Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

shaming of mothers with a career?!

263 replies

rubopp · 03/08/2023 08:51

Again today I’ve read a thread where a women is criticised for needing childcare when their child is under one.

AIBU to think if we had threads/comments saying ‘why aren’t you in a decent job to provide well for your dc?’, that they would be deleted?

There’s actually lots of evidence that children do well in life and thrive in higher income homes. No, it’s not everything and overall it probably doesn’t matter… just like it doesn’t matter in the long run if someone decides to stay home with their dc until their dc go to school.

What IS this shaming of mothers who dare to have a career?! Jealously? Narrow mindedness?

I find it mind boggling that people think you can take years out of a career and come back to it… in highly successful roles actually you can’t do that. Though I suspect those people who post such nasty things have no idea if they’ve never achieved that themselves.

There’s lots of benefits to being able to fund all your child’s activities, holidays, books, cultural trips especially as they get older and need house deposits, cars etc so let’s not pretend that the only way to raise a child is to live frugally and don’t dare to make anything of yourself.

Rant over.

OP posts:
Jellyx · 04/08/2023 18:12

@MrsBennetsPoorNerves

Parents can make their own decisions.
Personally I'd prefer to be at home - that's a luxury a few can afford or are willing to sacrifice their career for.

If you think it's better to have a career and that's better for your children then go for it.

I'm just not convinced the research says that's better for children but each to their own.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 04/08/2023 18:09

Thepeopleversuswork · 04/08/2023 18:05

Tell me you think “career mothers” are selfish without telling me you think career mothers are selfish….

You have basically just dumped all the ill informed and judgmental little cliches about “career mothers” as you put them, into one neat little post. This is exactly what the OP means.

It’s not about choosing to have less income. For me it would be choosing to have no income. Because there is no one else who provides that income. It’s just me. So there is no such choice.

Also fuck off with “my children’s wellbeing is a priority”. I choose to prioritise my child by working long hours to put food on the table. Would walking out of a job really be prioritising my child? I can’t believe people like you genuinely can’t understand that for some people “prioritising my child” does mean working.

And as for leaving children with “randoms”: my child is with a qualified, DBS checked childminder who has known her eight years.

You say you have a different view of what is good care for children. What you actually have is an incredibly privileged and short sighted set of prejudices which completely ignore economic reality.

Don't let her get to you @Thepeopleversuswork. This kind of shit is always spouted on these threads. To be fair, there is shit that gets spouted the other way. It's usually insecurity on either side.

Those of us who know that we're doing the best for our children - whether WOHP or SAHP - don't need to get sucked in to the nonsense.

It's a shame that we can't have honest and genuine discussions about this subject, which is still a challenging issue for many women, without the need for the not-so-subtle digs.

Thepeopleversuswork · 04/08/2023 18:05

Jellyx · 04/08/2023 17:45

I think it's ok - people are allowed to have different opinions than others.

Personally, I'd rather be the one caring for my children then trust randoms I've paid. And id rather have less of an income as a result. My children's well-being is a priority over my career and I happen to believe that me being present with my children can't be replaced by activities.

Each for their own. I'm not saying career driven mothers are selfish - I just have a different view of what is good care of children.

Tell me you think “career mothers” are selfish without telling me you think career mothers are selfish….

You have basically just dumped all the ill informed and judgmental little cliches about “career mothers” as you put them, into one neat little post. This is exactly what the OP means.

It’s not about choosing to have less income. For me it would be choosing to have no income. Because there is no one else who provides that income. It’s just me. So there is no such choice.

Also fuck off with “my children’s wellbeing is a priority”. I choose to prioritise my child by working long hours to put food on the table. Would walking out of a job really be prioritising my child? I can’t believe people like you genuinely can’t understand that for some people “prioritising my child” does mean working.

And as for leaving children with “randoms”: my child is with a qualified, DBS checked childminder who has known her eight years.

