Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Its fine to save money letting women die in child birth this year, as long as we are going to spend money preventing other women die in child birth in other years.

111 replies

Market1 · 02/08/2023 13:46

( second posting, as first one vanished...)

We have been culpable in contributing to horrendous poverty and conflict in so many areas of the globe, through political interference in the past, and climate damage now, so it is right and proper that we think long and hard about supporting pregnant women abroad in the future, and as long as we promise to continue thinking long and hard, it is fine for a few thousand to die in child birth while we think, after all, they are a long way away, and their English isn't very good.

And if they don't fancy their chances of survival in their home countries, there is always an easy road and a warm welcome waiting for them here! And a mere quarter of a million unsafe abortions? That is nothing to concern ourselves about.

YANBU - it is fine, we need to save money, and a few thousand deaths in childbirth is nothing in the grand scheme of things
YABU - we should support these women through overseas aid today, even if their English isn't very good....

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-66378364

An Army paramedic holds a baby during evacuation of British nationals in Sudan

UK foreign aid cuts: Thousands will die as a result, says report

Women will face unsafe abortions, and thousands will not get healthcare, ministers are warned.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-66378364

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Yellowdays · 02/08/2023 21:22

MintJulia · 02/08/2023 14:08

I'm sure you're aware that the money is being redirected to cover the costs of asylum seekers who have come to the UK.

Where would you rather the money came from? Cancelling free school meals for primary children, or cutting adult care services even more? Reducing care for SEN pupils? The NHS?

We have the highest debt levels we have ever had. We can't have everything, so what would you choose to do without?

So much money being given back to the richest in society.

Tax cuts

Huge contracts for ministers' mates

Weapons

Yellowdays · 02/08/2023 21:18

OP your thread title is a bloody good question. I suspect the current government will say yes. Not that it'll change that much, with plans for so much more of the medical work in future to be undertaken by less qualified staff.

Moneynewpence · 02/08/2023 19:27

AmadeustheAlpaca · 02/08/2023 13:53

Thousands of women already die in childbirth in Africa as a result of FGM. This is not supported by the British government.

But everything is our fault. Everything. Didn't you get the memo?

MakeMeShine · 02/08/2023 19:26

Market1 · 02/08/2023 17:56

what is silly?

Thousands of women will die because of this decision.

Real human woman, not just abstract numbers on some political balance sheet

Are you OK with that? reallY??

Firstly, I think you’re being dramatic, but even if you weren’t yes I would be okay with that, because it is what it is. Their own country needs to support them, not us.

AbraKedavra · 02/08/2023 18:51

AFAIC all the talk of what better use we could have of the money is a non sequitur. It doesn't matter whether we could or couldn't put it to better use.

Fact is, poor people dying thousands of miles away isn't our responsibility. It's tragic, but still not our responsibility.

I might be able to see an argument if we had a surplus of money, that perhaps we have a moral duty to all of mankind. But as we're in debt, all foreign aid should be cut.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 02/08/2023 18:41

I always wonder how much aid money/food ends up in the wrong, corrupt hands?

Most of it unfortunately, and not just in the hands of corrupt officials but also into the back pockets of the executives who run the "charities'. I think it's save the children who have 60+ employees on 6 figure plus salaries in their London offices alone.

I've also seen it argued that aid often undermines a country's ability to develop and progress as it helps prop up corrupt regimes. Why would a dictator worry about improving things for the the people when foreign governments and charities will just give them money and how do the people make their voices heard when the foreign aid that's supposed to help them had instead furnished the presidential guard with brand new automatic weapons to oppress dissenting voices?

Let's also jot forget that the aid sector as a whole is corrupt beyond belief and has a record of abject failure in dealing with exploitation and abuses committed by its own personnel. They are now more concerned about their reputation and keeping the donations flowing than they are about helping anyone.

Now it is clear the tories havent made these cuts because they're concerned about the impacts of foreign aid but, we do need to have a conversation about how we can administer it so that it actually helps those in need.

JamSandle · 02/08/2023 18:39

We don't even look after people here. Why and how are we expected to look after people elsewhere?

The British Empire is over and in fall..

