Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU that Rishi Sunak's holiday to Disneyland be headline news?

166 replies

iwillnotstaycalm · 02/08/2023 14:11

There is almost like a 'read the room' feeling on this. Personally I think it's distasteful given the current cost of living crisis - I'm not saying going on holiday is distasteful but highlighting it to the general public as headline news just seems insidious. Why is this even news ? If someone can please explain it to me that would be wonderful.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
CobraKaiNeverLoses · 08/08/2023 23:29

yogasaurus · 04/08/2023 06:13

That’s not a crime, although you wouldn’t think it sometimes. Seems some think he should just give their money away as a penance for being wealthy.

I don’t have a problem with it. I’d love £700m.

stayathomer · 05/08/2023 08:08

He has money because his wife has a net worth of circa £700 million. Nothing to do with running a country. They were rich as Croesus before he became PM and will still be rich as Croesus when he’s done.
Sorry I shouldn't really have started with the reason I thought he had money-I just meant people have money, they can't just ignore that fact because there's a col crisis and he can't give it all away!!

wlana · 04/08/2023 21:07

I think the picture got into the media for several potential reasons:

  1. nice photo of him, wife, 2 sweet kids - makes him look relatable/nice/friendly/good dad whatever - to increase popularity.

  2. to make people jealous and frothy and decrease his popularity

personally I don’t see why his kids shouldn’t have a holiday in Disneyland, regardless of how anyone feels about him and regardless of whether others can’t afford a holiday or the electricity bill. If he didn’t go on holiday, his money would stay in the bank (or wherever you put that much money) - not going on people’s electricity bills.

jgw1 · 04/08/2023 20:56

AgathaSpencerGregson · 04/08/2023 20:49

I am not sure why you think that is relevant to a discussion of whether refugees have the right to claim asylum where they like? You appear to be addressing a different point. But in any event, to state the blindingly obvious, to say that someone is unlikely to be prosecuted (which is what the article actually says) is not the same thing as saying they have not broken the law. The average burglar in this country is unlikely to be prosecuted. Burglary is still illegal.

If you don't think the article is relevant why did you link to it?

jgw1 · 04/08/2023 20:54

AgathaSpencerGregson · 04/08/2023 20:49

I am not sure why you think that is relevant to a discussion of whether refugees have the right to claim asylum where they like? You appear to be addressing a different point. But in any event, to state the blindingly obvious, to say that someone is unlikely to be prosecuted (which is what the article actually says) is not the same thing as saying they have not broken the law. The average burglar in this country is unlikely to be prosecuted. Burglary is still illegal.

The reason for the lack of prosecutions is important.

In the case of asylum seekers as the article explains the UKs obligations as a signatory to the 1951 refugree convention means that asylum seekers cannot be successfully prosecuted for illegal entry. That the Tory government has for the past 13 years defunded the justice system so that few burgulars are prosecuted is a different discussion which I am quite happy to have.

On the subject of whether or not asylum seekers have the right to claim asylum in any safe country, both your article and the full fact article I linked to are clear that the 1999 case on this subject means that as far as the UK is concerned transit through another country does not negate an asylum seekers right to claim asylum in the UK.

AgathaSpencerGregson · 04/08/2023 20:49

jgw1 · 04/08/2023 20:45

Since you don't like me quoting part of the summary of the article you linked to I will quote the whole summary.

"Summary
It is likely that many of the people crossing the Channel in dinghies are illegal entrants, and some of them may commit one or more immigration offences. This may be so even if they are refugees, because of the UK government’s failure to align our domestic law with our obligations under Article 31 of the Convention. A person is entitled to the protection of Article 31 if they claim asylum in good faith within a short period of arriving in the UK. They are not deprived of that protection by having travelled through other safe countries on their way here.
In order to give effect to Article 31, the CPS will generally not prosecute a person who is entitled to its protection and who committed the offences “reasonably or necessarily in the course of flight from persecution or threatened persecution”. If such a prosecution is brought, the defendant will in some circumstances have a statutory defence, and in cases to which the statutory defence does not apply, the court may give effect to our obligations under international law by bringing the proceedings to a halt."

