Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Controversial marriage question

385 replies

wedding12341 · 04/08/2023 09:45

Thinking about another thread on here where someone has moved in and had children with their fiancé who has now changed his mind about getting married. Someone on the thread said it is just a small minority of women that are disadvantaged by marriage.

Eg - the woman brings more assets / money to the marriage than the man.

Based on the above

If you were one of these women in the minority (or your friend / daughter was) - Would you advise them not to get married?

OP posts:
Giveover80 · 05/08/2023 08:32

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Gerrataere · 05/08/2023 08:32

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

It’s not that clear cut is it? A man is usually high earning because it is still the societal norm for him to hold a career with no breaks. Having children (and this includes pregnancy) has little real term implications on how he is seen a function member of an economic society. He is unlikely to be turned over for promotions and in interviews. Women of child baring age (even if they choose not to have children) will be prejudiced because there is always the assumption they will ‘eventually want to settle down’, a prospective employer will always look for the most financially secure option in hiring.

Marriage for women in many circumstances is security for their own lives, and for any children produced from the relationship. It is not comparable the other way around because circumstances and reality dictates that legally men are far less likely to face a great loss of income or will struggle to have one in comparison to women of child baring/having age. Children who in most cases will have the mother as their primary caregiver and will need greater assets to reflect this.

When society truly moves away from ‘father brings in the money, mother does the caring’ idealisms then we can ask ‘is divorce fair on men’ more.

Giveover80 · 05/08/2023 08:31

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

magicalkitty · 05/08/2023 08:26
  • But if she was much wealthier than partner

Then taking maternity leave unlikely to change that*

Yes but I'm talking about the other scenario (wealthy man and not wealthy woman). She would be taking time out of work, going part time, harming career growth etc while he stays rich. Then if the relationship goes tits up in a few years, he swans off with all his wealth still intact while she nurtured the family and her earning potential is harmed as a result.

Giveover80 · 05/08/2023 08:20

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Giveover80 · 05/08/2023 08:18

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

magicalkitty · 05/08/2023 08:14

But I should add, in a scenario where there won't be children, for example if they are past childbearing age, my opinion would be the same - a rich man would also be very stupid to marry someone with a lot less.

magicalkitty · 05/08/2023 08:12

@Giveover80 no it's not the same in a relationship where there will or could be children. Women usually 'lose' a lot more in this instance - a year's maternity and then it's nearly always the woman who goes part time when the child is born. That harms her career growth and earnings potential in the long run. Men's careers are not harmed by having children, in-fact research shows it often benefits.

Giveover80 · 05/08/2023 08:02

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

magicalkitty · 05/08/2023 07:51

If a woman has substantially more than the person she is marrying then yes, I would think she is stupid to get married.

Caprisunny · 05/08/2023 05:23

Jumpingthruhoops · 05/08/2023 02:28

This reply can't be to me.

-I clearly said 'some not all' - so not sure why you'll still referring to the 'vast majority'.
-I didn't specifically say people 'chose divorce' over having a difficult conversation. I said 'cut ties', by which I meant 'left the marital home' without any warning.
-I've been married 18 years (together for 28). Not sure where 2/3 has come from.

Yes the reply was to you.

The comment you said wasn’t condescending was condescending. That comment was made by someone who has been married 2/3 years. Because that’s the comment we are talking about.

If you aren’t talking about divorce then I don’t get your point at all. Because I was specifically referencing a comment about divorce. And if they live in the martial home and leave to cut ties, the inevitable step is divorce.

It’s condescending to say ‘I just know I won’t get divorced. Me and my husband will work on our marriage. People just give up to easily and we won’t’. That poster might have well finished off with ‘we are just built different’

That same poster then went on to tell someone how they were partially to blame for their husband cheating. They were condescending and quite cruel.

wedding12341 · 05/08/2023 05:10

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 04/08/2023 23:22

@wedding12341 re the comment about the financially richer man being mean for not marrying the woman..: that is because what generally happens is that the woman has dropped a career to support her dp in every way with running the house hold and child care. It's not often the case that men do this for women- have all their laundry done holier cleaned dinner cooked etc. the men are usually working a bit but just not earning much and the higher earning woman is paying for childcare and doing lots of the childcare in spare time. So it's not mean to not marry a man in your scenario as 1. He is still usually following his career and 2. The woman's success and money has usually not only been made possible due to free domestic labour from her dp

Entirely fair point.

