Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Controversial marriage question

385 replies

wedding12341 · 04/08/2023 09:45

Thinking about another thread on here where someone has moved in and had children with their fiancé who has now changed his mind about getting married. Someone on the thread said it is just a small minority of women that are disadvantaged by marriage.

Eg - the woman brings more assets / money to the marriage than the man.

Based on the above

If you were one of these women in the minority (or your friend / daughter was) - Would you advise them not to get married?

OP posts:
MightWriteNight · 04/08/2023 13:55

I'm one of these women. I'm both the higher earner and come from money (as in my inheritance tax bill will be several million). I am also happily married with kids. I guess every situation is different, but I never hesitated, we don't have a prenup, and I assume if we get divorced our assets will be divided in half. Hope I chose a good one (so far all signs point to yes)!

Caprisunny · 04/08/2023 13:55

C1N1C · 04/08/2023 13:37

I actually agree with your comment, and to the other one (yes I did read the rest of the thread), but in here, it is the minority. As I stated, men typically DO earn more (for whatever reason, I'm not getting into that)... and yet the overwhelming majority of posts outside of this one will call him a waste of space, a time waster, not serious etc etc if he doesn't want to go married.

A man not wanting to marry is often seen as immature, unreliable, not wanting to commit... but a woman not wanting to is seen as strong, independent, powerful... no? As was stated, both should be able to protect their assets.

I very rarely see someone being told their partner is a time waster or immature if they are clear from the beginning that they don’t want to get married.

i don’t want to get married. I earn almost 4 times what he does. He knows marriage has never been an option. I would be wasting his time and being immature if I wasn’t clear.

The other thing is that men often are quite happy for the women to take the majority of the responsibility for the house and children, impacting her own career whilst not offering and financial protection but keeping the women hanging on with ‘I will propose’ or ‘yeah I do want to get married’.

If me and dp were having kids, absolutely no way would I expect him to take a hit to his own earnings without providing him with financial protection. It would be an awful thing to do to let him take that hit without making it clear that I was never marrying him.

Like it or not, in the vast majority of cases there is a difference between men and women when you look at this situation.

That said, I have a girl and a boy and both have been told the same when it comes to marriage. They have both had the exact same advice.

MisschiefMaker · 04/08/2023 13:40

My DH became a higher earner than me after the birth of DC (we earned roughly the same before that) but absolutely benefits from being married, and he would be the first to admit that. Essentially, being married means we can make decisions that are beneficial for the family unit, rather than me feeling like I have to look out for myself as an individual even if that negatively impacts him or my DC.

For example, if we weren't married I would have gone back to work after 4 months maternity leave (working with Americans that was all I could take really). He would have had to do 50% of the childcare and 50% of the night wakes and household chores and cooking. Instead, I basically do everything except for when he plays with the toddler after dinner. He works long hours and earns enough that he doesn't 'miss' my salary, so that trade off of me not working and him getting a better quality of life was absolutely worth it to him.

From a values perspective, both DH and I preferred the thought of DC being cared for by their DM (or DF) rather than at nursery for the first 2 years. If I was working that wouldn't have been possible but if we weren't married I would have wanted to go back to work to protect myself... So we're both living a life aligned with our values, thanks to being married. I think that counts as a benefit to DH.

Also, he wanted to move to a low tax European country. The amount he saves in tax is the equivalent to a decent UK salary. So, we save the equivalent of one decent salary in tax AND I don't have to work AND my DC is better off (not just because I'm home with DC, but also because it's a lovely place and DC will be bilingual and also living by the coast has fixed their eczema). No way would I have moved to a country where I don't speak the language if I wasn't married because I can't get work here.

Also, we've moved country twice on my DH's request (once to the USA and once to Europe) and in both cases it was 100% easier to get the visa as a married couple. Actually, I definitely wouldn't have been able to live in the USA without being married to him and therefore he wouldn't have moved there and that would have dented his earnings a lot too.

