Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Its fine to save money letting women die in child birth this year, as long as we are going to spend money preventing other women die in child birth in other years.

111 replies

Market1 · 02/08/2023 13:46

( second posting, as first one vanished...)

We have been culpable in contributing to horrendous poverty and conflict in so many areas of the globe, through political interference in the past, and climate damage now, so it is right and proper that we think long and hard about supporting pregnant women abroad in the future, and as long as we promise to continue thinking long and hard, it is fine for a few thousand to die in child birth while we think, after all, they are a long way away, and their English isn't very good.

And if they don't fancy their chances of survival in their home countries, there is always an easy road and a warm welcome waiting for them here! And a mere quarter of a million unsafe abortions? That is nothing to concern ourselves about.

YANBU - it is fine, we need to save money, and a few thousand deaths in childbirth is nothing in the grand scheme of things
YABU - we should support these women through overseas aid today, even if their English isn't very good....

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-66378364

An Army paramedic holds a baby during evacuation of British nationals in Sudan

UK foreign aid cuts: Thousands will die as a result, says report

Women will face unsafe abortions, and thousands will not get healthcare, ministers are warned.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-66378364

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
5
CoffeeCantata · 03/08/2023 15:28

Olio
If I smash up your bike, give it back to you then ask why your bike is so slow. That like what we did. Gave the bike back, what's the problem?
I'm not saying we are responsible for everything, or should be trying to fix everything but I think it's despicable to bow out completely.

I don't accept the analogy at all.

As I said, I'm no apologist for imperialism but come on! The ex-colonies do have railways and infrastructure both concrete and abstract (in the form of admin, medical and educational institutions etc) which came as a result of the Empire. We didn't go in and bash up their bikes - often they didn't have bikes in the first place.

Imperialism is a stage in capitalism, or just economic development - nearly every powerful and successful country in history is guilty of it. Not nice, but it's a very long time since some of the colonies got independence and to keep blaming the UK for their ills is sounding very hollow now.

TheSnootiestFox · 03/08/2023 13:53

Market1 · 02/08/2023 17:39

we have people in poverty, but extreme poverty is very rare, everybody has food, everybody has access to flushing toilets....

That's not actually true. I'm another that supports cutting foreign aid to zero until the UK is in a much better position economically.

millymollymoomoo · 03/08/2023 13:34

Personally think foreign aid cuts don’t go anywhere near enough thanks

RudsyFarmer · 03/08/2023 13:00

We can’t even afford to pay our bloody debts in this country. Have you looked around? Everything is falling apart and what’s left is held together by threads. Those who are wealthy are abandoning ship and leaving to live elsewhere. I think you need to hold the begging bowl out to someone else. What country is doing well currently? Anyone know?

BillaBongGirl · 03/08/2023 12:54

NewNovember · 03/08/2023 12:48

Also where did you get six from I said a family of one adult and four children. Two primary age children would eat the same as a man so assuming a single mum with children age 4,6,8, 12 for example then £80 is a very normal budget.

Sorry missed the single parent bit.

BillaBongGirl · 03/08/2023 12:54

NewNovember · 03/08/2023 12:46

I know the cost to the school is not £15 a week but the cost for non fsm kids is £3 a day. And yes you can feed a family on £80 you are not living in the real world if you don't realise that is a very normal budget.

You didn’t say it like you knew because your rationale for the schools wasting money was the fact the voucher is £15 and “once economies of scale” are applied that covers more than 5 lunches. This rationale would only work if you think that the schools spend £15 for 5 lunches - when they do not spend nearly that much. They also have access to much greater economies of scale than does a single family, so that £15 would go further if it were applied to lunches made in school.

I do live “in the real world”. I just paid my DD’s grocery shop for the week at Lidl and it was £29 for just her, a young adult who cooks from scratch and does things like roasts a whole chicken because it’s cheaper than buying two packs chicken breasts, and grates broccoli stems to add to rice. You thinking one can still feed two adults and four children on £80/week is sadly out of date.

NewNovember · 03/08/2023 12:48

BillaBongGirl · 03/08/2023 12:19

Due to the cost of living crisis, I don’t believe that even shopping at Lidl or Aldi will feed a family of six on only £80 a week!

Also, you are making a rookie error by assuming that the £15/week per child voucher = the cost to the schools to feed a child per week. Hint, it doesn’t. They set the voucher amount completely independently from what they’d spend internally.

Also where did you get six from I said a family of one adult and four children. Two primary age children would eat the same as a man so assuming a single mum with children age 4,6,8, 12 for example then £80 is a very normal budget.

NewNovember · 03/08/2023 12:46

BillaBongGirl · 03/08/2023 12:19

Due to the cost of living crisis, I don’t believe that even shopping at Lidl or Aldi will feed a family of six on only £80 a week!

