Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Controversial marriage question

385 replies

wedding12341 · 04/08/2023 09:45

Thinking about another thread on here where someone has moved in and had children with their fiancé who has now changed his mind about getting married. Someone on the thread said it is just a small minority of women that are disadvantaged by marriage.

Eg - the woman brings more assets / money to the marriage than the man.

Based on the above

If you were one of these women in the minority (or your friend / daughter was) - Would you advise them not to get married?

OP posts:
Chickenkeev · 05/08/2023 14:27

whumpthereitis · 05/08/2023 14:16

Even if it is, it’s hardly necessary to pull out ‘read the room!’ as if there is only one room, and people can only acknowledge their wealth if they pay appropriate tribute to those with less.

Yeah, grand, but it's all a bit my wallet is too small for my 50s and my diamond shoes are too tight. And on a forum where so many are dirt poor. I'm poor so I suppose sensitive? But it was a lengthy treatise on how hard life is with loadsa cash.

whumpthereitis · 05/08/2023 14:16

Chickenkeev · 05/08/2023 14:10

She did indeed, ad nauseum. She's loaded, fair play to her. How are the minutiae of her finances relevant to anything no more than mine are? It's a brag. Perhaps inadvertent, but leave it out.

Even if it is, it’s hardly necessary to pull out ‘read the room!’ as if there is only one room, and people can only acknowledge their wealth if they pay appropriate tribute to those with less.

Chickenkeev · 05/08/2023 14:10

whumpthereitis · 05/08/2023 14:03

Oh ffs, she shared her experience that is relevant to the thread, i.e ‘the room’.

She did indeed, ad nauseum. She's loaded, fair play to her. How are the minutiae of her finances relevant to anything no more than mine are? It's a brag. Perhaps inadvertent, but leave it out.

whumpthereitis · 05/08/2023 14:03

Chickenkeev · 05/08/2023 13:38

While it's truly lovely to read your essay on how rich you are and how great your life is, cop the f on, the vast, vast majority of people do not have that experience. Read the room (if you're real). If you're on here much at all, you'll know that people are availing of food banks. Not because they're all lazy, or stupid, or whatever. Statistically, it's impossible for everyone to amass great wealth.

Oh ffs, she shared her experience that is relevant to the thread, i.e ‘the room’.

Thepeopleversuswork · 05/08/2023 13:52

I have never been in a relationship with a man who earns more than me. I out earn both my present partner and my ex husband by a factor of three to one.

I very foolishly got married and narrowly avoided losing my home when my marriage ended. I’m not making that mistake again.

My present partner and I are talking about cohabiting (undecided). The cornerstone of that (if it ever happens) will be:

  • categorically no marriage under any circumstances
  • Deed of trust on any property
  • Clarity that there will not be a shared tenancy
  • Cobtract specifically mandating separate finances

I have a child (not his) snd there’s no way any of her inheritance is going to be acquired by him.

The adage that marriage protects women only works when the woman is the financially weaker partner. Which is true most of the time but increasingly not.

Women who have decent earnings and assets are at risk of sleepwalking to disaster by marrying. It’s not worth it.

Chickenkeev · 05/08/2023 13:38

Globetrotterx · 05/08/2023 13:29

Long post (sorry short wasn't that short)

I am self-employed with an international career in a regulated sector and can work in over 54 countries so my earnings vary and can be as much as £400K in a year ( even much more, but that's enough for this purpose). However, I have 2 countries I can always work and live in with different economies which is helpful. So, I can change my circumstances at a moment's notice.

I have amassed a fortune from real hard-work. I am motivated by what I do and not by money. I therefore have never been money focused- this helped when it came to marrying- but I am values focussed. It's why you must believe those who say find your passion if it's money you want. So, in my belief, it is easy to make money - just work hard.

I then met a kindred heart (late DP) before I met my DH who was exactly like me and made his money similarly. We were drawn towards each other by values, passion and wanted to help others. We were planning to marry and he died of Covid- of course I was devastated as I didn't; have to ask if he was with me for money etc etc. We had an easy relationship. I am due a windfall from the work we did together before he died.

After DP's death, I had all sorts showing an interest in me while I was grieving, clearly because they saw an opening. It was DISGUSTING. My alarm bells went off and I knew I had to protect myself. Luckily I know the city well and the city types including pretenders- so it was easy to avoid them. Cut long story short, I decided to forget about men and focus on the work which would lift many people in 3rd world countries out of poverty and forget the rest. As I was putting those plans in motion, I met my DH.

