Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that big events aren't always good for locals?

40 replies

GlasgowCityCouncilAgain · 04/08/2023 08:58

Glasgow and Scotland generally are hosting the UCI Cycling World Championships which is great. I'm very happy for us to host events and invite people to visit our city, particularly as we aren't nearly so touristy as Edinburgh. However is it too much to ask that locals are allowed to go about their business with minimal disruption and is it acceptable that businesses have been forced to shut their stores because they can't gain access? This has happened to a business that I'm very fond of and they aren't the only ones. They don't even know if they'll be able to gain access tomorrow though they were promised it today.

It's shit for the tourists too who may want to frequent local businesses like that and can't.

AIBU to think that businesses and locals should not lose out when a city is hosting an event?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Tara336 · 05/08/2023 17:31

@Floogal we live in the same area, already dreading the ridiculous traffic for this year's "event".

We also have had a cycling event in the nearby national park which is awful no one can really enjoy the park when it's on as the MAMILS take over racing (although they claim its a timed event not a race) they threw rubbish everywhere, I witnessed them screaming at the ponies who have right of way over everyone to get out the way as they flew down the lanes and the abuse they gave drivers who were trying to just use the narrow roads.

lljkk · 05/08/2023 17:11

isn't someone always going to "lose out" for any event that might happen, I don't think "no one losing out" is a viable target.

I wonder how many animals have died in recent years due to ordinary levels of traffic preventing vets from getting somewhere in time. Not to mention all the roadkill incidents. Our local facebook seems to have at least one notice a week about pet animals run over by cars.

I am surprised about no warning about the cycle race routes that PP mention; my experience being volunteer at running races is that everyone along the route gets a lot of warning that the event is coming & roads will be closed.

Teaandsympathy · 05/08/2023 16:45

Fourfurrymonsters · 05/08/2023 16:25

It’s not just Glasgow either. My daughter and her fiancé are in Perth in a flat with a dead-end road, and came out Thursday to find their one exit was closed off with cones for the UCI…no warning whatsoever. So they just took the cones off the road. No other way to get out. I also have friends in rural Perthshire who pretty much can’t go anywhere because many roads are closed for the Cycling Wankers. The general consensus is that unless you’re a cycling wanker it’s a giant PITA. You have to wonder what would happen in an emergency…

My local Perthshire town was basically shut yesterday.. no benefit to the local economy as race was just passing through. Perth itself was a nightmare as the Perth show was on too!

MichelleScarn · 05/08/2023 16:38

I need to go from DumGal up to QE hospital on Thursday, shit. Better go check my route!

Mrsjayy · 05/08/2023 16:30

My eldest Dd works in rural Stirling and its taking her an extra 25 minutes to get to work it's just ridiculous.

Fourfurrymonsters · 05/08/2023 16:25

It’s not just Glasgow either. My daughter and her fiancé are in Perth in a flat with a dead-end road, and came out Thursday to find their one exit was closed off with cones for the UCI…no warning whatsoever. So they just took the cones off the road. No other way to get out. I also have friends in rural Perthshire who pretty much can’t go anywhere because many roads are closed for the Cycling Wankers. The general consensus is that unless you’re a cycling wanker it’s a giant PITA. You have to wonder what would happen in an emergency…

GenieGenealogy · 05/08/2023 16:20

@TenOhSeven I worked in various tourist related businesses on the Royal Mile when I was a student, hated August. After work I had to run the gauntlet of street performers and leafletters and the rest of it to get down onto Princes St for the bus. And that was in the 90s, it's much bigger now.

GenieGenealogy · 05/08/2023 16:16

And remember during Cop26 when they had a VIP reception at the Kelvingrove, banned foot access and sent lone women on a walking diversion through a pitch dark park?

That's the Council for you.

TenOhSeven · 05/08/2023 16:14

I live in Edinburgh so I 100% agree! When the Festival and Hogmanay were cancelled because of COVID it was great. There was a real chance to try and reset these events after the pandemic to make them more sustainable and less disruptive to locals but sadly money making trumped everything.

GenieGenealogy · 05/08/2023 16:14

oops

https://www.traffic.gov.scot/uci-road-race

are bloody hopeless and you can't zoom to see what roads are closed and what ones aren't. There are lots of digital signs around Glasgow saying that roads will be closed, not which ones and when.

I am hugely in favour of large scale events in Glasgow and have volunteered at similar events in the past. But not everyone wants everything to shut for the cycling and businesses should be able to trade as normal. I was also involved in the filming of the Batgirl movie which involved the closure of Ingram Street for three consecutive nights 8am - midnight, and that obviously meant bars and restaurants couldn't trade. The producers agreed compensation with them.

UCI Championships - Men's Elite Road Race | Traffic Scotland

Traffic Scotland gives you the real-time information you need about Scotland’s trunk road network

https://www.traffic.gov.scot/uci-road-race

GenieGenealogy · 05/08/2023 16:11

Not just Glasgow City Council. We are in East Dunbartonshire and the road race is coming through here tomorrow I think, and there's another road race next weekend. Their maps like this one

Floogal · 05/08/2023 16:07

I live in a costal town that hosts a 'free' 4 day airshow every summer. Apart from takeaways, restaurants , stall holders and hotels in the town centre, many of the local business lose out on custom. Also highly inconvenient for the people living here (disrupted traffic, anti social behaviour etc). No one here knows whether it actually does benefit the town, or even breaks even

PTSDBarbiegirl · 04/08/2023 12:14

GlasgowCityCouncilAgain · 04/08/2023 09:20

It's 11 days so that's a lot of disruption.

