Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why it’s so hard to find a children’s book without a dead parent or pity for only children?!

81 replies

SashaPearce · 02/08/2023 22:03

Trying to choose a book as a birthday present for a friend’s daughter. She’s turning 9 and is an only child. Thought it would be easy as I loved reading and still own lots of my favourites but finding it really hard! Several I feel like I’m having to rule out because they include a brief conversation where characters with multiple siblings are pitying an only child, ‘isn’t it sad, they must be so lonely’. Find this infuriating! I guess it’s an index of how unusual one child families were in the past - and maybe a sign that I need to be looking at more contemporary books rather than classics - but seriously, why? Did it really not occur to the authors at the time that it wasn’t nice to introduce to only children who might well be perfectly happy the idea that they ought to feel sorry for themselves?

The other thing I’m really struggling with is the number of parental deaths. Can’t believe how many children’s books seem to begin with this in some form or another! I wonder if I’m worrying too much, because I read these books myself as a child, and strangely even though I was quite an anxious kid it somehow never occurred to me to make the connection between the character’s parents dying and the idea that mine might. But one of my favourites starts with a parent dying in a plane crash. We flew a lot when I was a kid (due to DF’s family living overseas) and I never worried about this, but friend’s daughter also gets taken on a lot of international trips and I really don’t want to be the one to introduce the idea that this is something she needs to worry about! Am I being over-scrupulous?

YABU: kid will be caught up in the story and won’t even notice or care about the bits about only children being pitiable and parents being killed in plane crashes

YANBU: pick something else

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
RoyalImpatience · 04/08/2023 20:51

Agree endlessness parents dying in children literature

SashaPearce · 04/08/2023 20:46

ToWhitToWhoo · 03/08/2023 22:46

While orphans are common in children's fiction, I am surprised that you would find so many books with pity for only children.

I would perhaps avoid plane crash stories under the circumstances; but there are many books without such disasters.

E. Nesbit's 'Five Children and It' series is excellent; also 'The Railway Children'; father is in prison on a wrongful charge for much of the book, but no dead parents.

I second the recommendation of Beverly Cleary's 'Ramona' books. Other good American series (though I don't know how easy they are to come by nowadays) are Maud Hart Lovelace's 'Betsy-Tacy' books and Sydney Taylor's 'All of a Kind Family' books.

An old series which has a very positive portrayal of an only child with both parents, several loving adult relatives, and a good circle of friends is Joyce Lankester Brisley's 'Milly Molly Mandy' series. But probably a bit young for a 9-year-old.

I love ‘All of a Kind Family’ and was actually thinking about getting her the first book in the series, but frustratingly it turned out to be a prime example of what I’m talking about - in the first chapter the sisters meet a kind female librarian who tells them she has no brothers or sisters, and they all pity how awful that is, which she agrees with.

’Milly Molly Mandy’ rings a bell as something I enjoyed as a kid but I don’t remember it very well - will have to look it up!

OP posts:
TheWayoftheLeaf · 03/08/2023 23:15

Generally taking the parents out of the situation sets the protagonist free. The child can explore the world, go to fairyland, become a doll, sail a ship BECAUSE they have no parents to hold them back or for them to feel sad about leaving behind or to tell them no.

It's a common trope likely because it makes the character untethered. It also makes them an underdog... so even if they're a bit of a snit it's excused because they're orphaned.

All sorts of reasons. It's just a literary trope. But yes, it's quite strange when you focus on it.

ToWhitToWhoo · 03/08/2023 22:47

I second the recommendation of 'Harriet the Spy'.

ToWhitToWhoo · 03/08/2023 22:46

While orphans are common in children's fiction, I am surprised that you would find so many books with pity for only children.

I would perhaps avoid plane crash stories under the circumstances; but there are many books without such disasters.

E. Nesbit's 'Five Children and It' series is excellent; also 'The Railway Children'; father is in prison on a wrongful charge for much of the book, but no dead parents.

I second the recommendation of Beverly Cleary's 'Ramona' books. Other good American series (though I don't know how easy they are to come by nowadays) are Maud Hart Lovelace's 'Betsy-Tacy' books and Sydney Taylor's 'All of a Kind Family' books.

An old series which has a very positive portrayal of an only child with both parents, several loving adult relatives, and a good circle of friends is Joyce Lankester Brisley's 'Milly Molly Mandy' series. But probably a bit young for a 9-year-old.

incognitomosqiito · 03/08/2023 21:41

ZacharinaQuack · 03/08/2023 12:48

I used to love Harriet the Spy by Louise Fitzhugh when I was little. She's an only child and her parents are both alive. Also Judy Blume's Tales of a Fourth-Grade Nothing and Superfudge are good - Peter has siblings but they are really annoying!

Oh gosh I
Forgot about harriet the spy

CampsieGlamper · 03/08/2023 20:17

AndIKnewYouMeantIt · 02/08/2023 22:15

Famous Five. George is an only child, and awesome.

However. There is all the racism and sexism. And smugglers.

Racism in famous five - no. Only anti Americanism in two of them. Attitudes are those of the time written and would need an explanation. Secret seven, the adventure series.
Anything by e h nesbitt.

