Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you be upset - it's a work one

145 replies

Ceci03 · 02/08/2023 15:47

I have 2 managers and 3 team mates. While I was away on leave last week, an invitation was sent to me and the 3 others inviting us to 'refresher training' yesterday. I only realised when I got into the office that 3 individual meeting requests had been sent. So it was just the 2 managers, me and a p/t member of staff who it was explained was there as she was an 'expert'. (She has worked here longer than the other team members). So anyway when I went into the meeting room (p/t member told me I would need my laptop) - it turned out to be a test. I was a bit shocked and tbh got very nervous. The p/t member of staff gave me a task, and I had to complete it in front of them with them all looking over my shoulder. I got caught out a couple of times - she had put things in to 'catch me out', although if I had had a few mins I would have 'got it'.

They then proceeded to say that it had been brought to their attention that a lot of mistakes were being made but they didnt know by who, so that's why I had to do the test. They kept asking me 'who is making mistakes' and I just said I hadn't noticed anything specific, and was certainly not going to name names, and that I looked on it as 3 of us were new since Jan and were on a steep learning curve, and we learned from our mistakes. It was extremely uncomfortable.

At the time I was a bit shell shocked and just went along with it. The next team member to go in - I gave him a heads up and said it wasnt a training session but a test. He spoke to me afterwards. He also was upset and said it felt extremely demeaning. Which I agree with. The third person due to sit this test was on a/l. She was back today and we warned her - gave her a chance to 'swot'. I think it was very sneaky and not nice - am I right to be upset about it.

OP posts:
Smartstuffed · 06/08/2023 17:53

Mari9999 · 06/08/2023 16:50

@Ceci03
Your employers have the right to expect the accurate and correct output for which they are paying. Quality control testing is not and should not be a problem. They should however alert employees that this will be happening at random times.

Do you think it fair that employers should have to accept sub par work without trying to determine the source? An alternative might be to let the entire team go because they are unable to determine who is the source of the problem. They might also determine that the entire team needs retraining.

An employee who knows the job and functions well, really has nothing to fear from random testing.

All well and good as long as the staff have actually received training in the first place. But when they haven't....

Grendell · 06/08/2023 16:55

This is going to be a hard thing to survive. I would start looking for another job ASAP and say very little at the meeting. Just sit still and breath slowly and try and keep your heart rate down.

My guess is they know who is making mistakes. They can give a pop quiz if they want to in an effort to be fair - I don't think it's that crazy. But getting over-emotional and have a rant aimed at management - that's a hard one to come back from.

Mari9999 · 06/08/2023 16:50

@Ceci03
Your employers have the right to expect the accurate and correct output for which they are paying. Quality control testing is not and should not be a problem. They should however alert employees that this will be happening at random times.

Do you think it fair that employers should have to accept sub par work without trying to determine the source? An alternative might be to let the entire team go because they are unable to determine who is the source of the problem. They might also determine that the entire team needs retraining.

An employee who knows the job and functions well, really has nothing to fear from random testing.

stayathomer · 06/08/2023 16:21

Op this sounds really dramatic but I would honest to god rather be unemployed and take anything that results out of that (eg couch surfing, moving in with relatives etc), than work in this environment. Forget about them bringing ANYTHING against you, this honestly needs to go to court or to a union. Insane. Huge hugs op x

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 06/08/2023 16:06

Sounds appalling

LlynTegid · 06/08/2023 15:46

Look for another job. Unreasonable, other than your warning the others.

SmudgeButt · 06/08/2023 15:46

I've been through similar things a couple of times.

In one there was 3 managers vs me (& I do mean vs!) and they kept saying "you did this wrong" and I'd ask "when?" Reply "last October and you never did it right at any time since" And I'd ask "so how was I supposed to know that it was wrong if you kept letting me do the same thing without any feedback".

Another time I was dealing with a real bully and went in with my notes ready. It was a right long list of "you did this and I responded and you shouted at me" "I did this and you humiliated me in front of my colleagues". There was a second manager in the meeting as scribe and witness and she said afterwards she was really impressed that I was calm, organised, coherent and basically didn't put up with any carp.

