Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

shaming of mothers with a career?!

263 replies

rubopp · 03/08/2023 08:51

Again today I’ve read a thread where a women is criticised for needing childcare when their child is under one.

AIBU to think if we had threads/comments saying ‘why aren’t you in a decent job to provide well for your dc?’, that they would be deleted?

There’s actually lots of evidence that children do well in life and thrive in higher income homes. No, it’s not everything and overall it probably doesn’t matter… just like it doesn’t matter in the long run if someone decides to stay home with their dc until their dc go to school.

What IS this shaming of mothers who dare to have a career?! Jealously? Narrow mindedness?

I find it mind boggling that people think you can take years out of a career and come back to it… in highly successful roles actually you can’t do that. Though I suspect those people who post such nasty things have no idea if they’ve never achieved that themselves.

There’s lots of benefits to being able to fund all your child’s activities, holidays, books, cultural trips especially as they get older and need house deposits, cars etc so let’s not pretend that the only way to raise a child is to live frugally and don’t dare to make anything of yourself.

Rant over.

OP posts:
MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 04/08/2023 09:59

stealthbanana · 04/08/2023 09:39

No, but it’s the implication of suggesting that women with families should only ever prioritise work that doesn’t take up too much of their time. Some careers require dedication and, yes, time commitment. Take the example given above of someone working in ER - they work long hours with little flexibility. Should women with families not do this?

Well, I'm certainly not going to argue that women shouldn't do demanding roles. As a female CEO whose daughter is about to embark on a medicine degree, clearly I'm not going to argue that women should have small jobs that don't take up too much of their time.

I don't think that's what the poster was saying though. She was merely making the point that a successful career which requires lots of dedication isn't the only way of leading a good life. And I agree with her.

And fwiw, I don't think men or women with "big" jobs should focus on career to the exclusion of all else. Balance is healthy and we would do better to change our working culture to allow everyone to have a better balance between work and other aspects of their lives, rather than forcing people to choose between all-consuming careers or giving up. There is a middle way, and as a woman in a senior leadership role, I see promoting that balance as an important responsibility. For everyone, not just for working mums.

Wenfy · 04/08/2023 09:52

I agree with you OP. In my experience of mumsnet only low to mid earners (who can’t afford to pay for childcare or whose jobs aren’t flexible) become full time housewives after the baby is born. Higher earners rarely do because they don’t need to - we tend to get more flexibility and better benefits on top of the money.

RoyalImpatience · 04/08/2023 09:49

Stealth, all the usual caveats aside of course babies need their mums /care givers as much as possible.

When children are older they go to nursery so their needs are being met and mixed up with nursery as in activities and parents.

stealthbanana · 04/08/2023 09:44

RoyalImpatience · 04/08/2023 09:11

I certainly hope my girls have children and a career.
The difference is putting your baby first if you can until they are as old as possible?..

Why pose things in such a black and white extreme way eg a woman's life would be ruined and we wouldn't have female doctors if they stayed with their actual " babies" as much as they can.

In an entire lifetime of work, decades and decades with working age pushed further and further back I cannot fathom why anyone thinks taking a year or two out to look after your own babies would put your career at risk.

If that's the case that's the bigger issue

I must say that in terms of the benefit children derive from having parents at home my experience has been the opposite - that babies needs are much more easily met, it’s now my kids are a bit older that they need and want me more. Taking a year off is just maternity leave, if you want to take an extra year off, sure. I’m not convinced that putting children in good quality childcare really makes a huge difference either way (and certainly the Nordic countries back this up, where it is really rare to not be in childcare from 1 onwards). In any event, I don’t think that’s what people are talking about on this thread.

stealthbanana · 04/08/2023 09:39

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 04/08/2023 08:21

That's not what she said, to be fair.

No, but it’s the implication of suggesting that women with families should only ever prioritise work that doesn’t take up too much of their time. Some careers require dedication and, yes, time commitment. Take the example given above of someone working in ER - they work long hours with little flexibility. Should women with families not do this?

Hillstreet · 04/08/2023 09:13

I think that mums are judged and criticised no matter what they choose to do and it’s incredibly annoying.

My situation is the opposite to yours. I chose to put my career on the back burner when I had my children because that’s what felt right for me.

Despite being financially comfortable and incredibly happy spending my time at playgroups, parks and planning activities, people still do the faux concern head tilt…

The most annoying question is “Oh are you not bored! I’d hate not using my brain everyday” (I’m pretty sure I work harder at looking after my children than I have ever done at in a job, or my MA degree for that matter).

