Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Its fine to save money letting women die in child birth this year, as long as we are going to spend money preventing other women die in child birth in other years.

111 replies

Market1 · 02/08/2023 13:46

( second posting, as first one vanished...)

We have been culpable in contributing to horrendous poverty and conflict in so many areas of the globe, through political interference in the past, and climate damage now, so it is right and proper that we think long and hard about supporting pregnant women abroad in the future, and as long as we promise to continue thinking long and hard, it is fine for a few thousand to die in child birth while we think, after all, they are a long way away, and their English isn't very good.

And if they don't fancy their chances of survival in their home countries, there is always an easy road and a warm welcome waiting for them here! And a mere quarter of a million unsafe abortions? That is nothing to concern ourselves about.

YANBU - it is fine, we need to save money, and a few thousand deaths in childbirth is nothing in the grand scheme of things
YABU - we should support these women through overseas aid today, even if their English isn't very good....

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-66378364

An Army paramedic holds a baby during evacuation of British nationals in Sudan

UK foreign aid cuts: Thousands will die as a result, says report

Women will face unsafe abortions, and thousands will not get healthcare, ministers are warned.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-66378364

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
BillaBongGirl · 02/08/2023 17:25

Oliotya · 02/08/2023 15:10

But you need to ask yourself why there are so many corrupt governments. Many exist purely because we paraded around the world dismantling existing power structures, taking everything we could before pissing off with little care for what we left behind. How rich, or not, we are now has little to do with our responsibility to repair this damage.

This is pure ahistorical nonsense. When the British “discovered” other civilisations most of us had our own thousands of years of empires and so on in addition to our advanced sciences, arts and culture. The British did not invent corruption, nor was it new to us. There was corruption before, during and after the British. What is racist is pointing at foreign governments and going on about how corrupt they are when our British government is off the scale corrupt itself!

MarySmit · 02/08/2023 17:14

As for the rediculous idea of stopping FSM and giving money to parents instead, you realise that the reason we have fsm is that parents were often sending no, or nutritionally terrible lunch, to school with their children?

FSM is to ensure that children get one healthy meal a day at the minimum. Ask anyone who has worked in a school about the things they see in packed lunches: children coming in with nothing and going hungry unless school staff spend their money on them, cold KFC etc.

MarySmit · 02/08/2023 17:06

Not everything in the world is the fault of the UK. This extreme left narrative is unhelpful, and in some cases dangerous. The UK has taken a stance on dangerous practices abroad, including fgm and wife burning.

Before we find maternity care abroad, we need to properly fund maternity care in the UK. Our neonatal death rate is relatively high for a developed country, in large part due to underfunding of services and staff shortages (due to underfunding). Midwives need to be paid a respectable wage, and their course funded. More work needs to be done in retention. Card in this country sadly falls short, and this leads to unnecessary suffering and death.

Oliotya · 02/08/2023 16:52

DisquietintheRanks · 02/08/2023 16:40

Which situations? Women dying in childbirth predates even the British colonial era.

Well obviously. But the circumstances that lead to a lack of basic healthcare; corrupt governments, instability, conflict, climate change, etc. Look into it, and we're involved in an awful lot of it in very recent history.

DisquietintheRanks · 02/08/2023 16:40

Oliotya · 02/08/2023 14:42

People shouldn't be so quick to minimize our role in causing a lot of these situations. My in laws remember gaining independence, and have lived through the decades of shit that have followed. If we make a mess we need to be prepared to clean it up IMO.

Which situations? Women dying in childbirth predates even the British colonial era.

Biscuitandacuppa · 02/08/2023 16:27

I work in a secondary school and the fsm allowance barely covers the cheapest meal with not enough left over for a drink. A slice of pizza is too expensive!

In an ideal world we would be increasing overseas aid if we were financially able to. But with the cost of covid, cost of living, health and social care in dire straits, education cut to the bone and people on the brink of insolvency, now is not the time. We need to put our own oxygen mask on before we can help others.

I think the shameful waste of money and corruption by our governments is a travesty and if we were French we’d have been burning our cities and rioting for months. We are too bloody polite and passive.

Iamgoingtohell · 02/08/2023 16:15

AuntieJune · 02/08/2023 14:48

Except it doesn't, does it? The cuts here won't go to that. They'll be spent on HS2 or whatever bullshit.

