Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why the 90s music was so childish?

93 replies

magicalkitty · 02/08/2023 21:02

I just pondering.

I was a 90s kid, and remember the charts were full of various bands that made music that appealed to kids. S Club 7, Steps, Bewitched, even the Spice Girls to an extent, to name a few. As a child I loved this music, but it's quite surprising now, as an adult, to remember how popular these songs were, as adults would have been buying it. The bands, their music videos, their image, was usually aimed at kids too, not adults. I feel I have grown out of this music now and can't understand why adults would like it, except for nostalgia reasons.

These days the number 1s are more often than not more 'adult' songs, and music aimed at kids doesn't really chart well. What has changed?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Fightyouforthatpie · 08/09/2023 16:28

NeverDropYourMooncup · 02/08/2023 22:01

The Osmonds?
The Jackson 5? (Started in the 60s)
The Partridge Family?
The Monkees? (OK, from the 60s but shown every Saturday morning)

Bay City Bastarding Rollers

BalletBob · 08/09/2023 16:17

The chronically offended are out in force, totally missing the point as usual 🙄

I think it's an interesting point, OP. Funnily enough myself and DH were having a similar conversation a few days ago. My primary aged DC listen mostly to "our" music (things that we liked as teens and young adults, plus things that our parents played to us, and a smattering of new stuff), they also like current songs from movies and TV shows and as they are getting older they are being introduced to more mainstream current music at dance classes and by friend's older siblings etc. But there isn't really anything that seems to be really aimed at young kids specifically like there was in the 90s. Like you say, no equivalent to Bewitched, S Club 7. It seems a shame to me because so much of what's in the charts just isn't appropriate for young DC and I know my kids would love to follow a band like S Club, learn the dances and watch all the interviews like kids in the 90s did.

I think it's probably largely down to the way we consume media nowadays. Everything is streamed. Kids aren't watching so much live TV and the shows like SMTV or Live and Kicking don't exist anymore.

Annaishere · 08/09/2023 16:00

@BeautifulWar well finally it makes sense thank you

BeautifulWar · 08/09/2023 11:57

I remember ‘what’s she going to do with a chimney on her head’

Massively late response, but the lyrics were 'what's she gonna look like with a chimney on her?'

The 'chimney' being slang for a black eye. 😂

Annaishere · 31/08/2023 23:27

I remember ‘what’s she going to do with a chimney on her head’

Richmondgal · 31/08/2023 23:24

Now it’s the useless George Ezra and women hating rappers

freetheunicorn1 · 31/08/2023 23:22

We're you very young in the nineties? Nineties music was so much better than that asinine pop!

maddening · 31/08/2023 23:20

My 90s music was rock, indie and brit pop which I still enjoy

TeamSleep · 31/08/2023 22:56

You’re talking about the late 90s early 00s era really OP and I agree with you, pop music did go through a childish phase. I was playing s club 7 in the car today and my kids were loving it and I was thinking there aren’t bands/songs like that anymore tailored that age group, unless I just don’t know about them.

MolkosTeenageAngst · 09/08/2023 12:17

The 90s was the first decade where female vocalists started to dominate the charts whether as solo acts, as girl bands or mixed group bands with female leadse were male equivalents too such as Five, A1, North & South etc but they were not as popular in the time of girl power.

I think in the 9ps because the music industry was previously male dominated it hadn’t been sexualised yet so the female artists aren’t dressed in sexualised ways and their lyrics about love etc seem quite tame by todays standards because there was no expectation to put in innuendos and try and reference sex all the time. Once female artists became popular though the music industry obviously then realised that they could sexualise all these female acts to make them appeal to a wider audience (eg: men) and so later girl bands like The Sugababes, Girls Aloud etc which came about at end of 90s/ early 00s all have more raunchy videos and are dressed more sexily etc. I don’t think that trend has really changed, because little girls will always be into popular music whatever it is so there’s no need to cater to them specifically now the industry has realised that it can sell sex alongside music to reel in a wider audience.

tennesseewhiskey1 · 09/08/2023 11:48

Prodigy was not childish! The Foos?! Nirvana?! And spice girls singing about 2 becoming 1 was hardly childish?! :)

NotDavidTennant · 09/08/2023 11:33

The 90s was a bit of a mixed era for music. Yes, there was the britpop/indie rock stuff like Nirvana, Oasis and Radiohead but it was also the era when 'manufactured' pop went through a big revival with groups like Take That, Boyzone and the Spice Girls that were aimed at a younger, mainly female audience.

