Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"Therapy" is no better than a natter with a friend or a placebo.

313 replies

Market1 · 02/08/2023 09:19

I am starting this thread to see what people think of therapy. I am personally convinced it is at least 80% useless - I am not saying completely useless, as I am sure talking about a problem makes you feel better, although you can talk things through with your pet rabbit - I used to as a teen! There is also some value in learning some techniques such as CBT, but that can be learnt from a book, so again, not sure of the value of an actual therapist.

I've come to this conclusion through two main sources, children and holocaust survivors.

I have known thousands of children through teaching, and fostering, and many many of them have seen therapists. My main observation is that huge expectations are placed on therapy as some sort of magic bullet that is going to cure all problems, but the result is inevitably disappointment, as nothing changes. Parents, and children too are left wondering what magic was supposed to have happened, and why it didn't. One fostering social worker once mentioned to me that she thought it was a complete waste of time after the age of 8, and I think she was right. Between the ages of 5 and 8, you can possibly use therapy to teach children a bit about the emotions they are feeling, which can help them understand themselves, but beyond that there seems to be no benefit

My other source is coming from a family of holocaust survivors, who never had therapy, and survived by not talking about hte past - Many went on to have long, happy, successful lives, married and raised families, ( including me!) . They did not discuss the past, and I was told not to ask questions. They were not totally without problems. I was aware of the occasional nightmare, and several of them were binge eaters who became obese in old age. However, they lived with this problems quite happily, and there was no talk or expectation of "therapy" of any kind to address them

So I have started this thread to see what others think. Maybe I am wrong - I am open to being told that I am wrong in this. My experiences have not given me any confidence in arranging for therapy for any child, or suggesting it for any adult, but please tell me if it is really in fact a wonder drug and I have missed the point somehow!

I should say I have been sent for therapy twice myself - once after being in a road accident in which my closest school friend died, ( aged 16)it was awful, made me cry every time, I felt so much better when I was allowed to stop, and once sent by my employer after I was knifed ( quite gently!) by a student at school - I was taught some useful CBT, but in my opinion a book would have been more helpful than a difficult journey to speak to someone who was basically going very slowly through what I could have read for myself in half the time without the train journey.

so:

YABU - therapy is helpful - and please explain how!
YANBU - therapy is a waste of time /a money maker/ sending someone for therapy or providing it is just a way of letting someone feel they are doing something useful, when they are not

OP posts:
stargirl1701 · 02/08/2023 11:38

I have therapy to help me cope with parenting my autistic child. None of my friends or family can cope with discussing the issues that arise. They are either baffled by what I am talking about or very distressed. It seems very unfair to expect them to be there for this for 2 decades.

RattleRattle · 02/08/2023 11:37

This reply has been deleted

This user is a goady troll so we've removed their posts.

Ilovedthe70s · 02/08/2023 11:35

Surely this is another example of how everyone is different.
I cannot think of anything worse than talking about my problems/ early life/issues or anything else, with anyone, counsellor, therapist, friend, family member.
I believe, absolutely, that many, many people will have completely the opposite feeling and that is how it should be. Nothing in life is one size fits all.

Sunnysideup999 · 02/08/2023 11:33

Unfor that is well said.
it is a profession that attracts some odd types. Some therapists are well rounded and mentally stable and secure themselves, others less so.

Spendonsend · 02/08/2023 11:33

Reading these it sounds like it needs to be reframed as something you do to get things off your chest without burdening friends and relatives, but not as a solution to those problems.

My own experience is a relative having CBT transformed their life but they had previously had lots of talking therapies which made them feel better for a day but I think made them re-livr stuff over and over with no relief..and to be honest I think it entrenched some poor coping mechanisms.

NeedToThinkOfOne · 02/08/2023 11:26

V interesting topic to start @Market1
Also worth considering how accessible therapy has changed the demographic of who is seeking it too. It’s not necessarily used just for major traumas or accessed by laying on a sofa in a clinical setting. Isn’t it also the case that historically people relied more on community friendships- settings such as the pub, for conversations and having someone to talk to- as a tool for managing feelings. Friendship dynamics have also changed, with more virtual connections than close neighbourhood friends having an impact on the general mental health wellbeing of society. My concerns would be more around who is offering the therapy services, especially when people may need clinical support but find themselves talking to an unqualified listener through a pay-as-you-go counselling service on zoom. As long as the right kind of support is being offered, I know it can help people who need a safe space for talking and dealing with whatever makes them feel emotionally unstable.

goldfootball · 02/08/2023 11:23

@Market1 i think the fostering social worker you spoke to who said there’s no point in therapy past 8 was ignorant/irresponsible. I have seen therapy have a significant impact on looked after children as teenagers and I hate the idea that there are social workers who go about saying there’s no point in therapy when there are children who have so few ways of navigating their lives and need help.

