Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"Therapy" is no better than a natter with a friend or a placebo.

313 replies

Market1 · 02/08/2023 09:19

I am starting this thread to see what people think of therapy. I am personally convinced it is at least 80% useless - I am not saying completely useless, as I am sure talking about a problem makes you feel better, although you can talk things through with your pet rabbit - I used to as a teen! There is also some value in learning some techniques such as CBT, but that can be learnt from a book, so again, not sure of the value of an actual therapist.

I've come to this conclusion through two main sources, children and holocaust survivors.

I have known thousands of children through teaching, and fostering, and many many of them have seen therapists. My main observation is that huge expectations are placed on therapy as some sort of magic bullet that is going to cure all problems, but the result is inevitably disappointment, as nothing changes. Parents, and children too are left wondering what magic was supposed to have happened, and why it didn't. One fostering social worker once mentioned to me that she thought it was a complete waste of time after the age of 8, and I think she was right. Between the ages of 5 and 8, you can possibly use therapy to teach children a bit about the emotions they are feeling, which can help them understand themselves, but beyond that there seems to be no benefit

My other source is coming from a family of holocaust survivors, who never had therapy, and survived by not talking about hte past - Many went on to have long, happy, successful lives, married and raised families, ( including me!) . They did not discuss the past, and I was told not to ask questions. They were not totally without problems. I was aware of the occasional nightmare, and several of them were binge eaters who became obese in old age. However, they lived with this problems quite happily, and there was no talk or expectation of "therapy" of any kind to address them

So I have started this thread to see what others think. Maybe I am wrong - I am open to being told that I am wrong in this. My experiences have not given me any confidence in arranging for therapy for any child, or suggesting it for any adult, but please tell me if it is really in fact a wonder drug and I have missed the point somehow!

I should say I have been sent for therapy twice myself - once after being in a road accident in which my closest school friend died, ( aged 16)it was awful, made me cry every time, I felt so much better when I was allowed to stop, and once sent by my employer after I was knifed ( quite gently!) by a student at school - I was taught some useful CBT, but in my opinion a book would have been more helpful than a difficult journey to speak to someone who was basically going very slowly through what I could have read for myself in half the time without the train journey.

so:

YABU - therapy is helpful - and please explain how!
YANBU - therapy is a waste of time /a money maker/ sending someone for therapy or providing it is just a way of letting someone feel they are doing something useful, when they are not

OP posts:
Market1 · 02/08/2023 10:43

Siouxiesiouxiesioux · 02/08/2023 10:21

As someone who suffered from it, I would say that binge eating is a serious mental illness which requires therapeutic treatment of some kind. As I said up the thread once you have it under control you have to deal with the underlying issues, which can be very difficult. The fact that many of your relatives were binge eaters may indicate that they were living with a lot of unresolved pain. pain. Therapy helps to release that.

people often feel worse during therapy because the feelings they have been repressing and numbing out start to surface and can feel excruciating but soon you start to see them in perspective. The trauma is in the past. You will never forget it but you can live with it for the most part.

but the binge eating wasn't particularly troubling them. I am a binge eater too, and I put that down to being raised by binge eaters. It doesn't trouble me much either - definitely no "unresolved pain"

OP posts:
CattyCattle · 02/08/2023 10:42

WildUnchartedWaters · 02/08/2023 10:33

Shes not being aggressive at all. If someone starts a thread criticising something which has really helped her, shes entitled to her opinions, which she expressed really well.

She's picked me out of the thread when I've discussed my own childhood and how therapy didn't help me to comment how well it helped her. Other posters also spoke about penny dropping moments etc but not personally tagged me.

I made a generic post again explaining my position and then received an agressive response about how I've accused her of blaming her parents. I did not. There was no need to tag me and make out like I did.

KnackeredAF · 02/08/2023 10:42

I think it’s situation dependent.

If you’re going through a brief, tough life event and need support and guidance then a friend can be a helpful ear.

If you have chronic trauma/major trauma/a whole host of things going on in your life, sometimes it isn’t fair to burden your friends with those issues and they don’t necessarily come equipped with the tools to help you through them. They can support you, sure, but I don’t know that they can always be the ones to provide the way out.

