Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Controversial marriage question

385 replies

wedding12341 · 04/08/2023 09:45

Thinking about another thread on here where someone has moved in and had children with their fiancé who has now changed his mind about getting married. Someone on the thread said it is just a small minority of women that are disadvantaged by marriage.

Eg - the woman brings more assets / money to the marriage than the man.

Based on the above

If you were one of these women in the minority (or your friend / daughter was) - Would you advise them not to get married?

OP posts:
wikidee · 06/08/2023 11:24

I am Male and I have been married 4 times , my first wife took everything whilst i was out at work , the 2nd wife took nothing , the 3rd wife tried to take everything but was stopped by the courts and I have been married to my 4th wife 16 years . My point is this marriage is about love and how you feel about one another it should not be about who owns what . If I die I have just left everything to my 4th wife and visa versa . At the end of the day you cannot take material things with you and it is just stuff whereas love is everything and if you truly love someone then material possessions should not even enter the equation

Ohmygiddyauntie · 06/08/2023 11:02

Thepeopleversuswork · 06/08/2023 10:40

@Ohmygiddyauntie

Marriage goes beyond just being a measurable concept (Quantifiable). It provides valuable qualitative advantages.

A stable family based on two committed parents working together in the interest of the family unit provides qualitative advantages for sure. I’m not clear that marriage itself is what provides the advantage.

Marriage is often a mechanism to support this stability for the reasons discussed above
(ie that it provides financial stability for the woman, increasing the overall financial “pot” and makes it much more complicated for either of the parties to just up sticks and leave.)

But the only reason this is necessary in the first place is because women often struggle to support themselves when they are rearing children.

Its the financial wellbeing and continuity that provides the qualitative advantage to families, as opposed to something intrinsic to marriage. If women can provide this themselves marriage becomes an irrelevance.

Qualatative as you know doesn't just embrace the practicalites.

This discussion resembles the Utilitarian vs Hedonic debate. Both Dp and I place greater importance on the emotional rewards of relationships rather than just focusing on financial aspects and spreadsheets.
The focus is on adding value rather than simply tallying it up.

Thepeopleversuswork · 06/08/2023 11:02

Lennon80 · 06/08/2023 10:56

Absolutely - baffles me!

But often we are talking about situations where people who already have children from previous marriages remarry.

In that scenario the risk is that a spouse or partner stands to inherit money amassed under the previous marriage and earmarked for the children by virtue of the fact they are marrying.

I agree in principle having a child is a contract but it’s one which isn’t always honoured by both parties. If your marriage fails (and often they do), surely you have the right and the responsibility to prioritise your children in any subsequent?

Lennon80 · 06/08/2023 10:56

gogomoto · 04/08/2023 11:03

I don't understand people having a child with someone, a lifetime commitment, but unwilling to share finances. Surely if you can't agree on money or share finances then why would you bring a child into this world. Marriage is a contract but so is agreeing to have a child

Absolutely - baffles me!

Thepeopleversuswork · 06/08/2023 10:40

@Ohmygiddyauntie

Marriage goes beyond just being a measurable concept (Quantifiable). It provides valuable qualitative advantages.

A stable family based on two committed parents working together in the interest of the family unit provides qualitative advantages for sure. I’m not clear that marriage itself is what provides the advantage.

Marriage is often a mechanism to support this stability for the reasons discussed above
(ie that it provides financial stability for the woman, increasing the overall financial “pot” and makes it much more complicated for either of the parties to just up sticks and leave.)

But the only reason this is necessary in the first place is because women often struggle to support themselves when they are rearing children.

Its the financial wellbeing and continuity that provides the qualitative advantage to families, as opposed to something intrinsic to marriage. If women can provide this themselves marriage becomes an irrelevance.

TrishM80 · 06/08/2023 10:28

Onnonotagainhuh · 05/08/2023 20:50

I saw a friend with significant assets, several let properties and a well paid job, get married and divorced within two years to a guy who had been sacked from his job and came in to the marriage with very little compared to her. They had a baby in that time.

He took everything through the courts and wanted more than half of everything! Still hasn't been settled and they've been fighting it out longer than the marriage lasted.

Tbh, in a very mismatched case I wouldn't recommend marriage without a pre-nup after seeing this.

I think a lot of divorced men would say to your friend "welcome to our world"!

Ohmygiddyauntie · 06/08/2023 10:16

Thepeopleversuswork · 06/08/2023 09:06

Millions of people sleepwalk into being financially trapped because they believe marriage is a “symbol of love”.

Yes love should be present. But constructing a lifelong contract around love and thinking that everything will be ok is like gambling with your life. Love won’t keep a roof over your head and put food on the table.

I agree on the second paragraph though. For women who don’t need financial support it’s far better not to marry, or cohabit.

Marriage goes beyond just being a measurable concept (Quantifiable). It provides valuable qualitative advantages.

