Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Controversial marriage question

385 replies

wedding12341 · 04/08/2023 09:45

Thinking about another thread on here where someone has moved in and had children with their fiancé who has now changed his mind about getting married. Someone on the thread said it is just a small minority of women that are disadvantaged by marriage.

Eg - the woman brings more assets / money to the marriage than the man.

Based on the above

If you were one of these women in the minority (or your friend / daughter was) - Would you advise them not to get married?

OP posts:
Caprisunny · 04/08/2023 18:55

Jumpingthruhoops · 04/08/2023 18:26

I wouldn't say it's condescending at all. It's not true for all - but it totally is true for some. I know many couples who've cut ties in the first instance rather than have a difficult conversation.

🙄🙄🙄

So it’s not condescending because you know some people who did chose divorce (despite it being a long and difficult process) over having a converstaion. Which is funny because divorce involved lots of conversations.

Good job I repeatedly said ‘vast majority’ and similar all the way along. So I stand by what I said. The vast majority of people do not divorce on a whim. Divorce rates aren’t high, because people just fancy a change.

Its absolutely condescending to make blanket statements about how your marriage (of around 2/3 years) will last so you didn’t need to protect your assets, simply because those who do divorce just haven’t tried hard enough.

Just like when the same poster tried to explain to another poster that she must have been partially responsible for her husband cheating. Condescending and twatish

AlltheFs · 04/08/2023 18:53

DeeCeeCherry · 04/08/2023 18:09

I dont want my DDs to marry a man with less money than them. Neither do I want them to have children without being married. Or marry a lazy man.They're hard workers and save money well. Women should marry their equal

They know why - we are close so we chat about these things.
I know too many horror stories - women who were 'wife without the ring' then dumped after DCs and years together. & I had friends during the dating/marrying years who married for love/it's not about how much money he has/we split everything.. then they're on your phone after 10pm at night crying about their man who's tightfisted, or always broke etc. Far too many women out there lie to themselves for the sake of a man, and also to impress other women. Whilst their quality of life has gone to shit.

DP has more money than me. I have my own money so dont particularly need his. But it's nice that it's there, and he isn't a mean man. Im not mean with him either. We have a nice life together. I was married previously, still friends with ExH after divorce but lack of money killed our marriage stone dead. He didnt maximise his earning potential. I shouldn't have married him, all it did was make me broke and I had to work very hard to recoup. I relax now.

Life isnt a fairytale book.

Jesus Fucking Christ. What a way to bring up your children.

Some incredibly talented, very hard working people work in lower paid careers. Academics for example get paid fuck all. Is that not good enough for you?

What if for example you have a male MP vs a female investment banker. Is that not ok either?

Lots of very happy relationships exist where the man earns less than the woman. Does not mean they aren’t doing something worthwhile and working very hard.

Jumpingthruhoops · 04/08/2023 18:26

Caprisunny · 04/08/2023 12:17

I wish people wouldn’t come out with stuff like this.

Very few people get divorced on a whim. Most also don’t think they will get divorced.

What people do is not tell everyone about the whole reason they have got divorced. They won’t go into the years of general unhappiness, the million different things that led up to divorce.

It’s so condescending to say people get divorced because they just don’t try hard enough. And pointless. Divorce is an I redo my long process to go through. You wouldn’t go through it unless you really felt it was the best and only option.

Also, separating changes people and causes a lot of anger and resentment. Betting your financial future on a verbal agreement and a whats app is laughable. It may not even be his decision. If all you have is a message and a verbal agreement your assets are not protected in most countries (maybe all). Especially if you marriage is a long one.

I wouldn't say it's condescending at all. It's not true for all - but it totally is true for some. I know many couples who've cut ties in the first instance rather than have a difficult conversation.

DeeCeeCherry · 04/08/2023 18:09

I dont want my DDs to marry a man with less money than them. Neither do I want them to have children without being married. Or marry a lazy man.They're hard workers and save money well. Women should marry their equal

They know why - we are close so we chat about these things.
I know too many horror stories - women who were 'wife without the ring' then dumped after DCs and years together. & I had friends during the dating/marrying years who married for love/it's not about how much money he has/we split everything.. then they're on your phone after 10pm at night crying about their man who's tightfisted, or always broke etc. Far too many women out there lie to themselves for the sake of a man, and also to impress other women. Whilst their quality of life has gone to shit.

DP has more money than me. I have my own money so dont particularly need his. But it's nice that it's there, and he isn't a mean man. Im not mean with him either. We have a nice life together. I was married previously, still friends with ExH after divorce but lack of money killed our marriage stone dead. He didnt maximise his earning potential. I shouldn't have married him, all it did was make me broke and I had to work very hard to recoup. I relax now.