I do get why the ‘magic bullet’ aspect of it is annoying. And with children it’s tricky because they are not always buying in to it but essentially being made to do it in one way or another.

I think there are some really interesting questions about what makes therapy effective and I sort of get why you think it seems a bit pointless from
your impressions but I don’t think you could actually possibly know what impact therapy has had on the kids you have worked with.

I read once that the ‘therapeutic alliance’ - which is the sense that you trust your therapist and believe they are looking out for you - is a better predictor of good therapeutic outcomes than the actual style of therapy, and I have found this in my experience of counselling. So in that way, yes there are questions about whether or not a friend could fulfil some of that role. However personally the biggest thing counselling did for me was give me a space where I could say - I feel suicidal - and have an adult discuss that with me impartially and without emotion. It’s not always fair/ a good idea to say that to friends.

Middlelanehogger · 02/08/2023 11:21

Social connections and being involved within a community so your sense of belonging is achieved will make you feel better than therapy.

@CattyCattle I agree with a lot of your posts. My bad experiences with therapy have also involved a lot of navel-gazing about childhood events. But living in the past didn't take me forward.

I think there's a big trend online to say things like "it's wrong to burden your friends with your problems" or "friends aren't there to be your therapist" and the like. I really disagree with this attitude. I'm not saying don't also go to therapy if you click with them and it's helping, but the love and support and comfort that you feel from having friends and family who genuinely are there for you is incalculable. Even just sitting with them and feeling the warmth of their presence.

Siouxiesiouxiesioux · 02/08/2023 11:20

Market1 · 02/08/2023 10:43

but the binge eating wasn't particularly troubling them. I am a binge eater too, and I put that down to being raised by binge eaters. It doesn't trouble me much either - definitely no "unresolved pain"

Perhaps you are not a binge eater but an overeater? They are different things.

I would also ask why you call yourself a binge eater if you don’t see the quantities of food you eat as a problem? Why not just say that you like to eat a lot of food? Consistent bingeing is a disordered approach to food. Is this you? If not then you are just a regular eater. There are specific criteria by which binge eating disorder is diagnosed.

You cannot possibly know what another person experiences internally. No one can. A close friend of mine ended his own life. If you had told me that one of our group would do this. I would not have picked him in a million years. He was the life and soul of the party, a bright spark. I have heard the same from many others who have been bereaved in this way.

ime a certain generation kept quiet about painful experiences precisely because there was nowhere to take them. Therapy is a relatively new thing and for that generation was often seen as embarrassing precisely because they felt they should be able to deal with everything alone. Luckily, we no longer have to live with this attitude. I would encourage those who feel the need to seek out therapy. It could save your life.

crackofdoom · 02/08/2023 11:20

I have seen half a dozen therapists in my time- some helpful, some not so much. The thing that stands out with all the therapists I saw before my 40s, though, was that I would tell them all about my problems relating to other people, and not a single one picked up on the fact that I might be autistic. Awareness of neurodivergence remains very poor in the therapeutic community, IME. Now that I am aware of my own autism, I'm currently seeing a counsellor for a bit of a "service", and we have some interesting conversations about better ways to respond to neurodivergent people in therapy.

What was a gamechanger for me was CBT. Absolutely changed my life.

Twatalert · 02/08/2023 11:20

@XelaM 'never wallowed in self pity or seen a therapist '? I have heard it all now. What has wallowing and self pity to do with therapy?

What do you make of today's survivors of more recent wars, or those in the army sent to Afghanistan and coming back with PTSD?

I guess they are snowflakes?

Market1 · 02/08/2023 11:17

Gremlinsateit · 02/08/2023 11:10

Apologies, @Market1 , I misread earlier posts and I withdraw “strange and callous”. While I wasn’t using inter generational in the epigenetic sense, you are absolutely entitled to your view.

🙂💐

OP posts:
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 02/08/2023 11:14

Friends are not there to take the weight of someone else's trauma for them.

This!

It’s not your friends’ job to listen to you talking about yourself for hours on end even if it’s not trauma. Anyone who thinks therapy and a friendly natter are the same isn’t do one or other of them right!

crackofdoom · 02/08/2023 11:14

Well, having had a brief relationship with a man who would not stop talking about his kids' sexual abuse by another family member- and I mean, every time he was drunk he would go over the same harrowing, explicit details- and yet refused to go to therapy because "I'm not mad!" I would say that therapy benefits more people than the patient themselves.

unfor · 02/08/2023 11:14

I have personally found therapy life changing and am training to be a therapist. However, it is definitely NOT for everybody - as lots of people have said on this thread, some people do much better working things out for themselves, drawing on informal support, and generally dealing with things in their own way.