The article is quite clear in stating that asylum seekers are unlikely to be successfully prosecuted for illegal entry.

I am not sure why you think that is relevant to a discussion of whether refugees have the right to claim asylum where they like? You appear to be addressing a different point. But in any event, to state the blindingly obvious, to say that someone is unlikely to be prosecuted (which is what the article actually says) is not the same thing as saying they have not broken the law. The average burglar in this country is unlikely to be prosecuted. Burglary is still illegal.

jgw1 · 04/08/2023 20:45

AgathaSpencerGregson · 04/08/2023 20:41

You are, again dishonestly, cherry picking from the article. It explains quite clearly that the relevant convention confers no rights or obligations on asylum claimants, but deals with how contracting states deal with such claimants as between themselves. It makes clear that the first state in which a claimant could have claimed asylum is a relevant factor, but ranks below other factors in determining which state should deal with the claim.
it is untrue to say there is an obligation to claim asylum in the first contracting state you arrive in; it is equally untrue to say a claimant has a right to pick and choose freely.

Since you don't like me quoting part of the summary of the article you linked to I will quote the whole summary.

"Summary
It is likely that many of the people crossing the Channel in dinghies are illegal entrants, and some of them may commit one or more immigration offences. This may be so even if they are refugees, because of the UK government’s failure to align our domestic law with our obligations under Article 31 of the Convention. A person is entitled to the protection of Article 31 if they claim asylum in good faith within a short period of arriving in the UK. They are not deprived of that protection by having travelled through other safe countries on their way here.
In order to give effect to Article 31, the CPS will generally not prosecute a person who is entitled to its protection and who committed the offences “reasonably or necessarily in the course of flight from persecution or threatened persecution”. If such a prosecution is brought, the defendant will in some circumstances have a statutory defence, and in cases to which the statutory defence does not apply, the court may give effect to our obligations under international law by bringing the proceedings to a halt."

The article is quite clear in stating that asylum seekers are unlikely to be successfully prosecuted for illegal entry.

AgathaSpencerGregson · 04/08/2023 20:44

jgw1 · 04/08/2023 20:42

Fortunately both your and my links comment upon the 1999 case where a judge ruled (subsequently confirmed by HoLs on appeal) that asylum seekers can transit other countries before claiming asylum in the UK.
And since case law is an important part of the process of UK law, that remains the case to this day.

Yes, in some circumstances they can. That is not the same as saying an asylum seeker has the right to pick and choose.

jgw1 · 04/08/2023 20:42

AgathaSpencerGregson · 04/08/2023 20:37

The article you have posted does not establish that the Dublin convention confers any rights on refugees. In common with other international treaties it deals with the relationship between contracting states, not individuals and the state. There is no treaty, and certainly no domestic law, which gives an individual a right to cherry pick where he or she claims asylum.

Fortunately both your and my links comment upon the 1999 case where a judge ruled (subsequently confirmed by HoLs on appeal) that asylum seekers can transit other countries before claiming asylum in the UK.
And since case law is an important part of the process of UK law, that remains the case to this day.

AgathaSpencerGregson · 04/08/2023 20:41

jgw1 · 04/08/2023 20:36

For anyone who does not have time to wade through the link that has so kindly been provided I thought I would share a quote from the summary.

"A person is entitled to the protection of Article 31 [of the 1951 convention] if they claim asylum in good faith within a short period of arriving in the UK. They are not deprived of that protection by having travelled through other safe countries on their way here."

