Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Controversial marriage question

385 replies

wedding12341 · 04/08/2023 09:45

Thinking about another thread on here where someone has moved in and had children with their fiancé who has now changed his mind about getting married. Someone on the thread said it is just a small minority of women that are disadvantaged by marriage.

Eg - the woman brings more assets / money to the marriage than the man.

Based on the above

If you were one of these women in the minority (or your friend / daughter was) - Would you advise them not to get married?

OP posts:
Linzipinsy1590 · 05/08/2023 21:37

I wouldn't get married but then again I'd never live with anyone again neither. Sounds really odd, but I protect myself financially for my kids future

Thepeopleversuswork · 05/08/2023 21:36

CKL987 · 05/08/2023 21:32

It's all well and good to not get married to protect your assets from divorce but if you don't you need to do your financial planning in case of death.

Well yes but that’s a small price to pay to avoid giving half of your assets away.

CKL987 · 05/08/2023 21:32

It's all well and good to not get married to protect your assets from divorce but if you don't you need to do your financial planning in case of death.

Hardhat2 · 05/08/2023 21:04

In the minority

i would advise against marriage

had one divorce as marriage was just long enough for 50/50 - so that pay off was painful, he made a great return

Haven’t married in current marriage-like relationship, and kids are involved this time. I’ve sorted my will though.

frazzledasarock · 05/08/2023 21:03

DH and I bought similar assets to our relationship. If I had more than him I wouldn’t have married him. My career progression took the hit when I had dc with him, his carried on. I didn’t go part time or stop but the year I took out for mat leave materially affected my career. His was fine.

i would tell my DC to ensure they’re never financially dependent on anyone, and if they have DC to ensure they’re married and all assets are under joint names, otherwise don’t have dc and ensure you have assets and the ability to comfortably financially support yourself.

love doesn’t put a roof over your head.

Thepeopleversuswork · 05/08/2023 20:55

@Threenow

Thankfully I move in more normal circles, where people choose a partner based on love and respect rather than their earning potential.

Well that's all tickety-boo until the marriage fails (as just under half of them currently do).

Giving away half the money I've spent the last 30 years working my arse off for to a bloke because he's married to me, thus depriving my kid of their inheritance and despite the fact that he hasn't contributed materially to my household wealth, is a chance I'm not prepared to take. I narrowly avoided having to give half my house away to my ex, despite the fact I looked after his kid single handedly and worked FT. Which is why I would never marry my OH even though I "love and respect" him. Love and respect for a partner is all good and well but it will never trump my responsibilities to my child. That's a fairly specific example (because we don't share a child) but the same principle applies even with shared children.

If that makes me mercenary, so be it. Better mercenary than shafted.

Marriage was designed as a mechanism to protect women from unscrupulous men running off and leaving them penniless while they were at home giving birth to, nursing and caring for multiple children. It's evolved since then, for sure, but it is not and was never meant to be a way for a bloke (who doesn't have to give birth and is very unlikely to be looking after kids) to grab half of his wife's assets just because he is married.

Why should a bloke (who doesn't bear the same burden as a woman with respect to childrearing and childcare) benefit from what is essentially supposed to be a insurance policy for the child-rearing sex?

Onnonotagainhuh · 05/08/2023 20:50

I saw a friend with significant assets, several let properties and a well paid job, get married and divorced within two years to a guy who had been sacked from his job and came in to the marriage with very little compared to her. They had a baby in that time.

He took everything through the courts and wanted more than half of everything! Still hasn't been settled and they've been fighting it out longer than the marriage lasted.

Tbh, in a very mismatched case I wouldn't recommend marriage without a pre-nup after seeing this.

Threenow · 05/08/2023 20:43

AlltheFs · 04/08/2023 18:53

Jesus Fucking Christ. What a way to bring up your children.

Some incredibly talented, very hard working people work in lower paid careers. Academics for example get paid fuck all. Is that not good enough for you?

What if for example you have a male MP vs a female investment banker. Is that not ok either?

Lots of very happy relationships exist where the man earns less than the woman. Does not mean they aren’t doing something worthwhile and working very hard.

