Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What happens when one parent the court's ruling on contact with the other parent?

60 replies

Sushibecomesme · 02/08/2023 21:28

Sorry, I can't think where else to put this. Asking for a friend.

Mum has stopped contact between Dad (her ex) and their child for no obvious reason. Contact was an informal arrangement on her terms but happened every weekend. Dad has a strong relationship with their little boy. Social services are involved (Mum has history of mental health issues so have always been involved) and have stated there are no concerns around Dad seeing the child. Mum disagrees but has been disregarded. Social services have explained to Mum that the court is more than likely to reinstate weekly contact.

Dad is now going to court.

What if Mum laughs in the face of a court order? What can the court do to force her to obey their instructions? They're not going to jail her. If they were to fine her, Dad would be effectively paying it because it would come out of child maintenance and that would harm the child. Is there much point taking someone to court who will ignore the order? She would get legal aid but Dad wouldn't.

Previously Dad had afternoon contact for both weekend days but is now hoping for a 50/50 split.

Thanks for any info.

OP posts:
Theunamedcat · 03/08/2023 09:55

Sushibecomesme · 03/08/2023 09:37

As I've said, I assumed she would because she doesn't work and claims benefits. It seems I was wrong? Both parties would claim some level of domestic abuse took place while together but neither have evidence.

They have stopped legal aid now realistically you need to fit a tight criteria when I was getting divorced I got my coyrt fees paid but had to do everything online no solicitors and if I wanted the finance sorted I was told I had to pay so we separated the finance ourselves and called it good (rented property no assets)

Wishitsnows · 03/08/2023 09:47

@WeeWillyWinkie9 i think this is a very accurate description of what usually happens. Many men are using the courts to continue abuse. If a man wants something even if the child would be emotionally distressed he gets it. Sadly plenty of new partners believe the crazy ex stories and get used as unpaid childcare.

Sushibecomesme · 03/08/2023 09:37

RedHelenB · 03/08/2023 09:29

This.

As I've said, I assumed she would because she doesn't work and claims benefits. It seems I was wrong? Both parties would claim some level of domestic abuse took place while together but neither have evidence.

OP posts:
RedHelenB · 03/08/2023 09:29

Merryoldgoat · 02/08/2023 21:42

Why would she get legal aid?

This.

x2boys · 03/08/2023 09:17

WeeWillyWinkie9 · 02/08/2023 21:32

Dad will likely label mum as mad and come up with the age old BPD diagnosis used to control women and silence them, court will agree. Mum will get told she is not believed, contact will be ordered. Mum will be told she has to stop talking about abuse or else lose contact so if it is going on, she then has to accept the abuse.

Yes because of course mums own the children🙄

JudgeJ · 03/08/2023 08:47

Theunamedcat · 02/08/2023 21:43

If there is evidence of abuse she can (I believe)

Evidence or just her unsubstantiated claim? As she has abused the court I can't see how she should be allowed misuse the court for her own end. Only on MN is it always the case that he's wrong and she's right.

greenteaandmarshmallows · 03/08/2023 08:42

Sushibecomesme · 02/08/2023 21:36

Thanks for replying. I'm sorry, I don't understand. Is there a possibility that Mum could lose contact time if she doesn't obey the court order? She doesn't work, Dad does.

Working has nothing to do with it

Sushibecomesme · 03/08/2023 08:39

Goldbar · 02/08/2023 22:16

It reeks of "she spends my money on getting her nails done", doesn't it?

My point was simply that fining Mum would not be in the child's interests as it would eat into money the child needs to live on, so I thought it was unlikely that fines would be used as a sanction.

OP posts:
Sushibecomesme · 03/08/2023 08:36

Merryoldgoat · 02/08/2023 21:45

That’s my point - if she’d actually get legal
aid it suggests a less than straightforward ‘good dad, batshit ex’ scenario.

Or it’s a false assumption that ‘no
work = benefits = free stuff = scrounger’

I'm sorry, I assumed Mum would get legal aid because she doesn't work and gets benefits. Perhaps she wouldn't?

There is no evidence of abuse. Mum has been violent when psychotic but that's all.

OP posts:
ConnieTucker · 02/08/2023 22:54

Goldbar · 02/08/2023 22:16

It reeks of "she spends my money on getting her nails done", doesn't it?

It really does.

IDontFeelLikeCooking · 02/08/2023 22:43

ConnieTucker · 02/08/2023 22:12

What do you mean by ‘extremely flexible’? Just knocked around a little bit?

I mean that I have personal experience of domestic violence support groups being prepared to provide evidence that both men and women have been victims of domestic abuse with very little evidence.

