Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Controversial marriage question

385 replies

wedding12341 · 04/08/2023 09:45

Thinking about another thread on here where someone has moved in and had children with their fiancé who has now changed his mind about getting married. Someone on the thread said it is just a small minority of women that are disadvantaged by marriage.

Eg - the woman brings more assets / money to the marriage than the man.

Based on the above

If you were one of these women in the minority (or your friend / daughter was) - Would you advise them not to get married?

OP posts:
Caprisunny · 04/08/2023 14:54

C1N1C · 04/08/2023 14:21

@Caprisunny @G5000

So I don't spread out the post :)
True, but do you think this would be the case if the woman earned three times what the man does? I've observed (don't quote me!) That when men earn more, the woman stays at home (if they can afford to as this makes sense!), if they earn equal, then it's a coin flip of childcare or the woman staying at home (maybe due to them getting more maternity leave and having bonded more?)... but it's very rare that women earn more because statistically, women do not marry men that earn less... or if they do, the man doesn't earn pennies, he at least earns a respectable amount (say 60k to the woman's 100k).

If as you're saying, you're encouraging people not to marry (or perhaps have a prenup), if they are financially superior, then surely that is encouraging most men (who generally earn more) not to get married?
@G5000 what you said is true, but conversely, how many women would support a stay at home dad?

I am not encouraging people not to marry.

I am encouraging people to understand what it means legally and financially. Then make a choice.

I encourage people who have kids, give up their career (or take a step back from it) without marriage to really look at the risk. Then make their own decision.

If men also don’t want to marry on the back of the advice, good for them. They shouldn’t marry. But simply don’t expect your female partner to give up work, or go part time or damage their careers. These men need to be prepared to fully be 50:50 when it comes to the kids. Staying off for Sick days, using AL for school holidays m, obtaining a job with flexible working to do pick ups/drop offs. And also 50% of the house work.
Also do not hint that you do want to be married. Be clear. You don’t want marriage and be clear before moving in and having kids.

As I said before you can’t compare the situation for men and women as exactly the same. Because women usually take more of a career hit. That’s why women are often encouraged to get married, on Mn at least.

It appears you seem to think women should be prepared to take the financial hit but also not expect to be married? And to be happy about it.

You asked why it was ok to encourage women who have assets and/or wealth to not marry but to say men who don’t are immature or time wasters. It’s been explained to again and again why. But here it’s clear, because when it comes to raising children women are expected to take a financial hit. if you expect your partner to take a financial hit raise your joint children, you should give them some security.

The question you should be asking is why so many men are happy to have kids and see their partners take a financial hit, but don’t want to ensure the woman they love has some security.

Nodramabanana · 04/08/2023 14:51

greydressinggownofdoom · 04/08/2023 14:42

There most definitely is not any legal right to be next of kin in medical situations conferred by being married, which is the point I was making.

There is no legal standard of who is recognised as of next of kin. It can be anyone (except as I indicated above in the mental health act where it is called nearest relative and there is a hierarchy).

I agreed there is not legal right, but common practice is to recognise a spouse in decision making (where there is no formal power of attorney). Consistent with, e.g.:

https://www.royalfree.nhs.uk/patients-visitors/advice-and-support/next-of-kin/
https://www.leanderfamilypractice.co.uk/pages/Next-Of-Kin

Again, easily sorted with a POA, but often people don't do that as a matter of course.

Next of kin | Advice and support | For patients, carers and visitors | The Royal Free

Who is next of kin to a hospital patient is not actually defined in law. Find advice on how we define next of kin.

https://www.royalfree.nhs.uk/patients-visitors/advice-and-support/next-of-kin

SueVineer · 04/08/2023 14:48

greydressinggownofdoom · 04/08/2023 14:42

There most definitely is not any legal right to be next of kin in medical situations conferred by being married, which is the point I was making.

There is no legal standard of who is recognised as of next of kin. It can be anyone (except as I indicated above in the mental health act where it is called nearest relative and there is a hierarchy).

Absolutely correct - being married gives absolutely no rights to make medical decisions for anyone.

