Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Controversial marriage question

385 replies

wedding12341 · 04/08/2023 09:45

Thinking about another thread on here where someone has moved in and had children with their fiancé who has now changed his mind about getting married. Someone on the thread said it is just a small minority of women that are disadvantaged by marriage.

Eg - the woman brings more assets / money to the marriage than the man.

Based on the above

If you were one of these women in the minority (or your friend / daughter was) - Would you advise them not to get married?

OP posts:
Mari9999 · 04/08/2023 12:16

@Pressthespacebar
I think many mature adults become engaged solely for the ease of describing their relationship. I think many , men particularly, never have the intention of marrying. T think an equal number probably refer to their partner as a fiance or fiancee when marriage or engagement has never been a consideration, again, it is done for ease of describing the relationship to others.

SkyK · 04/08/2023 12:14

I am in this position and did get married. The marriage is all working out ok fortunately but no, I think it was actually a bad move financially for me if we were to split up so I wouldn’t recommend for my daughter if she was in same position.

greydressinggownofdoom · 04/08/2023 12:14

Dinoswearunderpants · 04/08/2023 12:13

I guess I'm 'that women'. I earn nearly double what my DH does. My house is also worth nearly three times my DH. I have far more than he does.

However, before we married we both agreed we would keep the assets we had prior to marriage. I know it was only a verbal agreement (followed up on a WhatsApp message) but I'd like to think we would agree with it.

Plus I genuinely feel we won't divorce. People give up far too easily these days. Life isn't always perfect but you should want to work together.

I didn't give up too easily. He cheated. I hate that narrative. How was i supposed to "work harder" at it?

Dinoswearunderpants · 04/08/2023 12:13

I guess I'm 'that women'. I earn nearly double what my DH does. My house is also worth nearly three times my DH. I have far more than he does.

However, before we married we both agreed we would keep the assets we had prior to marriage. I know it was only a verbal agreement (followed up on a WhatsApp message) but I'd like to think we would agree with it.

Plus I genuinely feel we won't divorce. People give up far too easily these days. Life isn't always perfect but you should want to work together.

greydressinggownofdoom · 04/08/2023 12:12

Hibiscrubbed · 04/08/2023 12:10

Does he have any redeeming features? I’m imagining a part-timer moping around, doing fuck all, with the ‘dressing gown stoop’.

He works full time and works hard. He's in the 40% tax bracket. But he doesn't earn as much as I do.

He has a house he has rented out, and he pays more than CMS maintenance for his kids. They are 18 and 16 - his eldest is about to go to uni and thanks to the fact that he lives with me, he will be able to continue to support them at university.

brawhen · 04/08/2023 12:12

Hmmm my sister was in this situation. She was older and (much) higher earning when they met. Her now DH was still a student while she was established in her career and had a house. However, her DH's family is asset-rich and they knew that in due course he would likely inherit a pile. His family basically insisted on a prenup to protect his family assets. It was quite hurtful actually. Sister then decided to keep her house fully in her name, as security. It was all a bit unusual to us, as our parents have always shared absolutely all finances jointly.

They married because they wanted children - and also to make the public commitment.

Now he is flying in his career and earns more than her and climbing. He has just inherited the first chunk of stuff.

It has worked out OK so far as (a) they remain happy in the marriage and (b) even though he is now significantly richer, she has still earned/saved enough to be secure in her independence. And (c) he is a good guy!

I guess the other positive was that it forced them to talk about all this stuff pre-marriage.

Chickenkeev · 04/08/2023 12:11

greydressinggownofdoom · 04/08/2023 11:34

Mrdressinggown is very caring - he has looked after me when I was long term ill. And I absolutely would do the same for him.

But he still isn't getting anything of mine that can be inherited - that is going to my children.

Why should he get what I worked hard for before he was on the scene? Why should his children benefit from my hard work? They have two parents of their own to provide for them, that's not my job.

I have done all I can to protect what money is mine. Mrdressinggown gets the benefit of living with me - his outgoings are less and he lives a better lifestyle than he could on his own - I pay for most things, including holidays.

Also, he knew the deal very clearly before he moved in - I was very clear on how it was going to be. If he doesn't like it, he can leave at any time.

Fair enough, i was just all in. But i owned nothing. I could just afford more. He paid for the majority of the house in the end bc his parents died so he got a lump. So it all evened out. But i suppose my point is, i ( personally) wouldn't be with someone if i was suspicious of their motives. Easy to say i know, and maybe naieve (sp?) but there you go, that's just me.

Hibiscrubbed · 04/08/2023 12:10

greydressinggownofdoom · 04/08/2023 10:42

Yes, I don't want him to get any of what I've worked for as I want that all to go to my kids.

He has kids - his can go to his kids, mine will go to mine.

We live in my house, he pays towards bills (I have no mortgage) in proportion to his income as against mine. He doesn't contribute to any repairs or maintenance of the house (on purpose so that he can't claim an equitable interest) and we have a cohabitation agreement that we drew up with solicitors (he had his own solicitor and I had mine).

