Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"Therapy" is no better than a natter with a friend or a placebo.

313 replies

Market1 · 02/08/2023 09:19

I am starting this thread to see what people think of therapy. I am personally convinced it is at least 80% useless - I am not saying completely useless, as I am sure talking about a problem makes you feel better, although you can talk things through with your pet rabbit - I used to as a teen! There is also some value in learning some techniques such as CBT, but that can be learnt from a book, so again, not sure of the value of an actual therapist.

I've come to this conclusion through two main sources, children and holocaust survivors.

I have known thousands of children through teaching, and fostering, and many many of them have seen therapists. My main observation is that huge expectations are placed on therapy as some sort of magic bullet that is going to cure all problems, but the result is inevitably disappointment, as nothing changes. Parents, and children too are left wondering what magic was supposed to have happened, and why it didn't. One fostering social worker once mentioned to me that she thought it was a complete waste of time after the age of 8, and I think she was right. Between the ages of 5 and 8, you can possibly use therapy to teach children a bit about the emotions they are feeling, which can help them understand themselves, but beyond that there seems to be no benefit

My other source is coming from a family of holocaust survivors, who never had therapy, and survived by not talking about hte past - Many went on to have long, happy, successful lives, married and raised families, ( including me!) . They did not discuss the past, and I was told not to ask questions. They were not totally without problems. I was aware of the occasional nightmare, and several of them were binge eaters who became obese in old age. However, they lived with this problems quite happily, and there was no talk or expectation of "therapy" of any kind to address them

So I have started this thread to see what others think. Maybe I am wrong - I am open to being told that I am wrong in this. My experiences have not given me any confidence in arranging for therapy for any child, or suggesting it for any adult, but please tell me if it is really in fact a wonder drug and I have missed the point somehow!

I should say I have been sent for therapy twice myself - once after being in a road accident in which my closest school friend died, ( aged 16)it was awful, made me cry every time, I felt so much better when I was allowed to stop, and once sent by my employer after I was knifed ( quite gently!) by a student at school - I was taught some useful CBT, but in my opinion a book would have been more helpful than a difficult journey to speak to someone who was basically going very slowly through what I could have read for myself in half the time without the train journey.

so:

YABU - therapy is helpful - and please explain how!
YANBU - therapy is a waste of time /a money maker/ sending someone for therapy or providing it is just a way of letting someone feel they are doing something useful, when they are not

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
pastatriangles · 05/08/2023 12:42

@ThePiglet you're right though. Even if it were just as good as a friend...how many friends would sit with you for an hour a week discussing your problems, your childhood, and your intimate issues? How many of us would want to share this with a friend? How many friends are equipped to deal with this?

Even if it was just as good as a random friend, we don't say 'a professional massage appointment is only as good as a friend giving you a back rub'...'a cleaner is only as good as your friend coming round with the hoover'...'a gardener is just the same as a friend coming over every week to mow the lawn.'

ThePiglet · 05/08/2023 10:56

Sorry, I misread this as the most recent post in the thread!

ThePiglet · 05/08/2023 10:55

onefinemess · 02/08/2023 09:25

I think if you have reached a point in your life where you have to pay a stranger to listen to you, then I think you have bigger problems.

But isn't that exactly the point - yes I do have 'bigger problems' - chronic anxiety and stress, very low self-esteem plus I find it difficult to open up to friends and family. And, frankly, none of my friends or family are equipped to deal with my problems - not because my problems are extreme, or because they are somehow inadequate people, but because they lack psychological insight, and have their own stuff going on.

poetryandwine · 04/08/2023 10:08

I am very sorry for what both you and your DH went through, @PermanentTemporary
I have Continental Jewish heritage from one side of the family, and my observations agree with you and OP’s that there is much superficial resilience and success there. But these people had and their children, the generation above me, have, great difficulty with negative emotions. It has led to difficulties with my generation

@Polik there is no correlation between emotional literacy or knowledge and a need for therapy. My home country has more of a tradition than the UK of intensive talking therapies. A certain degree of intelligence and emotional awareness is necessary for undergoing such therapies. My source is my aunt, a Professor of Psychology.