SueVineer · 04/08/2023 14:47

Hmmm, I was the higher earner and had more assets and didn’t marry my ex (who I had two dds with). It wasn’t just money but as I had two children I wanted to know I could provide for them.

I do think there are some women on mn who still see marriage as a career choice. I would always prefer to make my own way - I wouldn’t like to be financially dependent on another anyway. Obviously there is give and take in relationships but I am not the type who would happily live entirely off another for my whole life.

greydressinggownofdoom · 04/08/2023 14:42

Nodramabanana · 04/08/2023 14:30

It might not be legally, but my understanding is that hospitals will generally recognise spouses/ civil partners as next of kin, but not necessary cohabiting partners.

Next of kin is also really important in what happens on death - not just for inheritance. They can be sorted in a will but many people don't.

There most definitely is not any legal right to be next of kin in medical situations conferred by being married, which is the point I was making.

There is no legal standard of who is recognised as of next of kin. It can be anyone (except as I indicated above in the mental health act where it is called nearest relative and there is a hierarchy).

Nodramabanana · 04/08/2023 14:41

fullbloom87 · 04/08/2023 14:33

Why would it have been silly of him to of looked after his own child unless he was married?
Surely you become a sahp for the benefit of your child (and often the working parent) and the agreement is based on trust and love. If he didn't trust you enough to know you'd take care of your child and the family as whole then he shouldn't have had children with you let alone married you.
I know some people become a sahp and get left in lurch but that can happen even if you're a working parent.

trust and love only lasts till it doesn't. You'd be a fool to give up financial independence without at least marriage as security. Not just for divorce, but also death etc

Hubblebubble · 04/08/2023 14:40

As a single parent who owns a house outright, has savings and doesnt want more children, would anybody advise me to marry?

Brefugee · 04/08/2023 14:34

@fullbloom87 oh you sweet summer child.

Nobody plans for everything to go to ratshit. And yet, here we all are.

fullbloom87 · 04/08/2023 14:33

G5000 · 04/08/2023 14:22

No one forces anyone to scale back their career after children or marry feckless tossers who can’t pick their pants off the floor.

I don't understand what you're trying to say here. My point was that if a couple, both parners together, decide that for their family it is best that one earns all/most of the money and the other deals with majority of domestic tasks, then without marriage, those words about joint money and assets mean squat all in case of divorce.
So when we decided that DH will be SAHD when DC1 was small, it also would have bee silly of him to do that without marriage.

Why would it have been silly of him to of looked after his own child unless he was married?
Surely you become a sahp for the benefit of your child (and often the working parent) and the agreement is based on trust and love. If he didn't trust you enough to know you'd take care of your child and the family as whole then he shouldn't have had children with you let alone married you.
I know some people become a sahp and get left in lurch but that can happen even if you're a working parent.

Brefugee · 04/08/2023 14:32

C1N1C · 04/08/2023 14:27

@Brefugee fair point :)

thanks, sorry, i did come across unnecessarily harshly as a friend i have been telling to get him to put the freaking ring on it already has... been left high and dry. I have a hugely transactional view of marriage in many many ways.

Nodramabanana · 04/08/2023 14:30

greydressinggownofdoom · 04/08/2023 14:26

There is no legal definition of next of kin in medical situation - there is the concept of Nearest Relative under the Mental Health Act - but your next of kin can be anyone - it doesn't necessarily have to be your husband. It may be assumed that it is, but it's not a legal right they are given by virtue of the fact that you are married to them.

It does confer inheritance rights, but the next of kin situation is not the same.

It might not be legally, but my understanding is that hospitals will generally recognise spouses/ civil partners as next of kin, but not necessary cohabiting partners.

Next of kin is also really important in what happens on death - not just for inheritance. They can be sorted in a will but many people don't.

Brefugee · 04/08/2023 14:30

TedMullins · 04/08/2023 14:06

Don’t put up with men who don’t do their share of the domestic chores then. No one forces anyone to scale back their career after children or marry feckless tossers who can’t pick their pants off the floor.

but as we know from the relationships board, this often only manifests itself once the woman has made herself vulnerable by having children and stopping paid outside work.

