Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"Therapy" is no better than a natter with a friend or a placebo.

313 replies

Market1 · 02/08/2023 09:19

I am starting this thread to see what people think of therapy. I am personally convinced it is at least 80% useless - I am not saying completely useless, as I am sure talking about a problem makes you feel better, although you can talk things through with your pet rabbit - I used to as a teen! There is also some value in learning some techniques such as CBT, but that can be learnt from a book, so again, not sure of the value of an actual therapist.

I've come to this conclusion through two main sources, children and holocaust survivors.

I have known thousands of children through teaching, and fostering, and many many of them have seen therapists. My main observation is that huge expectations are placed on therapy as some sort of magic bullet that is going to cure all problems, but the result is inevitably disappointment, as nothing changes. Parents, and children too are left wondering what magic was supposed to have happened, and why it didn't. One fostering social worker once mentioned to me that she thought it was a complete waste of time after the age of 8, and I think she was right. Between the ages of 5 and 8, you can possibly use therapy to teach children a bit about the emotions they are feeling, which can help them understand themselves, but beyond that there seems to be no benefit

My other source is coming from a family of holocaust survivors, who never had therapy, and survived by not talking about hte past - Many went on to have long, happy, successful lives, married and raised families, ( including me!) . They did not discuss the past, and I was told not to ask questions. They were not totally without problems. I was aware of the occasional nightmare, and several of them were binge eaters who became obese in old age. However, they lived with this problems quite happily, and there was no talk or expectation of "therapy" of any kind to address them

So I have started this thread to see what others think. Maybe I am wrong - I am open to being told that I am wrong in this. My experiences have not given me any confidence in arranging for therapy for any child, or suggesting it for any adult, but please tell me if it is really in fact a wonder drug and I have missed the point somehow!

I should say I have been sent for therapy twice myself - once after being in a road accident in which my closest school friend died, ( aged 16)it was awful, made me cry every time, I felt so much better when I was allowed to stop, and once sent by my employer after I was knifed ( quite gently!) by a student at school - I was taught some useful CBT, but in my opinion a book would have been more helpful than a difficult journey to speak to someone who was basically going very slowly through what I could have read for myself in half the time without the train journey.

so:

YABU - therapy is helpful - and please explain how!
YANBU - therapy is a waste of time /a money maker/ sending someone for therapy or providing it is just a way of letting someone feel they are doing something useful, when they are not

OP posts:
SkinnyMalinkyLankyLegs · 02/08/2023 18:55

I disagree that therapy is no better than a good natter with a friend. I think that a natter with a friend can do the world of good however friends will have a level of bias and in depth knowledge of a persons behaviours, personality etc which will likely affect any therapeutic discussion they have with a friend.

Through my job, I've trained in a few therapy 'lites', so I'm not a therapist, but I do embed therapy techniques into my practice. I would find it difficult to be a therapist to a friend though, as I have too much background knowledge/bias about them. I'm not sure if I'm explaining myself properly, it makes sense to me!

FruitTartlet · 02/08/2023 18:38

I’m on the fence. I have some stuff I struggle with that I can’t really talk to people around me about. And so I go to therapy weekly. But I am sufficiently peri/meno whatever that my memory is fucking awful. So each week we talk but I wouldn’t say I am building on the sessions over time. I can’t remember what’s been said really, by me or them.
I can’t really afford it so am considering stopping it. So far I haven’t because I am worried that perhaps it is an important outlet for some things and if I stop doing it permanently I will freak out over not having that once a week time when I know that someone will listen. I find it extra difficult when I feel I can’t speak to anyone about those things and if I am struggling with them at the same time.

WildUnchartedWaters · 02/08/2023 18:34

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 02/08/2023 18:28

But with respect the ‘advances’ mentioned in medicine are to do with measurable physical effects on the physical body ( and not all of the ‘advances’ turn out to be that, the drugs which have to be withdrawn for their ‘side’ effects, lobotomy, electric shock treatment to name a few). The psychological and emotional problems which therapy is supposed to address are less easily defined , and their alleviation less demonstrable, except by the affirmation of the sufferer.

