Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To call a company that turned me down?

64 replies

Eyesonthesize · 03/08/2023 12:41

There was my perfect job. Increase in salary. I could DO the job. And we need the extra money badly - we are running out of savings as more is going out than coming in.

I spent so long researching, I read everything that the CEO and directors have ever said about anything. I did about 5 drafts of the cover letter. II have never tried harder for a job.

Turned down without an interview. It was a really well paid job for what they were looking for - as they said they've been surprised at the huge number of quality applications - but i wasn't as it was v well paid for the job and sector.

I was fully imagining my job there. My commute, what I would do there. I keep daydreaming about receiving a email inviting me to interview and letting myself imagine myself doing the job.

That sounds crazy right. I just nearly called the company to ask them to re-consider - that's a stupid idea right?

Can someone give me some stern words and help me get a grip.

OP posts:
MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 03/08/2023 14:19

tenbob · 03/08/2023 13:30

You expect HR people to show discretion?!

Have you ever met anyone who works in HR..? 😂

Yes. And some of them have been dreadful but even the worst ones generally had a fairly basic grasp of data protection. I'm sorry that your experiences have been otherwise.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 03/08/2023 14:17

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 03/08/2023 14:06

My understanding under Equal ops is that ALL applications that meet ALL the essential criteria are called for interview

I think there my be a public sector requirement to interview everyone who meets all the essential criteria and has a disability. But it certainly doesn't apply to everybody who applies to any job. It would be unmanageable.

It applies to any employer which has signed up to the disability confident scheme (used to be two ticks).

There is no legal requirement to interview people who meet the essential criteria otherwise. It would be completely unmanageable if that was the requirement!

SamW98 · 03/08/2023 14:15

Have to agree that calling them won’t achieve anything and might make you feel worse.

When I was a manager, we used to get 50-100 CV’s for every job we advertised and that just the external applicants. Our HR whittled them down so they only sent me the most suitable 10-12 and we probably interviewed 5 of those.

outdooryone · 03/08/2023 14:12

OP, I would not call back. It would not reflect favourably on you. Your personal motivation or dreams of getting that job is irrelevant. Can you imagine if every applicant phoned up and begged for an interview as they 'deserved' or 'wanted' the job more?

Last week I had to reduce 38 applicants down to a manageable number to interview. Selection is brutal - and something made them say no to you.

Move on, find that next opportunity and apply.

.

My understanding under Equal ops is that ALL applications that meet ALL the essential criteria are called for interview. As an employer, they have now met the lawful requirement of giving the opportunity to everyone capable equally )

That really is not the case.
You give everyone a chance equally through the application process.
You can then choose who the heck you like - from no-one to everyone - for interview.

fuckthisprivilage · 03/08/2023 14:08

I'm sorry to hear that, OP, it's absolutely heartbreaking to miss out on what feels like a perfect opportunity.

I'd like to offer a different perspective as a small business owner. Hiring is HARD, and in a small business we don't have HR or recruitment team or anything like that to help us. We have to write the job description ourselves, stick it on Indeed and LinkedIn, and then personally try to whittle it down to a few possible candidates from the tens or often hundreds of completely disparate applications we receive.

It's hugely time consuming and can be confusing and overwhelming, and although we do have a process we follow it still feels pretty random at times. We usually make good hires in the end, but I always finish the process very well aware that there may have been an even better candidate who for some reason didn't make the inital cut for interviewing.

Also, we don't close a job ad until we have had an offer accepted, so we keep getting applications once we are already at the interviewing stage (although I try to minimise this by lowering the ad spend or pausing it, depending on the platform). So unless the interviews were going badly or you were an absolutely stand out candidate, you wouldn't get an interview even if your application was as good as (or even slightly better than) the candidates already shortlisted.

In either case, I would definitely read an email/letter from a candidate I'd rejected, and consider it in the context of where I was in the process and the strength of your application. It's possible I'd realise you had "slipped though the net" and want to meet you.

(I know this all sounds quite shambolic, but it's the reality of recruitment in many SMEs, which are often underrepresented on MN where the assumption seems to be that everyone works for a large, mature organisation).

