Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"Therapy" is no better than a natter with a friend or a placebo.

313 replies

Market1 · 02/08/2023 09:19

I am starting this thread to see what people think of therapy. I am personally convinced it is at least 80% useless - I am not saying completely useless, as I am sure talking about a problem makes you feel better, although you can talk things through with your pet rabbit - I used to as a teen! There is also some value in learning some techniques such as CBT, but that can be learnt from a book, so again, not sure of the value of an actual therapist.

I've come to this conclusion through two main sources, children and holocaust survivors.

I have known thousands of children through teaching, and fostering, and many many of them have seen therapists. My main observation is that huge expectations are placed on therapy as some sort of magic bullet that is going to cure all problems, but the result is inevitably disappointment, as nothing changes. Parents, and children too are left wondering what magic was supposed to have happened, and why it didn't. One fostering social worker once mentioned to me that she thought it was a complete waste of time after the age of 8, and I think she was right. Between the ages of 5 and 8, you can possibly use therapy to teach children a bit about the emotions they are feeling, which can help them understand themselves, but beyond that there seems to be no benefit

My other source is coming from a family of holocaust survivors, who never had therapy, and survived by not talking about hte past - Many went on to have long, happy, successful lives, married and raised families, ( including me!) . They did not discuss the past, and I was told not to ask questions. They were not totally without problems. I was aware of the occasional nightmare, and several of them were binge eaters who became obese in old age. However, they lived with this problems quite happily, and there was no talk or expectation of "therapy" of any kind to address them

So I have started this thread to see what others think. Maybe I am wrong - I am open to being told that I am wrong in this. My experiences have not given me any confidence in arranging for therapy for any child, or suggesting it for any adult, but please tell me if it is really in fact a wonder drug and I have missed the point somehow!

I should say I have been sent for therapy twice myself - once after being in a road accident in which my closest school friend died, ( aged 16)it was awful, made me cry every time, I felt so much better when I was allowed to stop, and once sent by my employer after I was knifed ( quite gently!) by a student at school - I was taught some useful CBT, but in my opinion a book would have been more helpful than a difficult journey to speak to someone who was basically going very slowly through what I could have read for myself in half the time without the train journey.

so:

YABU - therapy is helpful - and please explain how!
YANBU - therapy is a waste of time /a money maker/ sending someone for therapy or providing it is just a way of letting someone feel they are doing something useful, when they are not

OP posts:
originalnuttah · 02/08/2023 12:44

I vote YABVU because op you’re on a massive wind up with this load of ignorant ‘I’m alright Jack’ bollox.

WildUnchartedWaters · 02/08/2023 12:43

Zebedee55 · 02/08/2023 12:25

Personally, I'd sooner crack open a bottle of wine with a thrusted, honest good mate and waffle away at her.

Waffling at a stranger wouldn't work for me - but each to their own.👍

Again...its not waffling.

Again, we ate talking about mental health terms in a way we wouldnt about physical.

Summerrainstorminagain · 02/08/2023 12:42

How many people end friendships because "I felt like I'd turned into their therapist" - too many! There is a need for it because there is a level of support people need that is too much for a standard relationship. PTSD and BPD being two conditions that can rapidly kill off friendship's.

RufustheFactualReindeer · 02/08/2023 12:41

Ds1 had therapy and it was very helpful for him, dd saw the same guy and loathed him…i used to have 30+ minutes of driving her home and the entire journey was taken up with how much she hated him and the whole process

she ended up seeing a psychiatrist and loathed that as well….she stopped going once she worked out what she needed to say to be ‘discharged’

a few years later she went through something else quite traumatic and got in very well with the counselor allocated to her and found them very helpful

so in my very limited experience I would say its good for some people and not for others and can vary depending on the issue and therapist

Wowokthanks · 02/08/2023 12:39

Therapy can be helpful, it has been for working through my OCD. The OCD thoughts are completely at odds with just about everyone else's view points and that's been a breakthrough in getting better.

