Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think newer cars can be cheaper overall

27 replies

forsythg · 02/08/2023 18:36

Hear me out.

My car has been in the garage countless times for car repairs over the last few years for my 10 year old 1.2l motor. Random faults, like needed a whole new computer unit as the electrics have got a bit confused, down to more expensive mechanical parts. It’s a city car, really, not designed for long distances. It’s done short of 45k miles and I am only the second owner, if it does 6,000 a year that’s all it does. It’s wear and tear related stuff and some random issues too along the way.

I could ‘afford’ a newer car with a bank loan, paying back £200 ish a month. Surely this is peace of mind that there won’t be any wear and tear, so should limit the amount of times in the garage? I have always tried to live humbly and own a cheap car outright as I think this is fundamentally better than being in debt. That said, I use my car more and more for work and will be doing especially as we start a family, I want something reliable that can be trusted.

I hate the uncertainty of things going wrong currently and don’t have much faith in my car. AIBU to think there’s some savings to be had with a new car despite the monthly outgoing?

OP posts:
forsythg · 02/08/2023 18:53

tescocreditcard · 02/08/2023 18:49

I agree. Second hand cars are only economical if you can do your own maintenance. Which I can't. Which is why I've always brought brand new cars or had lease cars.

I'm convinced that in the end there's no difference in cost, plus new cars don't break down so no stress either

Thank you. I’ve literally only just come to realise this! Would you recommend leasing over buying a new car?

OP posts:
tescocreditcard · 02/08/2023 18:49

I agree. Second hand cars are only economical if you can do your own maintenance. Which I can't. Which is why I've always brought brand new cars or had lease cars.

I'm convinced that in the end there's no difference in cost, plus new cars don't break down so no stress either

Swipe left for the next trending thread