Then I have friends who regularly face judgement for choosing to work… especially if their partner has an ‘impressive’ job. As if their hard work isn’t worth anything because it’s not needed to put food on the table.

I’m lucky to have the choice between working and staying home, I know that. But nobody should be judged for their choices on whether to work when their children are small. Especially when the only stay at home dad I know gets a ridiculous amount of praise for doing the same thing thousands of mums do everyday. And very few dads are judged for working on improving their career.

RoyalImpatience · 04/08/2023 09:11

I certainly hope my girls have children and a career.
The difference is putting your baby first if you can until they are as old as possible?..

Why pose things in such a black and white extreme way eg a woman's life would be ruined and we wouldn't have female doctors if they stayed with their actual " babies" as much as they can.

In an entire lifetime of work, decades and decades with working age pushed further and further back I cannot fathom why anyone thinks taking a year or two out to look after your own babies would put your career at risk.

If that's the case that's the bigger issue

MissTrip82 · 04/08/2023 08:56

Yeah these types never seem to be quite so mouthy about their opinions when they turn up with their sick kid to an emergency department or intensive care unit and find it staffed, mostly by people with young children being cared for by someone else. They seem to feel a lot more positive about parents having careers then.

AndIKnewYouMeantIt · 04/08/2023 08:50

Thepeopleversuswork · 04/08/2023 08:39

Women on both sides of this situation do certainly get shamed. There are unfair and inaccurate cliches employed both against SAHMs and WOHMs.

Having been on the receiving end of comments like “you’ll never get the time back” and other moronic little homilies for ten years I’m pretty hardened to it and if I am honest there are some pretty patronising assumptions made about SAHMs (they never use their brains etc).

I have to say though that I think the anti working mum camp wins hands down on sheer stupidity. How can someone not understand that a single parent or breadwinner cannot simply walk out of a job just because they want to be with their children. It should be breathtakingly simple to understand but still you get people piping up to accuse you of “farming out” your kids on here.

I just think we need to take the level of critical understanding up a few notches.

I agree. As soon as the word "dumped" is used (as in, my kids were never "dumped" in nursery) I write the poster off.

Thepeopleversuswork · 04/08/2023 08:39

Women on both sides of this situation do certainly get shamed. There are unfair and inaccurate cliches employed both against SAHMs and WOHMs.

Having been on the receiving end of comments like “you’ll never get the time back” and other moronic little homilies for ten years I’m pretty hardened to it and if I am honest there are some pretty patronising assumptions made about SAHMs (they never use their brains etc).

I have to say though that I think the anti working mum camp wins hands down on sheer stupidity. How can someone not understand that a single parent or breadwinner cannot simply walk out of a job just because they want to be with their children. It should be breathtakingly simple to understand but still you get people piping up to accuse you of “farming out” your kids on here.

I just think we need to take the level of critical understanding up a few notches.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 04/08/2023 08:21

stealthbanana · 04/08/2023 08:16

Right. So you don’t think women with families should be CEOs, or scientists, or newspaper editors or foreign correspondents or diplomats or chief technologists or run hospitals or do any of those things that take time (and yes, pay well)?

That's not what she said, to be fair.

stealthbanana · 04/08/2023 08:16

Right. So you don’t think women with families should be CEOs, or scientists, or newspaper editors or foreign correspondents or diplomats or chief technologists or run hospitals or do any of those things that take time (and yes, pay well)?

Threenow · 04/08/2023 08:07

stealthbanana · 04/08/2023 07:53

Well luckily not everyone is so dismissive of careers otherwise you wouldn’t have all the amazing technologies and services that enable you to have a nice life while you’re looking down on those other people who “prioritise” work. Unless you think the washing machine just invented itself, your car just fell from the heavens, the supermarket just runs itself etc. It takes all sorts to make the world work.

I didn't say there was anything wrong with having a career - can you not read? I said I have no time for people who think a career and having shed loads of income is the only way to have a good life. It is possible to have a career and yet not make it the only focus of your life.

