had been together before the introduction. So my ex is referring to two people, one of which is pretty historic and we never had overnights or lived together. He only brings this up to be combative with me.

OP posts:
Goldbar · 04/08/2023 12:41

Cucumber1234 · 04/08/2023 12:36

Your ex can't do anything right by your standards can he?!

You mean parenting responsibly and putting the DC's interests first?

Not a particularly high standard, this one.

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 04/08/2023 12:39

Some will be totally fine with 4yo sleeping in livignroom and some won't.

Oh come off it, no decent parent would be happy for their child to be sleeping on the sofa in the living room of a house shared with unrelated adults.

babyproblems · 04/08/2023 12:39

TomatoSandwiches · 04/08/2023 10:47

Why are you sending DS to see his dad when he refuses to acknowledge his additional needs, he sounds like a bully.
Does your DS even want to see him let alone overnight?

This

ReleasetheCrackHen · 04/08/2023 12:38

On his weekends, DS and him do the same routine, and often end up spending hours sat in his car as my ex does not want to spend the money on day trips and again, doesn't have a suitable home environment to take DS. He's also very strict with DS, and doesn't understand his struggles with ASD and ADHD (despite me explaining them) so he constantly tells him to 'make eye contact and look at him' and belittles him for not being able to listen and follow instructions well. All in all, DS doesn't like his dad, expresses this often and says every weekend that he doesn't want to see him.

This is all I needed to know to ask, why in the hell are you not taking legal steps to limit your ex to supervised contact? Your ex is literally verbally and emotionally abusing an 8yr old boy. You seem too concerned about whether he is fucking Anna. Your priorities are not where they should be.

Nanny0gg · 04/08/2023 12:38

OneTwoThreeShake · 04/08/2023 10:47

You neither have a right to know his relationship status or a right to refuse overnight contact.

Then she should go to court as the child isn't happy

Cucumber1234 · 04/08/2023 12:36

Your ex can't do anything right by your standards can he?!

BalletBob · 04/08/2023 12:34

NeverDropYourMooncup · 04/08/2023 11:38

She literally describes refusing permission for the boy to stay with his father. Ok, she claims she isn't - but then says outright that she has.

I am not stopping overnights - he has never had him overnight to stay. This is because he has lived in house shares for the last 6 years, which have been full of random blokes / women (at least 4+ at a time), and DS hasn't had his own bed or bedroom. DP has suggested DS staying overnight but it has meant DS being on the communal sofa in the living room of a house share - is this something you would allow for your child? Really?

No. You made a long list of false claims which are completely unsupported by anything that OP actually wrote.

The sentence you've quoted above is not evidence of OP attempting to alienate her child's father; it's evidence of her safeguarding her child. The reason the child doesn't stay with his father is not because OP is obstructive; it's because the father has failed to secure safe housing for his child.

Either your reading comprehension is very poor or you have an agenda. I imagine it's probably the latter and you have a deadbeat father for a partner/relative (or are one yourself) and are therefore invested in this narrative of "poor dad who is being kept away from his child", rather than holding this man accountable for his own abuse of his disabled child and failure to provide for him.

Swipe left for the next trending thread