Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Has Anyone Successfully Left the Catholic Church?

161 replies

Mercurial123 · 03/08/2023 13:11

Has anyone formally left the Catholic Church and if so how easy/difficult was it? And how did you feel afterwards?

It's something I've been thinking about for a long time. My friends who were baptised Catholic but are now atheist looked a bit shocked, probably because no-one has ever considered it.

This is from a US site, but the procedure be the same in the UK?

www.buzzfeednews.com/article/expresident/how-to-leave-the-catholic-church

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
5
Spidey66 · 05/08/2023 21:56

We just don't go, well only for hatches, matches and dispatches. You don't need to do anything else.

😂Love this and must remember it!

Jackandjillswell · 05/08/2023 21:26

OP I just don't understand why you want to "formally" leave.

Can you explain why this is so important ?

Notanotherusernameplease · 05/08/2023 18:38

Mercurial123 · 03/08/2023 13:14

That's not what I'm asking. I want to formally leave.

“Dear Vicar/priest/religious leader. I won’t be coming any more”. Surely you don’t need to make a big song and dance about it.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 05/08/2023 18:36

KnittedCardi · 05/08/2023 16:35

What rules?

Things life going to mass on Sunday, but you're not allowed communion.

porridgeisbae · 05/08/2023 18:09

You are still in the church even if excommunicated. All it means is you don't have the right to receive certain sacraments but are still meant to comply with the rules

What rules?

I'dve thought all of them. Supposedly the person in theory still should obey the rule of going to Mass for instance, but as the PP said, an excommunicated person can't take Communion.

Excommunication isn't usually for life nowadays, if the person stops doing the thing they were excommunicated for, and repents. It's more 'medicinal' to encourage the person to behave.

Coffeaddict · 05/08/2023 18:03

Mabelface · 03/08/2023 13:13

Just don't go anymore? I was raised Catholic and stopped going to church when I was 10.

This other then wedding and funerals I have not been in a church since I started secondary.

porridgeisbae · 05/08/2023 17:57

It is being damned if it does and if it doesn't. You can leave by not going but there is not a central database from which you are removed

Priests record it themselves and have to report it, I think at least to the diocese. https://classroom.synonym.com/how-to-get-a-copy-of-a-catholic-baptism-record-12084309.html

When my child was baptized it was made clear to me they were being baptized as a Christian not as a Catholic or Anglican.

Was one of you Catholic and one some other denomination? Or one of you not keen on Catholicism, like my mum only got married in a Catholic Church to please her mum? Otherwise I don't see why they would say it like that.

They do believe it does seal you as one of the Church (by implication, the Catholic church, but all baptism in the name of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit supposedly does the trick) There's the assumption that you'll carry on being Catholic.

Confirmation makes you a full participant.

I suppose just not following major rules of avoiding what they consider to be sins etc kind of takes you out of the Church anyway, as you're not in communion with it anymore.

How to Get a Copy of a Catholic Baptism Record | Synonym

https://classroom.synonym.com/how-to-get-a-copy-of-a-catholic-baptism-record-12084309.html

KnittedCardi · 05/08/2023 16:35

OchonAgusOchonOh · 05/08/2023 15:34

You are still in the church even if excommunicated. All it means is you don't have the right to receive certain sacraments but are still meant to comply with the rules.

What rules?

OchonAgusOchonOh · 05/08/2023 15:34

ExhaustedMuch · 05/08/2023 13:54

I know somebody who asked to be ex-communicated and actually was.

You are still in the church even if excommunicated. All it means is you don't have the right to receive certain sacraments but are still meant to comply with the rules.

ExhaustedMuch · 05/08/2023 13:54

I know somebody who asked to be ex-communicated and actually was.

Xenia · 05/08/2023 11:36

It is being damned if it does and if it doesn't. You can leave by not going but there is not a central database from which you are removed - that does not exist and given there are about 1.3 billion Catholics of 8bn people on the planet they will not be setting one up.

If it were a group where you have to tithe 10% of your income to the church as in some grops or pay to register each year for membership or the made it hard to leave that in my view would make it more of a problem.

I suppose someone who was bothered could set up their own datbase and allow ex Catholics who chose to have a public withdrawal to be registered on it in private or public to signify a formal leaving.