Does he have any redeeming features? I’m imagining a part-timer moping around, doing fuck all, with the ‘dressing gown stoop’.

Addictedtohotbaths · 04/08/2023 12:10

I was 8 years younger but earning much more than him when we married. When we divorced I was earning even more with unlimited potential.

He was awarded way more than me in court settlement but also played the game cut back on work and ran up debts in the run up.

I kept being told how unusual it was to be main earner (female) AND main carer of children.

I would not advise or get married again unless my future partner was earning WAY more than me / had assets and was clear as can be that he wouldn’t be after mine.

Only benefit I see to wealthy female getting married is pension sharing upon death.

Not very romantic…

Caprisunny · 04/08/2023 12:09

I am one of these women. Have my own home (small mortgage), 2 kids (1 an adult) and earn significantly more and have more in assets.

I was married to the kids dad from 20 to 35. Neither of us had much when we married so neither minded joining things financially.

Now I absolutely wouldn’t get married.

Would I advise a friend or my daughter not to get married? Not exactly. If a friend asked my opinion I would give it. If they didn’t I might drop into conversation about looking into the legalities and protecting themselves financially.

I have brought my daughter up (the adult) to not look at marriage through a romantic view only. That’s my issue with marriage. People think it’s a romantic commitment first and it’s not. It a legal and financial commitment first and foremost. And ‘but we are in love’ can cause you a world of pain down the road.

It always shocks me when women (on Mn and in RL) are the main earners or came into marriage with far more in assets and now heading for divorce that seem completely oblivious to the fact that getting married meant their husband/wife could walk a way with a big chunk of those assets.

ideally I would love to see anyone who wants to get married, have to seek to get financial and legal advice before marriage.

Though that doesn’t help the many women who don’t get married, damage their careers to take main responsibility for the kids, move into a house they don’t have their name on them get dumped.

I think parents who don’t teach their kids about these sorts of things are massively letting their kids down

greydressinggownofdoom · 04/08/2023 12:09

Jumpingthruhoops · 04/08/2023 12:06

Basing a marriage on 'who brings what' to it is why marriages don't work out.

My DH and I have always lived, loved and worked as a team. The End.

That's what I thought of me and my "D"H.

He cheated. I didn't see that coming.

I won't make the same mistake again.

TenderDandelions · 04/08/2023 12:09

DH and I were talking about this the other day as a friend of ours has just separated from her husband.

Over the course of their marriage, she's always earned more than her husband and also brought up the children almost entirely by herself and he was a selfish git.

He started numerous business ventures that ended up costing them money, so they remortgaged the house to clear the debts he'd raised. He cheated on her multiple times and has now moved out, renting his own place elsewhere, that's not big enough for the children to go and stay with him, though they're older and don't want to see him anyway.

He's "generously" told her that he'll continue to pay his half of the mortgage until it's paid off, then they'll sell the house and split the proceeds.

Legally, I know this is right that the house should be split 50:50, but morally it feels awful. Compared to what they'd each contributed over the years, both financially and in terms of time and effort, he will end up with far more than he should.

He'll be able to buy himself a little one bedroom place mortgage free with his half of the house, yet as she's still left with the (by then adult) children, she'll have to either tell them to move out and find their own place, or buy something of a similar size to what they're in now, to house them all (or buy him out of his half of the house).

So, just at the point that they should have been mortgage free, she'll have to take another mortgage to get shot of him.

That said, if they hadn't been married, there wouldn't have been any difference really. Neither of them have any other significant assets.

I think I'd only advise someone to not get married if there were other significant assets that the other person would potentially have a claim on later. That would apply no matter which person had the most money - husband or wife.

Jumpingthruhoops · 04/08/2023 12:06

Basing a marriage on 'who brings what' to it is why marriages don't work out.

My DH and I have always lived, loved and worked as a team. The End.

TakenRoot · 04/08/2023 12:05

If she owned significant equity in a house and he didn’t and couldn’t match her equity, yes I would suggest she look at the pros and cons of marriage.

If it was just a matter of different salaries I would say do what you like.

Pressthespacebar · 04/08/2023 12:05

I did very well out my first divorce and own a large property with no mortgage worth just under 6 figures.

I did go on to meet someone else and have more children and I agreed to get engaged as he didn’t like saying I was his girlfriend/partner but I would never get married again as my house is really all I have and it’s for my children when I die.

so in my case it was better not to marry and put myself at risk (I was right to, we’ve just split up!)

CouldBeOuting · 04/08/2023 12:03

I brought MUCH more to the marriage than DH. He was not working (actually states unemployed on the marriage cert.) and I was a high earner. He was a “house husband” effectively.
By the time we had our first child he was working and had a decent income. I gave up working until our last child went to secondary school - I was a “house wife”.
33 years later he is a high earner and I work part time on a low salary.
BUT through all the twists and turns EVERYTHING has always been shared.

If the relationship is a proper partnership then who “brings more” is totally irrelevant.