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 03/08/2023 14:06

My understanding under Equal ops is that ALL applications that meet ALL the essential criteria are called for interview

I think there my be a public sector requirement to interview everyone who meets all the essential criteria and has a disability. But it certainly doesn't apply to everybody who applies to any job. It would be unmanageable.

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 03/08/2023 14:03

It was a fairly niche department so they could check to see how long I’d been there.

Eh? You think as part of their hiring process they should have checked how long you had been a customer? Apart from being completely irrelevant to your ability to do the job, that would almost certainly be a data handling breach.

Sunshineclouds11 · 03/08/2023 13:56

🤣🤣 my bad I thought they had to. People can chill.

JenWillsiam · 03/08/2023 13:53

Sunshineclouds11 · 03/08/2023 12:50

The job most likely went to someone who was already lined up for it internally.
They legally still have to advertise.

I wouldn't ring/email them if you never got an interview.

No they do not.

www.acas.org.uk/hiring-someone/how-to-advertise-a-job

SunnieShine · 03/08/2023 13:53

I see no harm in phoning them. Yes, the job may have been ear marked for an internal candidate. On the other hand it may not, or they or the other applicants may not get the job/turn it down.

If you do, have your list of why you are suitable to hand.

I don't think this makes you look weird, it makes you look keen.

YukoandHiro · 03/08/2023 13:43

We had a lot of applicants is usually code for "we were only going to interview the two internal people we already knew but now need to explain to all these amazing people why we're not calling them, bollocks that'll do as an excuse"

VictoriaVenkman · 03/08/2023 13:43

You would be unreasonable to as them to reconsider. They've already told you that other candidates had stronger CV's so that is your feedback. I'm sorry you are so disappointed, I've been there myself and it is an awful feeling.

Lazylikeasundaymorning · 03/08/2023 13:41

Playingchesswithpigeons · 03/08/2023 13:38

My understanding under Equal ops is that ALL applications that meet ALL the essential criteria are called for interview. As an employer, they have now met the lawful requirement of giving the opportunity to everyone capable equally )
As much as you researched & as much as you tried, you clearly did not meet ALL of the essential criteria.
You could only contact them on the basis you missed an essential criteria and then ask if the applicants interviewed were not successful, you could be considered for an interview.

This isn’t true- what if there were 500 applicants who met the essential criteria?!

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 03/08/2023 13:40

RoseBucket · 03/08/2023 12:48

I wonder is the position went to an internal applicant?

Definitely.

I’ve had this sort of experience sort of recently but I did have the interview and got down to final 2. They’d already decided an internal applicant had it but I think she was either moving internally for some reason or not decided as I was asked how quickly I could start before, then there was a gap of a month before they got back to me.

It was my bank I’d had for over 30 years including savings and mortgage with them and I was furious afterwards and I do plan to switch accounts. It was a fairly niche department so they could check to see how long I’d been there. I also thought they’d be a good employer.

In your case definitely don’t chase them as they will think you’re strange.

GaspingGekko · 03/08/2023 13:39

I once did this OP. I won't explain the exact circumstances, but it wasn't for a permanent job, and there were a few places available, so this might differ from your situation.

I was surprised to have been rejected without even an invite to interview so I called them and asked if they could provide feedback on why, after looking again at my application they said there was no reason and offered me an interview slot.
I went on to gain one of the available places.

caringcarer · 03/08/2023 13:39

What you could do is email and ask if they will keep for CV for consideration if another job comes up.

Playingchesswithpigeons · 03/08/2023 13:38

My understanding under Equal ops is that ALL applications that meet ALL the essential criteria are called for interview. As an employer, they have now met the lawful requirement of giving the opportunity to everyone capable equally )
As much as you researched & as much as you tried, you clearly did not meet ALL of the essential criteria.
You could only contact them on the basis you missed an essential criteria and then ask if the applicants interviewed were not successful, you could be considered for an interview.

GoingGoingUp · 03/08/2023 13:37

TeapotCollection · 03/08/2023 13:31

This happened a good few years ago

The Company I work for was advertising for a Director. Lots of applications so, as others have said, they had to be brutal

Three days after sending out the ‘sorry but you haven’t got an interview’ letters, an envelope came in the post addressed to the owner of the Company, sent by Special Delivery. I wasn’t allowed to open his post, and knew he wouldn’t be in for a few days so I put it in his tray

Half an hour after I signed for the letter, I had a phone call asking what his response had been to the letter. I explained that he wasn’t in and wouldn’t be for a few days, cue rant about it being very important etc.