He didn't know anything about me, but just saw a woman who he thought was delightful. He really admired all my hard work, principles and values. I admired his focus and determination.

Marriage: Before we married, he made it clear he wanted nothing from me and I believed him. He was previously married and his wife died young and I saw how they lived, which is how I would want in a marriage. She didn't work as he didn't care what she did. I liked that because I have always valued making my own decision about what was important to me at any given time. The idea that I must work when I don't need to, or I don't want, was very weird to me. Same as the idea that if I wanted to work, I cannot- I believe in having a voice and a choice. He owned his brand-new house outright- not worth millions, but it was important to me that he had a secure home for himself.On top of that, he ran a small business which had potential to grow; one part of it might even make him millions any day but he is working o that- it may start at a couple of hundred thousands first before bigger sums. I like self-employed people, because although I was self-employed, many times, my assignments could just be like proper employment and I know how fixed and rigid employers can be. Most people can meet up every 2 or 3 weeks because they are still developing their career. Yes, I leap frogged my career as I went self-employed so I progressed faster than people my age. So I really didn't want to marry someone who was a slave to an employer- I just didn't want. So for the first 2 years, we travelled the world as we were our own bosses. That's enough for that.

Before we married, we discussed our wills. I was clear that all my stuff would go to my family ( I married late and they were there every step of the way including some difficult times -very short times thank God-when a woman like me earns more than men and that's frown up). He was clear that all his stuff will go to me. I was shocked, but that's how I knew, he really wanted nothing from me. He then made proposals as to what to do with his things after he dies ,in my new will after his death ( he is 9 years older than me) although he knows that will be 100% my decision. I will honour it though. I have left all designer stuff to him (handbags, Cartier , shoes, day dresses, evening dresses etc) worth around £150K to him in the will. He will be able to sell it at a better value and Gove the money to my family. I trust him enough to sell it within 3 years. I have left him all the cash too as I have invested all the cash anyway ( I don't keep cash- when you start investing, you get used to a no cash mindset so that anytime I am waiting for a windfall, my mind goes into deciding what to invest it in), so any money in there when I die will have been acquired within marriage. However, a certain amount is for my funeral and rest for him. He owns a Bentley which I very much enjoy being driven in- I was jokingly mentioning that if I came into money and paid off all my mortgages, I would treat myself to a Bentley, and then I met my husband and as the friend I joked with said: "Oh, now you no longer need to buy one;-)

If we have children, we will change the wills and I will establish trusts and give some assets to him.

So, that was before we married. Prenup done. Wills done 5 months after wedding- there was back and forth with sol.

Not to offend some, but I also married him because I knew he will not divorce me- not because I am wonderful (which I am :-), but, like me, he believes in the sanctity of marriage (like me- we are both old-fashioned in that respect). He relayed how his first wife cheated on him- they married very very young- but he still didn't want to divorce her. I am not interested in cheating- never cheated. Nor would I stay with him if he cheated, but it demonstrated to me that he truly wants to be married. In fact he outright said he won't divorce.

So, I knew my money (assets) was safe- especially when I saved it from open jaws of many sharks as soon as I was single and even before. Nothing pits me off of a person than they being focused on a woman's money.

I have retained the flexibility I had before marriage and I decide what work I want to do and when. I didn't;t even work for 8 months until a month ago. DH also own a company which I will take over to run even from home (I like working from home and have always done even before the pandemic) so is now teaching me how to do it. My main career is on hold now as I plan how to incorporate in how I want to live my life in old age- once I decide how, I will also do it from home only and can do it along side the business things. I was already transitioning into doing business only (for more flexibility) with late DP, before I met DH. So, I am continuing with that transition.

When my outstanding debt (over a mil- or maybe I will get nothing) from the work I did with DP before sudden death comes, but if I do, and no matter the amount- I plan to invest it in a property in my name only. Since the debt was incurred before marriage, I don't believe I need a post-nup, but will take advice. Again, not that fussed although I do want to in my name to make things easy for myself. As I will need a small mortgage that should be easy as his credit rating is very bad 6 years after someone stole his earlier business.