I come of the generation where ‘resilience ‘ was more highly valued than seems currently to be the case. Of course, that resilience was perhaps enabled by a more homogeneous society, and by the existence of alternative sources of support. I don’t understand why if previous generations were so ignorant about ‘ mental health’ , the rates of people apparently suffering in this respect seem to increase continuously.

So I think the assumption that our understanding, and more particularly, the availability of alleviation for mental distress is on a continuing upward trajectory is open to debate.

The headline? People are talking about it more, and social media.

My dad claims nobody was gay in his youth. Ian mckellen does a phenomenal speech about nobody in the premier league or in schools being gay 🤥 nobody in my entire year was autistic.

And ob that note, I attribute this generations mental health to the earlier generations inability or unwillingness to address neurodivetsity, sexuality and male mental health.

We are just talking ahout it more.

Re, the physical thing I understand what you're saying. But it cant be measured in tbe same way , can it? People have treatment and still die. It's the same on the mental health world. The only difference is , terminal illness or cancer is protected in the sense that a similar
OP about someone just needing to get over it because their granny did would be vilified. Bar a couple or oppositions that shes ignored, people have jumped on to bash counselling. Which takes me back to why we have the rates we have.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 02/08/2023 18:28

WildUnchartedWaters · 02/08/2023 17:11

So did I and i hope people continue to do so.
She also failed to respond to my question about the many things people used to do that we dont do with the advance in medicine.

But with respect the ‘advances’ mentioned in medicine are to do with measurable physical effects on the physical body ( and not all of the ‘advances’ turn out to be that, the drugs which have to be withdrawn for their ‘side’ effects, lobotomy, electric shock treatment to name a few). The psychological and emotional problems which therapy is supposed to address are less easily defined , and their alleviation less demonstrable, except by the affirmation of the sufferer.

I come of the generation where ‘resilience ‘ was more highly valued than seems currently to be the case. Of course, that resilience was perhaps enabled by a more homogeneous society, and by the existence of alternative sources of support. I don’t understand why if previous generations were so ignorant about ‘ mental health’ , the rates of people apparently suffering in this respect seem to increase continuously.

So I think the assumption that our understanding, and more particularly, the availability of alleviation for mental distress is on a continuing upward trajectory is open to debate.

WildUnchartedWaters · 02/08/2023 18:28

Twatalert · 02/08/2023 18:08

@Blatantlyfemale ah yes, agree with this. You couldn't work out a lot of things just on your own with this approach.

Person centred makes me angry, but humanistic I thought would be a bit different. Maybe it's not.

It's actually really important that the therapist facilitates the progress properly and doesn't rely on fucking silence.

I'm person centred. Can you explain why it makes you angry? (Sprry that was very person centred 🤣)

Merapi · 02/08/2023 18:23

I had counselling some years ago, and it really helped me a lot. Just as well, because I was teetering on the edge of a complete breakdown.

I'd spent many years not talking about it and putting it to the back of my mind, but that approach didn't work for me. I needed a professional counsellor to help me understand my thought processes, and how to look at my childhood traumas in a different light.

Everyone is different, and one size does not fit all.

Twatalert · 02/08/2023 18:08

@Blatantlyfemale ah yes, agree with this. You couldn't work out a lot of things just on your own with this approach.

Person centred makes me angry, but humanistic I thought would be a bit different. Maybe it's not.

It's actually really important that the therapist facilitates the progress properly and doesn't rely on fucking silence.

Grimchmas · 02/08/2023 18:06

I've had a very positive therapy experience.

I'm not a fan of trauma or emotional baggage dumping on friends, at least not if somebody does it regularly or when they really should see a therapist. Being put into the role of unpaid therapist is pretty shitty if it happens too often (and if you're a good listener and person with good empathy, it will happen often).

I've cooled off or just plain cut off friendships where people have taken the piss with that.

Blatantlyfemale · 02/08/2023 18:02

Twatalert · 02/08/2023 14:23

@Blatantlyfemale out of interest - could I ask why you view the humanistic approach as critical? I am just researching a bit trying to figure out what it does and if it might suit me.

Because counselors who use a person centred/ humanistic approach think if you let the client talk and talk they will arrive at their own epiphanies/ solutions ( according to the reading one gave me to). Which is bollocks. Though it does explain why do many people have bad experience of counselors, reporting ‘ they never really said anything. They never really did anything’. I used to think those were crap counselors but now I realise it is an entire therapeutic approach.