And it is multiplied exponentially (as is the hurt) when the long term "saving for a huge wedding/house deposit" turns round after 5, 10, 15 years and says "yeah, not marrying you ever" or just keeps saying "yeah, still saving" and the woman goes along with it.

I hate blunt instruments but they are sometimes needed: Marry me or we're over (and mean it) if you're planning a family, preferably before you fall pregnant.

G5000 · 04/08/2023 14:29

crossed psots C1N1C. Yes, I was happy to support SAHD, I would think many women would really if both partners felt that's the best option for their family.

but it's very rare that women earn more because statistically - ah that's interesting as women in their 20s now earn more than men. The gap appears when children come along. There are plenty of women who earn more or same but still decide to take the main carer role. Why, is another discussion.

C1N1C · 04/08/2023 14:27

@Brefugee fair point :)

greydressinggownofdoom · 04/08/2023 14:26

Nodramabanana · 04/08/2023 14:13

There are other advantages/ implications than just money though. E.g. inheritance, automatically being next of kin in medical situations, etc. These things can be resolved in other ways too, but can be complicated and people don't. Divorce is not the only eventuality in a marriage!

There is no legal definition of next of kin in medical situation - there is the concept of Nearest Relative under the Mental Health Act - but your next of kin can be anyone - it doesn't necessarily have to be your husband. It may be assumed that it is, but it's not a legal right they are given by virtue of the fact that you are married to them.

It does confer inheritance rights, but the next of kin situation is not the same.

Cupcakekiller · 04/08/2023 14:26

I'm getting divorced and it was the worst decision I made financially- I'll be worse off than before. I earned a lot more and had far more equity in the house.

Brefugee · 04/08/2023 14:25

C1N1C · 04/08/2023 13:37

I actually agree with your comment, and to the other one (yes I did read the rest of the thread), but in here, it is the minority. As I stated, men typically DO earn more (for whatever reason, I'm not getting into that)... and yet the overwhelming majority of posts outside of this one will call him a waste of space, a time waster, not serious etc etc if he doesn't want to go married.

A man not wanting to marry is often seen as immature, unreliable, not wanting to commit... but a woman not wanting to is seen as strong, independent, powerful... no? As was stated, both should be able to protect their assets.

yes but you made out that nobody had said it, when in fact it seems to me (I haven't counted, so sue me) to actually be the opinion of the majority of posters.

Nodramabanana · 04/08/2023 14:24

MisschiefMaker · 04/08/2023 13:40

My DH became a higher earner than me after the birth of DC (we earned roughly the same before that) but absolutely benefits from being married, and he would be the first to admit that. Essentially, being married means we can make decisions that are beneficial for the family unit, rather than me feeling like I have to look out for myself as an individual even if that negatively impacts him or my DC.

For example, if we weren't married I would have gone back to work after 4 months maternity leave (working with Americans that was all I could take really). He would have had to do 50% of the childcare and 50% of the night wakes and household chores and cooking. Instead, I basically do everything except for when he plays with the toddler after dinner. He works long hours and earns enough that he doesn't 'miss' my salary, so that trade off of me not working and him getting a better quality of life was absolutely worth it to him.

From a values perspective, both DH and I preferred the thought of DC being cared for by their DM (or DF) rather than at nursery for the first 2 years. If I was working that wouldn't have been possible but if we weren't married I would have wanted to go back to work to protect myself... So we're both living a life aligned with our values, thanks to being married. I think that counts as a benefit to DH.

Also, he wanted to move to a low tax European country. The amount he saves in tax is the equivalent to a decent UK salary. So, we save the equivalent of one decent salary in tax AND I don't have to work AND my DC is better off (not just because I'm home with DC, but also because it's a lovely place and DC will be bilingual and also living by the coast has fixed their eczema). No way would I have moved to a country where I don't speak the language if I wasn't married because I can't get work here.