I feel lucky and grateful things have worked out. Of course, others still haven't stopped trying their luck years on. One very recently even said, I am sorry your DH died lol lo I said, that was my DP. My DH is very much alive :-)

So, different people will always have different reasons for marrying, no matter their bank balance. Yes, I did feel like a celebrity, knowing I could very much find myself divorced within 3 months if it turned out to be a living hell- I was not shy to admit my mistake, but I am authentic and live an authentic and honest life. I also have a non-judgemental family who just want to see me happy :-)

While it's truly lovely to read your essay on how rich you are and how great your life is, cop the f on, the vast, vast majority of people do not have that experience. Read the room (if you're real). If you're on here much at all, you'll know that people are availing of food banks. Not because they're all lazy, or stupid, or whatever. Statistically, it's impossible for everyone to amass great wealth.

Globetrotterx · 05/08/2023 13:34

give, not Gove.

Globetrotterx · 05/08/2023 13:29

Long post (sorry short wasn't that short)

I am self-employed with an international career in a regulated sector and can work in over 54 countries so my earnings vary and can be as much as £400K in a year ( even much more, but that's enough for this purpose). However, I have 2 countries I can always work and live in with different economies which is helpful. So, I can change my circumstances at a moment's notice.

I have amassed a fortune from real hard-work. I am motivated by what I do and not by money. I therefore have never been money focused- this helped when it came to marrying- but I am values focussed. It's why you must believe those who say find your passion if it's money you want. So, in my belief, it is easy to make money - just work hard.

I then met a kindred heart (late DP) before I met my DH who was exactly like me and made his money similarly. We were drawn towards each other by values, passion and wanted to help others. We were planning to marry and he died of Covid- of course I was devastated as I didn't; have to ask if he was with me for money etc etc. We had an easy relationship. I am due a windfall from the work we did together before he died.

After DP's death, I had all sorts showing an interest in me while I was grieving, clearly because they saw an opening. It was DISGUSTING. My alarm bells went off and I knew I had to protect myself. Luckily I know the city well and the city types including pretenders- so it was easy to avoid them. Cut long story short, I decided to forget about men and focus on the work which would lift many people in 3rd world countries out of poverty and forget the rest. As I was putting those plans in motion, I met my DH.

He didn't know anything about me, but just saw a woman who he thought was delightful. He really admired all my hard work, principles and values. I admired his focus and determination.

Marriage: Before we married, he made it clear he wanted nothing from me and I believed him. He was previously married and his wife died young and I saw how they lived, which is how I would want in a marriage. She didn't work as he didn't care what she did. I liked that because I have always valued making my own decision about what was important to me at any given time. The idea that I must work when I don't need to, or I don't want, was very weird to me. Same as the idea that if I wanted to work, I cannot- I believe in having a voice and a choice. He owned his brand-new house outright- not worth millions, but it was important to me that he had a secure home for himself.On top of that, he ran a small business which had potential to grow; one part of it might even make him millions any day but he is working o that- it may start at a couple of hundred thousands first before bigger sums. I like self-employed people, because although I was self-employed, many times, my assignments could just be like proper employment and I know how fixed and rigid employers can be. Most people can meet up every 2 or 3 weeks because they are still developing their career. Yes, I leap frogged my career as I went self-employed so I progressed faster than people my age. So I really didn't want to marry someone who was a slave to an employer- I just didn't want. So for the first 2 years, we travelled the world as we were our own bosses. That's enough for that.

Before we married, we discussed our wills. I was clear that all my stuff would go to my family ( I married late and they were there every step of the way including some difficult times -very short times thank God-when a woman like me earns more than men and that's frown up). He was clear that all his stuff will go to me. I was shocked, but that's how I knew, he really wanted nothing from me. He then made proposals as to what to do with his things after he dies ,in my new will after his death ( he is 9 years older than me) although he knows that will be 100% my decision. I will honour it though. I have left all designer stuff to him (handbags, Cartier , shoes, day dresses, evening dresses etc) worth around £150K to him in the will. He will be able to sell it at a better value and Gove the money to my family. I trust him enough to sell it within 3 years. I have left him all the cash too as I have invested all the cash anyway ( I don't keep cash- when you start investing, you get used to a no cash mindset so that anytime I am waiting for a windfall, my mind goes into deciding what to invest it in), so any money in there when I die will have been acquired within marriage. However, a certain amount is for my funeral and rest for him. He owns a Bentley which I very much enjoy being driven in- I was jokingly mentioning that if I came into money and paid off all my mortgages, I would treat myself to a Bentley, and then I met my husband and as the friend I joked with said: "Oh, now you no longer need to buy one;-)

If we have children, we will change the wills and I will establish trusts and give some assets to him.