Here's an idea - we're the sixth richest country in the world, how about we fund healthcare here and find some spare to help people in other countries as well?

And you’re absolutely able to have that opinion. 6th richest yet we see a massive rise in food bank use by people who are in work. I would rather see those people given more assistance than worry about other countries. I would agree that any savings need to be spent on NHS.
Like I said, my nation is a priority for myself, I do get that others will be outraged by the cut it’s just I am not one of them.

Oliotya · 02/08/2023 15:10

itsmyp4rty · 02/08/2023 15:04

I always wonder how much aid money/food ends up in the wrong, corrupt hands? I also think foreign aid smacks of colonialism and the idea of the white saviour. I think it's needs scrapping. Pouring money into countries with corrupt governments makes no sense and helps no one. Does anyone think sending money to Afghanistan is actually going to reach and help the people who need it right now?

It's not about saving anyone anyway - otherwise why would we send 2 billion plus to India when there are 45 poorer countries (based on GDP) in the world and there has never been any evidence that it has had any impact? It's about politics.

We're still behaving like we're one of the really big players in the world. No one is really in that great a position any more and we're not even top 20 based on GDP. Right now we can't even save ourselves.

But you need to ask yourself why there are so many corrupt governments. Many exist purely because we paraded around the world dismantling existing power structures, taking everything we could before pissing off with little care for what we left behind. How rich, or not, we are now has little to do with our responsibility to repair this damage.

Sometimeswinning · 02/08/2023 15:09

Market1 · 02/08/2023 14:11

well the cost of free school meals could be halved for a start, by giving half of the current spend directly to parents to shop with, rather than to schools, who spend almost all of it on the staff that prepare it, and very little on the food.

By pass the cost of the staff that buy, prepare and serve the food, let parents do that, and you get ten times the nutritional value for half the cost

Because school dinners is the one hot meal alot of my kids will get that day. Some of them need breakfast aswell. There are parents who are not going to go to the effort of making a healthy packed lunch. But let's not worry about those children.

Please don't assume this is even close to a good idea.

itsmyp4rty · 02/08/2023 15:04

I always wonder how much aid money/food ends up in the wrong, corrupt hands? I also think foreign aid smacks of colonialism and the idea of the white saviour. I think it's needs scrapping. Pouring money into countries with corrupt governments makes no sense and helps no one. Does anyone think sending money to Afghanistan is actually going to reach and help the people who need it right now?

It's not about saving anyone anyway - otherwise why would we send 2 billion plus to India when there are 45 poorer countries (based on GDP) in the world and there has never been any evidence that it has had any impact? It's about politics.

We're still behaving like we're one of the really big players in the world. No one is really in that great a position any more and we're not even top 20 based on GDP. Right now we can't even save ourselves.

Begsthequestion · 02/08/2023 15:02

IMustDoMoreExercise · 02/08/2023 14:59

Yes of course tax the rich.

If you tax the rich they will just move to another country (as they are doing already because our tax rates are higher than other countries).

Who should we tax then?

What about taxing you?

Good riddance.

See you on the barricades xxx

Regholdsworthswaterbed · 02/08/2023 15:00

Market1 · 02/08/2023 14:49

and you are living in a fantasy world if you think the muck being handed out as a free school meal could be classified as a "decent meal" in any universe. - it is just a waste of money

The school meals in my kids school are pretty decent to be honest. But even if it wasn't great it's more than what some kids have at home. I used to run a brownie group and one kid would regularly have a pot noodle for dinner. Don't underestimate how shit some parents are.

IMustDoMoreExercise · 02/08/2023 14:59

Begsthequestion · 02/08/2023 14:11

Tax the rich.

Prise some of that unearned, undeserved, unjust wealth from their grasping hands and redistribute it where it is needed.

It's the only answer.

Yes of course tax the rich.

If you tax the rich they will just move to another country (as they are doing already because our tax rates are higher than other countries).

Who should we tax then?

What about taxing you?

CloudyMcCloud · 02/08/2023 14:57

How broad shouldered are we these days? The global situation is changing. Some countries are accelerating and it’s not really the west anymore

Not much we can do about that though, just general progression and change

meditrina · 02/08/2023 14:55

I think it is totally wrong and unacceptable to cut the aid budget.