Life isnt a fairytale book.

InSpainTheRain · 04/08/2023 17:51

I don't tend to give advice out so probably would say nothing. However, I (f) am the higher earner (always have been) and have more assets. We are not married. We've been together nearly 30 years and have children in their twenties.

Giveover80 · 04/08/2023 17:32

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Giveover80 · 04/08/2023 17:32

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Jumpingthruhoops · 04/08/2023 17:31

greydressinggownofdoom · 04/08/2023 12:09

That's what I thought of me and my "D"H.

He cheated. I didn't see that coming.

I won't make the same mistake again.

Sorry to hear that. I'm under no illusion that people change, circumstances change. But, as it stands, we're nearly 30 years strong. He's my best friend.

Ohmygiddyauntie · 04/08/2023 17:04

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

I understand that you may have some doubts, but there are longitudinal studies that support my statements. These studies show that two-thirds of individuals are affected by age 12, and 9 out of 10 are affected by the age of 20.
It's often argued that cohabitation can be just as beneficial for children as marriage, but there are many who believe that marriage provides the best environment for raising kids. This viewpoint is widely accepted as common knowledge.
Dp and I have both been through a divorce. We are able to minimize the negative impact by focusing on our family and utilizing our wealth. In the past, divorce was seen as a way to gain freedom during the '60s-'70s, but the long-term effects on society were not fully understood at the time.

You need to dig a little deeper.

Giveover80 · 04/08/2023 16:48

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Chickenkeev · 04/08/2023 16:40

onlylovecanhurtlikethis · 04/08/2023 16:21

I'm the much higher earner. I was very careful to protect a lot of assets which has stood me in good stead having recently got divorced. I wouldn't advise against marriage but very much be practical and hope for the best plan for the worst

That being said I would never recommend marrying a man (or anyone for that matter) who doesn't have similar ambitions (or if you are my ex - have no ambitions and happy for someone else to take the stress of being the main earner)

I get the point of what you're saying, but sometimes it's not an option for someone to all of a sudden be on a great salary. Qualifications/ age etc all come in to it. I'm definitely all for people protecting their well earned assets but it's not neccessarily wrong to marry someone who doesn't earn as well as you do. I have a particular interest as i said above, H was the lower earner. But he's paid me back a million times over. Again, this is not always the case, but a relationship should be scrutinised in lots of other terms other than just finances. I really think people should analyse behaviour rather than finances specifically. And included in 'behaviour', what are they like with money?

rhino12345 · 04/08/2023 16:29

Of all my close female friends (off the top of my head, 10) only one is married. The other 9, plus myself, are either the higher earner, or have substantially more assets than their male partner. They won't be getting married as they'd be at a financial disadvantage to do so.

LolaSmiles · 04/08/2023 16:22

Marriage is a legal arrangement and one that both people should make an informed decision about either way.

There are pros and cons of marriage for everyone. I'd advise everyone to look at their circumstances, their plans as individuals and couples, and make the decisions that works for their relationship.

The problem is that often people drift into situations that are strongly disadvantage them (eg giving up employment for long periods of time, losing pension contributions living in unmarried partner's house, paying towards properties they're not on the deeds for, throwing money into properties they have no claim on etc).

onlylovecanhurtlikethis · 04/08/2023 16:21

I'm the much higher earner. I was very careful to protect a lot of assets which has stood me in good stead having recently got divorced. I wouldn't advise against marriage but very much be practical and hope for the best plan for the worst

That being said I would never recommend marrying a man (or anyone for that matter) who doesn't have similar ambitions (or if you are my ex - have no ambitions and happy for someone else to take the stress of being the main earner)

AlltheFs · 04/08/2023 16:20

I’m the main earner by a considerable margin and provided all the equity for our home.

If only people that contributed equally financially could get married there would be very few weddings.

whumpthereitis · 04/08/2023 16:18

Plenty of women give up work not because their partner wants them to, but because they want to. Even if a partner wants them to though, that doesn’t mean they have to acquiesce.

If it’s important for someone to have the protections offered by marriage - it’s their responsibility to not make decisions that put them at a disadvantage.

Ohmygiddyauntie · 04/08/2023 16:05

Caprisunny · 04/08/2023 14:54

I am not encouraging people not to marry.

I am encouraging people to understand what it means legally and financially. Then make a choice.