So, that was before we married. Prenup done. Wills done 5 months after wedding- there was back and forth with sol.

Not to offend some, but I also married him because I knew he will not divorce me- not because I am wonderful (which I am :-), but, like me, he believes in the sanctity of marriage (like me- we are both old-fashioned in that respect). He relayed how his first wife cheated on him- they married very very young- but he still didn't want to divorce her. I am not interested in cheating- never cheated. Nor would I stay with him if he cheated, but it demonstrated to me that he truly wants to be married. In fact he outright said he won't divorce.

So, I knew my money (assets) was safe- especially when I saved it from open jaws of many sharks as soon as I was single and even before. Nothing pits me off of a person than they being focused on a woman's money.

I have retained the flexibility I had before marriage and I decide what work I want to do and when. I didn't;t even work for 8 months until a month ago. DH also own a company which I will take over to run even from home (I like working from home and have always done even before the pandemic) so is now teaching me how to do it. My main career is on hold now as I plan how to incorporate in how I want to live my life in old age- once I decide how, I will also do it from home only and can do it along side the business things. I was already transitioning into doing business only (for more flexibility) with late DP, before I met DH. So, I am continuing with that transition.

When my outstanding debt (over a mil- or maybe I will get nothing) from the work I did with DP before sudden death comes, but if I do, and no matter the amount- I plan to invest it in a property in my name only. Since the debt was incurred before marriage, I don't believe I need a post-nup, but will take advice. Again, not that fussed although I do want to in my name to make things easy for myself. As I will need a small mortgage that should be easy as his credit rating is very bad 6 years after someone stole his earlier business.

I feel lucky and grateful things have worked out. Of course, others still haven't stopped trying their luck years on. One very recently even said, I am sorry your DH died lol lo I said, that was my DP. My DH is very much alive :-)

So, different people will always have different reasons for marrying, no matter their bank balance. Yes, I did feel like a celebrity, knowing I could very much find myself divorced within 3 months if it turned out to be a living hell- I was not shy to admit my mistake, but I am authentic and live an authentic and honest life. I also have a non-judgemental family who just want to see me happy :-)

Globetrotterx · 05/08/2023 12:15

Name changed for this.

Thanks to OP for starting this thread. I am in the minority. I was in the meeting yesterday so I couldn't post but read most comments- sorry haven't read today's but I will. I will post twice. Short and long.

Short:
Get legal protection. I did a prenup as advised by my twice married friend- I wasn't fussed either way, but it was good to have it during the first few years (1st 2 years) as I adjusted to a new life.
I married late- subject of long post.
I met and married my DH in less than 3 months.
In my circumstances I would not marry JUST anyone (love or no love- I fall deeply lol), or marry just anyone that quickly (again love or no love)- reasons for accepting to marry DH in long post- so he was an exception.
I wouldn't marry just for IHT reasons.

Trust- elaborated in long post as clearly I have only known my Dh 3 weeks before proposal, so I need to explain what I mean- but that played a major role.
It was my decision as much as it was his, and I wanted and was ready for a change- otherwise, I wouldn't have married. As complicated as all that sound, I unbelievably can look at life in a simplistic way sometimes which can work for some but not for all. It works for me, because I take an informed decision, have many alternatives which I accept most people don't have, so I know I can always pick myself up.

Now off to long post.

I agree that posts that make other posters feel they didn't choose well, gave up too quickly etc etc are unhelpful and even hurtful. Whatever the financial cost to me, I would not stay in an abusive etc etc etc marriage a second longer!

Brefugee · 05/08/2023 11:18

magicalkitty · 05/08/2023 09:00

All her money would have been on childcare costs, he refused to pay towards it as he thought it was pointless for her to work.

And anyway, do you not think she was entitled to a share of what was effectively the family home, seeing as she nurtured and took 10+ years out of her life for THEIR children, while he just carried on his life as usual?

frankly? that should have been a clue for her to a) get back to work asap and b) not have a 2nd child with him, especially with such a huge gap.