Smoky1107 · 04/08/2023 08:00

When I had my children maternity leave was six months. My daughters were both in nursery by the age of five months and yes I have a nice career. I've enjoyed working part time until six years ago and now full time back in a full career in my early 40s. I don't really care if others don't or didn't approve as I made decisions based on my family at the times I needed too

stealthbanana · 04/08/2023 07:53

Well luckily not everyone is so dismissive of careers otherwise you wouldn’t have all the amazing technologies and services that enable you to have a nice life while you’re looking down on those other people who “prioritise” work. Unless you think the washing machine just invented itself, your car just fell from the heavens, the supermarket just runs itself etc. It takes all sorts to make the world work.

Threenow · 03/08/2023 21:24

JazbayGrapes · 03/08/2023 10:31

I have no time for people who think being career/money driven is the only way to have a good life, in fact I actually feel a bit sorry for them (and their kids).

You wait a couple of years until it becomes a competition of who can afford to move homes to better schools, extracurriculars, holidays, etc.

That is not nearly as relevant where I live (not the UK). It is important to some people of course - and yes, I feel sorry for them - but most people just send their kids to the local schools and have the holidays they can afford.

Boomboom22 · 03/08/2023 20:58

Un7breakable · 03/08/2023 18:25

Teaching is not good for working parents. Only benefit is the holidays and even then the insets often mean parents having to find childcare ad hoc. There's a total amount of teacher hours needed at schools so if you go part time it maybe many many years before someone leaves or wants to go part time to put your hours back up, or there may not be the staff to allow for part time. Since most schools have become academies changing schools often means a significant pay cut. I agree that it's better than some careers but often see on here people being told to try teaching as it's good if you have kids, and it's not that simple.

For me one school let me leave just after the kids, one finished quite early so could rush off by 3 and my current one I give the lessons I need off in March say and the timetable works with that. So one year I'll have a few lunchtime finishes and late starts, another year a few finishes early and a full day off. I've not had a big problem. If you are 0.8 you can often do most tlr but not hoy too.

AndIKnewYouMeantIt · 03/08/2023 20:40

Should add both mat cover and old boss applied for promoted role.

AndIKnewYouMeantIt · 03/08/2023 20:40

She probably would, but they offered her management of another department on the same pay. Which she didn't want. They promoted her mat leave, and made her old position redundant. It was difficult to argue against.

Yellowlegobrick · 03/08/2023 19:28

Eg the default is up to 52 weeks you should get your job back - from 26 to 52 weeks your employer has to prove its not reasonably practical for you to return to it and given they are required to give you a suitable alternative on the same terms & conditions you can't end up out of work as a result.

Yellowlegobrick · 03/08/2023 19:26

My boss got shafted in my old workplace because the bosses wanted to keep the maternity cover.

No - They have to show its not "reasonably practical" for you NOT to have your old job back - the example often given in guidance is that this does not apply if a mat cover is still in the role. If your old boss had fought them on this they would likely have won.

AndIKnewYouMeantIt · 03/08/2023 19:20

It's not 12 months of protection for your job, though. After 26 weeks you can only have it back if it's deemed "reasonably practicable", otherwise they can offer you something else with same pay and terms. My boss got shafted in my old workplace because the bosses wanted to keep the maternity cover.

Yellowlegobrick · 03/08/2023 18:53

I assume the surprise is because you are by law entitled to 12 months maternity leave with job protection, and people expect particularly higher income families to be able to afford that time off, either by saving in advance or the fact that professional jobs often have generous maternity pay well above statutory levels (i got 6 months on full pay and made it stretch over the full year).

I took a full year off with both my kids (as did most women i knew) and have not faced any career penalty. The bigger career penalty is if you stop for a few years completely - much harder to break back in.

SerafinasGoose · 03/08/2023 18:47

What I don't hold with is that women owe other women 'support' with their choices on account of the fact that we happen to share XX chromosomes.

We don't. And you don't hear men making this protestation about fellow XY people, either.

SerafinasGoose · 03/08/2023 18:45

I don't require others' approval as to the division of paid vs. domestic labour in my home, and I couldn't care less how they structure theirs. It affects me not one jot.

What is surprising is the number of women eager to justify their lifestyles, seek affirmation for their choices, or view someone else making a different decision from their own as some kind of personal affront.

You don't hear men splitting hairs over this stuff, and with the very good reason that they don't have to. Patriarchal society is structured entirely to their benefit and it's generally accepted that women are the ones who will make all the sacrifices to that end.

If we chewed the fat more over that instead, IMO we'd get further. All this WOHM vs. SAHM bickering is a treadmill to nowhere.