Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Controversial marriage question

385 replies

wedding12341 · 04/08/2023 09:45

Thinking about another thread on here where someone has moved in and had children with their fiancé who has now changed his mind about getting married. Someone on the thread said it is just a small minority of women that are disadvantaged by marriage.

Eg - the woman brings more assets / money to the marriage than the man.

Based on the above

If you were one of these women in the minority (or your friend / daughter was) - Would you advise them not to get married?

OP posts:
Doinst · 04/08/2023 10:48

This is my sister’s situation- she’s the higher earner and owned a house outright. The marriage is unhappy and she’s talked about divorce- he basically does nothing while she does everything while also earning twice what she earns- and she’s been advised that divorcing him would mean losing half the house and paying him maintenance. (They have a DD) She’d definitely have been better off not marrying, in retrospect.

Hindsight is 20 20 though. If you’re able to foresee this sort of situation, you probably shouldn’t be together at all. And of course things might have gone differently - he might have been a great husband and dad (presumably she thought he would be or she wouldn’t have married him). And she might have lost her job or become ill, who knows?

UndercoverCop · 04/08/2023 10:45

I was and am one of those women, I am also married. I don't see why men with more assets should be expected to marry and share with a spouse but women are told not to.
My husband works bloody hard has retrained in a new career and has doubled his earnings with more potential for progression. I still out earn him and maybe always will. He's also a hands on partner and father which MN doesn't expect so I think sometimes colours responses

WannaBeRecluse · 04/08/2023 10:44

whumpthereitis · 04/08/2023 10:41

Has it changed, or has the advent of internet meant that now we’re more aware of a wider range of opinions, outside of those of our social circles?

Well I've known a lot of people and have never known anyone to not just merge assets for a first young marriage. But I'm old enough to remember when living together without being married was rare.

PinkCherryBlossoms · 04/08/2023 10:44

wedding12341 · 04/08/2023 09:45

Thinking about another thread on here where someone has moved in and had children with their fiancé who has now changed his mind about getting married. Someone on the thread said it is just a small minority of women that are disadvantaged by marriage.

Eg - the woman brings more assets / money to the marriage than the man.

Based on the above

If you were one of these women in the minority (or your friend / daughter was) - Would you advise them not to get married?

Depends on their priorities.

For example, is this woman more bothered about reducing inheritance tax liability for the surviving partner than protecting assets in the event of separation? No right answer.

greydressinggownofdoom · 04/08/2023 10:42

wedding12341 · 04/08/2023 10:39

Is the intention not to marry due to your higher earning status?

Yes, I don't want him to get any of what I've worked for as I want that all to go to my kids.

He has kids - his can go to his kids, mine will go to mine.

We live in my house, he pays towards bills (I have no mortgage) in proportion to his income as against mine. He doesn't contribute to any repairs or maintenance of the house (on purpose so that he can't claim an equitable interest) and we have a cohabitation agreement that we drew up with solicitors (he had his own solicitor and I had mine).

whumpthereitis · 04/08/2023 10:41

WannaBeRecluse · 04/08/2023 10:39

Yeah, I don't think we have to go that far back. I'm just noticing the huge change in approach and attitude from posters vs. the general approach when I got married over 30 years ago.

Has it changed, or has the advent of internet meant that now we’re more aware of a wider range of opinions, outside of those of our social circles?

WannaBeRecluse · 04/08/2023 10:41

G5000 · 04/08/2023 10:36

Are people not partners in life anymore?

People were 'partners for life' because you could not get a divorce and/or as a woman, you could not support yourself without a man. Luckily this is no longer the case and you do not need to stay in a marriage that does not work for you any more.

Yes and if we divorced, we'd split everything evenly. Maybe partly because we got together very young and built everything together, this seems completely fair.

Echobelly · 04/08/2023 10:40

When we got married I brought a lot more capital, but he has much higher earning power. I put the deposit down the first place we bought together, and on the first one we specifically agreed that the ownership (tenancy in common) was 70% my name, 30% his. Next place obviously some of the deposit was value of first place although again mostly my deposit, and as he'd paid more of the mortgage of first place I offered he could own more of current house, but he insisted it remained at 70/30 split. I feel like we both got advantages in different ways,

wedding12341 · 04/08/2023 10:40

Heywhatawobderfulkindofday · 04/08/2023 10:37

I didn't get married for this reason. Used to pray he didn't propose, luckily for me he didn't and is now an ex!

Would you have gone ahead with it if he did propose?

OP posts:
wedding12341 · 04/08/2023 10:39

greydressinggownofdoom · 04/08/2023 10:37

I'm the higher earner between me and owner of said dressing gown in my username.

I will never marry him and we don't share money.

Is the intention not to marry due to your higher earning status?

OP posts:
greydressinggownofdoom · 04/08/2023 10:39

greenteaandmarshmallows · 04/08/2023 10:25

You might not always be the higher earner. You might end up in coma or something.

And I have made as much provision for that scenario as I can.

If he dumps me if I end up in a coma, he dumps me. What's to say that wouldn't happen if you were married?