So I do think that higher earners can benefit from marriage, in theory, even if the woman is the higher earner. However, from what I read on MN when the woman is the higher earner and the dad is at home it's usually because he's a grifter and he doesn't do anything around the house and normally demands that the kids are in nursery too... and then the woman gets screwed in the divorce.. so it's a very individual decision I suppose.

C1N1C · 04/08/2023 13:37

Brefugee · 04/08/2023 13:04

literally above your post @C1N1C

I actually agree with your comment, and to the other one (yes I did read the rest of the thread), but in here, it is the minority. As I stated, men typically DO earn more (for whatever reason, I'm not getting into that)... and yet the overwhelming majority of posts outside of this one will call him a waste of space, a time waster, not serious etc etc if he doesn't want to go married.

A man not wanting to marry is often seen as immature, unreliable, not wanting to commit... but a woman not wanting to is seen as strong, independent, powerful... no? As was stated, both should be able to protect their assets.

PinkCherryBlossoms · 04/08/2023 13:36

People cannot be assumed to behave themselves when partnerships end. This applies whether you're married or not.

Nodramabanana · 04/08/2023 13:31

Dinoswearunderpants · 04/08/2023 12:45

I assume you're divorced as you sound very bitter.

I am not divorced, and I am the higher earner, and I still think you sound pretty ridicuous claiming that in the event of divorce your husband will honour your verbal agreement. There would be no divorce lawyers if it were that simple.

SlipperyLizard · 04/08/2023 13:27

I’ve always earned more than DH, sometimes a little more, sometimes 10x more, currently 3x more. I married him because we were planning to have children & I wanted him to have the security I knew I would want in his position (as the lower earner, he took a step back in his career to be there for the kids).

I we were to divorce, I’d happily give him half - we built this together, and I couldn’t have had the career I have without his support.

I will never remarry, however, because what I’ve built is for me, DH and our kids - no way would I risk someone else getting their hands on it.

I’ve told DH that if I pre-decease him then I’m happy for him to move on, but I’d like him not to marry so no one can take what we’ve built for ourselves & the kids. Happy for him to share his wealth & be good to a new partner, but not to lose half his assets on divorce.

SerafinasGoose · 04/08/2023 13:21

We married because we wanted to order our affairs in the event that something happened to one of us. My mother died unexpectedly and at a young age. This brought it home to me how very difficult it would be for us both if one of us were to fall ill. I'd be at the behest of the abusive father I'd been estranged from for the entirety of my adult life. DH's family are not remotely interested in him and are extremely grasping and mercenary, as he sadly discovered when my FiL died. If something happened to him, there's always the possibility they would try to get their paws on his assets, despite the possible effect on our child. (My own father is also now dead).

It's impossible to imagine that, if you're facing the hardest situation of your entire life, such a scenario could be made even more painful. But it could. On both sides we would have been left in an even worse position should the unthinkable happen. We wouldn't even be able to register each other's deaths.

I'm entirely financially independent and never hankered after marriage. Until the death of my mother the above hadn't really occurred to me, or if it had, I hadn't thought about it particularly seriously.

It's a serious legal covenant: it's not all about hearts and flowers.

I think people know their own priorities. Others' situations will vary, and their own concerns might be entirely different from mine. The important thing is to make an informed choice.

Giveover80 · 04/08/2023 13:13

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Willyoujustbequiet · 04/08/2023 13:10

I'm in that minority. I was royally screwed over in the worst way.

I would strongly advise against merging assets no matter how long you are together. Anything my children inherit will be ring fenced for them alone.

PinkCherryBlossoms · 04/08/2023 13:06

AuntieJune · 04/08/2023 12:43

Any arrangement is fine if you go into it with open eyes.

The worst thing is to put all the power in one partner's hands, eg be a sahm with nothing in your own name and imagine your dp would do the right thing if you broke up.

People can turn into dickheads - age, illness, injury, life events, cheating, who knows - relationships sour and if you rely on good will in that situation you're likely to be fucked.

Yeah I tend to think that if people have given the situation some thought and actually base their decisions on knowledge, it's probably ok.

So if you've not got married because it's just a piece of paper and someone told you that you're common law anyway, that's taking a big risk. The same person making the same decision who understands the legal position and has tailored their life choices accordingly, probably not.