Play therapy and art therapy was helpful for allowing me to talk about the sexual abuse I suffered which means that my parents and related authorities knew the extent without me needing to have those conversations.

Much of the therapy I have been through is absolutely useless though.

I would however never talk to a friend about any of my struggles. I wouldn't trauma dump on anyone like that.

Gwenhwyfar · 02/08/2023 12:39

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 02/08/2023 09:36

Also, it very much depends on the therapist, there are some great ones out there and some that might be good, but are not right for you.,

I think this is the thing. You have to really click with a therapist. It was really useful for me, but I can no longer find that particular therapist. (I also had a meh experience with a different therapist).

Heidihooo · 02/08/2023 12:32

I think it depends partly on the reason why you are accessing therapy. Exposure response therapy has helped me cope with OCD and anxiety. It’s taught me things, and doesn’t just involve having a chat about feelings.

I may have been able to read about it in a book but my weekly sessions with a therapist has been hugely valuable in my recovery. CBT on it’s own made no difference. I started ERT 10 weeks ago and it’s changed my life so much already. Best money i’ve ever spent.

coming from someone who has accessed NHS CBT twice and 8 different types of medications! A good therapist makes all the difference IMO

JokerAndTheQueen · 02/08/2023 12:29

It depends on the therapy you are having vs problem you are trying to solve and who your therapist is. I think it also depends on your support network.

If you are surrounded by people who acknowledge your feelings and let you speak I don't think it's as helpful as someone who is surrounded by people who disregard your feelings or try to fix everything for you.

I got on with my life after childhood trauma and lived with it for 20 years seemingly happy and enjoying life but later life trauma unleashed it all and I needed the help of a therapist trained in trauma to help me process it. It was hard work but she helped me out things into perspective and to finally let go of the past. I can now look back and see how the issues in my childhood shaped the choices I made, the person I grew into and my inability to recognise unhealthy behaviours. Things that people would have said were me "living my best life" were actually a flight response and my constantly wanting to run. I also benefitted from talking therapy afterwards when I had a wobble and enabled me to calm down and engage with the coping tactics I had been taught before. I think it can be hugely beneficial when given to the right person in the right circumstances but just like most things it's not a one fit for all

PinkFootstool · 02/08/2023 12:27

Zebedee55 · 02/08/2023 12:25

Personally, I'd sooner crack open a bottle of wine with a thrusted, honest good mate and waffle away at her.

Waffling at a stranger wouldn't work for me - but each to their own.👍

Great, but how does that work if the conversation is far too brutal for your friend to listen to? I've given examples in here already of the kinds of things I've taken into counselling sessions - no way could I put that into someone who isn't prepared to cope with it.

Zebedee55 · 02/08/2023 12:25

Personally, I'd sooner crack open a bottle of wine with a thrusted, honest good mate and waffle away at her.

Waffling at a stranger wouldn't work for me - but each to their own.👍

xPeaceXx · 02/08/2023 12:23

I just clicked on the 5 steps to mental Well being.
The first is CONNECT, well in defence of therapy, it was a very connecting experience to be heard and validated when I had gone to therapy because family scapegoating made me feel other rejections more intensely. Also, as for number 5, mindfulness, my 2nd therapist (I've had 3, so far!) Got me in to self compassion and recommended the excellent work book by kirsten neff phd and Chris grtmer phd "mindfulness self compassion". I took that book a chapter per weekend because I wanted to do the exercises, do the work and I did feel better afterwards.