So write out your notes, take a witness in with you or at least a neutral person as scribe. after they start the meeting and say "we're here to discuss...." tell them you want to make a statement. Explain that the situation upset you and maybe you over-reacted but you think there are still things that they need to resolve. Best of luck with it.

BorsetshireBanality · 06/08/2023 15:41

MysteryBelle · 06/08/2023 15:37

But the it had been brought to their notice that mistakes were being made the thing is 3 out of 4 of us were new back in Jan.

The 4th person who’s been there longer is the one who has brought the ‘mistakes’ to the bosses’ notice.

This!

MysteryBelle · 06/08/2023 15:37

But the it had been brought to their notice that mistakes were being made the thing is 3 out of 4 of us were new back in Jan.

The 4th person who’s been there longer is the one who has brought the ‘mistakes’ to the bosses’ notice.

Newnamefor23 · 06/08/2023 15:03

TBH, given your past experience, I’d be wary about putting a request for further training in writing.

May be a discussion with others, your colleages, around - and make mention of the testing - but not a direct request.

Some years ago, new Head. I was a Hd of Dept. Big staff meeting, everyone saw in departments.

We had to list our departments strengths and weaknesses. We’d been honest, new Head, fresh ideas etc etc. Big mistake.

Strengths ignored. Weaknesses picked on relentlessly. Unions involved supporting 5 colleagues. ( And that was just 1 union)

I left for happier pastures a couple of years later.

Spinningjenny23 · 06/08/2023 14:23

I'd not only be upset, I'd be rampantly furious and actively looking for another job. This reminds me of a ghastly little publishing company with a name related to spiders that I worked for in Newcastle (now based in Gateshead) when I was desperate for a job and just took the first thing that came my way - and wished I hadn't. This is exactly the kind of stunt they would have pulled, the managers (some of whom owned the company) were always trying to catch us all out.

I know you don't want to move, but the environment at this company isn't going to improve. I'd bet money on them possibly being in financial straits, if not now, then in the very near future. If they're not in financial trouble, they're possibly under some kind of governance threat.

JenWillsiam · 06/08/2023 13:58

Crikey you need to step back. You’re going to get fired. And rightly so at this rate.

It’s perfectly fine for employers to have employees do on the spot tests or assessments and that is training in its own right. It helps employers identify training gaps, skill gaps, those who can work under pressure, it can help identify if people are making repeat mistakes. There is value. At this point you’re really making yourself look unprofessional and to then blow up. Enough.

καλοκαλoκαιρι · 06/08/2023 13:39

RedHelenB · 02/08/2023 15:54

Well by warning them you may well end up as the worst of the bunch on this " test"

well, good for them that their initial motivation was solidarity with their colleagues rather than underhanded collusion with their bosses then. Bravo OP, more of you pls

Appleofmyeye2023 · 06/08/2023 13:22

ohdamnitjanet · 06/08/2023 12:12

@Appleofmyeye2023 I want to work for you 😆

☺️
but I retired 2 years ago. Sorry 🤣🤣

I worked for some very good companies, with good hr and L&D departments, got good training on being a manager, and had some excellent managers as role models

it’s not intuitive- it comes with training, and experience.

Outerlimit · 06/08/2023 13:11

Piss poor management by any standards, but this sounds like something I witnessed. Basically fraud by someone above suspicion, with people ( maybe the p/t 'expert')colluding with the guilty to find a patsy to take the blame.
Start looking for a job OP, bad things are on the horizon.

Dibbydoos · 06/08/2023 12:47

Well done @Ceci03 I like how you managed this and what you did afterwards.

Did they ask your colleague to snitch too?

I'd be upset by this, shoes the lack of management capability imo.