Kteeb1 · 06/08/2023 09:16

As someone going through a horrible divorce, I doubt I would marry again. Precisely because I'm older now and very financially secure, marrying wouldn't bring me much. I am in a new relationship who I care for very much, but if we ever move in together I will be having legal agreements to protect us both. I would want to know going on that in the event I came out, I wouldn't be adding to my trauma by having to argue about finances. I split up with someone who I wasn't married to after 10 years and it was. Much easier. Being married hasn't given me anything but heartache and finances down the drain. Be very careful who you trust!

Thepeopleversuswork · 06/08/2023 09:06

Missingmyusername · 06/08/2023 08:55

“Because as I have explained upthread the point of marriage is to protect the financially weaker partner in the marriage from being left or exploited.”

Nonsense. Marriage should be a symbol of love and respect and a life long commitment. You need to raise the bar in the first place I think. Don’t get married, don’t live with a man and don’t have children - problem solved.

Millions of people sleepwalk into being financially trapped because they believe marriage is a “symbol of love”.

Yes love should be present. But constructing a lifelong contract around love and thinking that everything will be ok is like gambling with your life. Love won’t keep a roof over your head and put food on the table.

I agree on the second paragraph though. For women who don’t need financial support it’s far better not to marry, or cohabit.

Missingmyusername · 06/08/2023 08:55

“Because as I have explained upthread the point of marriage is to protect the financially weaker partner in the marriage from being left or exploited.”

Nonsense. Marriage should be a symbol of love and respect and a life long commitment. You need to raise the bar in the first place I think. Don’t get married, don’t live with a man and don’t have children - problem solved.

Thepeopleversuswork · 06/08/2023 08:42

@Mumof2teens79

Thats all true. Men generally benefit from marriage in a variety of ways. The only situation in which women benefit is when they are not able to generate their own money.

Thepeopleversuswork · 06/08/2023 08:37

@Missingmyusername

Erm so if the man earns more then you marry, but if the woman earns more then you don’t… love it lol 🤣🤣

Thats over-simplifying a bit but basically yes.

Because as I have explained upthread the point of marriage is to protect the financially weaker partner in the marriage from being left or exploited. This partner is almost always the woman. And the fact that the woman is usually weaker is because she gets pregnant, gives birth, then can take several years off to care for her children.

No man will ever give birth and very few take years off to care for children. So women’s ability to work and support themselves is hugely damaged by childbearing. While a man is able to amass more money (usually).

Marriage is basically compensation and insurance against this happening. This scenario almost never applies to men because it is never men who jeopardise their finances to look after children so why should they get to benefit from a mechanism which was set up to protect women from this?

Mumof2teens79 · 06/08/2023 08:34

Thepeopleversuswork · 05/08/2023 20:55

@Threenow

Thankfully I move in more normal circles, where people choose a partner based on love and respect rather than their earning potential.

Well that's all tickety-boo until the marriage fails (as just under half of them currently do).

Giving away half the money I've spent the last 30 years working my arse off for to a bloke because he's married to me, thus depriving my kid of their inheritance and despite the fact that he hasn't contributed materially to my household wealth, is a chance I'm not prepared to take. I narrowly avoided having to give half my house away to my ex, despite the fact I looked after his kid single handedly and worked FT. Which is why I would never marry my OH even though I "love and respect" him. Love and respect for a partner is all good and well but it will never trump my responsibilities to my child. That's a fairly specific example (because we don't share a child) but the same principle applies even with shared children.

If that makes me mercenary, so be it. Better mercenary than shafted.

Marriage was designed as a mechanism to protect women from unscrupulous men running off and leaving them penniless while they were at home giving birth to, nursing and caring for multiple children. It's evolved since then, for sure, but it is not and was never meant to be a way for a bloke (who doesn't have to give birth and is very unlikely to be looking after kids) to grab half of his wife's assets just because he is married.

Why should a bloke (who doesn't bear the same burden as a woman with respect to childrearing and childcare) benefit from what is essentially supposed to be a insurance policy for the child-rearing sex?

Marriage was invented by various patriarchal societies and religions and in most cases involved the paying of a dowry by the brides family to the groom, or conversely the groom "buying" the bride and paying a bride price to her family.
There was (ideally) some protection of the wife during marriage and in some cases a requirement to support her even if the husband took another wife but in many cases historically in most societies anywhere "assets" or "status" were involved (so not poorer families who lived hand to mouth) it was a carefully negotiated arrangement in which typically the husband DID accumulate and absord the assets and the brides family hopefully benefitted from his status and no-longer having to support her.

Mumof2teens79 · 06/08/2023 08:14

wedding12341 · 04/08/2023 11:22

Yes this is why I posted it as a controversial question. As like you say - the standard is that the higher earning man (more often than not) is mean for not marrying and therefore protecting the wife financially.

