Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Second child- am I being unreasonable for really wanting another one?

85 replies

Happyday122 · 04/08/2023 10:09

I will try to keep this short, we have tried for a couple of years to have a second kid, and it looks like we may need IVF. We always said we would not do IVF, we have a wonderful son, a very happy life as a family of 3, the only reason to do it would be my own burning desire to have another. DH is happy either way, one or two kids. Then I look at the state of the world and think maybe if it doesn't happen there is a reason for it not working. Are people with two kids always happier than people with 1?

AIBU- Of course not, it doesn't depend on family size on how happy you are
YANBU- More kids, more happiness

OP posts:
MrsTerryPratchett · 06/08/2023 22:57

Dombasle · 04/08/2023 10:21

Children are a blessing. Have another one if you and your husband want one and are in a living and happy relationship and can afford one.

Nothing else needs to be considered.

This is proper bollocks.

Mummytotheboy · 06/08/2023 22:53

WannaBeRecluse · 04/08/2023 10:17

There is no guarantee that siblings are best of friends, or have anything in common when older.

This! My partner and his brother hate each other and I dont use that word lightly. My partner says they have never got on. They have 1 thing in common which is hating each other.
I was an only child. I was never lonely, I went to lots of social things like Brownies, swimming, dancing. I always wanted a sibling but seeing my partner and his I'm glad I was an only child. The relationship I had with my parents was great.
We've got one child and are keeping it that way. We dont feel it's a bad decision mainly as I had a lovely childhood as an only child and my partner didn't due to not being!

MoonLion · 06/08/2023 22:53

I'm sure I'd have tried IVF if I'd been unable to have a child... but I don't think I would have if I hadn't been able to have a second (although it's hard to be sure). It's so personal though.

fourkid · 06/08/2023 22:47

Hi, I really think it is a personal thing. I think the biological urge was a massive factor for me, I just couldn’t shake wanting a third baby. Then we got twins! I’m in the thick of it now with 2/2/7/10! So just always worth considering- you might get two! Pros and cons come with one child or more than one child, sometimes that biological feeling can be more overwhelming than making a practical decision xx

Teaismymiddlename · 06/08/2023 22:41

I have one. He's now 12.

All my friends with two just say how much their kids argue all the time and how annoying it is

He goes to lots of clubs and has friends of all different ages

I just asked him for you if he ever gets lonely and he said that he loves being on his own. He gets quiet when he wants it and mates over when he needs company

Sometimes I worry as a lone parent that if anything happens to me he'll be very alone, but i have a sibling and we barely speak so that's really not a guarantee anyway

We are very very close with me just having the one

Dreamingofwalden · 06/08/2023 22:38

I was desperate to have a second child. We did not have IVF but did have some fertility treatments. Soon after the treatment I became pregnant with twins which was a huge shock. I had been desperate to have another child but going from 1 to 3 was very unexpected.
I truly love my boys and having experienced losses and unexplained infertility am very grateful to have three healthy children.

The jump from one to three was intense - financially, logistically and emotionally- for our eldest. I love our messy, noisy, chaotic life but it would definitely be a lot simpler if we had stuck with one. Just a different perspective for you to consider.

letloz · 06/08/2023 22:28

So hard to say as there's some bits that are better and some harder. I'd say for a while we were more miserable with two, as it was such hard work for the first year or so.. but thankfully that seems to have evened out now. But I wouldn't say we were more or less happy with two than we were with one. In general I don't think people are going to be less happy with one, unless, like you, they have a feeling there is something missing...

LillyLeaf · 06/08/2023 21:41

I have one via ivf and have decided to not try for more, lots of reasons but I think it's the right thing to do. Also Ivf was bloody expensive, not just the treatment but the drugs cost was insane. We spent easily over 20k. Luckily it worked, but we were very close to it not working. When do you stop if it's not working?

Happyday122 · 06/08/2023 21:34

Normalweirdo · 06/08/2023 18:31

If it helps I'm an only child that went on to have an only child by choice. I was never lonely and my parents' house is still full to this day; now with not just my friends but my daughter's friends. Our houses (mine and my parents) seem to be the hosting houses, the place everyone is welcome and there's always lots going on and full of love and laughter. Where everyone comes to relax or socialise.
When my dd was about 2 or 3yrs I did kind of panic. Everyone kept asking when I'd have another and suggesting I should. I'm sure hormones were raging through my body as biology tried to steer me to have more but it passed. I'm happy I resisted the hormonal urge and stuck at 1. I'm not saying it'll be the same for you but that is our reality and we're all very happy from grandparents through to teenage dd.

