Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

shaming of mothers with a career?!

263 replies

rubopp · 03/08/2023 08:51

Again today I’ve read a thread where a women is criticised for needing childcare when their child is under one.

AIBU to think if we had threads/comments saying ‘why aren’t you in a decent job to provide well for your dc?’, that they would be deleted?

There’s actually lots of evidence that children do well in life and thrive in higher income homes. No, it’s not everything and overall it probably doesn’t matter… just like it doesn’t matter in the long run if someone decides to stay home with their dc until their dc go to school.

What IS this shaming of mothers who dare to have a career?! Jealously? Narrow mindedness?

I find it mind boggling that people think you can take years out of a career and come back to it… in highly successful roles actually you can’t do that. Though I suspect those people who post such nasty things have no idea if they’ve never achieved that themselves.

There’s lots of benefits to being able to fund all your child’s activities, holidays, books, cultural trips especially as they get older and need house deposits, cars etc so let’s not pretend that the only way to raise a child is to live frugally and don’t dare to make anything of yourself.

Rant over.

OP posts:
Summertime109 · 03/08/2023 10:04

Women are always shamed for their choices - you have shamed sahm in your post.

I‘’m more of a middle ground. For me work is a means to an end. I am choosing to work less when I return from Mat leave as I believe it will give ne a better work life balance and this will in turn make me a happier person. I could not be reliant on a man for money (luckily as I did 7 years as a single parent). I don’t much care for promotions or work ‘opportunities’.

judgement of my choices wouldn’t impact me as I am happy with the choices I have made. I also don’t feel the need to judge others life choices, but do feel Sad that some women don’t have choices and that some End up being financially abused due to their choices

User839516 · 03/08/2023 10:03

rubopp · 03/08/2023 08:59

@EhrlicheFrau that’s exactly my point though.

People don’t say these things yet they could. We don’t shame women who choose to stay at home.

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

Threenow · 03/08/2023 09:59

How do you know what those taking time out have ever achieved in their lives?
Do you realise that you can 'make something of yourself' in ways other than career/money driven?)

Well said. I have no time for people who think being career/money driven is the only way to have a good life, in fact I actually feel a bit sorry for them (and their kids).

gingerguineapig · 03/08/2023 09:51

And yes I do understand that some women can't work because the childcare costs don't add up (but then why is it always the women who give up work and not the men - and why are the costs only netted off against the woman's earnings) - but the people I am talking about had good careers and could have afforded childcare but chose not to.

Some did go back after a couple of years - I know one person who did a degree and has worked ever since her dd was about 3 (and that was in a medical field).

Poorlymumma · 03/08/2023 09:50

I don't judge women who work or women who stay at home, as long as they ensure the children are safe and cared for. The thing that annoys me is people complaining about the cost of childcare/thinking that childcare should be free, as if it's a human right to pop out a baby and have someone else look after them all day for free. Nursery staff are not paid enough and this attitude is partly why.

gingerguineapig · 03/08/2023 09:48

In real life I've never been judged for working, I don't think people give a shit either way IRL

I hope times have changed. I was judged at primary school for being the only mother who was working full-time (other than two others who were "allowed" to as one was a single mum and the other was widowed).

JusthereforXmas · 03/08/2023 09:48

rubopp · 03/08/2023 08:59

@EhrlicheFrau that’s exactly my point though.

People don’t say these things yet they could. We don’t shame women who choose to stay at home.

Women who stay at home are shamed ALL THE DAMN TIME.

You LITERALLY started a whole thread to do just that while somehow claiming to be the victim.

Many of us aren't fortunate enough to work, thing about poverty is its a trap.

working hard does NOT equal 'higher income'.

Very few make it out of poverty and those that do believe it or not didn't 'just' through hard work, they did it with a lot of luck and a rare opportunity. Some of the hardest and longest working people I know (started in early teens and still going at retirement age in hard manual jobs) have never magic-ed they way out of poverty.

When you only have whats deemable as 'minimum wage' skills you cannot afford to go to work and pay childcare to go make a pittance... its a LUXURY.

I thought I 'got out' when I studied hard and went to uni (the ONLY person from my background to go, first in my family). I did a good medical based course as well not a 'throw away' degree.

State of the NHS now I literally can't afford to do those excessive hours for that little pay... its NOT possible and would bankrupt us. On top of that their have been massive redundancies in the sector I am in so not enough jobs to go around even if I was rich enough to take the financial loss.