Well said. Being on MN has been a revelation to me as I have never in my whole life come across so many women who are totally focussed on their career and the amount of money they have. Thankfully I move in more normal circles, where people choose a partner based on love and respect rather than their earning potential.

Isaidnomorecrisps · 05/08/2023 20:31

I wouldn’t marry.
I benefited from the 50/50 U.K. asset split rules on divorce and I’ve seen how awful the process is. We both worked full time for decades but my exH earned 3x my salary. I still got half our assets.
I don’t think he’s ever got over it.
Where I think U.K. law is fair is that I was able to get a house relatively close to his (he kept it) so our children had proper bedrooms at both places.
So I guess I’m saying don’t marry but if they/you have kids and then split up don’t be a xxxx in ensuring the ex can have the kids say 50/50 in a home they are used to.

Thepeopleversuswork · 05/08/2023 20:28

I don't actually understand where marriage fits in this time/age and it is astounds me that we don't have more teachings on it in school or something, along the lines of sex ed. Maybe it's just me, but everything about marriage in movies and society is about romantic love, fidelity, infidelity perhaps, the ideal being the romantic life partner... But in reality, none of that really matters, it's actually all about a legal contract and the obligations that come with it. If I knew what I knew now, I'd never have gotten married in a million years

I totally agree with this. The lens through which we see marriage is shockingly outdated and the emphasis on love and romance instils a wilful ignorance which is damaging to men and women.

I find it absolutely astonishing how few people understand that if you are married the working assumption is that your spouse will be entitled to half your assets. It beggars belief that people aren’t told about this when embarking on marriage. People spend months of their lives and tens of thousands of pounds on weddings, right down to fretting about napkins and bridesmaids shoes and other completely irrelevant details but fail to do the most basic self education around the legal and financial aspects of marriage.

It’s absolutely Medieval.

Mumof3confused · 05/08/2023 20:22

Pre-nips are not legally binding though, and ‘needs’ trumps pre-nups.

You can have mirror wills to protect both of you in case the other person dies.

Susiefish21 · 05/08/2023 20:22

You might want half his pension if he dies before you.

AmberMcAmber · 05/08/2023 20:10

I can here to shout that it’s an ‘out’ thing not a ‘me/you’ thing once you are married
there are other benefits too like inheriting the other’s assets so that if one of you dies, any children aren’t forced out of their home (or even the surviving partner of Jo kids) following bereavement
you can put all of these things into place but you have to know them all & then pay for a solicitor to do it

obviously if it’s not first marriage for either party, particularly if there are pre-existing children then it’s messy…

if I were in the position where I had a lot to lose (and still wanted to marry someone) then I’d get a pre-nup so that during relationship things are shared but that if they broke trust then I’m not as financially vulnerable

Mumof3confused · 05/08/2023 20:06

justtryingtodotherightthing · 05/08/2023 18:47

I don't actually understand where marriage fits in this time/age and it is astounds me that we don't have more teachings on it in school or something, along the lines of sex ed. Maybe it's just me, but everything about marriage in movies and society is about romantic love, fidelity, infidelity perhaps, the ideal being the romantic life partner... But in reality, none of that really matters, it's actually all about a legal contract and the obligations that come with it. If I knew what I knew now, I'd never have gotten married in a million years. I mean, I understood the commitment I was making on a moral level, for better or worse, in sickness etc... But I truly didn't understand that when I decided that after 20 years of standing by my wife and supporting her in every way, that when I eventually decided I couldn't do it any more and tried to work out an amicable separation that I'd be thrown out of the house, stopped from seeing my children, and held hostage to support her in perpetuity and be stripped of our wealth fighting shitty legal battles with the overall losers being our children.

Nope. Never again.

Any future partner, they can have their things, their house, their everything... I'll have mine, and we can have date nights :) lol.

I'm in the bitter phase, I admit. But independence and boundaries are so important, and understanding the legal obligations that marriage entails should be better taught to all.

I wholeheartedly agree, you should be made to take a short course on the reality of what you are signing up to and the likely scenarios of what might happen if/when you get divorced. I was told that as a mum, it was important to get married as it would somehow ‘protect’ me and I believed this. It’s the complete opposite if you are the one who brings assets to a relationship and happens to be more ambitious or hard working than your partner.

