Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what position you think you’d have in the handmaids tale society?

159 replies

Econowifeonabudget · 03/08/2023 19:52

Been rewatching recently and the whole society is so alien to me. I struggle to understand how their economy functions given that they don’t appear to have widespread internet access, manufacturing, consumerism being the norm, exports etc. However, it did make me wonder what would happen if the handmades tale society existed in the modern day UK. I would guess I’d be an econowife given I’ve never committed any of the major ‘sins’ that might make me a handmaid but myself and DH are certainly not rich, powerful or religious. My guess is that many on mumsnet would be commanders wives. I know a few individuals in real life who would revel in being aunts and commanders respectively (shudder). Aibu to ask what position you think you’d have in the Handmaids tale society?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
namechangenacy · 06/08/2023 23:42

InMySpareTime · 06/08/2023 22:51

The problem would be how to protect and control a pregnant Jezebel as they were more openly rebellious than Handmaids. They wouldn't be able to use drugs to keep her docile and They would have to hide her for months without letting her harm herself or the baby, or start admitting that God can bless even sinful fornicators.

They sterilise the Jezebels girls I believe

fitzwilliamdarcy · 06/08/2023 22:58

I’m an infertile childless lesbian so the colonies for me. Cheerful thought for a Sunday evening.

InMySpareTime · 06/08/2023 22:51

The problem would be how to protect and control a pregnant Jezebel as they were more openly rebellious than Handmaids. They wouldn't be able to use drugs to keep her docile and They would have to hide her for months without letting her harm herself or the baby, or start admitting that God can bless even sinful fornicators.

XenoBitch · 06/08/2023 22:51

I would not want to live in a world like that. I would be dispatching myself pronto.

Deadringer · 06/08/2023 22:26

InMySpareTime · 05/08/2023 20:09

If a Jezebel got pregnant there might be questions about how that happened, given the front that commanders are always faithful to their wives, and nobody fornicates.

I suppose so, but babies were in such short supply that if an infertile wife was presented with a newborn without the inconvenience of a handmaid she probably wouldn't ask too many questions.

limoncello23 · 05/08/2023 23:05

I've read Testaments. I'm pretty sure I'd have been executed in a football stadium early on.

InMySpareTime · 05/08/2023 20:09

If a Jezebel got pregnant there might be questions about how that happened, given the front that commanders are always faithful to their wives, and nobody fornicates.

Deadringer · 05/08/2023 19:57

I never understood why the Jezebels were sterilised. Surely if any of them got pregnant it would have been a bonus? I know it wasn't likely as apparently the commanders were often sterile but still.

itsallnewnow · 05/08/2023 19:57

Handmaid I reckon, v. Fertile and once got pregnant on the implant, successful birth history x 3 and only 31 so time for a few more by their logic

Deadringer · 05/08/2023 19:54

I would probably be an eco wife as I am married to my first real boyfriend, had children after marriage, nothing they could use against me really except perhaps that we are not religious.

Blueuggboots · 05/08/2023 19:49

Martha if they didn't know I was gay....

LoobyDop · 05/08/2023 19:45

Moira was sent to be a Jezebel because she was too rebellious and uncontrollable to be a handmaid. I expect looks were a factor as well.

MillicentTrilbyHiggins · 05/08/2023 10:50

According to Google "rebellious" girls were sent to Jezebels, and sterilised!

magicalkitty · 05/08/2023 10:11

PomegranateOfPersephone · 05/08/2023 10:06

How were the Jezebels chosen I wonder?

Obviously they would have been attractive to the commanders, and deemed immoral I suppose, but were they also definitely infertile? Surely they wanted as many handmaids as possible so they wouldn’t have wasted potential handmaids, fertile women who haven’t begun menopause, on Jezebels. They would have needed a lot of handmaids too, but could have managed with a smaller number of Jezebels because Jezebels could service many men in a short space of time but handmaids can only service one man for a year or more.

Post menopause women wouldn’t be wanted as Jezebels because they wouldn’t be attractive to men anymore. I imagine that once Jezebels are no longer attractive to men they are sent off to the colonies, nothing else can be done with them unless there are other roles in Jezebel house which they could take on, some might be able to do that. They could never mix with wider Gilead society.

Menopausal handmaids might become assistants to Aunts of handmaids the oppressed often become the oppressors after all, and they are fully integrated into that system. I don’t think they could become Marthas, unless doing that role at the handmaid house. Janine was becoming an assistant to Aunt Lydia, not due to menopause but other reasons…

I noticed in the television series that Aunts also taught in the girls schools as well as dealing with handmaids.

I read the book a long time ago. IIRC the Jezebels were young, infertile 'sinful' women of childbearing age. If they were fertile they would have been handmaids.

If they were above a certain age they would be sent to the colonies.