Scarfweather · 04/08/2023 09:26

Different types of therapy will suit different types of people. CBT is definitely not the only evidence-based therapy, but it’s the one NHS will give out because it’s easier to protocolise in their system. It will work for some, not all.
Some therapy will involve deep analysis and that won’t be for everyone either.
Other therapy will only focus on strength building and finding solutions.
There are good and bad therapists and those you ‘click’ with and those you don’t.

But talking with a friend cannot be compared to professional therapy. Therapy is an objective, non-judgemental, safe space where you can dump your issues and then close the door after the session. Your friend, if they even want to take the weight of your issues, will always view you through the lens of the help you needed. I’m not sure I’d want that.

ShoesoftheWorld · 04/08/2023 08:42

Lamelie · 03/08/2023 07:12

Lots of interesting points. There are definitely some unhelpful modalities and practitioners. One thing that jumps out from the OP is all the protective factors and tools (resilience) you have. This comment leapt out, “after I was knifed ( quite gently!)”

I noticed that comment too, and I saw it - with respect, OP - not as an indication of resilience, but rather as an indication of a tendency to minimise things that have happened to you.

Resilience isn't about dismissing or trivialising difficult or damaging experiences, or even 'bouncing back', it's about drawing on the resources available to you to maintain your wellbeing in the face of such experiences. Therapy can very much be one of those resources.

PermanentTemporary · 03/08/2023 14:28

I'm very much a lay observer of Holocaust studies but what I might say there was that as a rule, only those with additional resources in some form (eg youth, health, psychological resilience) survived. And I think it's simplistic to say that they were fine afterwards, though I totally accept what you're saying which was that they frequently built totally successful lives by any measure.

Exibstudent · 03/08/2023 11:55

EMDR therapy has changed my life and the lives of my husband and children forever.
I have plenty of friends to talk to but as a previous poster mentioned burdening your friends with trauma and abuse is over the line for me and would be too difficult. A friend is not necessarily a safe place in the way that a therapist is.
I was actually "ok" before I had emdr- I functioned in society, had a very nice life and was a good parent and wife. I would and did tell people I had dealt with my trauma. EMDR has still improved my quality of life so massively that I find it almost incredible.
I also had talking therapy- this was also very helpful and I needed this to get to the point I could access EMDR.
Not everyone finds any given therapy useful, not everyone is able to "do the work," even if they would find it helpful. Not everyone is traumatized or otherwise effected by things that would effect someone else.
It doesn't mean that therapy doesn't work.

Yusay · 03/08/2023 11:32

It’s true that pouring tour heart out to a friend who cares may be more beneficial than a chat with a counsellor. But, there are only so many times you can moan at a friend before the friend gets fed up and ditches you. Trust me I know!

georgarina · 03/08/2023 10:57

I have talk therapy with a psychotherapist and it has been absolutely life changing. I'm a completely different person now in terms of my trauma and complex PTSD. Nowhere near a 'natter with a friend.'

DaisyDaisyDaisyDaisyDaisyDaisy · 03/08/2023 09:24

I went to cruise following the death of my mum. My god that woman was absolutely wonderful. I still think about her now with such affection. The first few sessions were me sitting down, crying then leaving. Then she just somehow started coaxing me through my grief. She helped me in a way that my husband/ friends could not. I don't think she has any notion of how much she helped me as I may have been in too much of a mess to tell her at the time.

Middleagedmeangirls · 03/08/2023 09:24

A good therapist will know the right question to ask at the right time to help uncover blind spots in a persons thinking.

funinthesun19 · 03/08/2023 09:19

captainmarvella · 03/08/2023 09:13

All the pluses of therapy, of course, hinge on getting the right therapist. I was fortunate to have one like that. If you are not, then it can be a very very frustrating and disappointing experience.

I think this was partly the problem that I had.

funinthesun19 · 03/08/2023 09:18

I’ve recently tried therapy (CBT) and I found it useless. In fact it added to my stress to be honest. Maybe I will re visit it one day, but right now I found the whole thing a waste of time and an extra thing to worry about.