And this is why we tell women, constantly repeatedly and as if we are banging our heads against a brick wall until our brains bleed out: marry the father of your children, and secure your future independence/finances as much as you can.

whumpthereitis · 05/08/2023 11:05

Rocknrollstar · 05/08/2023 10:03

DiL has always been the higher earner and for much of their marriage DS has been a SAHF. She didn’t need someone who could earn a lot of money. she could do that herself. What she needed was someone who was warm, loving and caring and that was my son. She put down the deposit for their first home and he insisted on having a legal document drawn up that said if they split up she should get her money back. He has twice given up a career to look after the family. They have a very strong marriage and I find it so sad that people have put money before marriage. DH and I met when we were very young and had nothing so everything we have accrued through work has been shared.

Financial stress is one of the main causes of marital breakdown, however warm and loving a marriage may otherwise be. It’s disingenuous to pretend that money doesn’t matter when it absolutely does.

Personally I didn’t date men that weren’t on an equal financial footing to me. That isn’t to say that I put money over kindness, love, companionship et al, as I looked for those things as well. It isn’t the case that love and financial security are binary. If other people want to date/marry someone that isn’t on the same footing as them then that’s totally up to them, but choosing not to is an equally valid choice.

Caprisunny · 05/08/2023 10:10

Rocknrollstar · 05/08/2023 10:03

DiL has always been the higher earner and for much of their marriage DS has been a SAHF. She didn’t need someone who could earn a lot of money. she could do that herself. What she needed was someone who was warm, loving and caring and that was my son. She put down the deposit for their first home and he insisted on having a legal document drawn up that said if they split up she should get her money back. He has twice given up a career to look after the family. They have a very strong marriage and I find it so sad that people have put money before marriage. DH and I met when we were very young and had nothing so everything we have accrued through work has been shared.

Why does it make you sad?

Marriage is a legal and financial agreement. Some people don’t want it.

What is it about marriage that you hold so dear, that you think it people should risk their financial futures on it. Why do feel people should prioritise marriage?

Your son signed an agreement she gets her deposit back. In reality that will mean very little if they have a long marriage. He would still get half the equity. Which would outweigh her deposit.

and let’s not pretend that situation is the norm. It’s not the norm for men to be a sahd and actually take on the vast majority care for the kids, including all the things like doctors and dentists and after school activities. It’s great your son has, but it’s not the norm yet.

Rocknrollstar · 05/08/2023 10:03

DiL has always been the higher earner and for much of their marriage DS has been a SAHF. She didn’t need someone who could earn a lot of money. she could do that herself. What she needed was someone who was warm, loving and caring and that was my son. She put down the deposit for their first home and he insisted on having a legal document drawn up that said if they split up she should get her money back. He has twice given up a career to look after the family. They have a very strong marriage and I find it so sad that people have put money before marriage. DH and I met when we were very young and had nothing so everything we have accrued through work has been shared.

whumpthereitis · 05/08/2023 09:32

magicalkitty · 05/08/2023 09:00

All her money would have been on childcare costs, he refused to pay towards it as he thought it was pointless for her to work.

And anyway, do you not think she was entitled to a share of what was effectively the family home, seeing as she nurtured and took 10+ years out of her life for THEIR children, while he just carried on his life as usual?

She’s responsible for her own choices. She chose to have children with a man she wasn’t married to, and she chose to make herself financially dependent on him.

Jumpingthruhoops · 05/08/2023 09:30

Caprisunny · 05/08/2023 05:23

Yes the reply was to you.

The comment you said wasn’t condescending was condescending. That comment was made by someone who has been married 2/3 years. Because that’s the comment we are talking about.

If you aren’t talking about divorce then I don’t get your point at all. Because I was specifically referencing a comment about divorce. And if they live in the martial home and leave to cut ties, the inevitable step is divorce.

It’s condescending to say ‘I just know I won’t get divorced. Me and my husband will work on our marriage. People just give up to easily and we won’t’. That poster might have well finished off with ‘we are just built different’

That same poster then went on to tell someone how they were partially to blame for their husband cheating. They were condescending and quite cruel.

With respect, you don't know everybody's situation. Nor do you know everything about divorce.

I know at least three couples who have officially separated and live apart but are still married, so divorce isn't 'inevitable'. One woman I know just upped an left a few years back and she and her (still) husband have never had an actual conversation. That's what I'm talking about.

I don't agree with 'victim blaming' but, as we know, there are always two sides to every story.