PomegranateOfPersephone · 05/08/2023 10:06

How were the Jezebels chosen I wonder?

Obviously they would have been attractive to the commanders, and deemed immoral I suppose, but were they also definitely infertile? Surely they wanted as many handmaids as possible so they wouldn’t have wasted potential handmaids, fertile women who haven’t begun menopause, on Jezebels. They would have needed a lot of handmaids too, but could have managed with a smaller number of Jezebels because Jezebels could service many men in a short space of time but handmaids can only service one man for a year or more.

Post menopause women wouldn’t be wanted as Jezebels because they wouldn’t be attractive to men anymore. I imagine that once Jezebels are no longer attractive to men they are sent off to the colonies, nothing else can be done with them unless there are other roles in Jezebel house which they could take on, some might be able to do that. They could never mix with wider Gilead society.

Menopausal handmaids might become assistants to Aunts of handmaids the oppressed often become the oppressors after all, and they are fully integrated into that system. I don’t think they could become Marthas, unless doing that role at the handmaid house. Janine was becoming an assistant to Aunt Lydia, not due to menopause but other reasons…

I noticed in the television series that Aunts also taught in the girls schools as well as dealing with handmaids.

NaselHazel · 05/08/2023 09:51

I’m past childbearing age, so handmaiden is out. But I’ve had 4 births and healthy DCs, so that would get me some credit to become a Martha, instead of shipping me to the colonies. I’m a good cook and had a management job, so I might be useful as a Martha to a Commander. But I’ve got a postgraduate degree and I’m an atheist, lefty rebel, so if I was a Martha, I’d be part of the Underground Railroad smuggling handmaidens to Canada and putting poisonous mushrooms in the soup of nasty Wives.

SnakeBasket · 05/08/2023 09:38

I'm a cleaner so would probably be a Martha as too old to bear children now. 20 years ago I would have been a Jezebel!

magicalkitty · 05/08/2023 09:38

Elsiebear90 · 04/08/2023 13:48

As a 33 year old lesbian with no kids I reckon I would be straight to the colonies!

Nah, you would be forced to be a handmaid like poor Emily

magicalkitty · 05/08/2023 09:36

Anyone who has had a child outside marriage or married a man who was married before would be a handmaid.

I expect young women from 'poor' backgrounds would also be made handmaids in order to make as many babies as possible. Young women from rich and powerful families would be wives to commanders.

Econowives would be women already married pre-Gilead , as long as it was the first marriage for both of them.

Unmarried women past childbearing age would be marthas. If they were from rich and powerful families they may be an aunt.

CantFindTheBeat · 05/08/2023 09:32

PinkPlantCase · 04/08/2023 07:52

I don’t think people would see it coming either. I haven’t watched the series but read the books.

There was a slow erosion of women’s right and then suddenly one day women could have their own money. It was signed over to a man. If women didn’t have husbands they’d be in a pickle.

Good luck getting to the boarder without any money if your single or unmarried.

Given how all our money is basically electronic I can see how easily it could be done. Scary thought.

I think this too, @PinkPlantCase.

The early scenes with June and Moira, seeing the changes and then with cashless society, men telling them to coverup, etc, didn't hit home.

Even when June was told to leave her job (because she was a woman), didn't prompt them to leave (if I recall correctly).

Theredjellybean · 04/08/2023 17:44

I would be on the wall as a doctor who prescribed contraception and had referred women for abortions.

Also had an affair and got divorced...

ArcaneWireless · 04/08/2023 17:37

I’d be on the Wall most likely.

Failing that I’d be getting very very angry in the Colonies and would be summoning my inner core of June.

Turfwars · 04/08/2023 17:29

Skills wise I'm a Martha. I had one DC but now in peri menopause. I'm not authoritative enough to be an Aunt.

But I think we would have fled in time. Back when the first cases of covid hitting Europe I was already stocking up on tins and pasta (didn't think about the toilet paper though, dammit!) at DH's suggestion. So when the first panic hit the supermarkets we were grand.

My DB is a full on OFRS so he would have seen it coming a while back and likely I'd have hedged my bets and prepped a bit, once DH started to think that we should go, I'd be ready to go right away.

If our economy collapsed, we wouldn't be too bad I think. We've sufficient land to plant our own fruit and veg, and ILs have livestock so we could trade. So we'd have fruit and veg, eggs, meat and dairy, so we would probably be ok. Assuming the government didn't take it all off us!

LittleMissDarkness · 04/08/2023 17:21

Whatever position I was given I would definitely have been active in the resistance. Like to think I would have gone down fighting

Knotaknitter · 04/08/2023 16:48

I have a full set of Martha skills (I'd perhaps not make the grade on the cleaning but if my life depended on it, I'd learn) but I suspect I'd be an aunt or on the wall. It's the leadership skills that would be deadly, could I really keep my head down and my mouth shut for the rest of my life?