I encourage people who have kids, give up their career (or take a step back from it) without marriage to really look at the risk. Then make their own decision.

If men also don’t want to marry on the back of the advice, good for them. They shouldn’t marry. But simply don’t expect your female partner to give up work, or go part time or damage their careers. These men need to be prepared to fully be 50:50 when it comes to the kids. Staying off for Sick days, using AL for school holidays m, obtaining a job with flexible working to do pick ups/drop offs. And also 50% of the house work.
Also do not hint that you do want to be married. Be clear. You don’t want marriage and be clear before moving in and having kids.

As I said before you can’t compare the situation for men and women as exactly the same. Because women usually take more of a career hit. That’s why women are often encouraged to get married, on Mn at least.

It appears you seem to think women should be prepared to take the financial hit but also not expect to be married? And to be happy about it.

You asked why it was ok to encourage women who have assets and/or wealth to not marry but to say men who don’t are immature or time wasters. It’s been explained to again and again why. But here it’s clear, because when it comes to raising children women are expected to take a financial hit. if you expect your partner to take a financial hit raise your joint children, you should give them some security.

The question you should be asking is why so many men are happy to have kids and see their partners take a financial hit, but don’t want to ensure the woman they love has some security.

It's unlikely that the average salary of £36000 will make anyone wealthy. One common problem in families is the struggle between pursuing a career and raising children, which can create conflicts of interest. Combining incomes equitably can provide more security for both parties. However, the concept of financial security is not always reliable, as demonstrated by the significant income loss during the COVID-19 pandemic. While it's wise to plan for financial stability, it's unrealistic to expect a smooth journey throughout a lengthy marriage.

TedMullins · 04/08/2023 16:01

C1N1C · 04/08/2023 14:21

@Caprisunny @G5000

So I don't spread out the post :)
True, but do you think this would be the case if the woman earned three times what the man does? I've observed (don't quote me!) That when men earn more, the woman stays at home (if they can afford to as this makes sense!), if they earn equal, then it's a coin flip of childcare or the woman staying at home (maybe due to them getting more maternity leave and having bonded more?)... but it's very rare that women earn more because statistically, women do not marry men that earn less... or if they do, the man doesn't earn pennies, he at least earns a respectable amount (say 60k to the woman's 100k).

If as you're saying, you're encouraging people not to marry (or perhaps have a prenup), if they are financially superior, then surely that is encouraging most men (who generally earn more) not to get married?
@G5000 what you said is true, but conversely, how many women would support a stay at home dad?

it may be true that women don’t tend to marry men who earn less in general but personally I like being the higher earner the the security it gives me. No one can financially screw me over and I know I could afford the same lifestyle alone. I also think if a woman wants to be a SAHM she should, if the tables were turned, be hypothetically prepared to support a SAHD.

Coyoacan · 04/08/2023 15:58

I thought the days when mothers automatically got "custody" of the kids were long over. That used to be one of the benefits of being a woman.

But children usually do stilll end up being the responsability of the mother, which is one good argument for not the woman not marrying if she has more assets or a higher income.

There is equality and then there is fairness. We are not equal. Men don't get pregnant and cannot breastfeed. It makes a hell of a difference. Men, in general, find it quite easy to walk away from their children, whereas it is very unusual and highly criticised for a mother to do so.

greydressinggownofdoom · 04/08/2023 15:55

Evil women?

What like the ones that end up getting very little post divorce, who haven't built their careers coz they had a husband who wanted them at home, who then went and had an affair and the kids didn't suit his new life so he never bothered his arse going for any sort of formal arrangement but just wanted to be able to turn up and take the kids whenever suited him? Those sort of women?

G5000 · 04/08/2023 15:51

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

greydressinggownofdoom · 04/08/2023 15:42

Caprisunny · 04/08/2023 15:40

Before or after there’s a new girlfriend? 😂

Now that's a study I'd love to see.

greydressinggownofdoom · 04/08/2023 15:42

G5000 · 04/08/2023 15:40

what does it matter what %? If they want to have custody, they go, they win. If they don't bother then that's because they don't want to. Not because 'custody is invariably women's'.

Because most men don't bother. That's why it matters.

I can't believe I'm having to explain that tbh.

Caprisunny · 04/08/2023 15:40

greydressinggownofdoom · 04/08/2023 15:37

What % of men actually bother going to court for a child arrangements order?

Before or after there’s a new girlfriend? 😂

G5000 · 04/08/2023 15:40

what does it matter what %? If they want to have custody, they go, they win. If they don't bother then that's because they don't want to. Not because 'custody is invariably women's'.