Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Controversial marriage question

385 replies

wedding12341 · 04/08/2023 09:45

Thinking about another thread on here where someone has moved in and had children with their fiancé who has now changed his mind about getting married. Someone on the thread said it is just a small minority of women that are disadvantaged by marriage.

Eg - the woman brings more assets / money to the marriage than the man.

Based on the above

If you were one of these women in the minority (or your friend / daughter was) - Would you advise them not to get married?

OP posts:
greydressinggownofdoom · 04/08/2023 15:37

What % of men actually bother going to court for a child arrangements order?

G5000 · 04/08/2023 15:33

As the Spartans said to the Greeks.
Or in this case as the University of Warwick study said.

Brefugee · 04/08/2023 15:32

also ending up with custody of your kids, means jack shit when it comes to claiming your non-existent pension. But yay, you got to juggle DCs sickness, school holidays and all the gubbins.

greydressinggownofdoom · 04/08/2023 15:30

G5000 · 04/08/2023 15:30

Custody is invariably largely theirs
If fathers apply for custody, those applications are overwhelmingly successful.

As the Spartans said to the Greeks.

G5000 · 04/08/2023 15:30

Custody is invariably largely theirs
If fathers apply for custody, those applications are overwhelmingly successful.

Brefugee · 04/08/2023 15:29

C1N1C · 04/08/2023 15:08

@Caprisunny Interesting last point there. But isn't that in effect, a dowry? I honestly might not know what I'm on about, but I've always had the impression that was the purpose?

But to turn it around... don't women get the most important 'asset', the children? Custody is invariably largely theirs, they get greater (xernity leave) to spend with kids, and they have the sole right as to their birth in the first place. It is often swung that women suffer because they've given up so much by being SAHM, but I'd actually argue they get the better end of the stick. It's even worse for men marrying into stepdad positions... they could lose half of everything, they bond with a child and then have zero rights if the relationship ends. Women only have a career to lose, men have a whole life...

they get the kids and all the expense and faff and stress of that. And the best you can hope for is that your divorce will leave you with somewhere to live, at least and that your ex at least pays CM.

Without marriage? good luck with that

for pp who asked if a woman would support a SAHD - sure. I did for 18 months. it was great.

greydressinggownofdoom · 04/08/2023 15:28

G5000 · 04/08/2023 15:25

Then they get half your stuff. Also I can see how some couples get trapped where the dh or dw doesn’t want to return to work and the working spouse isn’t happy about it but it’s not enough to divorce. Then you end up supporting someone when you don’t want to.

They get half the stuff acquired during the marriage, i.e the time they were pulling their weight and they spouse was happy to stay married with them and create marital assets.
If someone says their partner is no longer doing their fair share but they don't want to take any drastic action then that's their choice of course.

They get half the stuff acquired during the marriage, i.e the time they were pulling their weight and they spouse was happy to stay married with them and create marital assets.

This is untrue. Please don't talk nonsense.

Caprisunny · 04/08/2023 15:27

C1N1C · 04/08/2023 15:08

@Caprisunny Interesting last point there. But isn't that in effect, a dowry? I honestly might not know what I'm on about, but I've always had the impression that was the purpose?

But to turn it around... don't women get the most important 'asset', the children? Custody is invariably largely theirs, they get greater (xernity leave) to spend with kids, and they have the sole right as to their birth in the first place. It is often swung that women suffer because they've given up so much by being SAHM, but I'd actually argue they get the better end of the stick. It's even worse for men marrying into stepdad positions... they could lose half of everything, they bond with a child and then have zero rights if the relationship ends. Women only have a career to lose, men have a whole life...

How is it a dowry?

Marriage is joining yourselves legally and financially. If you want kids and want your partner to take majority care and take a hit to their finances…..why would you not ensure they also have some security? Why would you think it’s ok they take all the financial risk?

Why do women usually ‘get the children’. Because they have, usually, been the ones doing the majority of the care. And usually because the Dads are happy to accept eow. Because they can continue to work and have less responsibility that way. Women don’t just get the children…:cause vagina.

If men don’t want their wives to get majority residency of the kids, they can (during the relationship) again do 50:50 care. They could also be very clear they don’t want their partner to work PT or be a sahp, before children happen. But they don’t want to. And they could and have the career.

I am a single parent with little input from the kids Dad and built my career. So Dads with a partner can definitely make sure they take on their fair share of responsibilities.

Again, the question is why are men having kids, sitting back while their female partner does most of the care and take on most responsibility if they really want to be an equal parent?

What do you mean ‘only a career’? It’s clear you don’t know what you are talking about, because it’s a jumble. Step mothers could also potentially loose our on their step kids. How is it worse for men?