CloudyMcCloud · 02/08/2023 18:35

BillaBongGirl · 02/08/2023 18:30

Why does the fact that India is punching so far above its weight in its contribution to planetary defence, mean we don't contribute to offsetting some of the damage we do to its climate?

Leaving aside what you may mean by “planetary defence”, we (the U.K.) don’t do any damage to the climate of India. They’ve pumped almost as much CO2 in the atmosphere in total emissions as the U.K. has, and they don’t have the excuse we have of having done most of it 100yrs ago when there was no such thing as green technology or renewable energy other than the odd hydro electric dam which sadly the U.K. doesn’t even have one a single river suitable for it.

Thanks for facts. Some of these posts are a bit what posters imagine is the case.

BillaBongGirl · 02/08/2023 18:30

Why does the fact that India is punching so far above its weight in its contribution to planetary defence, mean we don't contribute to offsetting some of the damage we do to its climate?

Leaving aside what you may mean by “planetary defence”, we (the U.K.) don’t do any damage to the climate of India. They’ve pumped almost as much CO2 in the atmosphere in total emissions as the U.K. has, and they don’t have the excuse we have of having done most of it 100yrs ago when there was no such thing as green technology or renewable energy other than the odd hydro electric dam which sadly the U.K. doesn’t even have one a single river suitable for it.

Its fine to save money letting women die in child birth this year, as long as we are going to spend money preventing other women die in child birth in other years.
Its fine to save money letting women die in child birth this year, as long as we are going to spend money preventing other women die in child birth in other years.
BillaBongGirl · 02/08/2023 18:19

Market1 · 02/08/2023 17:42

It is the difference between life and death to individual women, I don't suppose you would call it a !drop in the ocean" if it saved your life in child birth, or saved your baby

It’s also the difference between life and death for the 500 dying every week due to A&E delays, and the additional 2,175 dying every week due to NHS waitlists for treatment. We have the entire population of Colchester- 135,000 British residents dying every year due to an underfunded NHS, but you want to send money abroad because other governments are also letting their people die?

Any government’s first duty is to all the people living in their country before sending money to other countries. I am saying people living here because a significant % are not British that are living here. Immigrants have come here as have refugees trusting that we would fulfill our commitment to them that they work, pay an NHS surcharge, pay taxes and they’d get life saving healthcare.

We aren’t meeting our commitments here, so why should anyone expect us to also meet commitments made to people overseas in such circumstances? the U.K. is not rich, it is barely scraping by. Let others who are far wealthier take a turn helping those countries.

Market1 · 02/08/2023 18:18

We are one world!

Why don't people get that?

When you drive a car unnecessarily, when you throw away plastic unnecessarily, when you turn on the central heating or air con, when you buy throw away fashion, you are destroying lives all around the world.

When scientists scan the sky at night, when they pool their resources and observations every morning, when they cross check each others data and conclusions, they are protecting us all.

Meteorites hit the Earth. Small ones constantly, large ones occasionally.

Why does the fact that India is punching so far above it's weight in its contribution to planetary defence, mean we don't contribute to offsetting some of the damage we do to it's climate?

OP posts:
Market1 · 02/08/2023 18:14

CoffeeCantata · 02/08/2023 18:00

Oliotya
But you need to ask yourself whythere are so many corrupt governments. Many exist purely becauseweparaded around the world dismantling existing power structures, taking everything we could before pissing off with little care for what we left behind. How rich, or not, we are now has little to do with our responsibility to repair this damage.

No, I don't accept this. The British had an empire as did most other developed European countries, and other non-European countries at various times. As governors the Brits did good things as well as bad (they stopped suttee in India for a start). I'm not defending imperialism - just pointing out that nearly every country has done it AND had slaves and often ruled more cruelly. The Belgian empire was appallingly cruel.

But the para above is a perfect example of why I stopped reading the Guardian. Whatever was wrong in the world, I soon learned to skip to the final para of any Guardian article and sure enough, I'd be told that the Brits (and especially middle-class Brits) were actually to blame. In fact, pretty much everything that goes wrong in former colonies is Britain's fault, apparently. I was even told by someone that Britain was to blame for the Rwandan genocides!

