Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"Therapy" is no better than a natter with a friend or a placebo.

313 replies

Market1 · 02/08/2023 09:19

I am starting this thread to see what people think of therapy. I am personally convinced it is at least 80% useless - I am not saying completely useless, as I am sure talking about a problem makes you feel better, although you can talk things through with your pet rabbit - I used to as a teen! There is also some value in learning some techniques such as CBT, but that can be learnt from a book, so again, not sure of the value of an actual therapist.

I've come to this conclusion through two main sources, children and holocaust survivors.

I have known thousands of children through teaching, and fostering, and many many of them have seen therapists. My main observation is that huge expectations are placed on therapy as some sort of magic bullet that is going to cure all problems, but the result is inevitably disappointment, as nothing changes. Parents, and children too are left wondering what magic was supposed to have happened, and why it didn't. One fostering social worker once mentioned to me that she thought it was a complete waste of time after the age of 8, and I think she was right. Between the ages of 5 and 8, you can possibly use therapy to teach children a bit about the emotions they are feeling, which can help them understand themselves, but beyond that there seems to be no benefit

My other source is coming from a family of holocaust survivors, who never had therapy, and survived by not talking about hte past - Many went on to have long, happy, successful lives, married and raised families, ( including me!) . They did not discuss the past, and I was told not to ask questions. They were not totally without problems. I was aware of the occasional nightmare, and several of them were binge eaters who became obese in old age. However, they lived with this problems quite happily, and there was no talk or expectation of "therapy" of any kind to address them

So I have started this thread to see what others think. Maybe I am wrong - I am open to being told that I am wrong in this. My experiences have not given me any confidence in arranging for therapy for any child, or suggesting it for any adult, but please tell me if it is really in fact a wonder drug and I have missed the point somehow!

I should say I have been sent for therapy twice myself - once after being in a road accident in which my closest school friend died, ( aged 16)it was awful, made me cry every time, I felt so much better when I was allowed to stop, and once sent by my employer after I was knifed ( quite gently!) by a student at school - I was taught some useful CBT, but in my opinion a book would have been more helpful than a difficult journey to speak to someone who was basically going very slowly through what I could have read for myself in half the time without the train journey.

so:

YABU - therapy is helpful - and please explain how!
YANBU - therapy is a waste of time /a money maker/ sending someone for therapy or providing it is just a way of letting someone feel they are doing something useful, when they are not

OP posts:
CanNeverThinkOfAName · 03/08/2023 01:43

If therapy feels like chatting with a friend, the therapist is totally not fit for purpose! It's not supposed to be a friendly chat, you're there to draw out upsetting, painful things which are affecting you and you often don't want to accept yourself, let alone to a friend.

Also challenging negative core beliefs (which a good therapist will help you identify) is really hard work and it's pretty pointless if you're not in a place where you're ready to bring it out to process it.

I was forced into therapy as I had a panic attack when on the motorway with DC in the car. I had had them for a few years at that point but refused to accept they were panic attacks as only pathetic, weak people had them not someone hard as nails like me (know better now). I'd had medical investigations as I was insistent that they were physical symptoms rather than psychosomatic. It was the first one I'd had while driving. It terrified me and I knew I could not continue like that. Desperation took me to a hypnotherapist who I naively hoped could hypnotise them away quickly but that opened a big can of ugly worms and led to 5 years of on and off therapy.

I had undiagnosed OCD from childhood which was diagnosed by my GP shortly afterwards, after the hypnotherapy gave me the courage to seek further help, and is notoriously difficult to 'cure', but I am now 99% not bothered by it and that was due to an excellent trauma therapist putting the ground work in to help me work through severe childhood abuse and the core beliefs about myself which stemmed from that before I started therapy for the OCD.

Therapy has given me a great understanding of the human psyche too and my DC have definitely benefited from having a mother who's very open about mental health and understands the importance of it unlike my own who used to threaten me with taking me to the 'shrink' to get locked up which is what prevented me from getting help earlier and suffering for so long.

I personally think if everyone underwent a form of trauma therapy/debriefing from their childhoods at age 18-25 the world would be much better and safer place! Obviously impossible in practice.

The vast majority of the terrible things that humans do to each other are due to unresolved childhood trauma/injury to the developing ego including world wars and greed for money and power. On a smaller scale, road rage, I always say 'what happened to you then' when an aggressive twat cuts me up!

WildUnchartedWaters · 03/08/2023 01:28

PermanentTemporary · 03/08/2023 01:25

I've been in therapy for a while now since dh took his own life. Obviously I would feel a lot better some years after that event anyway. And I can't tell you exactly why it seems to help me. So it's not very convincing. All I can say is that when I have stopped, things get worse. Personal conflicts, illogical decisions, self destructive behaviours.