When the owner came in, the letter was asking him to reconsider his decision not to interview him, he knew he was perfect for the job and could outperform any other candidate (yes really!). It went straight in the bin. We still talk about it now

Definitely don’t ring them OP

Funny how there are such different experiences. I did the similar (although sent an email and didn’t chase up with phone calls going on about how important I am). But I did get the job and am often referred to as one of their best hires

Nellynoowhoareyou · 03/08/2023 13:35

Personally I think if you’ve got the guts to do it then go for it. I was desperate for a particular role/company once and the agency talked them into giving me an interview. Maybe you were borderline and just didn’t make the cut based on something trivial, who knows? I think it matters who you speak to though and I guess you have no control over that. Obviously you’d have to be extremely professional and non-desperate and plan how you’ll sell it very carefully. Give it a shot I say!

TeapotCollection · 03/08/2023 13:31

This happened a good few years ago

The Company I work for was advertising for a Director. Lots of applications so, as others have said, they had to be brutal

Three days after sending out the ‘sorry but you haven’t got an interview’ letters, an envelope came in the post addressed to the owner of the Company, sent by Special Delivery. I wasn’t allowed to open his post, and knew he wouldn’t be in for a few days so I put it in his tray

Half an hour after I signed for the letter, I had a phone call asking what his response had been to the letter. I explained that he wasn’t in and wouldn’t be for a few days, cue rant about it being very important etc.

When the owner came in, the letter was asking him to reconsider his decision not to interview him, he knew he was perfect for the job and could outperform any other candidate (yes really!). It went straight in the bin. We still talk about it now

Definitely don’t ring them OP

tenbob · 03/08/2023 13:30

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 03/08/2023 13:25

Fair enough. My organisation is obviously a bit more generous than others then. We wouldn't blacklist someone simply because they really wanted to work for us. Unless the OP is planning to go in with some sort of complaint or weird harassment campaign, we would just politely encourage her to try again next time.

As a Chief Executive, I would take a very dim view of our HR people sharing personal data about candidates with external contacts. I expect my staff to be more professional.

You expect HR people to show discretion?!

Have you ever met anyone who works in HR..? 😂

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 03/08/2023 13:25

tenbob · 03/08/2023 13:20

You have a lot to lose

Eg
Being blacklisted as a weirdo by the company and excluded if any other roles come up
The HR person telling their also-works-in-HR-mate over a glass of wine that they had the most bizarre call at work today and two companies blacklisting you if other roles come up

Fair enough. My organisation is obviously a bit more generous than others then. We wouldn't blacklist someone simply because they really wanted to work for us. Unless the OP is planning to go in with some sort of complaint or weird harassment campaign, we would just politely encourage her to try again next time.

As a Chief Executive, I would take a very dim view of our HR people sharing personal data about candidates with external contacts. I expect my staff to be more professional.

GoingGoingUp · 03/08/2023 13:25

Go for it. You have nothing to lose.

Happened to me a few years ago. It was through an agency but I just knew the job was for me. However, I was turned down.

My gut told me my application didn’t get any further than HR who probably aren’t the best place to decide if I’m right for the role, so I emailed the head of the department directly explaining how keen I am to work there. I got the job in the end!

Flyonthewall01 · 03/08/2023 13:21

I think it’s a bit disingenuous to say it’s gone to an internal candidate and that’s why. Even where there is a high chance of a job going internally most often companies will still interview the best external candidates too. The op sadly wasn’t selected as that either.
More likely is that they are up against better candidates.
OP it wasn’t meant for you and something better will come in it’s place

tenbob · 03/08/2023 13:20

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 03/08/2023 13:16

I don't think you have anything to lose by phoning them, OP, if you really feel compelled to, but if they haven't shortlisted you, it is presumably because they had plenty of candidates who better fitted their criteria.

You have a lot to lose

Eg
Being blacklisted as a weirdo by the company and excluded if any other roles come up
The HR person telling their also-works-in-HR-mate over a glass of wine that they had the most bizarre call at work today and two companies blacklisting you if other roles come up