No matter how much we may be feeling the COL crisis, it is for those with the broadest shoulders to take on the biggest burdens. And by global terms we are broad-shouldered and so should be at least maintaining our overseas aid spending

BillaBongGirl · 02/08/2023 14:54

Market1 · 02/08/2023 14:49

and you are living in a fantasy world if you think the muck being handed out as a free school meal could be classified as a "decent meal" in any universe. - it is just a waste of money

FSMs are the same meals that paying children get and they are decent meals imho. It’s not a waste of money when you consider the alternative is seagulling half eaten plates of food in cafes/restaurants and dumpster diving.

Only someone who hasn’t been hungry would turn their nose up at a school meal.

Annaishere · 02/08/2023 14:54

It makes sense with our own healthcare system so poor

AnSolas · 02/08/2023 14:52

Market1 · 02/08/2023 14:11

well the cost of free school meals could be halved for a start, by giving half of the current spend directly to parents to shop with, rather than to schools, who spend almost all of it on the staff that prepare it, and very little on the food.

By pass the cost of the staff that buy, prepare and serve the food, let parents do that, and you get ten times the nutritional value for half the cost

So you are willing to let UK children (whos parents would not use the money for food ) starve to save the Admin costs

We have been culpable in contributing to horrendous poverty and conflict in so many areas of the globe, through political interference in the past, and climate damage now, so it is right and proper that we think long and hard about supporting pregnant women abroad in the future

How about paying UK foreigin aid to Irish maternity hospitals ?

BillaBongGirl · 02/08/2023 14:52

Market1 · 02/08/2023 14:41

This civil service investigations indicates that the difference between honouring our aid commitments and not honouring them will be death for thousands of women.

For any one of those women, and their children, this is not "pissing in the wind", this is a tangible, life and death scenario.

Yes yes more deaths there but we have plenty of excess deaths here too due to lack of funded healthcare. In January 2023, the RCEM stated that there were 300 and 500 excess deaths each week in the UK solely due to A&E delays and doctors are warning this number is going to be higher this winter due to further A&E shortfalls, or 22,000 British residents for all of 2022.

This is in addition to the 113,000 excess deaths due to the longest ever NHS waitlists for nonemergency care for things like surgery and cancer treatment.

We are not a rich, powerful empire. We don’t even have the money to keep our own residents from dying when they should be surviving. Why on Earth should we be prioritising foreign aid in these circumstances?

Begsthequestion · 02/08/2023 14:51

MillWood85 · 02/08/2023 14:39

I'd rather we looked after our starving children and pensioners than sending money to countries that prioritise weapons and armies over their citizens. Foreign aid is like pissing in the wind.

Charity starts at home.

So, why don't "we" do either?

MintJulia · 02/08/2023 14:50

AuntieJune · 02/08/2023 14:45

People who say we should help those at home first - somehow always turn out to be the people who also want to cut benefits and services.

International Aid boosts our reputation hugely around the world and in the grand scheme of things it costs peanuts. We're losing global influence and becoming a sad backwater because of all this crabby small-mindedness.

The whole point is I DON'T want to cut services, (there is nothing left to cut) which is why I believe that while we deal with financial issues at home, we cannot increase the foreign aid budget.

MillWood85 · 02/08/2023 14:49

My DD is a student midwife and believe me, there's no way I'd want to give birth under the NHS these days. The service has been cut to the bone.

So yes I'd rather the money for foreign aid went there.

Market1 · 02/08/2023 14:49

Regholdsworthswaterbed · 02/08/2023 14:46

You live in a fantasy world if you think all parents will spend this on food and preparing nutritional meals for their kids. For some kids this might be the only decent meal they eat each day through feckless parenting.

and you are living in a fantasy world if you think the muck being handed out as a free school meal could be classified as a "decent meal" in any universe. - it is just a waste of money

OP posts:
AuntieJune · 02/08/2023 14:48

Iamgoingtohell · 02/08/2023 14:36

You’ll hate me but I would rather funding went into the care and well-being of British women & children.
I do not oppose the reduction in foreign aid. They have their own governments and laws and that is the root cause of their plight.

Except it doesn't, does it? The cuts here won't go to that. They'll be spent on HS2 or whatever bullshit.

Here's an idea - we're the sixth richest country in the world, how about we fund healthcare here and find some spare to help people in other countries as well?