This sounds so fabulous! I love that :-)

OP posts:
Sunandsea26 · 06/08/2023 21:23

hmmmm this is a really tricky one.
I always wanted more than one, was never an option to not (if I was lucky enough).
struggled to conceive DD1, then fell pregnant when she was 8m old and had DD2, 17months apart. It has been HARD! They are 4.5 and 3 now I look at friends with 1 in envy, thinking how much easier, cheaper, less hectic, more freedom life must be. My two fight a lot but are the best of friends and tbh I don’t really know life with one as it was so long ago and she was so little when her sister came along.
however…. If I was in your position I definitely would have kept trying as it wasn’t an option to only have 1.
I just had no one telling me how bloody hard multiples are and kinda wish I had.

Loloj · 06/08/2023 21:16

Positives and negatives to both I’d say. We have one child and for a few years I was undecided about a second - I think looking back this was because of what is seen in society as the “norm” and I felt my child needed a sibling - that he would somehow be lonely without one. My partner wasn’t keen so it didn’t happen. I do sometimes feel guilty as most of his friends have siblings, however the other day he had the neighbours kids over to play (sisters) and as soon as they left he said “Mummy I’m so glad I don’t have a little sister - that would be so annoying”. He’s a happy well adjusted child without a sibling and we get more freedom by just having him. I don’t think more kids = more happiness. Life would certainly be more stressful with more than one!

Sittingonasale · 06/08/2023 20:57

I have 3.2 were planned.
Personally, I think having one is a lot more demanding in many ways.
My 3 have 2 years between them all and though they have their normal squabbles, I couldn't imagine them as only children.
Them being able to talk and play together takes some of the pressure off. Also, they are able to comfort each other and look after each other.
I've been ill a few times and they've worked together to make meals, clean up and just generally be there for each other when I couldn't be there for them.

My dad was an only child and he always resented it recalling how lonely he was.

User1367349 · 06/08/2023 20:49

Do some reading up on the benefits of being / having an only child - they are apparently happier and wealthier. Lots of families are making that choice.

IVF is really very hard work even without a 3 year old, so you need to be really really sure.

Samlewis96 · 06/08/2023 20:45

WannaBeRecluse · 04/08/2023 10:17

There is no guarantee that siblings are best of friends, or have anything in common when older.

This is true I have 2 girls 3yrs 2 mths apart. They have never got on. I had years if them fighting and arguing constantly to the stage it was virtually impossible taking them anywhere together. They are now 32 and 28 and have nothing to do with each other

ginandtonicwithlimes · 06/08/2023 19:18

Peony654 · 04/08/2023 10:11

It’s far from black and white, no one else’s happiness or not can predict yours. In your situation I’d personally be concerned about the physical and emotional impact of you having IVF, on your son. It’s so intense.

Many couples have had IVF for a sibling and it hasn't affected the existing child. If it does then you should be considering if you are telling them too much. Many people don't find IVF difficult.

Couldntthinkofausername24 · 06/08/2023 18:57

@Happyday122 I was in the same situation as you this time last year. We have a wonderful 3 year old and I always wanted another and my husband was always on the fence. We decided sod it and have another. I'm now 6 months pregnant and I honestly feel we made the best decision.

You will never regret having a second but you may regret not having another

It's so crappy at the moment isn't it. Cost of living crisis etc but there is never a right time. I'm 36 and feeling a bit on the older side

I wish you best of luck what ever you decide
Xx

Private1980 · 06/08/2023 18:41

I'll be honest I get on well with on of my sibling but not at all with the other I have 5 kids all diffrent ages 25,24,17,12 and 9 the eldest 2 are close but it's hit and miss with the others haha. But if I'm honest the harder you try for a baby the harder it is to conceive its supposed to be fun trying not a battle with your sanity every month not to see your period and being heartbroken when you get it I've been there. In the end I set a target we would just carry on as normal if it happened in 2 years then yay if it didn't then I'd go back to contraception. Good luck x