I think there are also a lot of bad therapists out there. It is a profession that attracts some odd types. And even among the good therapists, you have to find one that you 'click' with. Not to mention finding the right type of therapy. This can be hard (particularly since many of the best therapists don't have spaces for new clients). My personal view is that lots of people who say "therapy is not for me" had a therapist who was crap/crap for them and might have benefitted from seeing somebody else.

XelaM · 02/08/2023 11:13

Totally agree with every word OP and this part of your post resonates with me My other source is coming from a family of holocaust survivors, who never had therapy, and survived by not talking about hte past - Many went on to have long, happy, successful lives, married and raised families, ( including me!) . They did not discuss the past, and I was told not to ask questions. They were not totally without problems. I was aware of the occasional nightmare, and several of them were binge eaters who became obese in old age. However, they lived with this problems quite happily, and there was no talk or expectation of "therapy" of any kind to address them

Both my grandfathers had horrific lives. One of my grandfathers was an army doctor during WWII. He was the youngest of 8 children and they were Jews living in Crimea. His brothers who enlisted with him disappeared during the war and he later spent many years looking for their graves (in vain). His mother and sisters were all executed by the Germans when Hitler occupied Ukraine. My grandfather was in all the main Soviet battles of WWII like Stalingrad; his regiment was the one protecting Moscow and was the closest to the German army when Hitler was by Moscow. He had many many medals for bravery and as an army doctor he had to be right on the battlefield running under bullets. He was only one from his family who survived the war. He hardly ever spoke about the war and went on to have a successful medical career, married, raised a big family and lived to be over 100.

My other grandfather was too young to fight during WWII, but his father died in an accident before he was even born. His stepfather was executed by Communists as "an enemy of the state" (for being an outspoken academic who criticised the Regime) and his mother was imprisoned as the wife of an enemy of the state. He was living in absolute abject poverty, being sent from relative to relative and living in absolute squalor. He managed through an unbelievable academic talent to become a very famous scientist in the Soviet Union and one of the leading experts who investigated the reasons behind the Chernobyl disaster. He also raised a large family.

Both were amazing grandparents and absolutely never wallowed in any self-pity or seen a therapist.

WildUnchartedWaters · 02/08/2023 11:10

Twatalert · 02/08/2023 11:09

This is fucked up. You aren't able to consider other views and believe you have the monopoly on the truth unless someone says their family have also been through the Holocaust. Somehow I doubt you'd even consider the experience of such a person as you clearly think you know it all.

Many people that are traumatized and dysfunctional don't recognise it.

Quite. Elderly people are really well known for talking about their mental health in great detail 🙄

I agree with you that op wouldnt listen anyway.

Ancientpsycho · 02/08/2023 11:10

At the start of my 1990s Russell group psychology degree we were told counseling/ psychoanalysis was worse than useless. However since then I think some good results have been found for cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT,). the Five ways to wellbeing are a better bet but we have voted in politicians who have systematically worked to make wellbeing less likely. Link

nhs.uk

5 steps to mental wellbeing

Read about 5 steps you can take to improve your mental health and wellbeing.

https://www.nhs.uk/mental-health/self-help/guides-tools-and-activities/five-steps-to-mental-wellbeing/

Gremlinsateit · 02/08/2023 11:10

Apologies, @Market1 , I misread earlier posts and I withdraw “strange and callous”. While I wasn’t using inter generational in the epigenetic sense, you are absolutely entitled to your view.

WildUnchartedWaters · 02/08/2023 11:09

Market1 · 02/08/2023 11:03

I have spoken only of my own experiences of holocaust survivors, which includes 30-40 years of very close relationships with around 20 of them, including my parents, 2 surviving grandparents, 2 surviving great grandparents, and a host of other aunties and uncles, and of my experience of myself and my children being involved in long term epigenetical studies - of more than 10 years...

"intergenerational trauma" is really not a thing, epigenetically, and the traits passed down as a result of life experiences are BENEFICIAL - obviously otherwise what would be the evolutionary advantage!

I am not going to respond to any more comments about holocaust survivors, or epigenetic effects, as I clearly have a far greater experience and knowledge than the other poster that are trying to impose their views on this topic, so unless there are actual constructive questions, it is totally pointless to reply to statements made by people who don't know anything about it

You could have said much more concisely ' I'm right and that's it'

You cant be surprised that people are appalled that you are trying to use a trauma to push your agenda - which I'm still unsure of.