It's an odd one to square in my mind. I think that's partly because it tends to be the woman that uses maternity and doesn't go back full time / sacrificing career when children come along.

It doesn't seem fair to have a different view depending on man or woman though.

Is this question about marriage or children though?
I am married, with children and have always worked full time (except two fairly short mat leaves)
I have friends who are in long term relationships with children but never married...and many of them don't work or have only recently returned to part time work
I have friends who are married with no children.

I am financially disadvantaged by having children but my husbands income off-sets that.

Also, not sure on the legal financial side of separation but are we talking strictly about a legal marriage or any long term relationship?

Missingmyusername · 06/08/2023 08:10

Erm so if the man earns more then you marry, but if the woman earns more then you don’t… love it lol 🤣🤣

I was the higher earner but now I’m not. I was desperately unhappy and have made a career change. We share everything, including money. We are compatible, we’re on the same page, neither one of us has a crazy expensive hobby, neither of us smoke. Husband isn’t interested in the home really, so I’m free to decorate as I wish.

He’s not that bothered about money come to think of it.

Ohmygiddyauntie · 06/08/2023 08:01

The most important takeaway is that divorce can be expensive. In our case, I have considerable assets and a high salary, while my partner has fewer assets but earns significantly more. Despite this, we both still want to get married again in the future. We're not dwelling on worst-case scenarios, and the idea of a lifelong commitment is still attractive to us despite our past divorces.

justtryingtodotherightthing · 06/08/2023 07:52

The point I was making was that we seem to learn very little about the legal contract that is marriage, and what it totally entails. For me this is not so much about protecting my assets, but about understanding the legal consequences of what has to happen if both/one of you decide to break that contract and divorce and especially so of it is not amicable or you simply don't have similar understanding/expectations around that process. Everything being "ours" is fine when you're a team, and it doesn't matter if one earns more / less if you're aligned on goals, lifestyle and have that mutual respect and love... but what happens when that falls apart? As sadly many do.

How many people understand that the conduct within the marriage doesn't usually have any bearing on the financial dissolution and split of assets? So you could have a partner that refuses to work, decides to do their own thing, break every moral vow they made, and you might still be faced with having to spend £100k on solicitors to not then pay them spousal maintenance, try and keep at least 50% of the assets and most importantly, stay in your children's lives.

Nope. No marriage for me ever again.

Riapia · 06/08/2023 07:48

Sign I saw outside a bar while on holiday.
“ Ladies step inside and meet your future ex-husband. “

It’s never wise to make long term plans where men are concerned.
As I know to my cost.

Transmummy · 06/08/2023 03:26

Linzipinsy1590 · 05/08/2023 21:37

I wouldn't get married but then again I'd never live with anyone again neither. Sounds really odd, but I protect myself financially for my kids future

I feel the same way. Particularly as (in Australia) ‘grey divorce’ is leaving a disproportionate number of women homeless. I was lucky we ended up with a house each first time. Next time I might not be so fortunate.

Tiqtaq · 06/08/2023 02:33

I'm been with my partner for 25 years and we have a child, now grown up.

I own the house we live in, it's now worth £1M.

I didn't get married because my DP (younger than me) brought no assets to the relationship and at the time earned less than me. Now earns a lot more as I can't work for health reasons.

Not getting married was definitely the right thing to do for me.

Our relationship has outlasted most of my friends' marriages.

AcrossthePond55 · 06/08/2023 02:12

I live in a place where pre-nups are legally binding. I'd advise ANYONE (male or female) who has the higher assets and/or income to get an air-tight pre-nup.

qtpa2t · 06/08/2023 01:36

If their fiancé is a bum or has rocky relationship with spending / history, is likely to be impulsive etc then I'd advise to consider a prenup or something or not to get married. But I'd give the same advice to a guy getting married to and earning more than a girl. How weird to make it about gender lmao. In this way we can claim men have been disadvantaged by marriage this whole time? Yeah sure in some way. But it's been going on for a while now. You either believe in the institution or you don't, either is fine, but this is a strange faux feminist take

Lindyloo23 · 06/08/2023 00:00

Yes

whumpthereitis · 05/08/2023 22:53

Threenow · 05/08/2023 20:43

Well said. Being on MN has been a revelation to me as I have never in my whole life come across so many women who are totally focussed on their career and the amount of money they have. Thankfully I move in more normal circles, where people choose a partner based on love and respect rather than their earning potential.

It’s not an either/or proposition where in order to have one you have to forego others. You can have love, respect and financial compatibility.

Changeychang · 05/08/2023 22:51

Man or women or W W, M M I would only advise marriage if there is a plan to have children. Then you need to protect the spouse whose career is likely to take a hit. For both individuals, if possible, I'd advise ring-fencing the assets they each had before marriage.