Examples: (n=1)
At uni I had a friends with benefits situation that turned out terribly, destroying some of my other major friendships. I needed a lot of hand holding from other friends, who were able to provide this.

I also have a mother with MS who was diagnosed when I was 1. She has a lot of unpleasant personality traits and my childhood wasn’t great as a result. Our relationship is now fine(ish), but not that of a typical mother and daughter. My friends can’t relate, as they haven’t been through this, and other than saying “that sounds hard” they can’t help me work out how I feel about this.

WildUnchartedWaters · 02/08/2023 10:42

The thing is, all of these but 50s years ago folk just got on with it so we all should (you might want to take a look at the suicide rate for males) or my friends aunties granny or the one counsellor up this thread who wasnt nice to her family xnone of that helps.

Its whether it works for them.

You might think it's pointless m, and what a blessed position to be in, but you dont need to go.

KeepYaHeadUp · 02/08/2023 10:41

No way - CBT has been literally life changing for me. It wasn't about needing a stranger to listen to me, it was the insight that stranger was then able to offer and how he changed my thought patterns. Empowered me

WimbledonHasselhoff · 02/08/2023 10:41

user1477391263 · 02/08/2023 09:39

Depends what kind of therapy. Most psychoanalytic therapy is waffle and a waste of time IMO. The people who are “into” it never actually seem to get any better.

Cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) is, as I understand, the only form of therapy that is actually evidence-based, with data showing that it really does work to a significant extent. However, over the past couple of decades, the data suggests that even CBT is gradually becoming less effective, probably because it is becoming contaminated with the kind of identify politics and vague prattle that characterize other kinds of therapy.

CBT has a larger evidence base because the style of therapy lends itself to being studied in that way. If you're trying to study the effectiveness of a therapy, you have to try to standardise everything as much as possible to avoid bringing extra variables into the study that would influence the results. You also have to work out how to measure the outcome in a standardised way so you can measure how much it has "worked". With a therapy like CBT that is very structured, this is much easier to do. With something where people are exploring their past, working out meaning, how things have affected them, working out how to build a better life going forward - it's much harder to fit into a standard model for scientific study.

CBT is also relatively cheap to deliver. So they rolled it out everywhere as a fix for everything. Which it is not. And as it is applied to more situations, it's becoming more apparent what it's limitations are, hence apparently being less effective.

Saschka · 02/08/2023 10:39

TeenLifeMum · 02/08/2023 09:40

I tried it after being rapped and found it made me feel awful - sharing my private feelings with someone who is only there because they’re paid to be didn’t make me feel supported or loved.

i think talking stuff through is hugely beneficial in processing but it ideally needs to be with someone who loves you and you can trust. I know there’s people who don’t have that so I guess counsellors have a role but I don’t think it’s a magic answer. I’m not sure tablets always are either.

So, I had trauma therapy for PTSD after a rape, and found it very helpful.

I started therapy about a year after the rape, after the court case, when I still wasn’t feeling any better. I cried on the way to my first appointment, and all the way through my first assessments, because I was so upset by talking about it. I was having trouble leaving the house due to intrusive PTSD symptoms and fear of being raped again.

12 weeks later and my symptoms were gone, I was off antidepressants and back at college, and I was able to visit the site where I was raped. I would never have believed that would have been possible 3 months earlier.

I didn’t go to feel supported or loved - I already felt supported and loved by my family, and that wasn’t enough to treat the PTSD.

MattBerrysHair · 02/08/2023 10:38

YABU

I've had a lot of different kinds of therapy: ACT, CBT, DBT, psychoanalysis etc. Without it I'd be dead, or perpetuating the generational cycle of abuse that has been present in my family for eons.

Some people, like myself, process their emotions as they're talking, and I really don't want to be burdening my friends with much of the trauma I've experienced. It's too personal and too many negative emotions, such as shame and guilt, were attached to those events. Being in a safe, non-judgemental talking space was the only way I was able to recognise how and why my childhood experiences dictated my thought patterns, unhealthy boundaries, and emotional responses. Locking them away would have meant guaranteed continued suffering. Once that was done I was able to create a new story about myself, one where I was no longer a passive victim, but a survivor with agency, healthy boundaries, and positive coping mechanisms. It's hard work, and those old habits do rear their ugly heads at times, but I've got the self-knowledge and tools to recognise it and distance myself from them in order to create space for the new coping skills to be implemented.

