Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"Therapy" is no better than a natter with a friend or a placebo.

313 replies

Market1 · 02/08/2023 09:19

I am starting this thread to see what people think of therapy. I am personally convinced it is at least 80% useless - I am not saying completely useless, as I am sure talking about a problem makes you feel better, although you can talk things through with your pet rabbit - I used to as a teen! There is also some value in learning some techniques such as CBT, but that can be learnt from a book, so again, not sure of the value of an actual therapist.

I've come to this conclusion through two main sources, children and holocaust survivors.

I have known thousands of children through teaching, and fostering, and many many of them have seen therapists. My main observation is that huge expectations are placed on therapy as some sort of magic bullet that is going to cure all problems, but the result is inevitably disappointment, as nothing changes. Parents, and children too are left wondering what magic was supposed to have happened, and why it didn't. One fostering social worker once mentioned to me that she thought it was a complete waste of time after the age of 8, and I think she was right. Between the ages of 5 and 8, you can possibly use therapy to teach children a bit about the emotions they are feeling, which can help them understand themselves, but beyond that there seems to be no benefit

My other source is coming from a family of holocaust survivors, who never had therapy, and survived by not talking about hte past - Many went on to have long, happy, successful lives, married and raised families, ( including me!) . They did not discuss the past, and I was told not to ask questions. They were not totally without problems. I was aware of the occasional nightmare, and several of them were binge eaters who became obese in old age. However, they lived with this problems quite happily, and there was no talk or expectation of "therapy" of any kind to address them

So I have started this thread to see what others think. Maybe I am wrong - I am open to being told that I am wrong in this. My experiences have not given me any confidence in arranging for therapy for any child, or suggesting it for any adult, but please tell me if it is really in fact a wonder drug and I have missed the point somehow!

I should say I have been sent for therapy twice myself - once after being in a road accident in which my closest school friend died, ( aged 16)it was awful, made me cry every time, I felt so much better when I was allowed to stop, and once sent by my employer after I was knifed ( quite gently!) by a student at school - I was taught some useful CBT, but in my opinion a book would have been more helpful than a difficult journey to speak to someone who was basically going very slowly through what I could have read for myself in half the time without the train journey.

so:

YABU - therapy is helpful - and please explain how!
YANBU - therapy is a waste of time /a money maker/ sending someone for therapy or providing it is just a way of letting someone feel they are doing something useful, when they are not

OP posts:
neverbeenskiing · 02/08/2023 14:18

Therapy draws you back into your pain and you keep discussing it. you wont ever change what happened. Go out there and live your best life while your alive, sing, dance and do other things you enjoy.

Patronising, vacuous nonsense. On a thread full of ill-informed opinions, I think this one really takes the cake.

I'm so glad that when I was diagnosed with PTSD I saw a qualified psychiatrist who correctly determined that what I needed was treatment in the form of evidence-based psychological therapy, instead of inane, meaningless platitudes that sound like they came from a motivational quote on Instagram.

Therapy did not draw me back into my pain, it helped me claw my way out of it. It quite possibly saved my life, and it certainly enabled to me regain my functioning to the extent that I could return to work and parent my children. I have also worked with many suicidal adolescents whose lives have been saved by therapy.

Please do not go around discouraging people from accessing a legitimate form of treatment for their Mental Health that you clearly know absolutely nothing about. The goal of therapy isn't to "change what happened," nor is it to keep discussing traumatic events over and over. In fact, one of the most effective therapies for trauma (EMDR) doesn't involve discussing traumatic or distressing events at all!

JussathoB · 02/08/2023 14:18

It’s a complex situation, there’s no one size fits all. Human experiences, feelings and minds are extremely complex and individual. Of course sometimes a chat with a supportive friend or family member can work wonders but in other situations the problem is too big or too difficult for that. Sometimes you actually need somebody external to talk through the feelings with, someone very close just won’t work.
Have you watched Couples Therapy on tv?? It’s an insight into how some couples have begun to find it difficult to live with each other. Sometimes through therapy they can learn to understand each other better, not misinterpret each other, and move forward together. Other times it becomes clear that they are going to go their separate ways. It’s not about proving who’s right.
Books and self help methods can often help too but a good therapist can ask questions to bring out more about the situation.