With that in mind would you agree to not entering into a marriage as the better off partner ?

OP posts:
Threenow · 05/08/2023 03:55

Jumpingthruhoops · 04/08/2023 12:06

Basing a marriage on 'who brings what' to it is why marriages don't work out.

My DH and I have always lived, loved and worked as a team. The End.

My marriage ended, and I owned a flat when we got married, but I didn't care that everything was divided 50/50 when we separated. I was also the higher earner for much of our relationship. I never looked at it as a "what we each brought" scenario - we were a team, it didn't work out, that's life. Actually, it doesn't matter whether you are married or not where I live so it would have been a 50/50 split anyway. Considering the financial implications when embarking on a life-sharing partnership somehow seems distasteful to me.

applepie04 · 05/08/2023 02:37

We split everything 50-50 whether it's mine or his because we love each other. It's not about money, it about building a life and partnership together.

Jumpingthruhoops · 05/08/2023 02:28

Caprisunny · 04/08/2023 18:55

🙄🙄🙄

So it’s not condescending because you know some people who did chose divorce (despite it being a long and difficult process) over having a converstaion. Which is funny because divorce involved lots of conversations.

Good job I repeatedly said ‘vast majority’ and similar all the way along. So I stand by what I said. The vast majority of people do not divorce on a whim. Divorce rates aren’t high, because people just fancy a change.

Its absolutely condescending to make blanket statements about how your marriage (of around 2/3 years) will last so you didn’t need to protect your assets, simply because those who do divorce just haven’t tried hard enough.

Just like when the same poster tried to explain to another poster that she must have been partially responsible for her husband cheating. Condescending and twatish

This reply can't be to me.

-I clearly said 'some not all' - so not sure why you'll still referring to the 'vast majority'.
-I didn't specifically say people 'chose divorce' over having a difficult conversation. I said 'cut ties', by which I meant 'left the marital home' without any warning.
-I've been married 18 years (together for 28). Not sure where 2/3 has come from.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 04/08/2023 23:22

@wedding12341 re the comment about the financially richer man being mean for not marrying the woman..: that is because what generally happens is that the woman has dropped a career to support her dp in every way with running the house hold and child care. It's not often the case that men do this for women- have all their laundry done holier cleaned dinner cooked etc. the men are usually working a bit but just not earning much and the higher earning woman is paying for childcare and doing lots of the childcare in spare time. So it's not mean to not marry a man in your scenario as 1. He is still usually following his career and 2. The woman's success and money has usually not only been made possible due to free domestic labour from her dp

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 04/08/2023 23:16

Hubblebubble · 04/08/2023 11:07

I own a house outright and have a child. I'll never marry. Why would I mess with the security of my child's future inheritance and my own wealth?

I guess if you met a man with similar assets and situation that you did want to build a life with into old age, you might want to buy one bigger or better house together and you'd want to avoid inheritance tax if one of you dies

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 04/08/2023 23:15

MadamWhiteleigh · 04/08/2023 11:06

When you enter into any situation due to a relationship, be it a house purchase, pregnancy, marriage, you should first look at the legal implications and, vitally, what would happen if the relationship broke down. Too many people are being emotional making these decisions when they need to be logical and practical.

I agree

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 04/08/2023 23:15

Babdoc · 04/08/2023 11:05

Marriage is meant to be a total partnership between two equals, for life.

The vows made in the presence of God at the start include “With all my worldly goods I thee endow”, and refer to the couple becoming one flesh.
If anyone - male or female - is planning how to avoid sharing their assets, or to sequester them in the event of a divorce, then they really should not be getting married in the first place. They obviously don’t intend to commit to a marriage, merely a sexual relationship for their own benefit, of debatable duration.

