Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Has Anyone Successfully Left the Catholic Church?

161 replies

Mercurial123 · 03/08/2023 13:11

Has anyone formally left the Catholic Church and if so how easy/difficult was it? And how did you feel afterwards?

It's something I've been thinking about for a long time. My friends who were baptised Catholic but are now atheist looked a bit shocked, probably because no-one has ever considered it.

This is from a US site, but the procedure be the same in the UK?

www.buzzfeednews.com/article/expresident/how-to-leave-the-catholic-church

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
lilacsinbloom · 04/08/2023 14:10

Puzzledandpissedoff · 04/08/2023 12:43

Spoken like a true catholic, lilacsinbloom

Regarding facts, I'd ask if you've read the IICSA report into all this, or even considered why Vincent Nichols was allowed to remain in post after its publication, but suspect there's probably not much point

Hun, I left the Catholic church when I was 15. No-one followed me or chased me down. Carry on weirding.

Jackandjillswell · 04/08/2023 14:09

lilacsinbloom · 04/08/2023 11:56

This thread is like a consortium of freeman on the land. It's a mishmash of musinderstandings blown out of proportion and presented as facts.

Yup.

Couldn't agree more.

"Give a dog a bad name and hang him"

YetAnotherSpartacus · 04/08/2023 13:59

I remember a German friend telling me that paying the tax entitled them to church welfare in times of need and in old age (?).

Rheia1983 · 04/08/2023 13:56

LeonardCohensRaincoat · 04/08/2023 09:57

@UnicornStarfish

all recognised faiths in Germany have the tax, not just RCC. My German friend who is Lutheran opted out by filling in a govt form- just in case this gets latched on to as another thing to throw at only Catholics.

It was clergy in Munich, I think, where the RCC dominates and is a wealthy part of Germany. Not that it makes right, of course.

This is also the case in Switzerland. If you are a member of one of the three official churches (protestant, roman catholic and christ catholic) you pay taxes that are collected by the state and forwarded to the churches.

In order not to pay the tax you need to make a formal declaration to the parish you belong to and forward this declaration to the tax authority.

Sandra1984 · 04/08/2023 13:34

I was raised Catholic, got baptised, did first communion. In my teens stopped going to church, in my twenties became a Buddhist and now in my 50’s still am. Ones Spiritual beliefs are not an airport, there’s no need to announce any departures (unless you want to disclose to friends and loved ones). OP it all depends on your personal circumstances and how Social or professionaly entwined you are with Catholic religion. I was single, childless and financially independent so nobody cared but your personal circumstances may differ if your family is very religious or you teach at a catholic school.

LeonardCohensRaincoat · 04/08/2023 13:22

@Iwasafool

i think it’s a government/administrative thing - I don’t think it has any bearing on church records just tax records

https://wwkn.de/en/german-church-tax-kirchensteuer/#:~:text=The%20church%20tax%20is%20only,state%20(not%20religious)%20authorities.

“Members of a religious community under public law may formally declare their wish to leave the community to state (not religious) authorities. With such a declaration, the obligation to pay church taxes ends. Some communities refuse to administer marriages and burials of (former) members who had declared to leave it.”

But I have read elsewhere, it doesn’t affect religious records - may depend on Church/region?

German Church Tax (Kirchen­steuer) - WW+KN

German Church Tax (Kirchensteuer) In Germany, on the basis of tax regulations passed by the ...

https://wwkn.de/en/german-church-tax-kirchensteuer/#:~:text=The%20church%20tax%20is%20only,state%20(not%20religious)%20authorities.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 04/08/2023 12:43

lilacsinbloom · 04/08/2023 11:56

This thread is like a consortium of freeman on the land. It's a mishmash of musinderstandings blown out of proportion and presented as facts.

Spoken like a true catholic, lilacsinbloom

Regarding facts, I'd ask if you've read the IICSA report into all this, or even considered why Vincent Nichols was allowed to remain in post after its publication, but suspect there's probably not much point

lilacsinbloom · 04/08/2023 11:56

This thread is like a consortium of freeman on the land. It's a mishmash of musinderstandings blown out of proportion and presented as facts.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 04/08/2023 11:54

Nor abusing a child either ...

Well spotted and funny, that.

Iwasafool · 04/08/2023 11:54

LeonardCohensRaincoat · 04/08/2023 09:57

@UnicornStarfish

all recognised faiths in Germany have the tax, not just RCC. My German friend who is Lutheran opted out by filling in a govt form- just in case this gets latched on to as another thing to throw at only Catholics.