Also, we've moved country twice on my DH's request (once to the USA and once to Europe) and in both cases it was 100% easier to get the visa as a married couple. Actually, I definitely wouldn't have been able to live in the USA without being married to him and therefore he wouldn't have moved there and that would have dented his earnings a lot too.

So I do think that higher earners can benefit from marriage, in theory, even if the woman is the higher earner. However, from what I read on MN when the woman is the higher earner and the dad is at home it's usually because he's a grifter and he doesn't do anything around the house and normally demands that the kids are in nursery too... and then the woman gets screwed in the divorce.. so it's a very individual decision I suppose.

I'd say even with marriage you are still in quite a vulnerable financial position.

G5000 · 04/08/2023 14:22

No one forces anyone to scale back their career after children or marry feckless tossers who can’t pick their pants off the floor.

I don't understand what you're trying to say here. My point was that if a couple, both parners together, decide that for their family it is best that one earns all/most of the money and the other deals with majority of domestic tasks, then without marriage, those words about joint money and assets mean squat all in case of divorce.
So when we decided that DH will be SAHD when DC1 was small, it also would have bee silly of him to do that without marriage.

C1N1C · 04/08/2023 14:21

@Caprisunny @G5000

So I don't spread out the post :)
True, but do you think this would be the case if the woman earned three times what the man does? I've observed (don't quote me!) That when men earn more, the woman stays at home (if they can afford to as this makes sense!), if they earn equal, then it's a coin flip of childcare or the woman staying at home (maybe due to them getting more maternity leave and having bonded more?)... but it's very rare that women earn more because statistically, women do not marry men that earn less... or if they do, the man doesn't earn pennies, he at least earns a respectable amount (say 60k to the woman's 100k).

If as you're saying, you're encouraging people not to marry (or perhaps have a prenup), if they are financially superior, then surely that is encouraging most men (who generally earn more) not to get married?
@G5000 what you said is true, but conversely, how many women would support a stay at home dad?

Nodramabanana · 04/08/2023 14:13

There are other advantages/ implications than just money though. E.g. inheritance, automatically being next of kin in medical situations, etc. These things can be resolved in other ways too, but can be complicated and people don't. Divorce is not the only eventuality in a marriage!

SerafinasGoose · 04/08/2023 14:13

TedMullins · 04/08/2023 14:06

Don’t put up with men who don’t do their share of the domestic chores then. No one forces anyone to scale back their career after children or marry feckless tossers who can’t pick their pants off the floor.

This is true.

I'm also interested in the claim upthread that "divorce = 'bitter'".

How do they know?

Some women end up a sight happier after divorce than before, my sensible mum being a prime example. Nor was she remotedly interested in finding a new partner.

Would the same observations be made about a male? Or is it still assumed in some quarters that the sole measure of a woman's worth is her ability to get and keep a man?

comfyshoes2022 · 04/08/2023 14:10

No. Tbh, I really love being married and the sort of commitment it means that we have to each other and the life we have built.

TedMullins · 04/08/2023 14:06

G5000 · 04/08/2023 14:00

The other thing is that men often are quite happy for the women to take the majority of the responsibility for the house and children, impacting her own career whilst not offering and financial protection

This. Marriage is advocated when a woman comes here to post that she is or is about to become a SAHM/work very part time, so she can facilitate DHs career and he can earn the money. Quite logical to point out that in such cases, being unmarried, she is not taking the load for house and kids in exchange of 'family' money, but all money he earns is solely his.

Don’t put up with men who don’t do their share of the domestic chores then. No one forces anyone to scale back their career after children or marry feckless tossers who can’t pick their pants off the floor.

G5000 · 04/08/2023 14:00

The other thing is that men often are quite happy for the women to take the majority of the responsibility for the house and children, impacting her own career whilst not offering and financial protection

This. Marriage is advocated when a woman comes here to post that she is or is about to become a SAHM/work very part time, so she can facilitate DHs career and he can earn the money. Quite logical to point out that in such cases, being unmarried, she is not taking the load for house and kids in exchange of 'family' money, but all money he earns is solely his.