Both types of music sat side by side but by the end of the decade it was the 'manufactured' stuff that became dominant which is perhaps the era you are remembering. This lead on to a new generation of 'publicly manufactured' stuff like Pop Stars and The X Factor.

CoffeeWithCheese · 09/08/2023 11:06

Plus - since the 90s is like insanely cool right now - you get to relive any bands you might have missed and look like you're really "with it".

Elepunt · 09/08/2023 10:30

If was fine to be a child back then, of course there were other bands and artists that appealed to others, but childrens entertainment was viable whereas now teens and even younger children are just seen as small adults in regard to a lot of pop culture and its sad. I remember when my DS started reception another child was bullied for having a paw patrol lunch box, they're only 4 or 5 ffs- but no that's uncool even at that age. The 90s were a great time to be a child imo, although appreciate there were a lot of other issues in society.

MasterBeth · 09/08/2023 10:27

VivaDixie · 09/08/2023 10:07

OK Computer 🤣🤣

Nice

MasterBeth · 09/08/2023 10:27

The OP raises an interesting point, and everyone reminding her of the cool, adult bands they liked at the time is missing it.

She hasn't said that kiddie music was the only popular style back then, or that dance music, rock music, Britpop or "whatever you liked" didn't exist. She's saying that, compared to now, kiddie music had a prominence in the charts and popular culture which it doesn't have now.

I think it's much more about the way music is distributed, consumed and sold. Record sales (inc. CDs, cassettes etc) peaked in 1999. Today, record sales make up a tiny percentage of total music revenues. (Chart here from the US, but trends very similar in the UK: https://www.statista.com/chart/17244/us-music-revenue-by-format/ )

So, the real answer is more about the percentage of kids buying singles, the role of Saturday morning kids TV, the beginning of fragmentation of media channels, the early internet etc etc. That's a more interesting discussion to have than dozens of people saying "what about Radiohead?"

Infographic: From Tape to Tidal: 4 Decades of U.S. Music Sales

This chart shows U.S. music industry revenue since 1980 by format.

https://www.statista.com/chart/17244/us-music-revenue-by-format

AutumnCrow · 09/08/2023 10:08

I reported the AI but nobody cares 🫤

VivaDixie · 09/08/2023 10:07

touseef877 · 09/08/2023 09:15

The shift you've noticed from music geared at children to more "adult" songs topping the charts is affected by a variety of variables including changes in the music industry, cultural upheavals, and growing tastes. Here are several significant reasons that could influence this shift:

Changing Music Industry Dynamics: The music industry has changed dramatically over the last few decades. The proliferation of digital platforms, streaming services, and social media has altered how music is consumed and promoted. The music industry has become more receptive to individual preferences thanks to focused marketing and tailored playlists, allowing a greater diversity of musical genres and styles to achieve appeal
.

OK Computer 🤣🤣

mogtheexcellent · 09/08/2023 10:03

I remember getting enough pocket money to buy a 7"single and some sweets every other week in the mid 80s.

Dd bought a kylie greatest hits album (I blame ghosts on BBC) at a car boot sale yesterday. Its not really the same thing.

EmmaPaella · 09/08/2023 10:00

CoffeeWithCheese · 09/08/2023 09:43

I think music in the 90s was quite polarised - you listened to what "group" you fitted in with's music a lot more than people do now in a streaming-oriented word. You either had to buy the music yourself, or manage to tape a track off the radio, or it was your friends who'd bought albums that you could manage to borrow and copy that limited your access to music... so you had all these little mini music-tribe echo chambers going around and woe betide you dared cross the genres! I'll out myself a bit here by saying that a certain BBC presenter (6 music, Glasto darling, One Show) now beloved on MN took the piss out of me no end at school when I lent a friend a copy of a tape and it dared have "indie" stuff on the B side of it (I'd copied it from a friend of a friend) and I wasn't one of the indie kids so why did I have access to this kind of music.