Gardeningisfun · 04/08/2023 12:03

I got married young, neither me or DH had any money. We have built a life and family together. At times I have earned more than him and him more than me. I am lucky that it has worked out for us. Our marriage isn’t perfect but we are old fashioned in the way we see it as a sacred commitment and we are building a life together as a team.

However if anything were to happen to DH I wouldn’t get married again. I don’t think I would achieve this equality with someone else. It wouldn’t be about building a life together so I wouldn’t see the point that marriage would serve.

fireflyloo · 04/08/2023 11:59

Yes if I wanted to have children as I would want the security of marriage for them. If I didn't want children and I was financially independent then I'd think twice about marriage.

greydressinggownofdoom · 04/08/2023 11:59

Although @ActDottie I'm not sure what you mean by being trans parents?

greydressinggownofdoom · 04/08/2023 11:57

ActDottie · 04/08/2023 11:56

I’d advise them to get married. I earn more than my husband and also come from a wealthier background. We’ve built a life together so we share all. To me this is what marriage is about sharing a life and being trans parents about everything together. My husband and I are a team.

That's what I used to think - then he had an affair and we divorced.

Iwasafool · 04/08/2023 11:57

whumpthereitis · 04/08/2023 10:14

If asked then yes, I’d either advise them to avoid marriage, or to at least put things in place to secure their assets as best as possible beforehand.

My husband and I were/are evenly financially matched, and even then we considered a prenup.

Few people marry anticipating that it will fail, yet half do. Similarly, no one gets in a car and expects to crash it, but they’ll still put on the seatbelt.

Before it was legally enforced most people didn't wear a seat belt. I suppose that's why they brought in the legislation.

coolcahuna · 04/08/2023 11:57

Frankola · 04/08/2023 11:30

I am in the minority. I definitely wouldn't advise AGAINST getting married if that's what both partners want. What I would advise is any woman in the situation take steps to financially protect themselves in case of divorce. I have. I'm married and I'm very happy. It helps knowing I'm protected though.

Can I ask what you've done to protect yourself?

ActDottie · 04/08/2023 11:56

I’d advise them to get married. I earn more than my husband and also come from a wealthier background. We’ve built a life together so we share all. To me this is what marriage is about sharing a life and being trans parents about everything together. My husband and I are a team.

Goldbar · 04/08/2023 11:56

Marriage offers some protection against the exploitation of unpaid labour within a relationship. Unpaid labour skyrockets when there are children involved, and can get in the way of undertaking paid labour and achieving financial security.

There are two ways you can run a relationship imo... as a partnership or both paying your way. So either you have marriage or some other form of financial sharing or both parties pay their own way. And that means not only sharing expenses and financial commitments but also compensating the other partner when they provide more than their share of childcare and household labour at market rates. Anything else is financial exploitation imo. It's fine not to want to marry and share finances, but it's absolutely not fine to then refuse to do your share of childcare/chores or fail to financially compensate your partner for stepping up and doing more, especially if it is then limiting their financial independence.

lookingforhomemum · 04/08/2023 11:51

RedPony1 · 04/08/2023 11:38

Because i don't see why getting married means everything has to merge in to one? My earnings are part of my identity.

My pot. House/holiday/family pot. His pot.

Everybody should be looking at protecting themselves. I've worked very very hard top make sure (as long as i'm in good health) that i am never financially reliant any anybody else but me. I've been burned before and i can see friends stuck in unhappy marriages because they have shared income and can't get out.

Being financially independent doesn't make you any less of a good, loving family/parent.

I agree with you when you say "My earnings are part of my identity. My pot. House/holiday/family pot. "

I completely agree in principle, but that's not how the law works. There are pros and cons for getting married, but You are better off getting married if he is the high earner or sole earner, for example, if you end up taking care of the children at home. You lose this "identity and pot" you mention because you lose your income and pensions growing, and other employee benefits, while he still has his. If you get divorced, The law takes into account the children you have raised and the employment sacrifices you have made. Make sure you have a good lawyer if he tries to divorce you, especially after you gave your body/womb, sacrificed income and pensions for this family he has enjoyed. Being the stay-at-home parent should be paid for, and that's another topic I won't get into here.

In the case of a partner's death, as a legal spouse, all his/her money goes to you directly without it being taxed. If you are married, spouses are spared tax on "inheritance". The same with a house - it all goes to the surviving spouse. Children on the other hand, pay inheritance tax. It gets more complicated for your children if you are divorced and he re-marries with children from this second marriage etc. There is lots of information on the internet.

There are pros and cons obviously, but honestly, I think people should get married if the partnership is good, safe and full of love to benefit from the laws that do work in your favour.

Personally, I think where I'd like the law to change is allowing a spouse (women in particular) own their own property that has nothing to do with the other spouse. For example, if a woman buys a property by herself before she marries, but then gets married, I don't think it's fair that it also becomes part of the spouse's assets. I think actions and assets before marriage should be kept separate, but at the same time, I can see this disadvantaging people who may end up in marriages where they grew up poor, but the spouse had parental handouts. Life and marriage is complicated.

Try to marry a good person first and foremost.