I'm not starting threads about the ignorance of the privileged working mams who dont realise how being able to afford child care so you can focus on your own career and mental/social health (trust me being able to go into an office and converse with other adults instead of being screamed at 24/7 by people who cant communicate their needs is something most SAHM would love) is not something afforded to everyone.

gingerguineapig · 03/08/2023 09:47

pastatriangles · 03/08/2023 09:45

Someone on a thread once criticised me for not quitting my career and going on benefits. It was a thread about NCPs not seeing their kids, and the rebuttal was 'you can't complain about your kids not seeing their dad unless you quit your job and stay home with them on benefits 24/7.'

Really not sure why I still post on here tbh

Cross-post! I wonder if it was the same one?

gingerguineapig · 03/08/2023 09:47

When my son was very small I was on MN and the anti-working-mum feeling was quite strong. I also remember someone saying that it was better to stay at home and claim benefits than go out to work and farm your child out.

I also remember going to some NCT or similar event and mentioning that I was working 4 days a week when I went back to work and the person I said it to looked very disapproving. Yeah, I just didn't choose a rich enough husband to allow me not to work, sorry.

I think times have changed and it is more acceptable for women to work, especially part-time. And I think it's very silly to aim to rely on benefits and/or a man. Make sure you keep your own income and maintain your skills.

I've never understood all the angst around nurseries etc given that they are widely used across the Nordic countries and the kids seem very well adjusted to me!

pastatriangles · 03/08/2023 09:45

Someone on a thread once criticised me for not quitting my career and going on benefits. It was a thread about NCPs not seeing their kids, and the rebuttal was 'you can't complain about your kids not seeing their dad unless you quit your job and stay home with them on benefits 24/7.'

Really not sure why I still post on here tbh

EhrlicheFrau · 03/08/2023 09:44

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 03/08/2023 09:39

I don't feel that I compromised on either, personally.

I had a career before my child-rearing days, so while I did give some of that up to be at home, I don't feel I missed out overall. I do think it feels like a balancing act for some people though, plus whatever you do someone will be lurking to say 'oh, why don't you......(insert whatever they think you should be doing)'? I definitely don't think shaming those who make different choices is the way to go, even if we don't understand their choices. It's also nice to hear that you feel you haven't had to compromise too much (I genuinely mean that, it's not sarcasm!).

Saoirse82 · 03/08/2023 09:43

You're saying women don't get shamed for staying at home while shaming women for staying at home. SAHMs get shamed on here more often because the majority of us on here seem to be working mothers.

I took a years maternity with both mine but needed to go back although I would have liked to have taken a couple of years out but it just wasn't possible.

My Mother was an accountant though in a managerial role and she took 4 years out when my sister and I were little and went back still the higher earner, so it's not true that all women can't take a break.

In real life I've never been judged for working, I don't think people give a shit either way IRL.

JazbayGrapes · 03/08/2023 09:41

Because motherhood is a toxic competition

NewCracker · 03/08/2023 09:40

I think the simple answer to this question is ALL mothers are shamed. Be it SAHM, or WM. It could be jealousy that the WM feels she has to go out to provide this certain lifestyle and wishes she could stay home and spend time with her much loved children. But on the flip reverse the SAHM may wish she could provide more of a "comfortable" lifestyle for her children but a minimum wage job would barely cover childcare so there isn't really any point in her working.
One thing you have to remember OP is that this country wouldn't run on only people who are "successful" or have "made something of themselves", it runs on the minimum wage workers doing the shitty jobs that the high earners don't want to do.

This society shames everyone for everything, but unfortunately women get the brunt of it, and we are also pretty bad for shaming each other. This is a very deep rooted and complex issue in society, not one that I think we're going to get to the bottom of on MN.

Although I think maybe we can all agree that we are just doing what we think is right for our children in our individual lives.

itsmyp4rty · 03/08/2023 09:40

It's lucky you're not nasty or judgemental OP like those other mums who could never aspire to reach the dizzying heights you have in their career.

I'm not jealous of your career, I'm only envious of people who are genuinely really happy in life and you don't sound like one of those people.

Kaibashira · 03/08/2023 09:40

YANBU for saying women who choose to use fulltime childcare options should not be shamed.

YABU for equating "career" with high income. There will be plenty of scenarios where a woman needs FT childcare but isn't raking it in.

Access to high quality, affordable childcare to enable parents to earn a decent wage, achieve work-family balance, and contribute to society / the economy are things we should all be demanding.

There's also the employer issue: exactly why can't an extended career break be taken? Other than simply tradition / expectations based on men = earner, woman = carer. Who says you can't take a few years off and come back at the same level? Why not?