You say you have a different view of what is good care for children. What you actually have is an incredibly privileged and short sighted set of prejudices which completely ignore economic reality.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 04/08/2023 18:04

Jellyx · 04/08/2023 17:47

But are the children really better off?
Lots of boarding school children have money and activities but weird relationships with their parents when they get older and abandonment issues

This thread is about WOHPs and SAHPs. I'm not sure that boarding school has anything to do with it.

Tbh, @Jellyx, your posts are giving the impression that you consider yourself to be a superior parent because you don't WOH. It isn't very interesting.

And fwiw, I never trusted "randoms" to look after my child either. It's a shame that you feel the need to phrase things in this way. Are you having a bit of a dig at WOHPs because you are feeling a bit inadequate or something? There is nothing wrong with being a SAHP if it works for you and your family, and you don't have to justify the decision by picking at the choices others have made.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 04/08/2023 17:58

Jellyx · 04/08/2023 17:46

That's sad to hear.

I wish motherhood was valued more in western society then perhaps some women wouldn't feel resentful

I don't think society valuing motherhood more would have resolved it for my mum tbh. She was of a generation when SAH with kids was almost universally seen as a positive thing to do, and she does feel that all of the "mothering" she did was really valuable. She doesn't regret that at all - she is very proud of me and dsis and what we have achieved. It's more the stuff that she could have done but didn't that bothered her.

She regrets not having had the opportunity to use her talents more widely, and not having had an impact on the lives of more people. She had a career before marriage that was very focused on helping vulnerable people, and she sees how much more she could have contributed to the world if she had gone back to work after children. That is just her personal view of it, not a value judgement on my part.

I think it has been harder for her in a way as a result of watching me and dsis. Both of us have chosen careers with a social purpose, in which we can make a real difference. But equally, both of us have fantastic relationships with our kids who are clearly thriving, and she has seen that we have managed to have successful careers without having to compromise on the quality of our family lives or the dc's upbringing. And while she is absolutely thrilled for us that this is the case, she understandably wishes that she could have had the same sense of purpose and achievement that Dsis and I get from our work alongside the pride and satisfaction that she had as a mother. Not sure if that makes sense?

Jellyx · 04/08/2023 17:47

Wenfy · 04/08/2023 09:52

I agree with you OP. In my experience of mumsnet only low to mid earners (who can’t afford to pay for childcare or whose jobs aren’t flexible) become full time housewives after the baby is born. Higher earners rarely do because they don’t need to - we tend to get more flexibility and better benefits on top of the money.

But are the children really better off?
Lots of boarding school children have money and activities but weird relationships with their parents when they get older and abandonment issues

Jellyx · 04/08/2023 17:46

Thepeopleversuswork · 04/08/2023 14:22

@MrsBennetsPoorNerves

Actually, one of my mother's greatest regrets is that she didn't spend more time working. She gave up her career to SAH with us as children because that was sort of the done thing back in those days, and she then lost all of her confidence and never got it back.

Mine too. I could have written this about my own mother. She bitterly regretted giving up her career and was extremely resentful of the fact she never really got her mojo back after having children. She drummed into me the idea that I would also regret it if I didn’t have a career and she was right.

That's sad to hear.

I wish motherhood was valued more in western society then perhaps some women wouldn't feel resentful

Jellyx · 04/08/2023 17:45

I think it's ok - people are allowed to have different opinions than others.

Personally, I'd rather be the one caring for my children then trust randoms I've paid. And id rather have less of an income as a result. My children's well-being is a priority over my career and I happen to believe that me being present with my children can't be replaced by activities.

Each for their own. I'm not saying career driven mothers are selfish - I just have a different view of what is good care of children.

Thepeopleversuswork · 04/08/2023 17:42

ofacertainage · 04/08/2023 17:24

But what is there to actually say? Why compare yourselves to people who you have no idea about? If you enjoy your job - great. If you want to be a stay-home mum - great. If you have no choice - well that's that then. Or any of the infinite possibilities in between. What more is there to say?