Normalweirdo · 06/08/2023 18:31

If it helps I'm an only child that went on to have an only child by choice. I was never lonely and my parents' house is still full to this day; now with not just my friends but my daughter's friends. Our houses (mine and my parents) seem to be the hosting houses, the place everyone is welcome and there's always lots going on and full of love and laughter. Where everyone comes to relax or socialise.
When my dd was about 2 or 3yrs I did kind of panic. Everyone kept asking when I'd have another and suggesting I should. I'm sure hormones were raging through my body as biology tried to steer me to have more but it passed. I'm happy I resisted the hormonal urge and stuck at 1. I'm not saying it'll be the same for you but that is our reality and we're all very happy from grandparents through to teenage dd.

jodes88 · 06/08/2023 18:18

I think it's all.abput personal choice. We have one Daughter who is 9 and are more than happy with just one. We spend loads of time with her but she is also very self sufficient she has lots of friends and is a little social butterfly!

Financially one is much easier and I have been able to get a career back now she is older. We also never struggle for childcare with just having one.l!

From an only child's perspective I am one and don't feel I really missed out on anything in comparison to friends who had siblings. My parents always let me take a friend on holiday with us from when I was about 12 etc...

TrishM80 · 05/08/2023 13:03

There's no right or wrong answer, OP. All families are different. You can have wonderfully happy families with just one kid and miserable, dysfunctional families with multiple kids. And vice versa!

Goldiebear1 · 05/08/2023 12:59

Happyday122 - not sure if this helps but what we did was make peace with having one child and I had therapy etc to make sure I was in a good place and could see a happy family with the 3 of us. Lots of benefits- great holidays, could give him all our time and also no sleepless nights and hard toddler stage! And then along side that I did the IVF so if it worked it was a bonus. I also found the IVF absolutely fine - I mentally said ok this is how we have/ make babies and I just didn’t put too much pressure on it or overthink it too much. Maybe worth exploring. We did packages where you get a refund if it doesn’t work so worth looking into that. X

Possimpible · 04/08/2023 11:02

Lots of people don't get on with their siblings, so having another child for that reason never makes sense to me. Of course more children doesn't mean more happiness, it's completely dependent on the person. It does sound like you feel something's missing, so it might be worth pursuing. As an aside, you should find a way to tell your extended family it's none of their business. They're being very rude by asking.

Lkahsvtv · 04/08/2023 10:55

DH and I always said we were happy with 1 and thst if another didn’t happen then so be it but once we started trying that biological urge took over and I just couldn’t imagine not having another.
We had agreed though that IVF wouldn’t be something we’d pursue for a second though from an emotional point of view I wasn’t sure I could cope with it and the financial side was a consideration as we’d have had to borrow money.
I don’t think though that having 1 DC makes you any less happy than having 2; there’s good and bad bits to both.

Merrz · 04/08/2023 10:49

Why don't you say we'll try 1 round of IVF and if it doesn't work that's it. I wouldn't say I'm any happier with 2 than 1, infact i do miss the days of 1 dc. They seemed calmer and more organised and a lot quieter!! However i think having 2 feels a lot more like a family, busier and more fun. Also like you said, I like the idea of a full table in years to come

kikisparks · 04/08/2023 10:41

Happyday122 · 04/08/2023 10:33

Goldiebear1, thank you so much for your (and everyone elses!) answer. I never actually had a "set" number of children in my head, but now that I see how wonderful it is to have a child, I would like more, and also a full table later in life, if possible. I just feel I have lots more love to give but of course I am immensely happy with 1 child, my son is the light of our lives, I am so grateful to have him. I think I am just wondering how "hard" I should/ want to try for a second- I am not sure I would cope well with having IVF, the uncertainty etc. I guess I wish someone had a crystal ball and just told me if I was to ever have another, and then I would not have to think about it anymore. The topic has become pretty much all consuming for me and if someone in my extended family asks me "When are you going to have another", "Better be getting on with it" etc. I have to try not to start crying.

That sounds like how I felt whilst dealing with infertility and wanting a child. It is very hard. During the 4 years I tried for DD I often felt like I wished there was a crystal ball that could just tell me if it would ever happen, and of course once we had her all the pain and stress was worth it but at the time I was going through it I didn’t know if it would happen for us. It was all consuming. IVF was hard but I was glad that at least I was doing something and things were moving. Do you have the money for a private round of IVF?

I’d recommend posting on the infertility boards and also if you have time the podcast Big Fat Negative is very good and the hosts have a book as well.