Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we could manage a £2200 mortgage payment

388 replies

Dyr · 03/08/2023 09:58

on a take home pay of £4k.
After purchasing the house we would have £40k - £50k left in savings / investments.
The repayments would be about £2.2k per month but our combined take home would be £4k, and due to the jobs we are in its unlikely to increase. late 30s/early40s with 2 kids (primary school age)

OP posts:
Combusting · 03/08/2023 14:55

mast0650 · 03/08/2023 14:43

Our take home pay is 7.5k and our mortgage is 2.55k. It's a real struggle!

Really?? It's a "real struggle" to live on almost 5k a month after tax and mortgage? We're getting a very skewed selection of responses here. On other threads this response would receive outright derision!

Trying hard to understand this. Our combined take home net pay is £7k. On this was manage to -

  1. Overpay mortgage (1881) significantly to actually pay 3130 a month on mortgage by choice. That’s £1249 in OPs monthly.
  2. Keep 1 child in FT nursery
  3. Have other child attend an after school activity club daily, plus various holiday clubs and 3 additional activities, both also swim at non bog standard pools.
  4. Have £200 stashed away monthly for holiday
  5. Manage to save for ourselves and kids
  6. Do all other bills, including having a dog and live in the SE.

Our personal allowances are ridiculously low I guess. We cut our own hair, never buy new clothes etc.

How are you quite so struggling?

PuffyShirt · 03/08/2023 14:54

No way. We take home a lot more than that and there’s no way I’d even consider those repayments.

Greeneyegirl · 03/08/2023 14:49

I don't think that's bad. Our mortgage is £980 and our take home pay £3300 so you'd be about the same.

mast0650 · 03/08/2023 14:49

but thats "keeping savings for a rain day" is going to cost you money, can you make as much on compound interest on the £50,000 which is going to cost £50k in extra repayments on a mortgage

If the interest rate on the mortgage and savings is the same, then it makes absolutely no difference to the final financial position whether she reduces the mortage now or or hangs on to all the savings and pays down the mortgage later.

Of course, if she ends up spending the savings at some point, then that is equivalent to borrowing more and will cost more in interest. But the ability to dip into the savings does give a bit more flexibility, for as long as she still has them.

Figgygal · 03/08/2023 14:45

No way
We have joint income over £5k a month and struggle with all bills and a mortgage of £1400 a month
You would be surviving not living with little flex in finances for the unexpected
Kids get more expensive as they get older and there's still so much unknown about living costs in the short term
You'd be bonkers

mast0650 · 03/08/2023 14:43

Our take home pay is 7.5k and our mortgage is 2.55k. It's a real struggle!

Really?? It's a "real struggle" to live on almost 5k a month after tax and mortgage? We're getting a very skewed selection of responses here. On other threads this response would receive outright derision!

FoodFann · 03/08/2023 14:38

No chance. You’ve found a bank that will agree to this?

WetBandits · 03/08/2023 14:32

Oh god no! Our combined take home is around £4K and we are struggling with paying £1100 plus all our other bills, and that is just for two adults, no kids in the mix. You would be insane to even consider this.

Whatafustercluck · 03/08/2023 14:30

Yabu. £63 is based on your current outgoings. Your outgoings will increase. That is an inadequate buffer. Are you prepared to live without luxuries, too?

Letitgonowgr · 03/08/2023 14:27

Dyr · 03/08/2023 11:11

I've done a budget calculator, and excluding the mortgage our total expenses would have £63 quid left over each month.

Are you mad?

outdooryone · 03/08/2023 14:25

I personally would look to buy a cheaper house AND use a significant chunk of savings to reduce the mortgage.
I would not be comfortable earning £4k joint a month and only having £63 left. The slightest bill increase, luxury or issue and that is gone, every month.

arlequin · 03/08/2023 14:22

Could you get a lodger? We managed a very tight mortgage by doing this and gave us an extra £800/month

MrsR87 · 03/08/2023 14:18

For me, £63 is was too little of a buffer per month. My children’s nursery fees increased by £8 each per day recently and that equates to more than your buffer extra per week, never mind month; so had we used the same calculations as yours, we’d be screwed.

For what it’s worth, our take home pay is around £6000. Our mortgage is currently £1000. We just worked out our finance spreadsheet and we are cutting it super fine at that. The only “luxuries” we have in this are life insurance policies, sky, Spotify and contact lenses. I’d probably also include our pension payments as a luxury that could be cut if necessary. All other bills are things like gas, water, council tax, car insurance, food and of course our killer at £2500 a month, childcare!
we always worked on the rule that we could afford our mortgage and absolutely essential bills on one of our wages which we could comfortably do until the cost of living crisis (by comfortably I mean still have the odd meal out, a family day trip here and there and a bottle of wine a week plus haircuts etc and cover mortgage and bills on one wage). Now let’s assume I lost my job…which is the exact amount of money the childcare costs (so nursery doesn’t affect this equation) and now we would not be able to afford any extras, we’d have to sell one of the cars and we’d have to drop all the none essentials like contact lenses, sky, Spotify and probably pension payments for a while too. Ridiculous really but it’s the way it is. Too many people have, through inflation ended up with buffers much smaller than yours, or even deficits who three years ago would have been deemed as “well off”. I would not knowingly put myself in a position where my buffer was £63 a month in the current climate unless I absolutely had no other choice.

rainingsnoring · 03/08/2023 14:14

Absolutely bonkers. Have people learned nothing from the rising interest rates and inflation?