It was clergy in Munich, I think, where the RCC dominates and is a wealthy part of Germany. Not that it makes right, of course.

Do you know if leaving the church, any church, to avoid the tax a legal thing, I mean is it just so you don't pay the tax or is the church saying it means you are no longer a member.

Prettybutdumb · 04/08/2023 11:48

Interestingly enough I was verbally / formally removed by a priest during confession - I obviously confessed to doing something he didn’t like. He said I am officially no longer a child of god or a member of his church and only the archbishop or the pope can ever agree to take back on board. Best breakup ever!

Puzzledandpissedoff · 04/08/2023 11:42

Note that punching the Pope and procuring an abortion are up there (with reasons for excommunication) ... but not murder or rape

Nor abusing a child either ...

OchonAgusOchonOh · 04/08/2023 11:34

KimberleyClark · 04/08/2023 10:02

I thought that the only way to really leave the Catholic Church was to be excommunicated. Once baptised Catholic,always a Catholic, even if you never go again?

Excommunication doesn't get you out. You're just not allowed to receive sacraments until you repent.

KimberleyClark · 04/08/2023 10:02

I thought that the only way to really leave the Catholic Church was to be excommunicated. Once baptised Catholic,always a Catholic, even if you never go again?

LeonardCohensRaincoat · 04/08/2023 09:57

@UnicornStarfish

all recognised faiths in Germany have the tax, not just RCC. My German friend who is Lutheran opted out by filling in a govt form- just in case this gets latched on to as another thing to throw at only Catholics.

It was clergy in Munich, I think, where the RCC dominates and is a wealthy part of Germany. Not that it makes right, of course.

romdowa · 03/08/2023 23:58

You used to be able to leave formally as I know someone who has done it but I think they changed it during Vatican 2

UnicornStarfish · 03/08/2023 23:55

HelloHellebore · 03/08/2023 16:23

I know of several people in Germany who have formally left the catholic church. In Germany there is a “church tax” which is collected along with normal income tax and passed onto the church. In order to stop paying the church tax, you have to leave the church.
Only in german:

Get out of here! Shut the front door! What have I just read?!?! 😱😮Wooooow, the things I learn on MN! I can't belive what I've just read! Well, it's on wikipedia so it must true but honestly, jokes aside, I can't believe Germany has something like this. If you said this happens somewhere in Latin America or Africa I'd believe it without any issues but Germany?!?! Bloody heck! I can't believe this happens in a place like Germany. This doesn't even happen in Italy!
All of sudden it kind of makes sense how yeeears ago a Bishop (or a Cardinal?) in Germany got kicked in the behind for having gold taps and living in opulence in a very fancy schmancy mansion. Now I see where the money came from.
This sounds a lot like greed to me, one of them mortal sins!

Hannahsbananas · 03/08/2023 20:40

Op is so intent on going with a bang, not a whimper; but honestly no one will notice or particularly care.

Barrell · 03/08/2023 20:34

Why does it require the big performance? Just stop going to church and if anyone asks if you’re Catholic, say no.

Donotunderestimateme · 03/08/2023 20:31

I’m sure the census option (in U.K. in 2021) just says Christian. It does not differentiate between the denominations

LlynTegid · 03/08/2023 17:51

Surely if you were to be received or admitted into another church or another faith, effectively you would have left?

Or as others have said, you just stop going.

Jackandjillswell · 03/08/2023 17:49

I left the Catholic Church last Sunday at precisely 11.30.am. I went out of the side door, and then round the corner to the church hall for coffee and a biscuit.
It was simple and quite painless.
You can try it OP, it doesn't hurt. 😂

Iwasafool · 03/08/2023 17:32

Boomboom22 · 03/08/2023 17:21

I guess it depends, if there is a record of the number baptised which is used to back up arguments then you should be able to be removed surely? Like you can leave a political party. If not then it doesn't matter.

How would they know if you are still alive? People die, my husband hasn't been to church for 60 years, he was Baptised but how would they know if he's alive or dead.

The Baptismal Register is a historical record, you can't say it didn't happen if it did.

Boomboom22 · 03/08/2023 17:21

I guess it depends, if there is a record of the number baptised which is used to back up arguments then you should be able to be removed surely? Like you can leave a political party. If not then it doesn't matter.