You are, again dishonestly, cherry picking from the article. It explains quite clearly that the relevant convention confers no rights or obligations on asylum claimants, but deals with how contracting states deal with such claimants as between themselves. It makes clear that the first state in which a claimant could have claimed asylum is a relevant factor, but ranks below other factors in determining which state should deal with the claim.
it is untrue to say there is an obligation to claim asylum in the first contracting state you arrive in; it is equally untrue to say a claimant has a right to pick and choose freely.

jgw1 · 04/08/2023 20:40

AgathaSpencerGregson · 04/08/2023 20:37

The article you have posted does not establish that the Dublin convention confers any rights on refugees. In common with other international treaties it deals with the relationship between contracting states, not individuals and the state. There is no treaty, and certainly no domestic law, which gives an individual a right to cherry pick where he or she claims asylum.

Could you perhaps provide a link to somewhere that explains that asylum seekers have under the 1951 convention to claim asylum in the first safe country they come to?

AgathaSpencerGregson · 04/08/2023 20:37

The article you have posted does not establish that the Dublin convention confers any rights on refugees. In common with other international treaties it deals with the relationship between contracting states, not individuals and the state. There is no treaty, and certainly no domestic law, which gives an individual a right to cherry pick where he or she claims asylum.

jgw1 · 04/08/2023 20:36

AgathaSpencerGregson · 04/08/2023 20:21

The law doesn’t say this, in fact. The relevant convention confers no rights or duties on asylum claimants at all; it deals with how such individuals should be dealt with as between the contracting states.
heres a useful discussion; which I have posted before in an attempt to prevent this poster spreading disinformation.
https://levinslaw.co.uk/dinghies-in-the-channel-illegal-entrants-and-immigration-offences/

For anyone who does not have time to wade through the link that has so kindly been provided I thought I would share a quote from the summary.

"A person is entitled to the protection of Article 31 [of the 1951 convention] if they claim asylum in good faith within a short period of arriving in the UK. They are not deprived of that protection by having travelled through other safe countries on their way here."

jgw1 · 04/08/2023 20:30

AgathaSpencerGregson · 04/08/2023 20:21

The law doesn’t say this, in fact. The relevant convention confers no rights or duties on asylum claimants at all; it deals with how such individuals should be dealt with as between the contracting states.
heres a useful discussion; which I have posted before in an attempt to prevent this poster spreading disinformation.
https://levinslaw.co.uk/dinghies-in-the-channel-illegal-entrants-and-immigration-offences/

I will let others decide which of us is spreading misinformation.

https://fullfact.org/immigration/refugees-first-safe-country/

Worth noting of course that whilst the UK was in the EU the Dublin convention could have been applied and refugees returned to the first EU country they passed through, but the UK government consistently chose not to do so.

Do refugees have to stay in the first safe country they reach? - Full Fact

Refugees are not required to seek asylum in the first safe country they reach. But under EU law they can sometimes be returned to the first safe EU country they reached.

https://fullfact.org/immigration/refugees-first-safe-country

AgathaSpencerGregson · 04/08/2023 20:21

jgw1 · 04/08/2023 11:40

Then we need to change the law, because currently it says that they can legally claim asylum in any safe country they choose having arrived by any route.

Can anyone explain to me why there is so much focus on about 50,000 asylum seekers and not the other 500,000 migrants that come to the UK each year?

The law doesn’t say this, in fact. The relevant convention confers no rights or duties on asylum claimants at all; it deals with how such individuals should be dealt with as between the contracting states.
heres a useful discussion; which I have posted before in an attempt to prevent this poster spreading disinformation.
https://levinslaw.co.uk/dinghies-in-the-channel-illegal-entrants-and-immigration-offences/

Dinghies in the Channel - Illegal entrants and immigration offences - Levins

There is much controversy in the media at the moment about migrants crossing the Channel in dinghies. In this article, we set out to explain some of the relevant law and clear up some misconceptions. This article is intended to be a general commentary...

https://levinslaw.co.uk/dinghies-in-the-channel-illegal-entrants-and-immigration-offences/

StillWantingADog · 04/08/2023 17:35

There is always coverage of the prime minister’s holidays and a photo shoot almost every year.
I think they agree to a few pics then get left alone to get on with it
agree it’s ridiculous
i don’t recall any with Boris but it was pandemic times Tbf. Cameron and his lot used to pose in some posh corner of the Algarve, Theresa May in the Swiss alps.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 04/08/2023 17:31

jgw1 · 04/08/2023 11:40

Then we need to change the law, because currently it says that they can legally claim asylum in any safe country they choose having arrived by any route.