Not only is this attitude wrong but it's incredibly patronising - suggesting, as it does, that (for eg) African countries are helpless and have no agency since they became independent. Some of them have been independent for 80+ years. Time to stop blaming the old colonial power, I would have thought.

And it's quite right that no more financial aid should go to India. It has a space programme, for God's sake!

Here we go again! The Indian space programme! The best, most efficient, most economical in the world - we need planetary defence! We need to be monitoring and predicting near earth objects, and we need to be able to respond to them if they threaten us! The world needs the Indian space programme - we all benefit from it in added security.

This is where the dinosaurs went wrong- they didn't allow India to develop a space programme!

OP posts:
Nordicrainagainagain · 02/08/2023 18:08

Dotjones · 02/08/2023 14:11

Foreign aid should be scrapped entirely, at least until the country is debt-free and we have world-leading services here.

It's not that foreign deaths don't matter, it's just that it's not our responsibility to deal with it. We used to have appalling childbirth death rates, but as a country we decided to do something about it. It didn't happen overnight, it required effort through several generations.

Those abroad who are not satisfied with the services available in their country, or their government, need to do what we did - work to improve things. Accept that change doesn't happen overnight, it will take a few generations at least.

But above all, we need to stop thinking that we are somehow responsible for everyone else. Foreign aid is inherently racist, it is given from the point of view that we are better than them.

so many eyerolls on this🙄

We just are so superior, hardworking and clever that we decided to sort ourselves out, while those idiot countries are just too stupid/ lazy etc to stop dying all over the place. Nothing at all to do with the historical context of how those countries came about and the role that imperialism played in it.

And then the little racism reversal twist at the end.

10/10 for bigoted post. [slow clap]

Begsthequestion · 02/08/2023 18:03

CoffeeCantata · 02/08/2023 18:00

Oliotya
But you need to ask yourself whythere are so many corrupt governments. Many exist purely becauseweparaded around the world dismantling existing power structures, taking everything we could before pissing off with little care for what we left behind. How rich, or not, we are now has little to do with our responsibility to repair this damage.

No, I don't accept this. The British had an empire as did most other developed European countries, and other non-European countries at various times. As governors the Brits did good things as well as bad (they stopped suttee in India for a start). I'm not defending imperialism - just pointing out that nearly every country has done it AND had slaves and often ruled more cruelly. The Belgian empire was appallingly cruel.

But the para above is a perfect example of why I stopped reading the Guardian. Whatever was wrong in the world, I soon learned to skip to the final para of any Guardian article and sure enough, I'd be told that the Brits (and especially middle-class Brits) were actually to blame. In fact, pretty much everything that goes wrong in former colonies is Britain's fault, apparently. I was even told by someone that Britain was to blame for the Rwandan genocides!

Not only is this attitude wrong but it's incredibly patronising - suggesting, as it does, that (for eg) African countries are helpless and have no agency since they became independent. Some of them have been independent for 80+ years. Time to stop blaming the old colonial power, I would have thought.

And it's quite right that no more financial aid should go to India. It has a space programme, for God's sake!

Have you read much about the origins of the Rwandan genocide? Or colonialism in general?

I ask because the British education system firmly refuses to teach much of anything about these things until university level, so many people don't know about it, unless they go out of their way to educate themselves.

CoffeeCantata · 02/08/2023 18:00

Oliotya
But you need to ask yourself whythere are so many corrupt governments. Many exist purely becauseweparaded around the world dismantling existing power structures, taking everything we could before pissing off with little care for what we left behind. How rich, or not, we are now has little to do with our responsibility to repair this damage.

No, I don't accept this. The British had an empire as did most other developed European countries, and other non-European countries at various times. As governors the Brits did good things as well as bad (they stopped suttee in India for a start). I'm not defending imperialism - just pointing out that nearly every country has done it AND had slaves and often ruled more cruelly. The Belgian empire was appallingly cruel.

But the para above is a perfect example of why I stopped reading the Guardian. Whatever was wrong in the world, I soon learned to skip to the final para of any Guardian article and sure enough, I'd be told that the Brits (and especially middle-class Brits) were actually to blame. In fact, pretty much everything that goes wrong in former colonies is Britain's fault, apparently. I was even told by someone that Britain was to blame for the Rwandan genocides!