It is of course noticeable that therapy has grown in popularity in societies where religion is declining, and also where formal conversation is less common. Regular ethical and personal discussions are normal in most religions, and where there is a clerical class of people, that's their role. I am not going to talk to a vicar or a rabbi and find religion unhelpful now. But even thigs like regular visiting and deeper conversations or correspondence just aren't supported. Therapy is about the only place I have those conversations any more.

💕

PermanentTemporary · 03/08/2023 01:25

I've been in therapy for a while now since dh took his own life. Obviously I would feel a lot better some years after that event anyway. And I can't tell you exactly why it seems to help me. So it's not very convincing. All I can say is that when I have stopped, things get worse. Personal conflicts, illogical decisions, self destructive behaviours.

It is of course noticeable that therapy has grown in popularity in societies where religion is declining, and also where formal conversation is less common. Regular ethical and personal discussions are normal in most religions, and where there is a clerical class of people, that's their role. I am not going to talk to a vicar or a rabbi and find religion unhelpful now. But even thigs like regular visiting and deeper conversations or correspondence just aren't supported. Therapy is about the only place I have those conversations any more.

WildUnchartedWaters · 03/08/2023 01:03

ssd · 02/08/2023 23:03

I had bereavement counselling with cruise after my mum died. It didn't really work. There was one thing the Counsellor said that stuck with me but really i just sat and cried and felt awkward. I really wanted more from it. But its volunteers who are the therapist's and i just needed more. I know they have training but i just felt i was sitting crying to someone who just looked at me. And i waited 6 months till the person was available, its not like you can pick and choose who you see.

Sorry I missed the cruise point . Like with mind it is volunteers. Not counsellors.

We dont recommend grief counselling til 6 months in.

WildUnchartedWaters · 03/08/2023 01:01

ssd · 02/08/2023 23:03

I had bereavement counselling with cruise after my mum died. It didn't really work. There was one thing the Counsellor said that stuck with me but really i just sat and cried and felt awkward. I really wanted more from it. But its volunteers who are the therapist's and i just needed more. I know they have training but i just felt i was sitting crying to someone who just looked at me. And i waited 6 months till the person was available, its not like you can pick and choose who you see.

Is this matching with mind?

With counselling you can absolutely choose.

ssd · 02/08/2023 23:03

I had bereavement counselling with cruise after my mum died. It didn't really work. There was one thing the Counsellor said that stuck with me but really i just sat and cried and felt awkward. I really wanted more from it. But its volunteers who are the therapist's and i just needed more. I know they have training but i just felt i was sitting crying to someone who just looked at me. And i waited 6 months till the person was available, its not like you can pick and choose who you see.

BimboandTopsy · 02/08/2023 22:56

I had EMDR as part of therapy for PTSD and even though I was the biggest sceptic about therapy it was life changing.

I'm waiting for this type of therapy. Whilst talk therapy has helped to an extent (an avenue to vent when I don't have any other avenues), it hasn't really changed things around for me. I'm hoping, really hoping that EMDR makes a difference.

Blueberr · 02/08/2023 22:35

A lot of kids are just brutally honest with anyone.

As adults even when nattering with a friend we might apply a filter, whereas with a therapist you don’t know you can be completely honest if you wish and that is very liberating for some.

For some people though there is something to be said about forgetting and not talking about things, e.g. some people with ptsd respond better when focussing on how to avoid flashbacks….reliving the details of the trauma isn’t always helpful.

EthicalNonMahogany · 02/08/2023 22:32

I've read all the thread.

OP said two interesting things. One was to ask "What is 'doing the work, anyway?'".

The other was to say "I was raised by binge eaters and I am a binge eater too, but there isn't any suffering or trauma associated with it".

I respond- doing the work means willingly experiencing your own pain. Feeling it, not surpressing it, not trying to make it go away, but exploring what happens when you try and get your brain to respond differently to a painful stimulus. It's very brave because humans are programmed to avoid pain. It's why I said it's like training for a marathon- you push and push yourself to sit with the pain.

You're a binge eater, OP. Commiserations, I'm one too. There's no pain you feel right now. When you meet a hard emotional trigger you don't need to feel pain, you soothe with food!! And so you don't feel the pain. Things are stable, there is no reason you need to address the pain. So long as your eating disorder doesn't in itself make you ill, or as long as you don't for example move on to use alcohol or gambling or drugs to do that job for you - as they are more dangerous more quickly.

If you were in therapy, your work might start with choosing a binge eating moment and then...simply not eating. How might you feel? What might surface? What might that tell you about yourself? It would hurt like buggery, and you would soon feel the discomfort intensify and intensify. But if you wanted to break the process of smothering emotions with food, it might be interesting.

Would you be brave enough?