Well if you’d read the thread (and many like it), you would know there is a long Mumsnet history where a certain subset of posters are judgemental about women based on their financial and domestic setups and the way they care for their children. (I’m not going to call them “choices” in the MN vernacular because often they are not actually choices.

Some women think it’s damaging to children for women with children to work. Some women think women who stay at home with their children are wasting their lives and making themselves financially vulnerable. Both are reductionist and insulting stereotypes. But because women are insecure about how society perceives their roles as mothers they are very sensitive about this.

The fact that we are sensitive about this and feel defensive tells me it’s a deep seated social issue which affects a lot of women and deserves unpacking and discussion. And actually deserves much wider attention than threads on Mumsnet. It’s one of the most important issues facing women.

It’s very relevant to me and my life. If you don’t think it’s interesting you don’t have to comment. But I’m not going to be told to move along there’s nothing to see, thanks very much.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 04/08/2023 17:28

ofacertainage · 04/08/2023 17:24

But what is there to actually say? Why compare yourselves to people who you have no idea about? If you enjoy your job - great. If you want to be a stay-home mum - great. If you have no choice - well that's that then. Or any of the infinite possibilities in between. What more is there to say?

Well, there is plenty more to say as evidenced by the many threads on this topic. I completely agree that it doesn't matter and people should choose whatever lifestyle suits them best, but that's not the point. If they want to discuss their choices, they can!!

You are not the arbiter of what is or isn't a valid conversation on MN. If you aren't interested, you don't have to participate. You don't understand why people want to talk about their lifestyle choices. I don't understand why you would repeatedly hang around taking notes on who is saying what on threads that patently don't interest you. Ultimately, I presume you have your reasons for doing what you do. Other people will have reasons of their own.

ofacertainage · 04/08/2023 17:24

But what is there to actually say? Why compare yourselves to people who you have no idea about? If you enjoy your job - great. If you want to be a stay-home mum - great. If you have no choice - well that's that then. Or any of the infinite possibilities in between. What more is there to say?

Thepeopleversuswork · 04/08/2023 17:14

ofacertainage · 04/08/2023 16:44

Why is it always the same people saying the same repetitive things on these threads? Every. Single. Time. Who are they really trying to convince? None of this matters at all and the comparisons are pointless. Everyone is in totally different circumstances and people seem hell bent on taking offence at nothing. It's very weird.

Why do people comment on threads about topics that interest them or are relevant to their lives? I can’t imagine.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 04/08/2023 16:51

ofacertainage · 04/08/2023 16:44

Why is it always the same people saying the same repetitive things on these threads? Every. Single. Time. Who are they really trying to convince? None of this matters at all and the comparisons are pointless. Everyone is in totally different circumstances and people seem hell bent on taking offence at nothing. It's very weird.

If you recognise posters from previous threads, then I presume that you keep coming back to this topic yourself. Why is that, if you don't find the discussion important or interesting?

Perhaps some of us aren't trying to "convince" anyone. Perhaps we're just talking about subjects that we want to talk about. If you find the conversation weird, there are plenty of other threads on MN available. Or start one of your own?

ofacertainage · 04/08/2023 16:44

Why is it always the same people saying the same repetitive things on these threads? Every. Single. Time. Who are they really trying to convince? None of this matters at all and the comparisons are pointless. Everyone is in totally different circumstances and people seem hell bent on taking offence at nothing. It's very weird.

Thepeopleversuswork · 04/08/2023 14:28

Cardshark · 04/08/2023 12:48

No one ever tells men they will regret having worked too hard on their deathbeds.

Course they do, to workaholics and the like, who don't have a good work/life balance.
And there are men too who in old age have regretted all the hours they spent in the office.

But no one tells working fathers they only work to buy more shoes and handbags, which is one of the more common accusations thrown at working mums.