Does the 40-50k of savings include pensions or not? Is the 4k month of net income after pension deductions?
Even if the answer to the questions is positive you can only afford a mortgage half the size at present.

Treesinmygarden · 03/08/2023 14:14

HangerLaneGyratorySystem · 03/08/2023 13:52

Whilst I think it might be a bit foolish to take on such a large mortgage, I'm watching this thread with interest as posters are pretty unanimous that a family of 4 can't live on £1,800 cash a month ...?!

I was paying up to £1300/month for childcare, and that was a few years back!

pinkpirlie · 03/08/2023 14:13

Nope, don't do it.
Take home is over £5k and we pay £800 mortgage and don't have kids and I wouldn't want the mortgage any higher than that.

Weedoormatnomore · 03/08/2023 14:12

Dyr · 03/08/2023 11:11

I've done a budget calculator, and excluding the mortgage our total expenses would have £63 quid left over each month.

Is that using costs incurred from new house water bill heating etc will be more. Do you really need 50k in savings?
Got to say seems madness sorry would be surprised if you could get a mortgage in principle.

Mortgageportgage · 03/08/2023 14:09

HangerLaneGyratorySystem · 03/08/2023 13:52

Whilst I think it might be a bit foolish to take on such a large mortgage, I'm watching this thread with interest as posters are pretty unanimous that a family of 4 can't live on £1,800 cash a month ...?!

It's crazy but true I think. If you factor in say £800 for bills (council tax, energy, insurances etc) another £500 for food that leaves you £500. I pay that in childcare alone. Even if I didn't you'd need money for savings, kids activities, adult spending money, transport (public or running a vehicle), holidays, Christmas, clothing and haircuts, house maintenance and upgrades, £1,800 really doesn't go as far as it should.

Extraordinarytimes · 03/08/2023 14:09

Due to Covid salary downturn, and the interest rate increase, we take home 4.5k and our mortgage is 2.2k. When the rates started to rise out term expired and we fixed at the then high rate of 5%; it was that or move. Snap decision and I question it most days as obviously we are now locked in with big penalty charges. We have three children and run two cars. The children have clubs of a few hundred each month total; this could be cut but we prioritise them.

The leftover is just enough for total non-frills, no leisure, no clothes etc etc. I therefore try to earn around another 500-1k per month so that we have money for birthdays/clothes/furniture/holiday/etc etc. Even with overtime, the available spend for my husband and I is nil, and we are both knackered.

From the outside, we probably appear fine for money; it’s happened suddenly so we have some nice things and we have a large house. The kids are largely unaware and have what they need, and some of what they want. Reality is quite miserable and unless there is a significant financial uplift in the next year or so, we will have to downsize. It is not a position to willingly put yourself into.

Butchyrestingface · 03/08/2023 14:05

Dyr · 03/08/2023 11:11

I've done a budget calculator, and excluding the mortgage our total expenses would have £63 quid left over each month.

Definition of insanity right there.

porridgeisbae · 03/08/2023 14:04

@Dyr If the last couple of years has taught us anything, remember your mortgage could go up at some point in the future. So it's better to leave yourself plenty of leeway. Also one day one of you might happen to be unemployed for a while. So I'm not an expert but I'dve thought it's better to have an amount that you could cover with one of your salaries at a push.

Lastnightschips · 03/08/2023 13:58

I’m paying that with an income of just under 4K (not by choice, interest rate increase) and it’s very challenging. Even with income closer to 5.5k we didn’t have masses left over. The less comfortable end of comfortable.

WimbyAce · 03/08/2023 13:57

I would say no! I think you would be better off using some of the savings to reduce the balance particularly with mortgage rates the way they are at the moment.

Bluepolkadots42 · 03/08/2023 13:57

We have take home pay of £4k like you. Once we've paid all bills, food, childcare, petrol etc. We have a 1.5yo and a 5yo and have very little left at end of month. Our mortgage is £1300. I don't think your plan is affordable at all I'm afraid and would be very surprised if you passed affordability checks with lenders for a £2.2k/month mortgage.

OrangeSpicedBun · 03/08/2023 13:57

The problem is vulnerability...you never know what could happen with illness/work ect. I know that's what savings are for but the more manageable the better. Offsetting with your savings might reduce the payments ...but only by a bit.

Is it worth it?

Swipe left for the next trending thread