Giveover80 · 05/08/2023 09:17

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

G5000 · 05/08/2023 09:12

in a very comfortable position thanks to child and spousal maintenance. a secent ex though

So your ex pays voluntarily way more than he would be legally required? That's of course very decent of him. But you know spousal maintenance is very rare nowadays, there are billions in child maintenance owed in the UK and half of single-parent families live below the poverty line. So still a risky business to give up your career and keep fingers crossed that your dh will also be a decent ex.

Giveover80 · 05/08/2023 09:10

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

HappyAsASandboy · 05/08/2023 09:05

When I married I was in a far better financial position to my now husband. I owned a property, I earned more money, I had significant savings where he had none. I was definitely bring more financial input to the "all that I have, I share with you" aspect of our marriage!

I didn't hesitate to get married. Our joint plan for the future was together, and that meant all assets becoming joint.

Having said that, the assets remained in my name and under my control - they're really only joint in name (ie if we were to separate or if I was to die).

Since my marriage, things have worked out most as we thought they would. I retained my fairly high-earning career, but also became "default parent" because I wanted to be at every nativity play, take maximum leave, take days off when they're ill etc. this has enabled my husband to focus on his career and he has gone from earning 3/5ths of my salary to earning 2x my salary.

So I guess because my marriage is still strong, marriage was the right thing for me despite me holding all the money on the way in. Our marriage has benefited (and continues to benefit) from my initial assets, but we also benefit from my husbands higher salary.

Whether or not I'd recommend someone else in my position to marry depends on the intended partner. What is his attitude to work? What is his financial potential and will he put the work in to reach it? What is his attitude to "her" money? Are day-to-day spending habits aligned between them (and if not, who is the spender?!)? How old are they (if I was in the better financial position and beyond the "building a family" years then I think I'd want to keep separate finances because there's no reason not to!)?

Marriage is a bit of a leap of faith.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 05/08/2023 09:04

All her money would have been on childcare costs, he refused to pay towards it as he thought it was pointless for her to work.

Maybe it would. But the issue here is that this is misogynist if not abusive from the outset.

Not so much - 'should she have married' but more 'should she have reproduced with this particular specimen?'

And if she hadn't given up her work then she'd have had ongoing financial security.

And anyway, do you not think she was entitled to a share of what was effectively the family home, seeing as she nurtured and took 10+ years out of her life for THEIR children, while he just carried on his life as usual?

What on Earth made you think I didn't think she was entitled to this?

magicalkitty · 05/08/2023 09:00

YetAnotherSpartacus · 05/08/2023 08:58

If they had been married she would have been entitled to a share of the house.

If she hadn't given up her job she'd have been financially independent.

All her money would have been on childcare costs, he refused to pay towards it as he thought it was pointless for her to work.

And anyway, do you not think she was entitled to a share of what was effectively the family home, seeing as she nurtured and took 10+ years out of her life for THEIR children, while he just carried on his life as usual?

wedding12341 · 05/08/2023 08:59

Thanks all for the input - been an interesting insight with no clear persuasion either way I'd say.

I'm sure if it were a man rather than a woman perspective there would be more of a general consensus but appreciate it may not be considers as apples and apples for comparison.

Overall I think the legal protection for marriage is a good reason for it - inheritance tax also.

OP posts:
YetAnotherSpartacus · 05/08/2023 08:58

If they had been married she would have been entitled to a share of the house.

If she hadn't given up her job she'd have been financially independent.

magicalkitty · 05/08/2023 08:45
  • let me take a punt

you have ZERO experience of divorcing in this country in the above scenario you outline*

Eh?

I'm not sure you understand what I am saying.

I have a friend who had two children with a very wealthy man. They never married. She wanted to, he said there is no need, he will look after her. They don't need marriage. After kids She didn't work, she stayed at home to look after the kids - he said it's best this way due to childcare costs. She was in her mid-20s and her previous salary would only have just about covered childcare costs.

So she stopped work when the first child was born. When child started primary school, they had their second child. When the second child started primary, she had been out of work for 10 years.

A couple of years later, he decided the relationship wasn't what he wanted anymore. Actually, he had found another woman.

The house was in his name, she had to move out with the kids and find somewhere to rent. He paid child maintenance of course until the youngest was 18, but she found it hard to find work after the gap and only having a few years experience under her belt pre-kids. She could only get hired for minimum wage jobs.

If they had been married she would have been entitled to a share of the house.