Begsthequestion · 02/08/2023 14:15

A friendship is a reciprocal relationship.

A therapist is a professional who has support from their peers and who does not expect you to help them with their problems.

This is one of the most useful things about therapy.

WildUnchartedWaters · 02/08/2023 14:11

SunflowerSunflower · 02/08/2023 14:06

Oh. And a well trained therapist wouldn’t allow you to become dependent on therapy. There are, sadly, lots of ‘dabblers’ out there that give properly trained and supervised counsellors and therapists a bad name. It’s good to do your research and check for registration with professional bodies like the BACP or HCPC.

This we are trained to end even if we know the counsellor wants to continue.

SunflowerSunflower · 02/08/2023 14:06

Oh. And a well trained therapist wouldn’t allow you to become dependent on therapy. There are, sadly, lots of ‘dabblers’ out there that give properly trained and supervised counsellors and therapists a bad name. It’s good to do your research and check for registration with professional bodies like the BACP or HCPC.

SunflowerSunflower · 02/08/2023 14:04

Polik

Clinical supervision and therapy are different things. Talk to your supervisor if you are not finding it helpful.

OP. INRTFT and I am sure this has already been said but whether or not therapy is helpful depends on many different factors;

  • a good therapeutic relationship where you feel safe enough with the therapist.
  • How ready you are to change and how well resourced or supported you are.
  • right model for what you want to work on.

There are many different models of therapy and counselling. Some are very directive and quite informative (e.g CBT), some are completely led by you (e.g Humanistic/person centred) and everything in between. Some are based on very sound science and research and some have developed through theory. Some therapists have very little training and others are highly trained and skilled.

It’s not a simple question with a simple answer.

crapactually · 02/08/2023 14:01

Zebedee55 · 02/08/2023 12:25

Personally, I'd sooner crack open a bottle of wine with a thrusted, honest good mate and waffle away at her.

Waffling at a stranger wouldn't work for me - but each to their own.👍

This perfectly represents the total lack of understanding of mental health here and in society in general.

I really hope this attitude doesn't prevent people in crisis from reaching out and accepting help but actually we know that it does.

Thepeopleversuswork · 02/08/2023 13:47

I think its very dependent on the person undergoing the therapy (and the therapist, obviously) and their capacity to digest, unpack and view themselves and their emotional hard-wiring.

I personally have got a great deal out of it because I'm naturally a fairly analytical person and I like to have a non-biased, non-involved sounding board to process things. I think its enormously helpful when you're in a "negative feedback loop" when you keep cycling through negative or self-destructive thoughts: having an objective third part making you see how irrational this is is often half the battle. I think for most people having this kind of outlet for their own damaging thoughts and habits is a positive thing. I think more people benefit from it than don't.

But I think there is a grain of truth in what the OP says: I think people can become rather dependent on it and start to use it as a bit of a crutch and an excuse to constantly overthink fairly insignificant life events and visit their neuroses on others. I have a friend who has seen a therapist for decades and who is incredibly prone to offloading constantly about more or less everything all the time and I do sometimes think (rather uncharitably) that it might help her to be listened to a bit less than she currently is. There is sometimes a virtue in knowing when to stop thinking about things and just get on with it.

Icannoteven · 02/08/2023 13:39

I think there are a lot of variables that affect whether or not therapy will work for you, including the type of therapy, the therapist/your relationship with the therapist, your approach/objective e.g are you using the therapist as a sounding board, are you trying to problem solve, are you trying to learn more about yourself/the world/others etc.

I briefly had therapy (heavily dbt influenced) and found it absolutely life changing. It gave me a whole new perspective on how I think and process emotions.