For example a man who was certified as being a victim of domestic abuse because he was distressed about not being allowed to spend time with his child (with no questions asked about WHY he wasn’t spending time with his child - he was a regular user of class A drugs) and a woman who was certified as being a victim of domestic abuse because a former partner sent three very short polite messages over 7 days asking how she and their new born baby were doing after finding out that she has given birth to their child on social
media.

The reality is that a change in law has actually incentivised parents to make allegations of domestic abuse against the other as it is the only way they can legal aid.

This has caused huge problems in the family court system. Delays whilst schedules of allegations and responses are prepared. Additional often unnecessary hearings taking up judicial time and most worryingly detracting from those cases where domestic abuse is a serious issue that then got lost in a system.

Goldbar · 02/08/2023 22:16

ConnieTucker · 02/08/2023 22:10

If they were to fine her, Dad would be effectively paying it because it would come out of child maintenance
that is such an odd sentence. Does he assume anything she buys comes out of child maintenance?

It reeks of "she spends my money on getting her nails done", doesn't it?

ArcticSkewer · 02/08/2023 22:12

ConnieTucker · 02/08/2023 22:11

It is terrible how many abusive men use court as a way to continue abuse.

it was really really awful and i am horribly cynical now about courts

ConnieTucker · 02/08/2023 22:12

IDontFeelLikeCooking · 02/08/2023 21:48

A person can get legal aid if they 1. Can show they are on a low income and 2. Can establish they have been a victim of domestic abuse.

Domestic abuse can be proven by a police report / GP letter or a letter from a domestic violence support agency.

In my experience domestic violence support charities (those for men and women) are prepared to be extremely flexible when providing evidence of abuse.

What do you mean by ‘extremely flexible’? Just knocked around a little bit?

ConnieTucker · 02/08/2023 22:11

ArcticSkewer · 02/08/2023 22:07

I know someone whose abusive ex continually took her to court. Eventually he got primary custody after telling many many lies. He only needed one judge to believe him. Parental alienation.

It is terrible how many abusive men use court as a way to continue abuse.

ConnieTucker · 02/08/2023 22:10

If they were to fine her, Dad would be effectively paying it because it would come out of child maintenance
that is such an odd sentence. Does he assume anything she buys comes out of child maintenance?

ArcticSkewer · 02/08/2023 22:07

I know someone whose abusive ex continually took her to court. Eventually he got primary custody after telling many many lies. He only needed one judge to believe him. Parental alienation.

WeeWillyWinkie9 · 02/08/2023 21:57

MissJoGrant · 02/08/2023 21:34

Wow.
Projecting much?

I'm not in this situation nor have been.

Goldbar · 02/08/2023 21:50

If you're asking on behalf of a new/potential partner, I'd be careful that you're not being lined up for unpaid nanny duties so they can avoid paying maintenance.

IDontFeelLikeCooking · 02/08/2023 21:48

Merryoldgoat · 02/08/2023 21:42

Why would she get legal aid?

A person can get legal aid if they 1. Can show they are on a low income and 2. Can establish they have been a victim of domestic abuse.

Domestic abuse can be proven by a police report / GP letter or a letter from a domestic violence support agency.

In my experience domestic violence support charities (those for men and women) are prepared to be extremely flexible when providing evidence of abuse.

WishIranonBatteriesNotSleep · 02/08/2023 21:47

My Ex tried to use the "She works so DD will be in childcare all the time" line against me, it didn't work.

WishIranonBatteriesNotSleep · 02/08/2023 21:47

Working doesn't mean a thing to the courts.

When ExH took me to court for DD I was working he wasn't. Judge didn't care, said as long as me working didn't mean DDs needs where unmet thats all that mattered.

Merryoldgoat · 02/08/2023 21:45

Theunamedcat · 02/08/2023 21:43

If there is evidence of abuse she can (I believe)

That’s my point - if she’d actually get legal
aid it suggests a less than straightforward ‘good dad, batshit ex’ scenario.

Or it’s a false assumption that ‘no
work = benefits = free stuff = scrounger’

Theunamedcat · 02/08/2023 21:43

Merryoldgoat · 02/08/2023 21:42

Why would she get legal aid?

If there is evidence of abuse she can (I believe)

Anothnamechang · 02/08/2023 21:43

Courts where I live tend to side with fathers… even where valid reasons are provided.

If Mum disobeys the court order, Dad can submit a failure to obtemper to the courts and Mum will have to had very good reasons for contact ceasing- in an ideal world she would raise a minute to vary as opposed to stopping contact altogether.

Children can and will be removed from Mums who fail to uphold a court order.

In my experience Dads can completely dismiss the court order for over a year with zero contact inbetween and then return to full court ordered rights without any consideration for the children inbetween.

Family courts are a war ground and it can impact both mums and dads mentally& financially. Ideally sorting outwith court would be the much preferred method where parents are able to.