WildUnchartedWaters · 02/08/2023 21:10

KerkyraBlue · 02/08/2023 21:07

I hope anyone reading this thread who was considering therapy isn’t put off by some of the comments on here. Therapy is far, far, more than ‘nattering’, and as a Clinical Psychologist who spent years training, and much of my own money doing further training, I feel offended by that.

I adore my job, working with people who have been haunted by their past experiences, who feel stuck in vicious cycles of thinking, feeling, behaving, who feel they can’t burden friends and family with their darkest thoughts and fears. Yes sometimes it helps to talk to people who know us, but the majority of my clients comment on how useful it is to speak with someone neutral and objective.

I have also had my own therapy as part of my training. We didn’t natter. She helped me look at some uncomfortable truths about myself and my experiences within a safe relationship and I am a better mum, partner and friend because of it.

I did note from your first post- you said you were ‘sent’ to therapy. In my experience that can make a huge difference as to how much someone benefits from therapy. If you feel ‘sent’ or ambivalent about it, it will be less effective as you will be less invested in it.

❤ I currently work in a role, outing, but provides counselling to a specific group of people. I'm horrified by this thread.

KerkyraBlue · 02/08/2023 21:07

I hope anyone reading this thread who was considering therapy isn’t put off by some of the comments on here. Therapy is far, far, more than ‘nattering’, and as a Clinical Psychologist who spent years training, and much of my own money doing further training, I feel offended by that.

I adore my job, working with people who have been haunted by their past experiences, who feel stuck in vicious cycles of thinking, feeling, behaving, who feel they can’t burden friends and family with their darkest thoughts and fears. Yes sometimes it helps to talk to people who know us, but the majority of my clients comment on how useful it is to speak with someone neutral and objective.

I have also had my own therapy as part of my training. We didn’t natter. She helped me look at some uncomfortable truths about myself and my experiences within a safe relationship and I am a better mum, partner and friend because of it.

I did note from your first post- you said you were ‘sent’ to therapy. In my experience that can make a huge difference as to how much someone benefits from therapy. If you feel ‘sent’ or ambivalent about it, it will be less effective as you will be less invested in it.

ShoesoftheWorld · 02/08/2023 20:51

WildUnchartedWaters · 02/08/2023 20:09

Usually people think after their 12 sessions or whatever theyl feel better.

This seems to me to be part of the problem - the idea of therapy as something administered to you, that 'works' as a drug might. It's an interaction - the therapeutic relationship, with two people in it, is its foundation. At various points in my own therapy I described it as 'hard labour'. But it has been instrumental in making my life livable.

Then there's the (related) idea that a few sessions are, or should be, enough to 'fix' you. I'm in a country where the minimum course of CBT available on statutory insurance is 25 sessions. The minimum. Often this is extended by another 25. And psychoanalysis starts at 100. The therapist has to provide an individual rationale to the insurer as to why it's needed in this particular case before they'll cover it.

Therapy won't 'cure' everyone. Surgery and chemo/radio don't cure all cancers. Very sadly, people still die of them, and some have a much lower survival rate than others. But nobody sensible would call those treatments 'ineffective' in general, or suggest that a cancer patient shouldn't try them. Mental health conditions have similar ranges of prognosis and greater or lesser intractability.

WildUnchartedWaters · 02/08/2023 20:35

Anybody reading this who resonates with the amazing posters, please, please dont dismiss it.

XenoBitch · 02/08/2023 20:29

YABVVU, and dangerous with your views. I really hope someone teetering on the brink does not think they should not bother to try and access professional help, and instead thinking talking to a friend is better.

Therapy saved my life... both 1:1 and DBT, of which I did for 5 years. A professional (who would also be having their own support) helped me reflect and taught me skills. I could offload onto them. I would never think of trauma dumping on friends... that is not fair on them, and not helpful for me.

Elsiebear90 · 02/08/2023 20:12

Begsthequestion · 02/08/2023 20:07

What does your BIL mean by therapy "working"? What kind of outcome is he measuring?

It's not a magic pill of course. But it has improved the lives of many people I know, so I'm surprised your BIL is so adamant it doesn't work.

I should have added more detail to the post, he deals with children and young people who have complex mental health issues/trauma, many have had years and years of therapy of varying types and according to him there is very little improvement in their mental health. He doesn’t think it can’t work, just thinks that the people who need it the most often benefit the least from it. He works within the NHS, so I imagine he is dealing with the “worst” cases, which obviously will skew his view.

WildUnchartedWaters · 02/08/2023 20:09

Begsthequestion · 02/08/2023 20:07

What does your BIL mean by therapy "working"? What kind of outcome is he measuring?

It's not a magic pill of course. But it has improved the lives of many people I know, so I'm surprised your BIL is so adamant it doesn't work.