I think some forms of therapy can be harmful though. CBT is my personal bugbear. It’s literally just gaslighting. I hate how it has become so ubiquitous, it’s even being used (misused) in the workplace

PostOpOp · 02/08/2023 13:28

There are plenty of holocaust survivors who have had therapy. There are a lot of Jewish therapists (especially in the US) who went into the field after witnessing their parents/grand parents' trauma.

I also don't buy that your binge-eating obese elderly relatives were actually happy. Especially when they were alone, because that's presumably when they binge-ate. They may have been happy when family/others were around though, which is good. Nobody who has an eating disorder is a poster child for happiness though.

I think the issue is muddied because the field isn't clear. I have experience of therapy helping a lot (developmental/complex PTSD). But I've had other less helpful experiences. However, there's then things like a therapist I saw 20 years ago at uni. I thought he was crap and didn't understand the situation. I found a diary 18 years later in which I wrote about our sessions. What I thought was crap then was actually SPOT ON! I just hadn't been ready to hear/able to understand it at that time.

I have also done a counsellor course. Over two years there was one out of twenty students who I'd want to see for any kind of therapy, or who I'd refer anybody to. I later studied psychology to have a scientific/research background, rather than relying on interpretations of research from people who often didn't understand it themselves!

And finally, therapy limited to 12 sessions is a complete waste of time if you actually have a problem. If you need someone to chat to or learn a few tips from, that's fine. Otherwise it barely scratches the surface, or worse, opens things that are better kept shut in such a short time.

WildUnchartedWaters · 02/08/2023 13:24

Sirzy · 02/08/2023 13:23

Ahh yes finding the answers in the bottom of a wine glass. That’s a well proven method for improving mental health isn’t it!

Fantastic for addiction services.

Could you imagine someone posted a thread claiming their physically ill friend who was accessing medical treatment should just 'get on with it' and have awee chat with a friend?
People are so ignorant about mental health and it infuriates me.

Sirzy · 02/08/2023 13:23

Zebedee55 · 02/08/2023 12:25

Personally, I'd sooner crack open a bottle of wine with a thrusted, honest good mate and waffle away at her.

Waffling at a stranger wouldn't work for me - but each to their own.👍

Ahh yes finding the answers in the bottom of a wine glass. That’s a well proven method for improving mental health isn’t it!

Blatantlyfemale · 02/08/2023 13:20

My tuppence worth is most therapists and some therapy approaches ( humanistic/ person centred) are crap. Only useful if you just need someone to vent to. But then the Samaritans do that for free. And do it better than therapists I’ve paid for as they don’t feel the need for professional detachment.

A therapist who can help you analyze your thinking and help to plan a way through your issue is useful, but the problem is the ‘patient’ needs to have the motivation and drive to put the work in, and many, because they are at a place where they turn to therapy, won’t be able to do that or at least keep it up long term. Also, a good therapist chslkenges their patient, so the ‘patient’ needs to be able to cope with that to progress.

Saschka · 02/08/2023 13:12

WildUnchartedWaters · 02/08/2023 12:43

Again...its not waffling.

Again, we ate talking about mental health terms in a way we wouldnt about physical.

Agre. Why have physiotherapy after an injury, when you could just move your arms and legs about yourself?

catscatscurrantscurrants · 02/08/2023 13:12

It depends very much on the therapist, the bond established with the client, and on the willingness of the client to fully engage with the techniques taught. To dismiss it altogether seems to me to be shortsighted. The value of a therapist lies in their experience, knowledge, and especially their complete objectivity. The last you do not always get with a friend or relative, because their affection for you can skew their judgement and advice.
I've seen 2 therapists. The first one I did not get on with at all, the aggressive and confrontational manner grated on me. The second one suited me very well, I engaged with all techniques and truly valued their perspectives; and with their help, I began my recovery.

Saschka · 02/08/2023 13:09

Zebedee55 · 02/08/2023 12:25

Personally, I'd sooner crack open a bottle of wine with a thrusted, honest good mate and waffle away at her.