Pretty sure no one would tell a breadwinning father to just chuck in a job and not pay the mortgage for a bit. Oh, but it will all work out because you won’t have to “farm your kids out to childcare”. Nah. People don’t say that to men.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 04/08/2023 14:23

Thepeopleversuswork · 04/08/2023 14:22

@MrsBennetsPoorNerves

Actually, one of my mother's greatest regrets is that she didn't spend more time working. She gave up her career to SAH with us as children because that was sort of the done thing back in those days, and she then lost all of her confidence and never got it back.

Mine too. I could have written this about my own mother. She bitterly regretted giving up her career and was extremely resentful of the fact she never really got her mojo back after having children. She drummed into me the idea that I would also regret it if I didn’t have a career and she was right.

Yep, my mum drilled that into me and dsis too. I am very grateful for it tbh.

Thepeopleversuswork · 04/08/2023 14:22

@MrsBennetsPoorNerves

Actually, one of my mother's greatest regrets is that she didn't spend more time working. She gave up her career to SAH with us as children because that was sort of the done thing back in those days, and she then lost all of her confidence and never got it back.

Mine too. I could have written this about my own mother. She bitterly regretted giving up her career and was extremely resentful of the fact she never really got her mojo back after having children. She drummed into me the idea that I would also regret it if I didn’t have a career and she was right.

Highdaysandholidays1 · 04/08/2023 13:33

I do know several women who regret not making more of a mark in the world, whether through paid work or not. One is in her eighties now, and she just didn't take her chance with carrying on with acting when she got pregnant and ended up doing very little work, in the end her pension was compromised by not having done enough years (which you can rectify if you know this). My mid-life friends are all contemplating what they've done and a couple feel regret they took the compromise job or p/t work that has ended up being very boring. That said, it worked for them at the time and I think it's easy to look back and imagine things would have been different, but maybe it would have been difficult in different ways (time, energy). It is hard though if you hit fifties having never felt interested in your work, especially if you have many years to go before retirement.

Cardshark · 04/08/2023 12:48

No one ever tells men they will regret having worked too hard on their deathbeds.

Course they do, to workaholics and the like, who don't have a good work/life balance.
And there are men too who in old age have regretted all the hours they spent in the office.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 04/08/2023 12:22

Thepeopleversuswork · 04/08/2023 11:13

@stealthbanana

I agree. There’s an unpleasant undertone that crops up in a lot of these threads around how morally vacuous it is to enjoy your career, as if liking your career is an attempt to fill an emotional hole.

You get these silly “no one on their deathbed ever regretted not working more” etc. The assumption is that work is always driven by greed or avarice or a desire for a certain unsustainable lifestyle etc.

It’s all very gendered. It takes as read that women don’t really need to work and that their motives for doing so are suspect and against their children’s interests. And it implies that men’s motives for work are inherently nobler.

No one ever tells men they will regret having worked too hard on their deathbeds.

Actually, one of my mother's greatest regrets is that she didn't spend more time working. She gave up her career to SAH with us as children because that was sort of the done thing back in those days, and she then lost all of her confidence and never got it back. At 80, she deeply regrets not having maintained her career - she feels like she wasted her talent and potential and that she could have done so much more with her life.

Of course, some people quit their careers and are perfectly happy and fulfilled doing other things, but yes, I too get very annoyed by people who bang on about people on their deathbed regretting time spent at work. My work is hugely important and meaningful to me and it enables me to make a real and lasting contribution to society that reaches well beyond my own family and friends. Why would I regret that?

Thepeopleversuswork · 04/08/2023 11:13

@stealthbanana

I agree. There’s an unpleasant undertone that crops up in a lot of these threads around how morally vacuous it is to enjoy your career, as if liking your career is an attempt to fill an emotional hole.

You get these silly “no one on their deathbed ever regretted not working more” etc. The assumption is that work is always driven by greed or avarice or a desire for a certain unsustainable lifestyle etc.