If only someone before you hsd realised that all mental health can be cured by a natter with friends.

you cant claim in your posts to be somewhat informed and researched and know lots about everything when you make statements like that.

Btw, by your own confession, ALL of your 'research ' is anecdotal and biased and totally non admissible.

But as youge started a thread based on evidence you're unwilling to discuss, I'm not sure what you hope to achieve.

Twatalert · 02/08/2023 11:09

Market1 · 02/08/2023 11:03

I have spoken only of my own experiences of holocaust survivors, which includes 30-40 years of very close relationships with around 20 of them, including my parents, 2 surviving grandparents, 2 surviving great grandparents, and a host of other aunties and uncles, and of my experience of myself and my children being involved in long term epigenetical studies - of more than 10 years...

"intergenerational trauma" is really not a thing, epigenetically, and the traits passed down as a result of life experiences are BENEFICIAL - obviously otherwise what would be the evolutionary advantage!

I am not going to respond to any more comments about holocaust survivors, or epigenetic effects, as I clearly have a far greater experience and knowledge than the other poster that are trying to impose their views on this topic, so unless there are actual constructive questions, it is totally pointless to reply to statements made by people who don't know anything about it

This is fucked up. You aren't able to consider other views and believe you have the monopoly on the truth unless someone says their family have also been through the Holocaust. Somehow I doubt you'd even consider the experience of such a person as you clearly think you know it all.

Many people that are traumatized and dysfunctional don't recognise it.

vipersnest1 · 02/08/2023 11:09

I had some therapy early last year after struggling to come to terms with a chronic condition which was recently diagnosed, and the fact that I might never be able to work again. (I am back at work now, admittedly I still struggle with the condition.)
What really helped me and the way I react to difficult circumstances was the realisation that it all stems back to circumstances in my childhood. Therapy didn't 'fix' me, and I still get anxious, but I understand myself a lot better now.

xPeaceXx · 02/08/2023 11:07

@EthicalNonMahogany true, and some people prefer the comfort of the lie or the mask. It's been a real gift to my mother, her ability to project everything on to her family. Eg, she is not heartless - dad is a hypochondriac, she is not heartless - her daughter is sensitive/emotional, it's not hard on her daughter that her daughter cannot raise an issue or ask to be heard - her daughter is aggressive, it's not that she has no ability at all to resolve small conflicts - it's that her daughter is detached from reality. It's not that she is judgemental - it's that her son is weirdly secretive. I coukd go on, but why would she at this point in her life unwrap herself from the middle of the warm and comforting lies??

WildUnchartedWaters · 02/08/2023 11:06

Gremlinsateit · 02/08/2023 10:56

Completely agree. I find it very strange and callous to suggest that Holocaust survivors are homogenous and haven’t had lasting, devastating, inter-generational trauma.

I find it utterly...bizarre, to say the least, that one would use one of the worst traumas in history just to bash counselling.

I remember my father telling me there wasnt any gay men when he was younger. No dad, they were all married to women or committed suicide or lived long isolating lives.
Same as the total lack of autistic children in the last generation.

Mental health is at a crisis. Services are lacking. People are dying in their thousands. And we are criticising counselling because....well, let's just make up reasons why.

I've asked it a few times now and nobody has been able to answer it.

There are physical treatments available for things that years ago people just had to live with. Women years ago wouldnt have had access to medicine and scans and all the marvellous things we hahe for pregnancy. But women before managed?

Our ancestors didnt hahe the half foods we have, and they managed?

Teeth were taken out with whisky?
We didnt try at all to protect vulnerable women who were soliciting, and they were fine?

So many examples. Why pick on mental health?

Counsellors arent allowed to counsel their own relatives. So suggesting one can manage perfectly fine with their friends and husband is all well and good, but somewhat performative.

I'm honestly baffled as to why anyone would want to criticise something like this.

As I said earlier if you've never needed counselling then consider yourself blessed. As it happens, I know many people who claim to har never suffered mental health and manage perfectly well with all that I would argue are in need of serious counselling. I also know many people who have been in counselling or are in counselling who cope far better than those who shout loudly how useless it is.

Going to a stranger to tell them you have had certain thoughts is the bravest thing a person can do and should be applauded.

JamSandle · 02/08/2023 11:06

Therapy can be very helpful but it only works if you do the work.

There is no magic fix.

I dont think combing over the past is helpful but if the past haunts you, there are techniques that can help it be managed.

Therapy is more about changing patterns of behaviour or thought that are harming people today.