Also, you are making a rookie error by assuming that the £15/week per child voucher = the cost to the schools to feed a child per week. Hint, it doesn’t. They set the voucher amount completely independently from what they’d spend internally.

I know the cost to the school is not £15 a week but the cost for non fsm kids is £3 a day. And yes you can feed a family on £80 you are not living in the real world if you don't realise that is a very normal budget.

BillaBongGirl · 03/08/2023 12:19

NewNovember · 03/08/2023 11:33

The £15 vouchers given to cover lunches per week are enough to cover every meal once economies of scale are applied. Take single parent family with 4 children that £60 plus £20 from the household budget ( for parent) gives £80 which will cover a weeks full of three meals a day.
Shows how badly the budget is managed in schools.

Due to the cost of living crisis, I don’t believe that even shopping at Lidl or Aldi will feed a family of six on only £80 a week!

Also, you are making a rookie error by assuming that the £15/week per child voucher = the cost to the schools to feed a child per week. Hint, it doesn’t. They set the voucher amount completely independently from what they’d spend internally.

NewNovember · 03/08/2023 11:33

BillaBongGirl · 02/08/2023 14:15

Who told you this cock and bull story?
Dinner staff cost the same whether they are making 200 school dinners or 100 school dinners. The FSM funds go to buying and making more food. The cost of the staff is zero extra.

The £15 vouchers given to cover lunches per week are enough to cover every meal once economies of scale are applied. Take single parent family with 4 children that £60 plus £20 from the household budget ( for parent) gives £80 which will cover a weeks full of three meals a day.
Shows how badly the budget is managed in schools.

Yusay · 03/08/2023 11:30

AmadeustheAlpaca · 02/08/2023 14:06

There isn’t enough publicity about FGM in African countries and the appalling history of how women have been treated in the past. It still exists to this day and even in Britain girls are still sent back to a country where this takes place for “a family visit”. White colonialists are always being criticised for taking over parts of Africa but they were the ones who first publicised the horrific abuse of young girls in the name of a culture.
I am sick and tired about hearing how bad Britain is as a nation. We are nowhere near perfect but we are better than a lot of other countries

This. We also stopped wife burning in India, and were the first country to ban slavery. Britain has done a huge amount for the world.

We can’t fund the world’s healthcare.

(We should also stop taxpayer funded sex changes and other surgery that isn’t medically necessary 🤢)

bigageap · 03/08/2023 11:28

Market1 · 02/08/2023 14:11

well the cost of free school meals could be halved for a start, by giving half of the current spend directly to parents to shop with, rather than to schools, who spend almost all of it on the staff that prepare it, and very little on the food.

By pass the cost of the staff that buy, prepare and serve the food, let parents do that, and you get ten times the nutritional value for half the cost

As much as that seems like a wonderful idea at least when the funding is given to schools directly the children are actually receiving a meal. That cannot be guaranteed if it’s given to the parents/guardians directly.

BillaBongGirl · 03/08/2023 11:23

The Indian space programme! The best, most efficient, most economical in the world - we need planetary defence! We need to be monitoring and predicting near earth objects, and we need to be able to respond to them if they threaten us! The world needs the Indian space programme - we all benefit from it in added security.

Im sorry but these organisations in the USA called NASA and US Space Force, already have this covered. Its not really needed for India to do it too.

BillaBongGirl · 03/08/2023 11:19

CloudyMcCloud · 02/08/2023 18:35

Thanks for facts. Some of these posts are a bit what posters imagine is the case.

You’re very welcome.

BillaBongGirl · 03/08/2023 11:18

@Iamgoingtohell
6th richest yet we see a massive rise in food bank use by people who are in work.

Lol, U.K. hasn’t been that high up the rich list in ages. We are currently #18

Its fine to save money letting women die in child birth this year, as long as we are going to spend money preventing other women die in child birth in other years.
Olderandolder · 03/08/2023 08:02

Lockdown was racist.

Few said anything about our destroying the economies and food chains of poorer countries.

BBC probably manipulating us to stop complaining about the cost of living crisis they caused by pointing out that others suffer more.

CoffeeCantata · 03/08/2023 07:54

Bugs
Have you read much about the origins of the Rwandan genocide? Or colonialism in general?

Er..yes...and I remember it well. I read about it comprehensively in the press and BBC news reports and 'From Our Own Correspondent' with eye-witness accounts (horrific - they've never left me) and much more over the years. And you? You must be very knowledgeable from the tone of your post!

Rwanda was a German and Belgian colony. Just saying...

Chocolatefreak · 03/08/2023 07:24

The amount we give in aid is a pittance compared to what we make as a country from exploitation of labour and resources overseas. We take advantage of corrupt leadership and weak governance in order to do this, without recognising that our own actions are just as, if not more, corrupt.