sunstreaming · 02/08/2023 12:18

Therapy is a relationship between 2 people: the client and the therapist. What the client gets from it very much depends on their attitude to it and their willingness to carry on processing ideas after the sessions. It's not a magic bullet or cold compress to take away the pain. It's often hard work for the client because they have to confront things that they've done/that have happened to them and consider what meaning they have/what could be different another time. Therapy doesn't 'tell you what to do' but sets you goals where you can perhaps alter your way of dealing with events or even decide that the person/organisation hurting you is at fault and then you and only you, can decide what to do about it. While it is often helpful talking to trusted friend, there are times when this isn't the best thing to do. Therapists are trained NOT to bring their experiences into the conversation and also to be non-judgemental, so you don't have to edit what you say. Therapists probably don't know you or any people you might talk about, so there is no problem about you being totally honest. Also all properly accredited therapists are 'supervised' by a more qualified professional,so that, without breaking and confidences, the problem and their approach is discussed wit someone else and they are given advice and guidance, if necessary. Some of the problems people might want to discuss actually need action, e.g. abuse or criminal activity being done to them and a therapist would be more detached and knowledgeable about what you can do. Some peopleneed to have a lot of therapy,either because they have had really appalling experiences. Others need lots because they have little resilience and few coping skills and this can be improved through therapy. Others have no need of therapy because they haven't had experiences they can' cope with. Some others would resist therapy but the way they react to life shows that they could do with some help.These are the worst people to talk to 'as a friend'in my opinion,as they tend to use your situation to exercise their own need for revenge. Hope this is helpful.

BumpyaDaisyevna · 02/08/2023 12:18

The range of therapies and interventions is so wide that this question is almost impossible to answer.

A 6 week course of person centred counselling?

6 months of CBT?

Group dialectical behaviour therapy?

Group analytical therapy?

Mindfulness MBT?

18 months of once a week psychodynamic psychotherapy?

5-10 years of five times a week psychoanalysis lying on the couch?

All these things are so different in method, intensity and approach as to not be comparable.

I think two points are really key:

  • the therapist is someone that not only listens, but thinks differently to the patient. If the patient can cope with this fact, it leads to emotional growth
  • the therapy is not a treatment in the way that a drug is a treatment for an illness. It is the making of a space for a patient to think about themselves. There is a huge variation in the degree to which patients can use that space.
DisenchantedOwl · 02/08/2023 12:08

I've had loads of therapy over my lifetime. Sometimes it was brilliant and really effective, other times it was a waste of time.

It really depends on two things imo. The type of therapy suiting what you need and the therapist. Some therapists are very good and some are really not. Some therapists you click with and "get" you and some really don't.

So variable experience comes with the territory I think.

Suppressing and not talking about something rarely works though imo. You saying people had happy lives but were overeating to the point they were obese and having nightmares suggests otherwise. Unresolved or processed emotions leaches out on other ways if you try to just box them away.

My DH has these tendencies. So he has unresolved trauma from way back when he a teen/early twenties. He is amazingly good at appearing to the world as if he is on top of everything and very happy. The reality is underneath he is anxious and sometimes depressed. Literally no one other than me has any idea.

Processing emotions though doesn't have to be done with a therapist. That may work for some. But reading a self-help book or talking to friends and family, or meditating or thinking while on a long walk in nature might help others. It's all very personal and someone probably has to try different approaches to work out what works for them.

Cloudsarebright · 02/08/2023 12:06

In principle I agree.

But in reality I’m not going to talk to a friend about binging and purging, or the thought processes that occur before harming myself.

Ive never paid for it, I don’t see it as worth it as I can talk some things through. But on the nhs is been slightly more helpful than if I confided in a friend.

ActDottie · 02/08/2023 12:02

I think if you get the right therapist for you it can be amazing, but it’s hard to find the right one.

missingeu · 02/08/2023 11:58

Personally for me therapy has improved my life and me as a person. I have wonderful therapist who's guided me, reassured and most importantly listened to what I'm not saying. It's helped me come to terms with childhood trauma and someone I can talk about the awful things I see as a nurse that I can't tell my family.

I can understand how it may not work for everyone, as one size does not fit all.

I've also witnessed major trauma patients respond very differently to therapy, some positive/some negative.