Not only is this attitude wrong but it's incredibly patronising - suggesting, as it does, that (for eg) African countries are helpless and have no agency since they became independent. Some of them have been independent for 80+ years. Time to stop blaming the old colonial power, I would have thought.

And it's quite right that no more financial aid should go to India. It has a space programme, for God's sake!

Market1 · 02/08/2023 17:56

MakeMeShine · 02/08/2023 17:54

Oh don’t be silly. We can’t and shouldn’t try to help everyone. It is what it is.

Our money should be for our country. It’s that simple.

what is silly?

Thousands of women will die because of this decision.

Real human woman, not just abstract numbers on some political balance sheet

Are you OK with that? reallY??

OP posts:
MakeMeShine · 02/08/2023 17:54

Market1 · 02/08/2023 17:42

It is the difference between life and death to individual women, I don't suppose you would call it a !drop in the ocean" if it saved your life in child birth, or saved your baby

Oh don’t be silly. We can’t and shouldn’t try to help everyone. It is what it is.

Our money should be for our country. It’s that simple.

LlynTegid · 02/08/2023 17:53

There are many things I disagreed with the coalition government about, but one thing I did agree with them on was the overseas aid commitment. Which should have been retained and be something with cross-party agreement.

I know Mr Johnson cares not about women unless he can have a relationship with them. You would have thought though he'd care about safe abortion given one of the women he has had a relationship with has acknowledged having one.

And I would have hoped Mr Sunak would end the cruel decision to reduce the overseas aid budget.

Begsthequestion · 02/08/2023 17:48

FFSDILIGAF · 02/08/2023 17:29

I will support any party that pledges to cut foreign aid to zero. Our country is a mess. Our social care is a mess. We have people here living in extreme poverty.

A line needs to be drawn

What policies do you support to fix the problems you mention in social care and with extreme poverty?

FFSDILIGAF · 02/08/2023 17:44

Market1 · 02/08/2023 17:39

we have people in poverty, but extreme poverty is very rare, everybody has food, everybody has access to flushing toilets....

I cant decide if you are naive or not quite all there. Go and walk our cities streets or visit our housing offices up and down the country. Temporary accommodation if full to bursting. Rough sleeper teams are run off their feet. They dont ALL have access to food or clean water

Market1 · 02/08/2023 17:42

MakeMeShine · 02/08/2023 17:32

YABU. We can’t and shouldn’t be trying to pay for other countries when we have problems here.

Anything we give elsewhere is a waste anyway as it’s a drop in the ocean that doesn’t fix their massive problems.

It is the difference between life and death to individual women, I don't suppose you would call it a !drop in the ocean" if it saved your life in child birth, or saved your baby

OP posts:
Market1 · 02/08/2023 17:39

FFSDILIGAF · 02/08/2023 17:29

I will support any party that pledges to cut foreign aid to zero. Our country is a mess. Our social care is a mess. We have people here living in extreme poverty.

A line needs to be drawn

we have people in poverty, but extreme poverty is very rare, everybody has food, everybody has access to flushing toilets....

OP posts:
MakeMeShine · 02/08/2023 17:32

YABU. We can’t and shouldn’t be trying to pay for other countries when we have problems here.

Anything we give elsewhere is a waste anyway as it’s a drop in the ocean that doesn’t fix their massive problems.

Donotshushme · 02/08/2023 17:30

Market1 · 02/08/2023 14:11

well the cost of free school meals could be halved for a start, by giving half of the current spend directly to parents to shop with, rather than to schools, who spend almost all of it on the staff that prepare it, and very little on the food.

By pass the cost of the staff that buy, prepare and serve the food, let parents do that, and you get ten times the nutritional value for half the cost

You do understand that there are some children whose parents do not spend their money on food for them?

Which is why free school meals should be protected. It guarantees every school attending child at least one decent meal in a school day.

FFSDILIGAF · 02/08/2023 17:29

I will support any party that pledges to cut foreign aid to zero. Our country is a mess. Our social care is a mess. We have people here living in extreme poverty.

A line needs to be drawn

Swipe left for the next trending thread