How do men have a whole life to lose and women only have a career? That doesn’t even make sense.

How is it only a career? It’s someones financial future. If it’s only a career and doesn’t mean much, you would have thought more men would be happy to give it up.

DivineLillith · 04/08/2023 15:26

@Hubblebubble No one regardless of gender should marry in those circumstances.

G5000 · 04/08/2023 15:25

Then they get half your stuff. Also I can see how some couples get trapped where the dh or dw doesn’t want to return to work and the working spouse isn’t happy about it but it’s not enough to divorce. Then you end up supporting someone when you don’t want to.

They get half the stuff acquired during the marriage, i.e the time they were pulling their weight and they spouse was happy to stay married with them and create marital assets.
If someone says their partner is no longer doing their fair share but they don't want to take any drastic action then that's their choice of course.

DivineLillith · 04/08/2023 15:25

I have a friend who is in the minority and she married at a mature age when having children had zero possibility. I think she was really daft if I’m honest. She earns x3 possibly more than her DH and owns another house as well as the one they are both living in. Her assets are many more times his. I am really glad she is happy but he is about as interesting as an unpeeled potato and I do not see the attraction at all but I don’t have to live with him. He is a lot younger than her and a bit of a cocklodger I suppose.

Brefugee · 04/08/2023 15:25

Hubblebubble · 04/08/2023 14:40

As a single parent who owns a house outright, has savings and doesnt want more children, would anybody advise me to marry?

nope. That goes for whichever sex you are.
Unless your potential marriage partner has loads more than you in which case: put a ring on it (if you love them) 😀

SueVineer · 04/08/2023 15:22

Ponderingwindow · 04/08/2023 15:12

If children are involved, women should marry. This is true even if she is the higher earner or has more assets. This is because pregnancy is risky. Having children is risky. You don’t know what life will be like after having children. Even when women earn more, our bodies are the ones that are physically impacted by pregnancy. We are also more likely to become caregivers even when we have higher salaries.

being married mitigates risk. It is a contract that officially transfers some of the risk of parenting to the father.

I lost money in my divorce. I still don’t regret my decision to marry. It was the safe decision financially, I just chose poorly.

That’s total nonsense. I’m a single mum and the very reason I didn’t get married was to protect my children. Now our whole household is in a better financial position because I didn’t marry their father and he was not able to take my property when we split.

marriage transfers zero risk of parenthood to the father. That’s entirely untrue

Goldbar · 04/08/2023 15:22

But to turn it around... don't women get the most important 'asset', the children? Custody is invariably largely theirs, they get greater (xernity leave) to spend with kids, and they have the sole right as to their birth in the first place. It is often swung that women suffer because they've given up so much by being SAHM, but I'd actually argue they get the better end of the stick. It's even worse for men marrying into stepdad positions... they could lose half of everything, they bond with a child and then have zero rights if the relationship ends. Women only have a career to lose, men have a whole life...

Children are not a species of property. In financial terms, they're very much a liability. Perhaps that was less true when you could send them down the mines or into service and they'd bring money into the household, but alas those days are past...😂!

Fireroselily · 04/08/2023 15:21

I used to want to marry my ex so badly lol. After we split, I had a huge windfall and I thank my lucky stars everyday that we never married or he would have had half 😂

SueVineer · 04/08/2023 15:18

G5000 · 04/08/2023 15:16

Yes, in some cases it’s a joint decision, but in many it’s not. how do you force someone to go back to work?

True, you can't. You can divocre them though.

Then they get half your stuff. Also I can see how some couples get trapped where the dh or dw doesn’t want to return to work and the working spouse isn’t happy about it but it’s not enough to divorce. Then you end up supporting someone when you don’t want to.

G5000 · 04/08/2023 15:16

Yes, in some cases it’s a joint decision, but in many it’s not. how do you force someone to go back to work?

True, you can't. You can divocre them though.

SueVineer · 04/08/2023 15:16

Nodramabanana · 04/08/2023 15:01

I never said it was a legal right did I? In my original quote. Anyway....

What marriage does is that it combines a lot of things (rights, oblgiations, legal, pracitcal or simply just customary) you can do in other ways in one legally binding act. That's handy because more often than not don't take these steps before they are needed (when it might be too late). It makes life easier in many situations. Even just ringing up and cancelling your late husband's sky subscription or whatever it is.

You’re mistaken too if you think you can cancel your dh sky subscription because you’re married to him. If you can do that, it’s because it’s a joint account (which could be held if you were friends or siblings, etc.). Same as you have no right to make medical decisions because you’re married either.

G5000 · 04/08/2023 15:15

If he didn't trust you enough to know you'd take care of your child and the family as whole then he shouldn't have had children with you let alone married you.