I’ve had two good counsellors who were helpful, one challenged me and was really insightful, good at getting through my splurge of pain to identify my core ( unhelpful) thinking/ narrative and challenging me on it. The other focused on identifying my thinking patterns and helping me to challenge these, and use more helpful ways of thinking.

Johnisafckface · 02/08/2023 17:40

I wish I’d been given therapy as a child/teen/young adult to resolve issues of witnessing domestic violence, dysfunctional family life and narcissistic parents. I think it would’ve helped me make different decisions and react differently to things that have happened in my life. I feel my life would’ve been completely different (and better) if I’d had therapy to deal with all the issues/situations I had/experienced as a child/teen.

namechange55465 · 02/08/2023 17:26

"a book would have been more helpful than a difficult journey to speak to someone who was basically going very slowly through what I could have read for myself in half the time without the train journey"

Seriously, you're a teacher? Might want to look a bit closer to home for this...this was my entire school experience!

BodegaSushi · 02/08/2023 17:22

I don't think it's your friends job to offload your problems to, we all have our own shit and many times people are not at all self aware and have no clue about how much they can make every conversation about them and constantly be negative about everything. There are people that I have lowered then stopped contact with because of this. Pay a therapist.

WildUnchartedWaters · 02/08/2023 17:11

ThePiglet · 02/08/2023 17:06

Indeed, but I felt I had to challenge it

So did I and i hope people continue to do so.
She also failed to respond to my question about the many things people used to do that we dont do with the advance in medicine.

ThePiglet · 02/08/2023 17:06

WildUnchartedWaters · 02/08/2023 17:04

OP has refused to engage on the comment any further after not being applauded and indeed being questioned for her appalling post.

Indeed, but I felt I had to challenge it

WildUnchartedWaters · 02/08/2023 17:04

ThePiglet · 02/08/2023 17:02

It's simplistic to the point of offensive to invoke Holocaust survivors in this context. Many Holocaust survivors had therapy; some even were or became therapists. Some did not have therapy, and thrived. Some did not have therapy and did poorly, and likely would have benefitted from it. Many - including those who were ostensibly 'fine' passed on inherited trauma to their children and grandchildren which has resulted in them having serious mental health problems and needing therapy. I am one of those people.

There isn't anything 'special' about Judaism or the Jewish people which somehow mitigated the effects of what survivors went through (as one PP suggested). An enormous number of central European Jews were fully assimilated and with no particular connection to Judaism - some of those who survived had a connection to it, and many of those who survived did not or actively eschewed it.

OP has refused to engage on the comment any further after not being applauded and indeed being questioned for her appalling post.

ThePiglet · 02/08/2023 17:02

Market1 · 02/08/2023 09:19

I am starting this thread to see what people think of therapy. I am personally convinced it is at least 80% useless - I am not saying completely useless, as I am sure talking about a problem makes you feel better, although you can talk things through with your pet rabbit - I used to as a teen! There is also some value in learning some techniques such as CBT, but that can be learnt from a book, so again, not sure of the value of an actual therapist.

I've come to this conclusion through two main sources, children and holocaust survivors.

I have known thousands of children through teaching, and fostering, and many many of them have seen therapists. My main observation is that huge expectations are placed on therapy as some sort of magic bullet that is going to cure all problems, but the result is inevitably disappointment, as nothing changes. Parents, and children too are left wondering what magic was supposed to have happened, and why it didn't. One fostering social worker once mentioned to me that she thought it was a complete waste of time after the age of 8, and I think she was right. Between the ages of 5 and 8, you can possibly use therapy to teach children a bit about the emotions they are feeling, which can help them understand themselves, but beyond that there seems to be no benefit

My other source is coming from a family of holocaust survivors, who never had therapy, and survived by not talking about hte past - Many went on to have long, happy, successful lives, married and raised families, ( including me!) . They did not discuss the past, and I was told not to ask questions. They were not totally without problems. I was aware of the occasional nightmare, and several of them were binge eaters who became obese in old age. However, they lived with this problems quite happily, and there was no talk or expectation of "therapy" of any kind to address them

So I have started this thread to see what others think. Maybe I am wrong - I am open to being told that I am wrong in this. My experiences have not given me any confidence in arranging for therapy for any child, or suggesting it for any adult, but please tell me if it is really in fact a wonder drug and I have missed the point somehow!