"Women who don't have certain types of jobs which are well paid but aren't generally amenable to career breaks are envious of me and the money I make" is a take on this issue as bad and divisive as (e.g.) "no-one should put their child in nursery before one".

Cardshark · 03/08/2023 09:40

I find this thread goady too OP.
Not your point - of course mothers should be able to choose what to do without shame - but the way you said it.
Referring to SAHMs as people who "don’t dare to make anything of yourself"?
Not nice.
As someone who's spent time at home I can tell you now the shaming goes in both directions (as you've so aptly illustrated).

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 03/08/2023 09:39

krakenworst · 03/08/2023 09:32

its a fact not universally acknowledged that each of us chooses ( or has no choice due to economic reasons) how much to compromise career versus how much to compromise the children’s upbringing. To

I don't feel that I compromised on either, personally.

GCAcademic · 03/08/2023 09:38

Basically all women get shamed:

Mothers who work
Mothers who stay at home
Women who have the temerity not to have children

No one bothers themselves about fathers who work or men who don't reproduce. And if a father stays at home to bring up his child he's feted like a bloody hero.

EhrlicheFrau · 03/08/2023 09:38

Kim729 · 03/08/2023 09:35

Hmm, I didn’t agree with this part either but for this reason: the women I know who have become SAHMs left successful careers and their husbands are also successful - hence they became SAHMs as they earn enough to not be affected too much by the entire loss of an income.

I do think it’s a shortsighted criticism though and failing to understand someone else’s circumstances. Eg A woman might not have a choice to be a SAHM or have a maternity leave lasting beyond the full pay period because of finances, no family support to help with nursery pick ups, mental health or postnatal depression which makes them want to go back to work, the cost of nursery being more than they earn (yes, I know there are many benefits of work) etc… The list goes in. I’m sure all circumstances have already been covered many times throughout the thread.

But surely being rude about women who have decided to be SAHMs is not much better than being rude about women who decide not to be?

Your last line sums up exactly what I was trying to say back there - I completely agree with you.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 03/08/2023 09:36

Meh, my dd and her friends are all young adults now, and you really can't tell the difference between those who had WOHMs, SAHMs or something in between. One group is not happier, healthier or successful than the other.

It really doesn't matter what people do, as long as they provide a loving and supportive home for their children - the kids will be absolutely fine either way. So women should do whatever works best for themselves (and their partners where relevant).

Kim729 · 03/08/2023 09:35

AnneLovesGilbert · 03/08/2023 08:55

Though I suspect those people who post such nasty things have no idea if they’ve never achieved that themselves.

Goady as fuck.

Hmm, I didn’t agree with this part either but for this reason: the women I know who have become SAHMs left successful careers and their husbands are also successful - hence they became SAHMs as they earn enough to not be affected too much by the entire loss of an income.

I do think it’s a shortsighted criticism though and failing to understand someone else’s circumstances. Eg A woman might not have a choice to be a SAHM or have a maternity leave lasting beyond the full pay period because of finances, no family support to help with nursery pick ups, mental health or postnatal depression which makes them want to go back to work, the cost of nursery being more than they earn (yes, I know there are many benefits of work) etc… The list goes in. I’m sure all circumstances have already been covered many times throughout the thread.

But surely being rude about women who have decided to be SAHMs is not much better than being rude about women who decide not to be?

Seeline · 03/08/2023 09:34

People don’t say these things yet they could. We don’t shame women who choose to stay at home.

🤣🤣🤣
Honestly, one of the worst things you can do on MN is stay at home to bring up your own kids 🙄
Give up your independence
Rely on a man (it's always a man....)
Ruin your future
Rely on benefits (even if you don't)
Can't be intelligent because life with kids is sooo boring and you never have any stimulating conversation

Oh and did I mention relying on a man....

FOJN · 03/08/2023 09:33

I find it mind boggling that people think you can take years out of a career and come back to it… in highly successful roles actually you can’t do that. Though I suspect those people who post such nasty things have no idea if they’ve never achieved that themselves.

Speaking of nasty......

Sorry OP, I don’t know what planet you’re in to say this. ALL mothers are shamed, frequently and widely.

I think this is true. It wouldn't matter what you did someone would have an unfavourable opinion about it so stop letting it bother you and do what's best for you and your family.

Eyeapple · 03/08/2023 09:32

I’ve never experienced it. My friends both work and some stayed home for chunks of they’d kids childhood never once judged them, never felt judged by them. When it happens online which it occasionally does I respect that people with issues is about themselves and nothing whatsoever to do with me.

Swipe left for the next trending thread