I mean of course it would be lovely if people were always nice and fair and everybody lived happily ever after. We wouldn't need any laws or agreements ot anything.
The person you start a relationship with might not be so nice and cooperative when you break up with them. But then it's too late.

Ponderingwindow · 04/08/2023 15:12

If children are involved, women should marry. This is true even if she is the higher earner or has more assets. This is because pregnancy is risky. Having children is risky. You don’t know what life will be like after having children. Even when women earn more, our bodies are the ones that are physically impacted by pregnancy. We are also more likely to become caregivers even when we have higher salaries.

being married mitigates risk. It is a contract that officially transfers some of the risk of parenting to the father.

I lost money in my divorce. I still don’t regret my decision to marry. It was the safe decision financially, I just chose poorly.

SueVineer · 04/08/2023 15:12

G5000 · 04/08/2023 14:00

The other thing is that men often are quite happy for the women to take the majority of the responsibility for the house and children, impacting her own career whilst not offering and financial protection

This. Marriage is advocated when a woman comes here to post that she is or is about to become a SAHM/work very part time, so she can facilitate DHs career and he can earn the money. Quite logical to point out that in such cases, being unmarried, she is not taking the load for house and kids in exchange of 'family' money, but all money he earns is solely his.

In many cases though, the women don’t want to go back to work. Same as a pp on this thread who had a dh who could never seem to find the right job to go back to work. Yes, in some cases it’s a joint decision, but in many it’s not. how do you force someone to go back to work?

Also on mn it’s always women sacrificing their careers to facilitate men’s careers. But yet many of the women who have similar jobs have husbands and partners who work. And many of the women and men who “sacrifice” their careers didn’t earn much anyway. So I think it’s not that simple at all.

C1N1C · 04/08/2023 15:08

@Caprisunny Interesting last point there. But isn't that in effect, a dowry? I honestly might not know what I'm on about, but I've always had the impression that was the purpose?

But to turn it around... don't women get the most important 'asset', the children? Custody is invariably largely theirs, they get greater (xernity leave) to spend with kids, and they have the sole right as to their birth in the first place. It is often swung that women suffer because they've given up so much by being SAHM, but I'd actually argue they get the better end of the stick. It's even worse for men marrying into stepdad positions... they could lose half of everything, they bond with a child and then have zero rights if the relationship ends. Women only have a career to lose, men have a whole life...

greydressinggownofdoom · 04/08/2023 15:07

I'm just correcting the assumption that your husband or wife will be your next of kin legally - he or she won't be, there is no such right.

I have made provisions as much as I can to ensure that I am not left in a situation where I am vulnerable like I was the last time - the idea that the man who cheated on me would have been my next of kin absolutely terrified me.

I am not saying that I can recreate all the so-called protections of marriage as easily when I am not married, but for me they aren't really protections, they would disadvantage me and my children and therefore marriage isn't something I want to do again.

Nodramabanana · 04/08/2023 15:01

greydressinggownofdoom · 04/08/2023 14:57

The quote I replied to said

There are other advantages/ implications than just money though. E.g. inheritance, automatically being next of kin in medical situations,

I was pointing out that there is no legal right to be next of kin and that it can be anyone the person wants to be - and if you are incapacitated the medical staff will act in your best interests, especially in a situation where there is conflict between two people who both claim to be next of kin. (Which I have seen - new gf vs wife separated for many years but not divorced)

I never said it was a legal right did I? In my original quote. Anyway....

What marriage does is that it combines a lot of things (rights, oblgiations, legal, pracitcal or simply just customary) you can do in other ways in one legally binding act. That's handy because more often than not don't take these steps before they are needed (when it might be too late). It makes life easier in many situations. Even just ringing up and cancelling your late husband's sky subscription or whatever it is.

greydressinggownofdoom · 04/08/2023 14:57

Nodramabanana · 04/08/2023 14:51

I agreed there is not legal right, but common practice is to recognise a spouse in decision making (where there is no formal power of attorney). Consistent with, e.g.:

https://www.royalfree.nhs.uk/patients-visitors/advice-and-support/next-of-kin/
https://www.leanderfamilypractice.co.uk/pages/Next-Of-Kin

Again, easily sorted with a POA, but often people don't do that as a matter of course.

The quote I replied to said

There are other advantages/ implications than just money though. E.g. inheritance, automatically being next of kin in medical situations,

I was pointing out that there is no legal right to be next of kin and that it can be anyone the person wants to be - and if you are incapacitated the medical staff will act in your best interests, especially in a situation where there is conflict between two people who both claim to be next of kin. (Which I have seen - new gf vs wife separated for many years but not divorced)