Hope it blows over soon, but unless you out live your nanager, you may well need to find another job, not immediately, but this type of behaviour will rear its ugly head again :(

Branleuse · 06/08/2023 12:43

You have a manager that ignores you and another that is aggressive and abrupt. Your training has been poor. You and your colleagues have worked well amd done your best to learn the ropes and are managing well despite the hostile work environment created by the managers. The surprise tests have been extremely upsetting for all your team in the circumstances and have felt degrading and demeaning and designed to catch you out and shame you in front of these managers. The whole thing sounds dishonest and really bad managemen and shows exactly what they think of their staff. I think id seriously consider resigning if they dont give an apology at the meeting.
Dont let them turn it round on to you. You arent at fault here.

ohdamnitjanet · 06/08/2023 12:12

@Appleofmyeye2023 I want to work for you 😆

Intensiv14 · 06/08/2023 11:47

Gaps not gains

Intensiv14 · 06/08/2023 11:47

I don’t think you’ve done too much wrong, depending on how much you lost it.
You made a fair point that it wasn’t training, it was a test and they tricked you. They should’ve been upfront and they handled it poorly. It reflects badly on them too.
Definitely do not mention part-time, it’s not relevant. Focus your points on this test, how it was presented and why there are gains in the training and what they can do about that as a organisation. Don’t agree to take too much of the flack for this one!

ThreeLocusts · 06/08/2023 11:28

OP don't beat yourself up about getting angry. Water under bridge.

'Killing with kindness' sounds right. Just be sweetness and light in tone but stick to your guns on substance. Acknowledge that you spoke too sharply the other day if you think so - did you really? - but don't over-apologise.

And the colleague who encouraged you and then backpedalled - just forget about him. He should have tried to mediate in the moment if he really cared.

It's shit that so much of what would be assertive in a man is seen as shrill in a woman. Easy to get into no-win situations. Good luck!

Appleofmyeye2023 · 06/08/2023 11:10

Look for another job, op, this is shite on shite.

don’t tell them you’re looking, do what they want in meantime and leave when you’ve got a new position

join a union - immediately. Won’t help you with this, but too many people don’t realise that your average worker needs to be in a 7nion in case this sort of shifty legal hr stuff arises. If you were a member you’d be calling them for legal advice not posting here .

don’t join any organisation that gives you 2 bosses 🤦‍♀️

don’t join any company without asking about training for your role and ensuring you’ll be given formal training package to ensure you pass probabtionary period.

don’t join a company without a minimum of 1 dedicated person who is HR. Or if it’s a very small company , a boss who has informed themselves and conversant in uk employee law and can talk lucidly about policies and practices regarding your emplyment

and never join without a signed contract which relates to a written job description that you’ve seen and agreed to, that specifies exact tasks you’ll be doing and your overarching objectives of the role.

rwalker · 06/08/2023 11:09

There’s nothing w with a competency test identifies knowledge and skills gaps but the way they went about but is completely wrong

your all fairly new to the company have you had regular supervisions and feedback

a general offer of training is a get out of jail card for them if there is any problems they’ll say we offered training and support and no one said they needed it

Make sure you have supervisions and reviews any issues should be backed up with training and support

VaddaABeetch · 06/08/2023 11:09

I’m advance of your meeting I’d suggest;
Write bullet points of what you want to say, bring it in with you.

Keep it to Max 5 main points
Start opening sentences with a positive…I have been recruited as a competent professional. I am committed to learning and performing at a high level.
Finish with a positive. Thank you for meeting, I appreciate your time.

What do you want from this meeting? Best case, state that.

Do you have a friend you could practice a mock meeting with you?

If you feel yourself getting annoyed or flustered take a breath & reiterate one of your main points.

Use the power of silence, count to 3 in your head before answering any questions. If you’re not sure say I’ll need to think about that. Don’t be tempted to jump in & fill silences either.

Take notes

Appleofmyeye2023 · 06/08/2023 11:04

Ceci03 · 03/08/2023 16:15

@Illegallyblonder thank you! Can I take you into the meeting with me on Tuesday . I am beating myself up and this is why I often opt to say nothing as I seem to be incapable of holding my nerve. I just lose it and then of course I've lost the argument . I had thought I was getting better but I think I've just been getting better at holding it all in and trying not to care. Thing is I do cAre and want to do well and get it right that's why I'm upset too

Ask her why if it was “training”,

  1. you weren’t told in advance you’d be sat a test
  2. you were being observed the whole time by bosses who didn’t know how to do the task and why was that, why were they actually there at all
  3. point out exact
  4. Cal auto the proportion of time she was coaching you vs testing you and ask if she would feel, in your position, that it was a constructive form of training

say that you felt she was gaslighting you to ask if you enjoyed it. Ask her if she feels “sorry you feel that way” , why?

Swipe left for the next trending thread