We launder the profits, tax it inappropriately or not at all and bank it according to our rules.

Then we criticise other countries for not sorting out their economies and societies.

We also actively punish those who try to leave their desperate lives to seek better ones in countries like ours, who are rich because of them.

cloudydays97 · 03/08/2023 06:41

Market1 · 02/08/2023 18:18

We are one world!

Why don't people get that?

When you drive a car unnecessarily, when you throw away plastic unnecessarily, when you turn on the central heating or air con, when you buy throw away fashion, you are destroying lives all around the world.

When scientists scan the sky at night, when they pool their resources and observations every morning, when they cross check each others data and conclusions, they are protecting us all.

Meteorites hit the Earth. Small ones constantly, large ones occasionally.

Why does the fact that India is punching so far above it's weight in its contribution to planetary defence, mean we don't contribute to offsetting some of the damage we do to it's climate?

Because it's beyond ridiculous to try to shame people for the impact of putting on the central heating as if that is going to have the same impact as space exploration. Of course it's relevant that a country receiving aid from the U.K. chooses to spend what little money it has on space not its people.

cloudydays97 · 03/08/2023 06:38

I've got issues with the fact it's been reported in the telegraph that over £33 million has been sent to India, a country developing its own space program. I think this is just the tip of iceberg of problems with foreign aid. I don't think we should just keep giving blindly and not question who's using it

Oliotya · 03/08/2023 06:36

underneaththeash · 02/08/2023 22:57

The main issue is that most of the money we give is syphoned off.
It doesn't actually go to the people who need it.

Keep it here. improve our economy, there is a huge amount of giving here and charitable organisations are often able to keep better track of the money than governments.

Doesn't go to people who need it here either though does it

Oliotya · 03/08/2023 06:33

CoffeeCantata · 02/08/2023 18:00

Oliotya
But you need to ask yourself whythere are so many corrupt governments. Many exist purely becauseweparaded around the world dismantling existing power structures, taking everything we could before pissing off with little care for what we left behind. How rich, or not, we are now has little to do with our responsibility to repair this damage.

No, I don't accept this. The British had an empire as did most other developed European countries, and other non-European countries at various times. As governors the Brits did good things as well as bad (they stopped suttee in India for a start). I'm not defending imperialism - just pointing out that nearly every country has done it AND had slaves and often ruled more cruelly. The Belgian empire was appallingly cruel.

But the para above is a perfect example of why I stopped reading the Guardian. Whatever was wrong in the world, I soon learned to skip to the final para of any Guardian article and sure enough, I'd be told that the Brits (and especially middle-class Brits) were actually to blame. In fact, pretty much everything that goes wrong in former colonies is Britain's fault, apparently. I was even told by someone that Britain was to blame for the Rwandan genocides!

Not only is this attitude wrong but it's incredibly patronising - suggesting, as it does, that (for eg) African countries are helpless and have no agency since they became independent. Some of them have been independent for 80+ years. Time to stop blaming the old colonial power, I would have thought.

And it's quite right that no more financial aid should go to India. It has a space programme, for God's sake!

I don't read the guardian either. My opinions are based firmly on what I have heard and seen.
If I smash up your bike, give it back to you then ask why your bike is so slow. That like what we did. Gave the bike back, what's the problem?
I'm not saying we are responsible for everything, or should be trying to fix everything but I think it's despicable to bow out completely.

underneaththeash · 02/08/2023 22:57

The main issue is that most of the money we give is syphoned off.
It doesn't actually go to the people who need it.

Keep it here. improve our economy, there is a huge amount of giving here and charitable organisations are often able to keep better track of the money than governments.

AuntieJune · 02/08/2023 22:52

Iamgoingtohell · 02/08/2023 16:15

And you’re absolutely able to have that opinion. 6th richest yet we see a massive rise in food bank use by people who are in work. I would rather see those people given more assistance than worry about other countries. I would agree that any savings need to be spent on NHS.
Like I said, my nation is a priority for myself, I do get that others will be outraged by the cut it’s just I am not one of them.

It's not really either/or though is it? This is like the 'we send £250m a week to the EU, let's find our nhs instead'.

People relying on food banks is wrong, they should be paid a decent wage.

I don't see how that relates to us giving aid to people n desperate situations. Doing so benefits our international reputation.

The reason poor people in this country don't get enough money is because Tories hold them in control, not because we find vaccination and food aid programs in a few countries around the world.

Yellowdays · 02/08/2023 21:23

Oh, and shit loads of money to the numerous ex Prime Ministers we seem to be producing, plus all the cash for the trillions of extra House of Lords takers.