It’s all very gendered. It takes as read that women don’t really need to work and that their motives for doing so are suspect and against their children’s interests. And it implies that men’s motives for work are inherently nobler.

No one ever tells men they will regret having worked too hard on their deathbeds.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 04/08/2023 10:26

stealthbanana · 04/08/2023 10:07

I don’t disagree with any of that. But the original post spoke of feeling “sorry” for people (women) who prioritised career. As a female CEO I’m sure you’re familiar with those weeks when you simply have to - of course you aim for balance over time (not sure our male counterparts necessarily do) but it’s not always possible for your kids to be priority no 1 at every moment. There is a real tone on these threads of that somehow being selfish and morally suspect. I don’t agree with it. (But I also don’t care about it - I have my own life as a senior exec and im very happy with it and my kids are too).

I don't think she did actually say that she felt sorry for women who prioritised their career, or indeed for their children. I think she said that she felt sorry for people who thought that was the only way of leading a good life. I don't think that's unfair...if woken choose to prioritise their careers, then it should be a proper choice and not because they are unable to see any alternatives.

I have seen lots of stupid posters on here over the years expressing pity for the children of working mothers, and I hold those posters in the utmost contempt. I just don't think that's what the pp was saying.

stealthbanana · 04/08/2023 10:07

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 04/08/2023 09:59

Well, I'm certainly not going to argue that women shouldn't do demanding roles. As a female CEO whose daughter is about to embark on a medicine degree, clearly I'm not going to argue that women should have small jobs that don't take up too much of their time.

I don't think that's what the poster was saying though. She was merely making the point that a successful career which requires lots of dedication isn't the only way of leading a good life. And I agree with her.

And fwiw, I don't think men or women with "big" jobs should focus on career to the exclusion of all else. Balance is healthy and we would do better to change our working culture to allow everyone to have a better balance between work and other aspects of their lives, rather than forcing people to choose between all-consuming careers or giving up. There is a middle way, and as a woman in a senior leadership role, I see promoting that balance as an important responsibility. For everyone, not just for working mums.

I don’t disagree with any of that. But the original post spoke of feeling “sorry” for people (women) who prioritised career. As a female CEO I’m sure you’re familiar with those weeks when you simply have to - of course you aim for balance over time (not sure our male counterparts necessarily do) but it’s not always possible for your kids to be priority no 1 at every moment. There is a real tone on these threads of that somehow being selfish and morally suspect. I don’t agree with it. (But I also don’t care about it - I have my own life as a senior exec and im very happy with it and my kids are too).

Wenfy · 04/08/2023 10:06

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 04/08/2023 09:59

Well, I'm certainly not going to argue that women shouldn't do demanding roles. As a female CEO whose daughter is about to embark on a medicine degree, clearly I'm not going to argue that women should have small jobs that don't take up too much of their time.

I don't think that's what the poster was saying though. She was merely making the point that a successful career which requires lots of dedication isn't the only way of leading a good life. And I agree with her.

And fwiw, I don't think men or women with "big" jobs should focus on career to the exclusion of all else. Balance is healthy and we would do better to change our working culture to allow everyone to have a better balance between work and other aspects of their lives, rather than forcing people to choose between all-consuming careers or giving up. There is a middle way, and as a woman in a senior leadership role, I see promoting that balance as an important responsibility. For everyone, not just for working mums.

I think you’re right but there can only be equality of childcare when both men and women work. I don’t think it’s fair to expect sole breadwinners (male or female) to be doing 50/50 childcare and housework. These people need to work harder (especially if they’re on 100k+ salaries just to keep their families afloat.

Spacecowboys · 04/08/2023 10:06

It only happens on forums such as this. My favourite is the assumption that women only work because they have to. I love earning my own money and having a career. My friends are all on the same wave length so I never experience any negativity in real life. And I wouldn’t care if I did- I’m happy with my life choices and so are my family.