Abra1t · 02/08/2023 10:38

Market1 · 02/08/2023 09:47

I am not saying holocaust were "cured" - I am saying they chose to cope with the past by not talking about it, which was normal then, and seemed to work very well, better than I have seen therapy work. I know very few details, but what I do know is horrific beyond words, so I am amazed, looking back, that they all went on to have happy lives, and it was without any "therapy", which has always made me think, what is the point of therapy, if it is to get you to the stage of living a normal happy life, when that seems to happen best without therapy

i wonder if there’s something about being Jewish that helps in situations that seem almost unbearably hard to recover from? Being part of a community? Having centuries-old systems of support that could survive even the holocaust l? Not all Jewish people are observant and branches of Judaism operate very differently, of course. But perhaps survivors could draw on a collective wisdom, a sense of being part of something larger.

By contrast, my elderly parent remembers growing up in Australia when survivors of the Japanese POW camps returned home. There was a lot of alcoholism and domestic violence. Nobody talked about what had happened to them while they underwent the years of abuse and questions were discouraged. Clearly these men needed some kind of support before and during reentry.

Escapingafter50years · 02/08/2023 10:37

I'm in therapy for life-long emotional neglect and narcissistic abuse. I was "coping" all my life, on the outside I probably seem like a very capable person. On the inside I felt like I was the person who mattered least in the world.

Due to my "mother" finally saying something so horrible to me that I went to therapy, I have finally realised that it wasn't me. I almost subconsciously felt I was wrong, there was some reason I couldn't get things right. Now I know that no matter what I do, in her eyes it isn't enough. She is a very damaged person but that doesn't give her the right to abuse me. She used to tell me she loved me but her behaviour said otherwise, but I believed her words. Now I know that although I can have sympathy for the damage that was done to her, I do not have to accept her behaviour (or abusive behaviour from anyone). I asked her, gently, to get help but she refused and blamed me. I haven't seen her in 2 years and am ok with that. I've had flying monkeys try to get me to "forgive", i.e. ignore her behaviour which she has not apologised for and will not change; she has lied to everyone about what happened. My eyes are now fully open and I am putting me first.

Without therapy I probably still would be being abused by her and the effects on my family would continue. I am devastated that I allowed her abuse for so long, that is the next stage in my therapy, to help me come to terms with that.

DaisyDaisyDaisyDaisyDaisyDaisy · 02/08/2023 10:36

@CattyCattle I responded to you because you said 'I too have had those penny dropping moments' which is a phrase I had used, so presumed that something I had said had struck a chord with you. Guess that's how it started. We both have had different experiences from therapy and taken different things away from it. I certainly had no intention of being aggressive. Apologies if it came across that way.

Eyeapple · 02/08/2023 10:35

The example of Holocaust survivors is interesting but that's also a different generation. People were generally more resilient and just got on with it. I know someone who survived a Serbian concentration camp and they get on with life absolutely fine but there are triggers that can massively affect them.

I actually think a part of the reason that people recovered from the holocaust is a lot to do with the very strong identity and community that was formed among survivors. People heal in community and I actually think that the Jewish people particularly created incredibly strong communities as a result of their albeit as negative an experience as any ever in history. For example I don’t believe the Russians have recovered as well from their own death camp traumas and that is still being experienced as trauma now and is playing out in lots of ways in Ukraine.

WildUnchartedWaters · 02/08/2023 10:34

girlfriend44 · 02/08/2023 10:32

Therapy draws you back into your pain and you keep discussing it. you wont ever change what happened. Go out there and live your best life while your alive, sing, dance and do other things you enjoy.

Life is short and in 100 years time none of it will matter, we will all be dead.
My friends husband died she was offered grief councelling. She turned it down and said whats the point, just sitting there talking about it. He has gone and i have to accept it and enjoy life, and she has done just that.

Of course shes still sad and misses him, but she didnt see how any counselling would help.

Your constantly being drawn back into your pain and revisiting what the pain.

Would you say to someone with a physical illness to get out and sing and dance and all will be fine cause theyl die soon anyway?