Waffling at a stranger wouldn't work for me - but each to their own.👍

Waffling to a stranger doesn’t work for anyone, but luckily that isn’t what therapy is Hmm

LolaSmiles · 02/08/2023 13:02

It's not a magic bullet, but for the right topics and right circumstances it can help.

There's a lot of quacks out there though as anyone can set themselves up and call themselves a therapist. It matters to get someone good and respectable who you can build rapport with.

I actually find it more problematic when people expect their friends to be their therapists. Friend and therapist are different roles.

I think some people are quite bad at emotion dumping and offloading their trauma onto their friends.

Gwenhwyfar · 02/08/2023 12:57

I think conversations with friends can be helpful, but they are really not the same as therapy at all. I have some friends with whom I can't have this type of conversation at all - they just don't like to talk about things like this.
I have some that I could talk to, but of course it would not be fair to monopolise their time like that. They also need to get a chance to talk about what's going on in their own lives.
They have their own experiences and viewpoints and can never be impartial. They are part of your life themselves rather than an independent observer. There's also a risk of falling out and your secrets no longer being safe.

BlossomCloud · 02/08/2023 12:56

Gremlinsateit · 02/08/2023 10:56

Completely agree. I find it very strange and callous to suggest that Holocaust survivors are homogenous and haven’t had lasting, devastating, inter-generational trauma.

Agreed.
And @Market1 clearly hasn't read anything by Edith Eger -who herself was inspired by another Holocaust survivor who became a therapist.

or,.of course, Viktor Frankl,.another Holocaust survivor

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Viktor_Frankl

There's no right or wrong way to live after surviving something so monstrously horrific. But certainly it would not be correct to suggest that some didn't find therapy helpful

Viktor Frankl - Wikipedia

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Viktor_Frankl

WildUnchartedWaters · 02/08/2023 12:55

If only MN was in charge of mental health. Either just get over it or drink a bottle of wine with your pal. Problem solved.

CantFindTheBeat · 02/08/2023 12:49

onefinemess · 02/08/2023 09:25

I think if you have reached a point in your life where you have to pay a stranger to listen to you, then I think you have bigger problems.

@onefinemess - erm, isn't that the point?
Or are you always so one-dimensional?

Iggii · 02/08/2023 12:48

A therapist knows the right questions to ask you, it's not just aimless talking.

WildUnchartedWaters · 02/08/2023 12:47

originalnuttah · 02/08/2023 12:44

I vote YABVU because op you’re on a massive wind up with this load of ignorant ‘I’m alright Jack’ bollox.

👏👏

HouseIsOnFire · 02/08/2023 12:46

BrookNoRivals · 02/08/2023 09:46

It depends on so much. People often recommend it on here as if therapy will solve your problems- it won't. What can help (for example, with repeated bad relationship choices) is time, honesty and effort. Seeing a therapist is one way to make the effort but it isn't the only one. Talking to friends can help (although not always- depends on the friends. Sometimes what you need is to be challenged rather than supported.)

Also worth bearing in mind that no therapist ever said, "actually, you seem fine- save your money".

All the above applies to normal, run-of-the-mill problems. I think there's definitely a place for professional help where someone has experienced significant trauma.

Disagree with this, a good therapist will tell you when you've gone as far as they can take you.

My therapist "weaned" me down from weekly to monthly and it was the therapist who said she didn't think we need to see see each other anymore.

It's so dependent on getting a good therapist!

itsallnewnow · 02/08/2023 12:45

Saw a therapist in an abusive relationship and she was invaluable but she was a specialist in DV who helped me talk it through, validated my suspicions that I was being abused and also helped with practical things like referring to a lock smith. Maybe depends on the circumstance?

Also used a therapist when a close relative was dying of cancer, again they were able to deal with the specific emotions, tell me what was likely to happen and help with practicalities.

Both times it helped that it was someone detached from the situation