So if you were just listening to what was on TOTP (as there wasn't the massive access to music there is now) then yes, there were either the weeks where you had the joys of the Spice Girls and Mr Blobby... or those really cringe weeks where they'd got something more obscure that had had a freak chart breakout hit and the audience didn't know what the fuck to do with it.

I don't know if it's better or worse these days - streaming means you can hear one track and go look it up, access it and discover other stuff by the artist, but likewise, I meet a lot of people who claim to be like Metallica fans after Stranger Things - but will ONLY listen to the tracks that made it onto the TV show and have no idea of the range of back catalogue and will never listen to one of the album "filler" tracks that we all had to either carefully fast forward or sit through. We can access more niche and diverse music these days, and we don't need one of our friends to have got hold of the new album (or to be rich) to be able to do so.

So true about the music tribes and being ‘allowed’ to be into whatever music!

EmmaPaella · 09/08/2023 09:57

In the 80s, there was a lot of pop aimed at kids too. While I was bopping around to the frog song and Agadoo there were people older than me listening to The Smiths and Kate Bush…

CoffeeWithCheese · 09/08/2023 09:43

I think music in the 90s was quite polarised - you listened to what "group" you fitted in with's music a lot more than people do now in a streaming-oriented word. You either had to buy the music yourself, or manage to tape a track off the radio, or it was your friends who'd bought albums that you could manage to borrow and copy that limited your access to music... so you had all these little mini music-tribe echo chambers going around and woe betide you dared cross the genres! I'll out myself a bit here by saying that a certain BBC presenter (6 music, Glasto darling, One Show) now beloved on MN took the piss out of me no end at school when I lent a friend a copy of a tape and it dared have "indie" stuff on the B side of it (I'd copied it from a friend of a friend) and I wasn't one of the indie kids so why did I have access to this kind of music.

So if you were just listening to what was on TOTP (as there wasn't the massive access to music there is now) then yes, there were either the weeks where you had the joys of the Spice Girls and Mr Blobby... or those really cringe weeks where they'd got something more obscure that had had a freak chart breakout hit and the audience didn't know what the fuck to do with it.

I don't know if it's better or worse these days - streaming means you can hear one track and go look it up, access it and discover other stuff by the artist, but likewise, I meet a lot of people who claim to be like Metallica fans after Stranger Things - but will ONLY listen to the tracks that made it onto the TV show and have no idea of the range of back catalogue and will never listen to one of the album "filler" tracks that we all had to either carefully fast forward or sit through. We can access more niche and diverse music these days, and we don't need one of our friends to have got hold of the new album (or to be rich) to be able to do so.

DownNative · 09/08/2023 09:25

Music with a deliberate appeal to children and teenagers was nothing new by the 1990s!

In the 1970s, the Jackson 5 and the Osmonds appealed directly to kids with hits like ABC and One Bad Apple.

This model proved to be successful and has been replicated since by NKOTB, TT, S Club 7 and so on. There was lots of money in it.

But other styles of music NOT directly aimed at children and teenagers existed alongside as well.

Nothing new under the sun as they say.

Plumbear2 · 09/08/2023 09:21

You where a child so these are the songs you liked. I was in my 20s I didnt listen to that type of music. It's like saying the 80s where children's music because I like agadoo and similar because I was a child then. Of course that is not true.

touseef877 · 09/08/2023 09:15

The shift you've noticed from music geared at children to more "adult" songs topping the charts is affected by a variety of variables including changes in the music industry, cultural upheavals, and growing tastes. Here are several significant reasons that could influence this shift:

Changing Music Industry Dynamics: The music industry has changed dramatically over the last few decades. The proliferation of digital platforms, streaming services, and social media has altered how music is consumed and promoted. The music industry has become more receptive to individual preferences thanks to focused marketing and tailored playlists, allowing a greater diversity of musical genres and styles to achieve appeal
.