I should say I have been sent for therapy twice myself - once after being in a road accident in which my closest school friend died, ( aged 16)it was awful, made me cry every time, I felt so much better when I was allowed to stop, and once sent by my employer after I was knifed ( quite gently!) by a student at school - I was taught some useful CBT, but in my opinion a book would have been more helpful than a difficult journey to speak to someone who was basically going very slowly through what I could have read for myself in half the time without the train journey.

so:

YABU - therapy is helpful - and please explain how!
YANBU - therapy is a waste of time /a money maker/ sending someone for therapy or providing it is just a way of letting someone feel they are doing something useful, when they are not

It's simplistic to the point of offensive to invoke Holocaust survivors in this context. Many Holocaust survivors had therapy; some even were or became therapists. Some did not have therapy, and thrived. Some did not have therapy and did poorly, and likely would have benefitted from it. Many - including those who were ostensibly 'fine' passed on inherited trauma to their children and grandchildren which has resulted in them having serious mental health problems and needing therapy. I am one of those people.

There isn't anything 'special' about Judaism or the Jewish people which somehow mitigated the effects of what survivors went through (as one PP suggested). An enormous number of central European Jews were fully assimilated and with no particular connection to Judaism - some of those who survived had a connection to it, and many of those who survived did not or actively eschewed it.

neverbeenskiing · 02/08/2023 16:48

those people who think of it as paying someone to listen to you (and don't you have friends??) are absolutely missing the point.

I think that people who have very little understanding of therapy often assume that it's just sitting in a room complaining at someone. They don't realise it's a collaborative process, and it takes work.

I've heard it said that therapy is a bit like untangling Christmas lights. It's not just talking about what has happened to you in the past or what's going on now, it's about having someone highly trained work with you to "untangle" or make sense of it all. Venting to friends over a bottle of wine might make you feel better, but it's just a temporary release, it's not actually resolving anything.

Before I started therapy my thoughts, memories and emotions all seemed such a confusing mess I thought untangling it all wasn't possible. So I just ignored a lot of things, and of course it all got more and more tangled as the years went on. Now I realise I just needed someone who knew what they were doing to help me untangle it all. It's all still there, of course, but i'm not confused by it or ashamed of it anymore, because I understand it. I understand where it all came from, how it all links together and why it got in such a mess over the years. I also understand now that none of it was my fault. Perhaps most importantly, if it starts getting a bit tangled again, I've learned techniques in therapy to untangle it myself before I get in too much of a mess again.

BrokenButNotFinished · 02/08/2023 16:19

RonObvious · 02/08/2023 09:30

Therapy changed my life. No exaggeration. But I was fortunate to get the right psychotherapist at my first try. I had very specific goals - wanted to unpack a particular childhood trauma - and in the process, discovered that a lot of my mental health symptoms were due to dissociation. Once my goals were achieved, I stopped the therapy. There were times when I felt much worse after sessions, but since the treatment has finished, I have overall felt much better. I used to have regular periods of depression, and those are completely gone. I have been able to face and accept aspects of my childhood, allowing me to put them in the past. I wouldn't say that I am "fixed" - I don't think that developmental trauma is "fixable", but I am more complete and present.

I do understand your point though - constantly talking and reliving events can keep you in them - I call it "trauma cycling". It can become a bad habit, as you feel better when you are letting it out, but it never really goes anywhere. However, working with the right therapist isn't like that.

This. Therapy changed my life too. And those people who think of it as paying someone to listen to you (and don't you have friends??) are absolutely missing the point.

I was so damaged by childhood trauma that I didn't even see that I'd had an abusive upbringing. I thought the problem was that I just couldn't cope, that I was weak. I had a lot of coping strategies: denial, humour, alcohol. It took six months of my therapist gently redirecting my narrative, trying to get me to lose the defensive humour, to home in on certain key elements, before I had a breakthrough and started to realise how bad it all was. Something he had clearly realised very early in the process. For a while I couldn't imagine how it was possible to go on living in that much pain - but I got through that and learned to live with reality, not the story I told myself. It was absolutely transformative. I wish I'd done it much earlier 😁.