I agree, my area is pretty disrupted due to the same event in Glasgow. Various local authorities in and bordering GCC have diverted staffing to the areas being cycled through. While it's great that events are happening and bringing some related tourism money it would be helpful if same LA's brought in additional staffing to keep on top of the regular jobs in areas rather than relying on teams of often just 2 to cover enormous areas. On a separate note, it never fails to shock me just how incompetent leadership is in local authorities here in Scotland. The decision makers are very often just not equipped with the skills to effectively deliver a quality service. Perhaps if some people were brought in from private sector this would change. It's frustrating!!

Mrsjayy · 04/08/2023 11:59

GlasgowCityCouncilAgain · 04/08/2023 08:58

Glasgow and Scotland generally are hosting the UCI Cycling World Championships which is great. I'm very happy for us to host events and invite people to visit our city, particularly as we aren't nearly so touristy as Edinburgh. However is it too much to ask that locals are allowed to go about their business with minimal disruption and is it acceptable that businesses have been forced to shut their stores because they can't gain access? This has happened to a business that I'm very fond of and they aren't the only ones. They don't even know if they'll be able to gain access tomorrow though they were promised it today.

It's shit for the tourists too who may want to frequent local businesses like that and can't.

AIBU to think that businesses and locals should not lose out when a city is hosting an event?

Yeah irs not great really, I have friends who live near the stirling route, where my dd works its restricted access and a few businesses have had to close but yayy cycling eh!

elderflowerandpomelo · 04/08/2023 11:56

I remember the chaos of the 2012 Olympics w all the priority lanes across the whole city! That went on forever, AND we paid a big additional Olympics subvention on our Council tax to pay for it, without getting any special priority for tickets or anything.

So long as it’s just disruption, I think it has to be borne… it’s when things are really really damaged - like in the park I mentioned up
the thread. Very little green space in the area; most of it walled off for Weeks for the event, and then returned in a state that means it’ll need huge reparative works and also shouldn’t be walked on at all for months…

DingDongDenny · 04/08/2023 11:13

I live in one of the areas where the roads are shut for long periods of time. We literally can't leave the house or if we are out, go home and these are residential streets. We did wonder why they were resurfacing all the roads earlier this year when they weren't that bad - compared to most. Now we know

Mochudubh · 04/08/2023 10:16

YANBU

The area I grew up in is virtually marooned for a cycle race. It's peak tourist season in a very picturesque part of Scotland. It's a massive pain in the arse for locals and tourists alike. This has been happening very year for over a decade.

I used to avoid going to visit elderly DM when the event was on but if she'd been taken ill that week there's a fair chance I wouldn't have been able to get there without a lot of hassle (it's a 2 hour drive as it is).

One year someone threw a load of tacks on the road which I don't condone but totally understand the frustration. It's disgusting that locals can't go about their daily business for the sake of a load of MAMILS. Especially in emergency situations like the vet in a PP.

ditalini · 04/08/2023 10:06

Comms from GCC are always crap. They squander so much good will just by not being on the ball with updating locals in a timely manner, and when social media is easy to update and widely used there really is no excuse.

Their websites are always unclear and frequently out of date.

EhrlicheFrau · 04/08/2023 10:05

I agree with you! Our area will, at some point in the not too distant future, be hosting quite a big event - while the event itself with undoubtedly be exciting I am already thinking of all the chaos it will (potentially) create, especially for some people in our community.

elderflowerandpomelo · 04/08/2023 10:03

@Fooshufflewickjbannanapants seven siblings?!? Yes if so…

Bernadinetta · 04/08/2023 09:57

elderflowerandpomelo · 04/08/2023 09:00

Our local park has been destroyed by 2 events, w no benefit to locals at all, just long lasting downside.
I reckon for a sporting event a part day closure is ok, but they shd get compensation from the organisers if it’s for longer. Locals just have to put up w it!

Tramlines?

Brushesarescary · 04/08/2023 09:53

The road closures preparing for the cycling championships seem to have been badly handled as well.

We were visiting Loch Lomond and then travelling up to Inverness with our caravan and the route was closed for resurfacing.

Not all the closures had been entered into the traffic management systems and it was impossible to get anywhere North towards Stirling- we had to go back to almost Glasgow. Signs for diversions were none existent.

I was glad that we are home before the event started as the potential for disruption looked huge and the information was vague at best- signage suggested some roads would be closed for days.

cruffinsmuffin · 04/08/2023 09:41

I'm near a popular seaside proms - absolute nightmare every summer. Roads closed, proms shut up and mangled, local businesses suffer (regularly raised on social media sites) etc etc.

The organisers don't want to take responsibility, they've had their license renewed for years into the future and it's a genuine pain.

Can't get to visit family because the roads are closed and the permit system is a mess, some of the older locals struggle with the pass system, some of our fave local shops really struggle as the town is so busy (gridlocked and accidents every time!) so regular customers can't get in to be able to spend the £££ they normally do.

Whilst the concert and acts are fab, it's just not been set up properly with consideration for the local area very well.

Fooshufflewickjbannanapants · 04/08/2023 09:38

@elderflowerandpomelo our local park too! Are you perhaps in the land of seven hills?