I think you have to be open and willing for it work but also understand it won't fix everything overnight.

jgjgjgjgjg · 02/08/2023 11:51

Not talking about traumatic events is certainly one coping skill and it works really well for some people. On the other hand it absolutely does not work well for others and can end up destroying them, physically and mentally. You already mentioned binge eating and nightmares and the likelihood is that those are just the tip of the iceberg in what these individuals are experiencing. Some reading and understanding of PTSD and cPTSD would be helpful here.

What would you suggest as an alternative to therapy for those for 'don't talk about it' isn't an effective strategy? For example, service personnel who have sometimes experienced ongoing and repeated trauma?

PeppermintPorpoise · 02/08/2023 11:49

YABsoooooU. Rant incoming.

I'm a therapist. It is not just chatting fgs. You can do some structured venting (and some people need that and are more comfortable with a stranger) but many mental health issues need specific treatment. There are many types of therapy, all with different purposes and techniques. CBT, ACT, EMDR, DBT, ERP, I could go on. The reason these things cant be done from a book is that people who are unwell often dont have the insight needed to do it, or the coping skills, and need support while they get better. I cant believe that isnt obvious tbh.

For example ERP is one of the types I practice, by all credible research it is the gold standard treatment for OCD. It is one of the few things that works for a life destroying illness. Do you think they should chat to a mate instead of getting evidence based targeted help? EMDR is for trauma and PTSD, DBT is for borderline personality disorder and so on. These cant be done alone. They all have a purpose. Therapy is more than just mildly sad people needing a vent and spreading this noxious rhetoric you have here is dangerous. I hope nobody who really needs help reads this and is put off. I envy your naiviete on the topic tbh.

As for envoking Holocaust survivors, I dont know where to even start on that.

I'll leave before I get much angrier but long story short, stop spouting off about things you demonstrably have no idea about.

Shelaydownunderthetable · 02/08/2023 11:49

Therapy profoundly changed the way I related to other people in my life and helped me understand myself better. It enabled me to disrupt patterns that I wouldn’t have had clarity on or the confidence to change without therapy - a natter with friends doesn’t compare, like apples and oranges.

I think the likelihood of therapy working for you depends on the following:

  1. Your willingness to engage in the process, tolerate the discomfort, and belief that it might be able to help you if you let it
  2. Your presenting problem - what you want help with
  3. The skill and approach of your therapist
  4. The relationship between you and your therapist - it needs to be a good fit

I think these 4 things all need to align for therapy to have maximum impact. It’s also not all or nothing - there’s probably a spectrum of degree of benefit, or lack thereof.

bewilderedhedgehog · 02/08/2023 11:48

Apologies I haven't had time to read all the posts. Personally I have found therapy extremely helpful. I have good close friends, but that is a different conversation. When things became extremely difficult in my life, the therapist definitely helped me through. I think much depends on the quality of the therapist and on the level of trust between therapist and client

MsCactus · 02/08/2023 11:47

I personally think CBT is great - very practical and useful. I think psychoanalysis is a bit of a waste of time, and is no better than chatting to a caring friend, but it seems to help some people

RattleRattle · 02/08/2023 11:45

This reply has been deleted

This user is a goady troll so we've removed their posts.

Joeylove88 · 02/08/2023 11:44

I think you have to really want and be ready for therapy for it to work for you. Therapy is hard work and not a quick fix. It can be painful because you are opening up and offloading painful events/emotions. With the right therapist you should be able to feel safe to do that and to put the work in to make changes. When someone is stuck in a cycle of anxiety/depression/and bad habit that has a negative effect on mental health, its about changing that routine and facing the issues instead of running away from them. I have wonderful family and friends who would support me but having an independent safe space to go and work on myself has been so beneficial for me personally. If you don't believe in therapy I truly think it won't work for you.

QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 02/08/2023 11:42

For me, talking therapy did not work, it just reminded me of the awful things that happened, I refused to engage and would rather just not talk about it ever. Trauma therapy including EMDR was a game changer for me.