WildUnchartedWaters · 02/08/2023 15:34

No social worker said that.

crapactually · 02/08/2023 15:34

neverbeenskiing · 02/08/2023 14:30

@Market1i think the fostering social worker you spoke to who said there’s no point in therapy past 8 was ignorant/irresponsible. I have seen therapy have a significant impact on looked after children as teenagers and I hate the idea that there are social workers who go about saying there’s no point in therapy when there are children who have so few ways of navigating their lives and need help.

I totally agree. I have worked with a lot of care experienced teenagers over the years, and being able to make sense of their early childhood experiences through therapy has been transformational for many of them. The ones who didn't find it helpful were almost always pressured into it by adults before they were really ready. I have a huge amount of respect for Social Workers, I liaise with them daily in my work and have met some wonderful ones. But they are not therapists and are not qualified to make such sweeping generalisations about the efficacy of therapy. Its not a magic bullet, but its not supposed to be and that doesn't mean it has no value.

I'd somehow missed that from the OP. I very much doubt a fostering social worker said that at all, and if they did, it's outrageous.

Akitasmum · 02/08/2023 14:44

I went to a psychiatrist for 4 years when I was young. I did have to try 3 before I found the right one for me but it was life changing. I did have family and friends but it’s not the same thing at all. It was hard work but it made me a much happier and stronger person. It doesn’t make all your problems disappear nor stop you from having new problems but it does help you to learn to cope with them. I can only speak for myself but I am glad that I had therapy.

neverbeenskiing · 02/08/2023 14:30

@Market1i think the fostering social worker you spoke to who said there’s no point in therapy past 8 was ignorant/irresponsible. I have seen therapy have a significant impact on looked after children as teenagers and I hate the idea that there are social workers who go about saying there’s no point in therapy when there are children who have so few ways of navigating their lives and need help.

I totally agree. I have worked with a lot of care experienced teenagers over the years, and being able to make sense of their early childhood experiences through therapy has been transformational for many of them. The ones who didn't find it helpful were almost always pressured into it by adults before they were really ready. I have a huge amount of respect for Social Workers, I liaise with them daily in my work and have met some wonderful ones. But they are not therapists and are not qualified to make such sweeping generalisations about the efficacy of therapy. Its not a magic bullet, but its not supposed to be and that doesn't mean it has no value.

Twatalert · 02/08/2023 14:23

@Blatantlyfemale out of interest - could I ask why you view the humanistic approach as critical? I am just researching a bit trying to figure out what it does and if it might suit me.

WildUnchartedWaters · 02/08/2023 14:23

neverbeenskiing · 02/08/2023 14:18

Therapy draws you back into your pain and you keep discussing it. you wont ever change what happened. Go out there and live your best life while your alive, sing, dance and do other things you enjoy.

Patronising, vacuous nonsense. On a thread full of ill-informed opinions, I think this one really takes the cake.

I'm so glad that when I was diagnosed with PTSD I saw a qualified psychiatrist who correctly determined that what I needed was treatment in the form of evidence-based psychological therapy, instead of inane, meaningless platitudes that sound like they came from a motivational quote on Instagram.

Therapy did not draw me back into my pain, it helped me claw my way out of it. It quite possibly saved my life, and it certainly enabled to me regain my functioning to the extent that I could return to work and parent my children. I have also worked with many suicidal adolescents whose lives have been saved by therapy.

Please do not go around discouraging people from accessing a legitimate form of treatment for their Mental Health that you clearly know absolutely nothing about. The goal of therapy isn't to "change what happened," nor is it to keep discussing traumatic events over and over. In fact, one of the most effective therapies for trauma (EMDR) doesn't involve discussing traumatic or distressing events at all!

👏👏👏

Lemonyyy · 02/08/2023 14:20

Not everyone has an emotionally literate friend/parent/sibling with the time and energy to listen to you and talk through your problems. My family was the cause of some of my problems so trying to broach anything with them simply made it worse.

I found a therapist was great for identifying certain problematic thought trains with lightning precision, then supporting me to interrogate that thought train instead of just rolling with it. Sadly my therapy was on the NHS and is done now, I could've probably done with quite a bit longer, but I did and do find it helpful for my specific issues.

Swipe left for the next trending thread