My father who had to be confirmed in the C of E in the 1940s to go to Durham university (the Bishop of Durham baptised him) started going to church again in his 70s and said the church missed a trick in gong after young families as instead older people with lots of time and spare money might be a better targe audience (he did sometimes go to Catholic mass with us as children occasionally. My point here is plenty of people dip in and out of the C of E and Catholicism across an 80 year life so if we started having official records of "leavers" it would be a lot of paperwork and then they might go back to the religion later anyway.

Jackandjillswell · 05/08/2023 10:11

Parker231 · 05/08/2023 09:40

Exactly - and one of the reasons organised religion is so wrong.

Why?

I's not a cult as the pp poster said.

It's not like Islam, where, in Muslim States, the punishment for Apostasy is death.

Parker231 · 05/08/2023 09:40

applepie04 · 05/08/2023 02:34

It's not a cult! Just leave and don't come back!

Exactly - and one of the reasons organised religion is so wrong.

Jackandjillswell · 05/08/2023 09:21

applepie04 · 05/08/2023 02:34

It's not a cult! Just leave and don't come back!

Exactly.

The Church will be wrong whatever it does.

If it gives people the right of self-determination it's accused of not caring.

On the other hand if it were to contact people try and encourage them to return, then it's accused of 'indoctrination', 'interfering in peoples' lives', brainwashing' 'controlling'etc etc

Xenia · 05/08/2023 09:07

I agree it is a complex issue as with my reference to some countries where there is the death penalty if you leave that religino (for apostacy). In the FLDS (polygamous fundamentalist mormons in the US) they regard apostates (those who leave) as much worse than people who were never in the religion and the shunning of those who leave by Amish, Jehovah's witnesses, those in Gloriavale in NZ and many other groups and the Scientologist cult is very difficult.

So the issue is certainly a big one although I don't think Catholicism is particularly top of the list in treatment of those who leave or want to leave. They will not be setting up a central register of who is a member and who leaves and remove someone from current membership but it would just be too big a task.

On baptism for those marrying in a Catholic church where one person is not Catholic they do want to see the baptism certificate such as from the C of E - eg my father was C of E and my mother Catholic. The Christian baptism is recognised in that sense. Although they will of course marry a Catholic in church who is not marrying a Christian.

The mainstearm mormon church (LDS) baptises dead people of all ages, even back to the 1600s which is why their family history records are such a wonderful free source of information and they have some of the best records. I have no problems with hat as it just does not count or have an effect (as I am not LDS) but some people do and they have stopped doing it for some groups who objected. If you don't believe in some other religions I don't personally have a problem with 10 different religions conferring blessings on you - bring them on, the more the better.

notol · 05/08/2023 06:47

I think I get it OP. You want them to notice that you feel deeply about this, and you'd like to receive more than a glib "no one cares, just stop going" response. You'd hope that people would care a little and wonder why, especially if you had some meaningful church connections.

The thing is that people are weird about others who leave organisations. There's something about group mentalities and dynamics. I don't know why it is, but there's often a "don't let the door hit you on your way out!" mentality instead of "what's the real problem" one.

Winterscomingagain · 05/08/2023 05:31

When my child was baptized it was made clear to me they were being baptized as a Christian not as a Catholic or Anglican.
The further rituals such as confirmation or communication are when a child is making a commitment to a particular church.

mathanxiety · 05/08/2023 05:22

NooNooTheNotSoGreat · 03/08/2023 13:40

The point is that the church still count her as a member, regardless of what she puts on the census or what she tells other people.

And...?

applepie04 · 05/08/2023 02:34

It's not a cult! Just leave and don't come back!

Willyoubuymeahouseofgold · 05/08/2023 00:47

😂No such thing as baptised Catholic! Just baptism . No discriminating criteria. I guess Confirmation would-be the Sacrament that " makes" you Catholic as you are joining the Church . Never knew they took names ,😁👀

Tomorrowillbeachicken · 05/08/2023 00:33

ASeriesOfTubes · 05/08/2023 00:33

Yes, Henry VIII.

😂

ASeriesOfTubes · 05/08/2023 00:33

Yes, Henry VIII.

porridgeisbae · 05/08/2023 00:25

@blueshoes Grin

blueshoes · 05/08/2023 00:24

You can check out any time you like but you can never leave.

Swipe left for the next trending thread