But I suppose it's I'll share everything with you while your my husband. Not if you run off with a younger woman one day and
Expect me to buy you both a home
To live in...

Chickenkeev · 04/08/2023 20:36

XelaM · 04/08/2023 19:29

Exactly. My dad comes from a very frugal background, and my mum was from much a wealthier family and also had a great job when they married (although my dad was always highly intelligent and hard-working).

Throughout their marriage, my dad made a lot of money and then lost it all and went bankrupt; then started afresh and got back on his feet. My mum and her family always stood by him throughout, but honestly I have never met a more amazing man, husband and father than him. He is the type of man who would do (and has done) absolutely ANYTHING for my mum and his kids/grandkids. I have never met a better man. I feel so lucky that he is my dad and my mum is incredibly lucky to have him and after 45 years of marriage and all the financial ups and downs, they are still best friends.

Don't just focus on money.

That is so lovely to read! It is the absolute opposite to my experience. But i know, if dad was still alive, he wouldn't have been anything like yours. It's so great to read about a good man, who stands up. Your dad sounds like him!

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 04/08/2023 20:20

I have recently advised a friend with a baby with a guy not to get married, as she has a house and a business and he has debts and no job. If they get married it would count as the family home and he could have some rights to it despite paying nothing towards it.

Nb he's not a stay at home dad
Doign childcare. She does most of that too. He's someone who is trying to start a start up and bringing in no money for months.

XelaM · 04/08/2023 19:29

Chickenkeev · 04/08/2023 19:04

Like, as an example, my da was loaded. He beat up my mum so we had multiple police calls/visits. He wouldn't feed us. My H is poor. He does everything for me and our daughter. Money really is not everything at all. There is so much more to it.

Exactly. My dad comes from a very frugal background, and my mum was from much a wealthier family and also had a great job when they married (although my dad was always highly intelligent and hard-working).

Throughout their marriage, my dad made a lot of money and then lost it all and went bankrupt; then started afresh and got back on his feet. My mum and her family always stood by him throughout, but honestly I have never met a more amazing man, husband and father than him. He is the type of man who would do (and has done) absolutely ANYTHING for my mum and his kids/grandkids. I have never met a better man. I feel so lucky that he is my dad and my mum is incredibly lucky to have him and after 45 years of marriage and all the financial ups and downs, they are still best friends.

Don't just focus on money.

Chickenkeev · 04/08/2023 19:04

Like, as an example, my da was loaded. He beat up my mum so we had multiple police calls/visits. He wouldn't feed us. My H is poor. He does everything for me and our daughter. Money really is not everything at all. There is so much more to it.

Chickenkeev · 04/08/2023 18:59

DeeCeeCherry · 04/08/2023 18:09

I dont want my DDs to marry a man with less money than them. Neither do I want them to have children without being married. Or marry a lazy man.They're hard workers and save money well. Women should marry their equal

They know why - we are close so we chat about these things.
I know too many horror stories - women who were 'wife without the ring' then dumped after DCs and years together. & I had friends during the dating/marrying years who married for love/it's not about how much money he has/we split everything.. then they're on your phone after 10pm at night crying about their man who's tightfisted, or always broke etc. Far too many women out there lie to themselves for the sake of a man, and also to impress other women. Whilst their quality of life has gone to shit.

DP has more money than me. I have my own money so dont particularly need his. But it's nice that it's there, and he isn't a mean man. Im not mean with him either. We have a nice life together. I was married previously, still friends with ExH after divorce but lack of money killed our marriage stone dead. He didnt maximise his earning potential. I shouldn't have married him, all it did was make me broke and I had to work very hard to recoup. I relax now.

Life isnt a fairytale book.

I would say that you're focussing on the wrong things though. Want them not to marry an arsehole. Money isn't a gaurantee of anything. Make them learn about behaviour and treatment of them. Teach them not to be dependent on any man. If you do those things, your daughters can walk away if whatever reason they need to. Sometimes (not saying you in particular) people get very hung up on men being evil when they're generally not. But a woman (or a man) should always, always! have the means to support themselves independently.

Swipe left for the next trending thread