LuckyPaisley · 03/08/2023 19:54

Diary of an Accidental Witch. She's an only child and lives with her father, I don't think the mother's absence is explained but it's not dwelt on. Nor is her only child status. The boy she's friends with is an only child, I think, but again it's not mentioned, just there's no mention of siblings.

Almostwelsh · 03/08/2023 18:53

Tom's Midnight Garden? He does have parents and a sibling, but he's sent away because his sibling has measles.

Fredthefrog · 03/08/2023 18:38

Dead parents or absent in some way (lost, uninterested in the kids, boarding school) means kids can have more adventures I think. Gives the child characters a chance to be in danger and solve problems in a way that you wouldn't need to if the parents were very involved and around.

WhiteFire · 03/08/2023 18:36

My DD and her friends have all liked the Murder Most Unladylike series from that age.

dollybird · 03/08/2023 18:34

I loved a book called The Little Gymnast when I was that age. Only child wants to be a gymnast, parents together but not very well off. I read it over and over

TropicalTrama · 03/08/2023 18:28

You sound lovely but also utterly bonkers! I’m an only child who read a lot growing and it’s honestly it’s never once entered my head. Clearly Anne of Green Gables doesn’t apply to me as it’s not the 19th century and I’m not Canadian. Nor Harry Potter as wizards aren’t real. I wouldn’t relate in some special way because we’re all only children and find the suggestion really quite strange if I’m being honest. Nicely, you’re really overthinking it. I’m sure she’ll love whatever you choose! Don’t discount classic literature because of orphans. It’s really just a literary device to enable lack of parental supervision so all sorts of capers can happen!

Jamtartforme · 03/08/2023 18:22

I said to DH yesterday that all the TV programmes in the early 00s seemed to feature children in the care system, like Tracy beaker and my parents are aliens. I grew up thinking living in a children’s home was very common Confused

OnGoldenPond · 03/08/2023 18:20

NuffSaidSam · 02/08/2023 22:16

I wouldn't worry about the dead parent thing unless this child had never seen/been traumatised by disney films. Can't move for dead parents in those.

I'd avoid the only child pity though.

Yes, for God's sake don't let her see Bambi! Grin

GiraffeDoor · 03/08/2023 13:38

There's also percy Jackson. His dad's not dead, but he is fairly absent, in as much as he's an ancient Greek god 🤷‍♀️

WomanAtWork · 03/08/2023 13:38

At this age my daughter LOVED the Podkin One-Ear books. Absolutely fantastic fantasy adventure stories about rabbits (think Lord of the Rings meets Watership down).

Thoroughly recommended!!!

GiraffeDoor · 03/08/2023 13:37

Tbh I think there are more only children in books than not. And the characters with siblings usually seem to find their siblings something of a trial rather than a bonus!

GiraffeDoor · 03/08/2023 13:34

My 9yo loves the dragon mountain series. It's about a boy who lives in california but who gets sent to stay with family in China for the summer (thereby managing to avoid having parents in the story, but without killing them off altogether!) Some very strong female characters as well.

FlickyCrumble · 03/08/2023 13:33

Try Katherine Randell books. Usually a female protagonist and full of adventure.

IbizaToTheNorfolkBroads · 03/08/2023 13:30

The Worst Witch books are good. No dead parents or pitiful only children.

But even better - the Ramona Books by Beverley Cleary. They are the tales of Ramona - younger daughter - growing up with her parents, big sister, pet cat, friends, school - told through her eyes (the books start when she's 4 and go to when she's 10). They are very funny and very relatable. I loved them when I was 8/9/10, and so did DD.

They're American and written between about 1960 and 2000, but are almost completely timeless /placeless apart from "western world in the 20th century". I have no idea why they have never been more well known in the UK.

AntiStuff · 03/08/2023 13:22

My 9yo only loves the Ottoline books by Chris Riddell. Only child, absent but loving parents.

As others have pointed out, parents need to be absent usually so that the story can take flight. Tricky to have adventures when your mum is there to make you go to bed at 8pm! Doesn't really bother my dd these days although we have talked to her about it from a plot pov, as the parents' ship going down in Frozen upset a little when she was younger.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 03/08/2023 12:49

I think you might be overthinking it tbh.Smile

My dd (only child) was a voracious reader and read a lot of the old classic children's books. She was always perfectly happy as an only child so I don't think she was ever bothered by the negativity.

She did have a particular love for Heidi, though, which is a classic children's book which happens to feature 3 only children! Just a thought?

Or there is Pippi Longstocking, who seems to live quite happily without parents or siblings?!

ZacharinaQuack · 03/08/2023 12:48

I used to love Harriet the Spy by Louise Fitzhugh when I was little. She's an only child and her parents are both alive. Also Judy Blume's Tales of a Fourth-Grade Nothing and Superfudge are good - Peter has siblings but they are really annoying!

Eskarina1 · 03/08/2023 12:42

I was just thinking I can't believe I forgot Ballet Shoes so I second that. A house full of loving supportive grownups.

Swipe left for the next trending thread