Mumof3confused · 05/08/2023 20:01

Having brought several hundred thousand pounds into our marriage and being the more hardworking one (both at work and at home), going through divorce now, I would say to ANYONE who has assets and ambition to be extremely careful. You will very likely end up with LESS than your partner from the shared assets if your marriage breaks down. Nobody gets married thinking it might not last, the reality is a large proportion of marriages do break down.

MissRoo1982 · 05/08/2023 19:29

Being on Mumsnet has actually confirmed to me I’m better of being childfree and unmarried. I had decided this a few years ago even though I’m in a relationship and sometimes while I’ve thought what if - I’ve realised being independent as much as possible is my actual security in life.

Chickenkeev · 05/08/2023 19:07

justtryingtodotherightthing · 05/08/2023 18:47

I don't actually understand where marriage fits in this time/age and it is astounds me that we don't have more teachings on it in school or something, along the lines of sex ed. Maybe it's just me, but everything about marriage in movies and society is about romantic love, fidelity, infidelity perhaps, the ideal being the romantic life partner... But in reality, none of that really matters, it's actually all about a legal contract and the obligations that come with it. If I knew what I knew now, I'd never have gotten married in a million years. I mean, I understood the commitment I was making on a moral level, for better or worse, in sickness etc... But I truly didn't understand that when I decided that after 20 years of standing by my wife and supporting her in every way, that when I eventually decided I couldn't do it any more and tried to work out an amicable separation that I'd be thrown out of the house, stopped from seeing my children, and held hostage to support her in perpetuity and be stripped of our wealth fighting shitty legal battles with the overall losers being our children.

Nope. Never again.

Any future partner, they can have their things, their house, their everything... I'll have mine, and we can have date nights :) lol.

I'm in the bitter phase, I admit. But independence and boundaries are so important, and understanding the legal obligations that marriage entails should be better taught to all.

You're 100% right, it should be taught in schools. It'd be way more useful than lots of what is taught. And so many people don't get the life lessons from their own parents. There are relationship courses/ sex ed, but nothing to do with marriage and the legal connotations.

AnnieSnap · 05/08/2023 18:58

I earned several times more than my ex husband and my income (we’re both retired) is twice my current husband’s. I love him, so it doesn’t matter.

justtryingtodotherightthing · 05/08/2023 18:47

I don't actually understand where marriage fits in this time/age and it is astounds me that we don't have more teachings on it in school or something, along the lines of sex ed. Maybe it's just me, but everything about marriage in movies and society is about romantic love, fidelity, infidelity perhaps, the ideal being the romantic life partner... But in reality, none of that really matters, it's actually all about a legal contract and the obligations that come with it. If I knew what I knew now, I'd never have gotten married in a million years. I mean, I understood the commitment I was making on a moral level, for better or worse, in sickness etc... But I truly didn't understand that when I decided that after 20 years of standing by my wife and supporting her in every way, that when I eventually decided I couldn't do it any more and tried to work out an amicable separation that I'd be thrown out of the house, stopped from seeing my children, and held hostage to support her in perpetuity and be stripped of our wealth fighting shitty legal battles with the overall losers being our children.

Nope. Never again.

Any future partner, they can have their things, their house, their everything... I'll have mine, and we can have date nights :) lol.

I'm in the bitter phase, I admit. But independence and boundaries are so important, and understanding the legal obligations that marriage entails should be better taught to all.

Notadramallama · 05/08/2023 18:30

Jumpingthruhoops · 04/08/2023 17:31

Sorry to hear that. I'm under no illusion that people change, circumstances change. But, as it stands, we're nearly 30 years strong. He's my best friend.

My ex husband and I were 20 years in. He was my best friend. I would have staked my life that he wouldn't cheat, but he did. You sound incredibly naive.

I have asserts of around £600k. My boyfriend has maybe a tenth of that. We will get married but my assets will be protected beforehand.

neighboursmustliveon · 05/08/2023 18:27

My oldest friend is one of those women who would be disadvantaged.