Usually people think after their 12 sessions or whatever theyl feel better.

Begsthequestion · 02/08/2023 20:07

Elsiebear90 · 02/08/2023 20:02

I was always a big advocate for therapy, I tried some CBT for anxiety and found it useless, but appreciate that’s not therapy. Was speaking with my BIL recently who is training to be a clinical psychologist and he’s feeling very demoralised lately as he’s come to the conclusion through his job that therapy in most cases does not work.

What does your BIL mean by therapy "working"? What kind of outcome is he measuring?

It's not a magic pill of course. But it has improved the lives of many people I know, so I'm surprised your BIL is so adamant it doesn't work.

Elsiebear90 · 02/08/2023 20:02

I was always a big advocate for therapy, I tried some CBT for anxiety and found it useless, but appreciate that’s not therapy. Was speaking with my BIL recently who is training to be a clinical psychologist and he’s feeling very demoralised lately as he’s come to the conclusion through his job that therapy in most cases does not work.

WildUnchartedWaters · 02/08/2023 19:49

CantFindTheBeat · 02/08/2023 19:45

I think it's such a worrying perspective, @Begsthequestion.

If OP is a foster carer or teacher, and therefore in a position of influence over vulnerable people, to be of the 'don't seek help, just get on with it' mentality is genuinely worrying.

I'm a very measured, balanced and successful person but have gone through very dark times. I had therapy during & after depression, for things my friends and family just couldn't have dealt or understood.

Had a good therapist not been available to me, I think my outcome may have been very different.

This sort of vocal belief makes me feel so afraid for others.

❤❤

WildUnchartedWaters · 02/08/2023 19:49

Begsthequestion · 02/08/2023 19:33

Yes I wonder why op thinks they can confidently pronounce that all their traumatised family members were fine without therapy, and actually "lived quite happily with their problems"which included nightmares and eating disorders!

Really, really odd thread imo.

Utterly bizarre thread and I'm disgusted by the holocaust refs.

CantFindTheBeat · 02/08/2023 19:45

I think it's such a worrying perspective, @Begsthequestion.

If OP is a foster carer or teacher, and therefore in a position of influence over vulnerable people, to be of the 'don't seek help, just get on with it' mentality is genuinely worrying.

I'm a very measured, balanced and successful person but have gone through very dark times. I had therapy during & after depression, for things my friends and family just couldn't have dealt or understood.

Had a good therapist not been available to me, I think my outcome may have been very different.

This sort of vocal belief makes me feel so afraid for others.

Begsthequestion · 02/08/2023 19:33

CantFindTheBeat · 02/08/2023 19:21

I think my perspective would be based on your control group, OP - you've stated that they are children, and holocaust survivors.

There is an enormous group of people between those two sections.

To me, if you switch out the word 'therapy, for 'insights, perspective, mentorship and coaching', which you absolutely could, the benefits of 'therapy' as a function is hard to ignore.

And without judging, it feels likely that you do not know the innermost thoughts, fears, concerns and behaviours of those who inform your opinion. What people think and feel, and what they share and portray, are frequently very different.

Yes I wonder why op thinks they can confidently pronounce that all their traumatised family members were fine without therapy, and actually "lived quite happily with their problems"which included nightmares and eating disorders!

Really, really odd thread imo.

WildUnchartedWaters · 02/08/2023 19:23

I doubt Op will return after her agenda failed but I hope people can continue to discuss therapy. It's so, so important.

CantFindTheBeat · 02/08/2023 19:21

I think my perspective would be based on your control group, OP - you've stated that they are children, and holocaust survivors.

There is an enormous group of people between those two sections.

To me, if you switch out the word 'therapy, for 'insights, perspective, mentorship and coaching', which you absolutely could, the benefits of 'therapy' as a function is hard to ignore.

And without judging, it feels likely that you do not know the innermost thoughts, fears, concerns and behaviours of those who inform your opinion. What people think and feel, and what they share and portray, are frequently very different.

WildUnchartedWaters · 02/08/2023 18:59

FruitTartlet · 02/08/2023 18:38

I’m on the fence. I have some stuff I struggle with that I can’t really talk to people around me about. And so I go to therapy weekly. But I am sufficiently peri/meno whatever that my memory is fucking awful. So each week we talk but I wouldn’t say I am building on the sessions over time. I can’t remember what’s been said really, by me or them.
I can’t really afford it so am considering stopping it. So far I haven’t because I am worried that perhaps it is an important outlet for some things and if I stop doing it permanently I will freak out over not having that once a week time when I know that someone will listen. I find it extra difficult when I feel I can’t speak to anyone about those things and if I am struggling with them at the same time.

You need to try and use the strategies your counsellor should be teaching you.

My problem was I knew what she was saying was right, being qualified myself , I just didnt feel it.