WannaBeRecluse · 04/08/2023 10:39

whumpthereitis · 04/08/2023 10:29

‘anymore’

Historically, marriage had little to do with love and romance. The earliest recorded prenup is over 2000 years old, and they were commonplace until the 20th century.

They can protect both parties, and if one party doesn’t feel like they are adequately provided for in the event of a divorce then they don’t have to sign it, and they don’t have to marry.

Yeah, I don't think we have to go that far back. I'm just noticing the huge change in approach and attitude from posters vs. the general approach when I got married over 30 years ago.

Heywhatawobderfulkindofday · 04/08/2023 10:37

I didn't get married for this reason. Used to pray he didn't propose, luckily for me he didn't and is now an ex!

greydressinggownofdoom · 04/08/2023 10:37

I'm the higher earner between me and owner of said dressing gown in my username.

I will never marry him and we don't share money.

MissTrip82 · 04/08/2023 10:36

We have both always worked and we do similar jobs with similar high earnings. We married for love, and share our lives, and despite both being well and truly capable of supporting ourselves it would make a big difference to both of us if we were to halve our household income by divorcing.

I don't think marriage is either to be avoided or the answer. I cringe reading threads about women treated like shit by their partners in every way and the advice is to get married.....nope. There is no security in being married to an arsehole.

LakieLady · 04/08/2023 10:36

I would advise them not to marry.

My ex had a few grand in savings when we married, I had a house with a reasonable amount of equity. No children involved.

When we divorced (2013), the court awarded him 47.5% of joint assets, which was £97.5k. I was earning about £20k at the time. Luckily, I was with my new partner by then, he had some money from his split with his ex, and a small inheritance from my late mother came through in the nick of time. We were still £20k short, so we took out several credit cards and got cash advances for 3 weeks until our remortgage was finalised.

There were two consoling factors: the house was valued at £60k more than it was when valued for the divorce, and my ex used a very expensive solicitor and was, apparently, a nightmare client, who overcomplicated everything. His legal bill was almost £30k. He'd turned down my offer of £70k, so ended up with slightly less than he would have done had he accepted it at the outset.

It still stung though, especially as he'd hidden some money and I couldn't prove it.

G5000 · 04/08/2023 10:36

Are people not partners in life anymore?

People were 'partners for life' because you could not get a divorce and/or as a woman, you could not support yourself without a man. Luckily this is no longer the case and you do not need to stay in a marriage that does not work for you any more.

DustyLee123 · 04/08/2023 10:33

DustyLee123 · 04/08/2023 10:32

Yes I would. And I’d advise them to give my children her surname.

  • any children
DustyLee123 · 04/08/2023 10:32

Yes I would. And I’d advise them to give my children her surname.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 04/08/2023 10:32

I was the higher earner and technically I have disadvantaged by marriage but we wanted children and DH was going to be the SAHP for a while so it was only fair. We’re still together and DC1 is nearly 20 so it worked out OK.

thecatsthecats · 04/08/2023 10:31

My husband and I have played leapfrog the past decade in salaries. I happened to have more when we married.

When I burned out and spent seven months off work, he earned a bit less. When I took up a new PT job to fit around studying, he earned double. As a result of my new qualifications, I'm not so far behind him any more.

He's interviewing for a job paying 40% more. If he gets it, we're both mindful of the fact that it's worth more to my career to gain another qualification before coming off Mat leave than it is to plough on in the same role. Our aim is for me to take the first step to lucrative part time self employment, and for him to follow suit in a few years.

We're a career team. We've always discussed job roles and financial plans. I don't think it matters who earns more if you can communicate and agree goals. If you can't do that, you shouldn't marry regardless of income.

whumpthereitis · 04/08/2023 10:31

greenteaandmarshmallows · 04/08/2023 10:25

You might not always be the higher earner. You might end up in coma or something.

It’s not necessarily about what you’re earning during the marriage, but what you’re bringing into it - family trusts, properties, businesses etc.

whumpthereitis · 04/08/2023 10:29

WannaBeRecluse · 04/08/2023 10:18

Are people not partners in life anymore?

‘anymore’

Historically, marriage had little to do with love and romance. The earliest recorded prenup is over 2000 years old, and they were commonplace until the 20th century.

They can protect both parties, and if one party doesn’t feel like they are adequately provided for in the event of a divorce then they don’t have to sign it, and they don’t have to marry.

greenteaandmarshmallows · 04/08/2023 10:25

You might not always be the higher earner. You might end up in coma or something.

IamAlso4eels · 04/08/2023 10:22

WannaBeRecluse · 04/08/2023 09:57

When we married we merged assets. We don't care who earns more, it's all ours. I understand this might be trickier in second marriages where there are children or other commitments that make finances more complicated but, for our first marriage, we don't care where the money comes from and who it comes from. There's no 'my finances' and 'your finances' just 'our fiances. So, on that basis, it's irrelevant to me when advising someone if they should get married or not because of financial discrepancy.

This is what DH and I do but when we got married we were earning the same salary, we then went through various transitional periods where our income didn't match (I was a SAHM for a time) and now our incomes are aligned again.

What I would advise anyone to do is to be careful who they have children with, once you have children you're tied together for the rest of your/their lives because even once they're adults there will be family events where you need to see each other and act civilly.