WildUnchartedWaters · 02/08/2023 10:33

CattyCattle · 02/08/2023 10:26

@DaisyDaisyDaisyDaisyDaisyDaisy I wasn't talking specifically to you. Please don't get aggressive with me for sharing my personal thoughts on therapy and why to the OP. If you feel you have made the right decision for you then good for you but no need to get defensive and pick on me when I wasn't speaking to you directly.

Shes not being aggressive at all. If someone starts a thread criticising something which has really helped her, shes entitled to her opinions, which she expressed really well.

honeylulu · 02/08/2023 10:33

Interesting. I would say it depends. I had counselling sessions (does that count as therapy? ) in my uni days for an eating disorder and then again when older following a late pregnancy loss. I didn't find either helpful. The ED counsellor seemed bored and irritated and I got nowhere, I felt more and more self conscious. The pregnancy loss counsellor was lovely but after a couple of sessions where it was nice to feel listened to (my husband had shut down and didn't want to talk about it) it wasn't getting me any further. A self help group for people who'd experienced similar was much more helpful.

Then lastly I was offered six free sessions of therapy by someone doing a PHD. The issues I wanted to explore were bad habits/ self destructive behaviours I couldn't shake off and didn't understand. I thought my issues were mainly stress related in the "present day" (high pressure job, young children etc) but she insisted we go right back into my childhood which I resisted at first but bloody hell a lot of the answers were there. It gave me a lot of peace and self forgiveness such has been amazing. The sessions stopped abruptly because there were only ever going to be six. I felt at a bit of a loss at first but I continued making progress by myself as I was on the right track. Hugely valuable experience and really illuminating.

girlfriend44 · 02/08/2023 10:32

Therapy draws you back into your pain and you keep discussing it. you wont ever change what happened. Go out there and live your best life while your alive, sing, dance and do other things you enjoy.

Life is short and in 100 years time none of it will matter, we will all be dead.
My friends husband died she was offered grief councelling. She turned it down and said whats the point, just sitting there talking about it. He has gone and i have to accept it and enjoy life, and she has done just that.

Of course shes still sad and misses him, but she didnt see how any counselling would help.

Your constantly being drawn back into your pain and revisiting what the pain.

Mamai90 · 02/08/2023 10:31

It's definitely over rated. I know lots of people who have had some some of therapy and it's been useless. The only person it worked for was my sister but this wasn't any deep seated trauma it was from working in a high pressure NHS environment at the height of covid which caused her a lot of stress and anxiety.

I didn't answer because I think it can be beneficial but only occasionally.

OnBoardTheHeartOfGold · 02/08/2023 10:30

I think for mild to moderate anxiety, low mood and depression, good friends, exercise and good food and vitamin levels can help massively.

Trauma is something else. Helping children through trauma is hard and I think those who care for them should be involved too. Those children will probably need therapy for years. It's not a magic wand but it can help from things getting worse if no improvement is obvious.

The example of Holocaust survivors is interesting but that's also a different generation. People were generally more resilient and just got on with it. I know someone who survived a Serbian concentration camp and they get on with life absolutely fine but there are triggers that can massively affect them.
It's a different time now and the West has changed regarding mantas health.
Many countries still expect people to get on with life, and they do because there's no other choice if they want to live.

crapactually · 02/08/2023 10:30

Therapy takes many forms and serves many different purposes. I am going to assume counselling is being lumped in here too.

It could be talking and reflection.
Making sense of emotions/a diagnosis.
Processing trauma.
Learning strategies.
Exposure therapy for phobias.
Piecing together work.

Sometimes therapy doesn't go well, the relationship is not helpful and they need to try something else.

So yes OP absolutely wrong.

CattyCattle · 02/08/2023 10:26

@DaisyDaisyDaisyDaisyDaisyDaisy I wasn't talking specifically to you. Please don't get aggressive with me for sharing my personal thoughts on therapy and why to the OP. If you feel you have made the right decision for you then good for you but no need to get defensive and pick on me when I wasn't speaking to you directly.

WildUnchartedWaters · 02/08/2023 10:25

Summermeadowflowers · 02/08/2023 10:23

@Annaissleeping - I think one of the problems with therapy and the reason I am wary about it is because of this. I’m not suggesting for a moment everyone who works as a therapist or counsellor is some sort of ruthless Shylock, but I do think there are some comparisons with almost cult like behaviour which is problematic for me.