Can anyone explain to me why there is so much focus on about 50,000 asylum seekers and not the other 500,000 migrants that come to the UK each year?

Because asylum seekers are an easy target.

It is much harder to address some of the other migration which brings direct benefits to our economy. The government knows that, but it is desperate to show that it is doing something to "tackle" immigration, hence the almost obsessive focus on "stopping the boats".

Twyford · 04/08/2023 17:28

yogasaurus · 04/08/2023 11:24

No, I don’t believe in a free-for-all for migrants. If they’re in a safe country, they don’t need to travel on to the UK.

The terms "migrants" and "asylum seekers" aren't synonymous.

Why don't asylum seekers need to travel away from the first safe country they get to? If other countries don't take their fair shares, the effects on safe countries bordering troubled countries like Afghanistan and Ukraine would be completely disproportionate and risks completely overwhelming their services. There is no reason why the UK should be exempt from taking its share just because it's an island.

jgw1 · 04/08/2023 11:40

yogasaurus · 04/08/2023 11:24

No, I don’t believe in a free-for-all for migrants. If they’re in a safe country, they don’t need to travel on to the UK.

Then we need to change the law, because currently it says that they can legally claim asylum in any safe country they choose having arrived by any route.

Can anyone explain to me why there is so much focus on about 50,000 asylum seekers and not the other 500,000 migrants that come to the UK each year?

yogasaurus · 04/08/2023 11:24

jgw1 · 04/08/2023 10:32

So you will join me in condemning anyone who calls legal asylum seekers illegal?

No, I don’t believe in a free-for-all for migrants. If they’re in a safe country, they don’t need to travel on to the UK.

AgathaSpencerGregson · 04/08/2023 11:12

jgw1 · 04/08/2023 10:32

So you will join me in condemning anyone who calls legal asylum seekers illegal?

If you mean will I join in your attempts to spread disinformation about the state of UK law, no.

Cheesenpickleontoast · 04/08/2023 10:33

CloudyMcCloud · 04/08/2023 09:51

Ha at this, especially your last line 😂.

Greenpeace are good enough at irritating people on their own steam.

The media did Disneyland because it was a good way to wind people up. It was reported initially due to an interview on LBC

Huh?

jgw1 · 04/08/2023 10:32

AgathaSpencerGregson · 04/08/2023 09:55

use of racist tropes needs to be called out. If you find that tough to deal with, time to have a look at yourself.

So you will join me in condemning anyone who calls legal asylum seekers illegal?

Mousey23 · 04/08/2023 10:30

Most news isn't news - it's politics and celebrity gossip. The gossip papers report the same about Harry/Meghan, for example.

The left-wing papers will want to portray him as having too much money and enjoying luxuries the rest of us can't have.

The right-wing papers want to portray him as an "ordinary" (by middle class England standards) person who at least isn't on a private Caribbean island owned by billionaires in the style of Boris.

This is then picked up on social media, along with the comments/opinions either way which newspapers would be too cautious to publish directly.

From reading the articles, he's briefed the papers about where he is going, which seems to imply that (i) he is quite willing for this information to be released and (ii) he thinks a trip to Disneyland, as a family man, will do his image more good than harm among target voters.

AgathaSpencerGregson · 04/08/2023 09:55

Blossomtoes · 04/08/2023 08:47

That poster’s default is to accuse others of racism @Bananasandcorn. Best not to engage.

use of racist tropes needs to be called out. If you find that tough to deal with, time to have a look at yourself.

Swipe left for the next trending thread