Brefugee · 04/08/2023 13:04

Purplecatshopaholic · 04/08/2023 12:57

Yup, same here. If you have more assets - be you male or female - think very carefully about marriage.

literally above your post @C1N1C

Brefugee · 04/08/2023 13:03

C1N1C · 04/08/2023 12:59

Sooo... given the majority of replies here...

Marriage is advocated as long as it financially benefits the woman?

...but men are wasting your time and not worth it if they (typically, statistically better off) don't want to marry a woman?

there are literally dozens of posts on this thread saying that they would advise anyone in the better financial/earning/asset position to think long and hard about protecting their assets

and yet some idiots who apparently can't read and inwardly digest come watlzing in and spout piffle

FrivolousTreeDuck · 04/08/2023 13:00

I am one of the minority, and I am married.

TedMullins · 04/08/2023 13:00

C1N1C · 04/08/2023 12:59

Sooo... given the majority of replies here...

Marriage is advocated as long as it financially benefits the woman?

...but men are wasting your time and not worth it if they (typically, statistically better off) don't want to marry a woman?

some might think this but I think it's complete hypocrisy. Totally understandable if men don't want to get married for financial reasons

C1N1C · 04/08/2023 12:59

Sooo... given the majority of replies here...

Marriage is advocated as long as it financially benefits the woman?

...but men are wasting your time and not worth it if they (typically, statistically better off) don't want to marry a woman?

Purplecatshopaholic · 04/08/2023 12:57

Grumpy101 · 04/08/2023 10:05

Well, I got royally screwed when my first marriage ended. I was by far the higher earner and I would absolutely advise every woman (and man) to be extremely careful if there is a discrepancy in assets or income. Delay marriage until you're 100% sure and older.

I made more money that my exDH because I worked harder. He enjoyed a very lavish lifestyle while together and he didn't deserve a penny from me but that's not how divorce works.

Yup, same here. If you have more assets - be you male or female - think very carefully about marriage.

Chickenkeev · 04/08/2023 12:57

AuntieJune · 04/08/2023 12:43

Any arrangement is fine if you go into it with open eyes.

The worst thing is to put all the power in one partner's hands, eg be a sahm with nothing in your own name and imagine your dp would do the right thing if you broke up.

People can turn into dickheads - age, illness, injury, life events, cheating, who knows - relationships sour and if you rely on good will in that situation you're likely to be fucked.

Sage advice.

Chickenkeev · 04/08/2023 12:56

greydressinggownofdoom · 04/08/2023 12:43

Mrgreydressinggownofdoom is great but I wouldn't say we have a perfect relationship.

He is still capable of winding me up by leaving wet towels hung over doors (put them on the fucking towel radiator that exists for that specific purpose) and his obsession with putting stuff away away when I need it on the regular.

I actually feel sick - no one has a perfect relationship and I honestly don't think I did anything that made my ex cheat on me. I don't understand why that is my fault?

It wasn't your fault! At all.

Hibiscrubbed · 04/08/2023 12:54

And one more for fun 😂:

I met my DH in Feb 19 and we married two years later and baby right away. You can't stifle love.

Such optimism foolishness.

Giveover80 · 04/08/2023 12:48

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Caprisunny · 04/08/2023 12:47

Dinoswearunderpants · 04/08/2023 12:45

I assume you're divorced as you sound very bitter.

What is your excuse?

Giveover80 · 04/08/2023 12:47

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Hibiscrubbed · 04/08/2023 12:46

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

I just had a good time ASing @Dinoswearunderpants too.

I came across this little nugget:

I earn £85k (pro rate to 4 days) and my husband earns about £40k. He struggles at but as he pays maintenance towards three other kids.

The toothless (literally) husband forks out for other kids and she’s done nothing to protect herself. There’s trusting, and there’s stupid.

greydressinggownofdoom · 04/08/2023 12:46

Dinoswearunderpants · 04/08/2023 12:45

I assume you're divorced as you sound very bitter.

After what you just said to me, that's a bit rich tbh.