I see it on here so much ‘you need counselling / have you considered counselling’ with the assumption that it will work. No one ever mentions that just like cults, MLMs and pyramid schemes some people at the very top are getting extremely rich.

Counsellors charge but they have to have had counselling themselves, yes? And to pay to qualify? And to keep their registration ? Someone somewhere is making a lot of money from the counsellors, who obviously have to make a profit themselves because they have to live, and so it goes on.

And if it doesn’t work, it’s always down to the client not putting in the effort or being in the wrong place. There’s no acknowledgement that sometimes it just doesn’t work because it isn’t particularly effective.

A very narrow view.

DaisyDaisyDaisyDaisyDaisyDaisy · 02/08/2023 10:24

@CattyCattle where did I say I blamed my parents for my childhood trauma? My parents were themselves products of their own trauma. As I said, I understand myself ( and others to be honest) more than I ever would have done if I had not had therapy. I would have carried on with my misunderstandings of people, my micro aggressions and my complete bewilderment as to why I couldn't deal in any way shape or form with certain situations in life that other people seem to find an absolute doddle.

Ylvamoon · 02/08/2023 10:24

I firmly believe the aim of therapy/ counselling is to help you see aspects of your life as they are.

Sometimes you can change things and sometimes you can't. Whatever it is, it does define who you are but it doesn't need to run your life.

A good therapist will explore and help with the processing. A crap therapist will just let you wallow in self pity.

Summermeadowflowers · 02/08/2023 10:23

Annaissleeping · 02/08/2023 10:00

And there are a lot of therapists working for peanuts because their clients can't afford their full fees and they want to help people above all.

Plus however rubbish the NHS is, it does still deliver a lot of mental health support completely free. And many charities offer free therapy too.

@Annaissleeping - I think one of the problems with therapy and the reason I am wary about it is because of this. I’m not suggesting for a moment everyone who works as a therapist or counsellor is some sort of ruthless Shylock, but I do think there are some comparisons with almost cult like behaviour which is problematic for me.

I see it on here so much ‘you need counselling / have you considered counselling’ with the assumption that it will work. No one ever mentions that just like cults, MLMs and pyramid schemes some people at the very top are getting extremely rich.

Counsellors charge but they have to have had counselling themselves, yes? And to pay to qualify? And to keep their registration ? Someone somewhere is making a lot of money from the counsellors, who obviously have to make a profit themselves because they have to live, and so it goes on.

And if it doesn’t work, it’s always down to the client not putting in the effort or being in the wrong place. There’s no acknowledgement that sometimes it just doesn’t work because it isn’t particularly effective.

brokenlore · 02/08/2023 10:23

It massively depends on 1)what the therapy is for 2)the type of counselling on offer and 3) the therapist/ counsellor.
For example cognitive behaviour therapy can be very useful for health anxiety.
Solution focused therapy can be very useful for looking at career moves or getting back on your feet following a period of illness.
Grief counselling following a bereavement can help some people come to terms with the death of a loved one.
There are plenty of other types of counselling out there, and both cognitive behaviour therapy and solution focus therapy have great applications than the examples I've given.
Sometimes it's just talking to someone who won't try and 'fix' things like a friend or relative might, because sometimes just having a person to talk to who won't judge, or tell you what they think you want to hear can be useful, not everyone has a good circle of friends or has family to talk too.
But counselling doesn't work for everyone, sometimes the timing is not right, some times the type of therapy isn't right, or the therapist / counsellor is less useful than a chocolate teapot.
Unfortunately it's not a regulated business and anyone can set up as a counsellor.
I'm not a therapist/counsellor but use a lot of those skills in my job, and have done a number of training courses, part of the skill is knowing when it might be useful to suggest therapy (and refer on) or use my skills alongside my core training (hcp).
It's absolutely not a 'magic' cure, but then to be fair nor are any therapies (physio, speech, OT, dietetics, portage, etc etc) all have their limitations and outcomes will depend on the condition and motivation of the client/ patient and support available outside the therapy session.
A good therapist/counsellor should be very honest about the limitations of the service they can provide, and set realistic expectations at first contact.