She owns (with small mortgage) the home they live in. She is only child and will inherit a fair amount assuming her currently healthy parents don’t require care homes.

Her partner doesn’t contribute much, all cash in hand, gives her money toowards bills. Has a child from a prev relationship they have one child together.

He is still on the mortgage with his ex and pays for his child well - even continued paying when child lived with them 100% during covid ie for well over a year.

I’ve told her if they get married and she goes before him, all het hard work and her grandparents and parents inheritance will go as a min minimum to her partners other child. There is massive favouritism with the older child in his family so I wouldn’t put it past him giving this child more than half if I’m honest.

Chickenkeev · 05/08/2023 18:19

Thepeopleversuswork · 05/08/2023 18:11

@Chickenkeev

Tbf, the posts that say you shouldn't have children out of wedlock are mainly saying so because it seems to be so easy for men to disappear into the ether when they're not married. I don't think a lot of the advice is based on a traditional mindset iyswim. More a protective one.

Sometimes, yes; there are those awful threads where someone tips up and says "he's been promising to propose to me for 15 years, I've got three kids and haven't worked for a decade" etc etc, in which its very clear cut that the OP should have insisted on marriage or walked out a long time ago.

But then an awful lot of "why aren't you married" posts. Or people saying "if he was really committed to you he'd have married you by now". It's still very much painted as a "prize" which every women has to aspire to, regardless of what her individual circumstances are. Partly, I think, because it's seen as a bellwether of a man's commitment and assumption is that the woman always wants it. But also because the default assumption is that the man will be or go on to be the breadwinner. When this is by no means always true these days.

I totally get you, everything you're saying but people are sometimes genuinely (rightly or wrongly) coming at it from a point of legal protection. Rather than lock him in or whatever. Women are screwed either way, marry for security and be judged, or don't marry for whatever reason and still be judged. There's no escape is there!

PinkCherryBlossoms · 05/08/2023 18:14

The posts about if the man was really committed he'd have married you by now are generally made in posts where the woman wants marriage and has been fobbed off. It's not a default assumption in that situation, it's a comment on the reality of the situation. That's not a good example.

Thepeopleversuswork · 05/08/2023 18:11

@Chickenkeev

Tbf, the posts that say you shouldn't have children out of wedlock are mainly saying so because it seems to be so easy for men to disappear into the ether when they're not married. I don't think a lot of the advice is based on a traditional mindset iyswim. More a protective one.

Sometimes, yes; there are those awful threads where someone tips up and says "he's been promising to propose to me for 15 years, I've got three kids and haven't worked for a decade" etc etc, in which its very clear cut that the OP should have insisted on marriage or walked out a long time ago.

But then an awful lot of "why aren't you married" posts. Or people saying "if he was really committed to you he'd have married you by now". It's still very much painted as a "prize" which every women has to aspire to, regardless of what her individual circumstances are. Partly, I think, because it's seen as a bellwether of a man's commitment and assumption is that the woman always wants it. But also because the default assumption is that the man will be or go on to be the breadwinner. When this is by no means always true these days.

Chickenkeev · 05/08/2023 18:06

Thepeopleversuswork · 05/08/2023 17:48

Indeed. But it’s interesting that although the moral justification for marriage has largely now been shown to be ridiculous, a lot of people still cling to the idea that it’s automatically the right thing to do in any LTR which involves children.

You get tons of posts on here when parrot the idea that you should refuse to have children outside of wedlock.

Of course in many circumstances this is absolutely correct: specifically when a woman isn’t working, marriage is essential. But it’s by no means a silver bullet in any scenario. There increasingly are a lot of situations where marriage is the worst thing a woman can do.

I wish we could all have a more pragmatic and grown up conversation about marriage: stop seeing it as an ultimate life goal and start seeing it more as a useful tool to be applied in the right circumstances.

Tbf, the posts that say you shouldn't have children out of wedlock are mainly saying so because it seems to be so easy for men to disappear into the ether when they're not married. I don't think a lot of the advice is based on a traditional mindset iyswim. More a protective one.

Swipe left for the next trending thread