ApolloandDaphne · 03/08/2023 09:17

I had therapy to help me through a traumatic event in my life. I had plenty of friends and family to talk to but this event happened within the whole community and everyone i knew was also struggling to come to terms with it. I was able to get space with someone who was removed from the situation to explore my feelings and responses to the event and she did EMDR with me. It found it very helpful.

captainmarvella · 03/08/2023 09:13

All the pluses of therapy, of course, hinge on getting the right therapist. I was fortunate to have one like that. If you are not, then it can be a very very frustrating and disappointing experience.

ssd · 03/08/2023 09:12

WildUnchartedWaters · 03/08/2023 01:03

Sorry I missed the cruise point . Like with mind it is volunteers. Not counsellors.

We dont recommend grief counselling til 6 months in.

I was 6 months in.

captainmarvella · 03/08/2023 09:10

Market1 · 02/08/2023 09:19

I am starting this thread to see what people think of therapy. I am personally convinced it is at least 80% useless - I am not saying completely useless, as I am sure talking about a problem makes you feel better, although you can talk things through with your pet rabbit - I used to as a teen! There is also some value in learning some techniques such as CBT, but that can be learnt from a book, so again, not sure of the value of an actual therapist.

I've come to this conclusion through two main sources, children and holocaust survivors.

I have known thousands of children through teaching, and fostering, and many many of them have seen therapists. My main observation is that huge expectations are placed on therapy as some sort of magic bullet that is going to cure all problems, but the result is inevitably disappointment, as nothing changes. Parents, and children too are left wondering what magic was supposed to have happened, and why it didn't. One fostering social worker once mentioned to me that she thought it was a complete waste of time after the age of 8, and I think she was right. Between the ages of 5 and 8, you can possibly use therapy to teach children a bit about the emotions they are feeling, which can help them understand themselves, but beyond that there seems to be no benefit

My other source is coming from a family of holocaust survivors, who never had therapy, and survived by not talking about hte past - Many went on to have long, happy, successful lives, married and raised families, ( including me!) . They did not discuss the past, and I was told not to ask questions. They were not totally without problems. I was aware of the occasional nightmare, and several of them were binge eaters who became obese in old age. However, they lived with this problems quite happily, and there was no talk or expectation of "therapy" of any kind to address them

So I have started this thread to see what others think. Maybe I am wrong - I am open to being told that I am wrong in this. My experiences have not given me any confidence in arranging for therapy for any child, or suggesting it for any adult, but please tell me if it is really in fact a wonder drug and I have missed the point somehow!

I should say I have been sent for therapy twice myself - once after being in a road accident in which my closest school friend died, ( aged 16)it was awful, made me cry every time, I felt so much better when I was allowed to stop, and once sent by my employer after I was knifed ( quite gently!) by a student at school - I was taught some useful CBT, but in my opinion a book would have been more helpful than a difficult journey to speak to someone who was basically going very slowly through what I could have read for myself in half the time without the train journey.

so:

YABU - therapy is helpful - and please explain how!
YANBU - therapy is a waste of time /a money maker/ sending someone for therapy or providing it is just a way of letting someone feel they are doing something useful, when they are not

YABU. Just because it didn't change your life, doesn't mean it hasn't changed other lives.

At one point I was out of control, self harming myself and trauma-informed therapy saved my life. Now that I am older, I see many people my age who find it invaluable, and post-pandemic have become a part of their lives as they cope with the new normal. Talking out things regularly to a person who is qualified to help you recalibrate your life, if you can afford it, it can be life changing.

Your family / long term friend, yeah you can talk to them, but they can never be impartial or objective. Everyone has their own agenda. A lot of people just don't have the time to be my free therapist. And I'd never dream of dumping my troubles on my friend/family. I'd rather pay and get professional help, just like how I pay for other medical services when I need them (I am not from UK)

FruitTartlet · 03/08/2023 09:10

I personally think if everyone underwent a form of trauma therapy/debriefing from their childhoods at age 18-25 the world would be much better and safer place! Obviously impossible in practice.

CanNeverThinkOfAName what you said is right. It’s why I waited many years to have children. I knew wasn’t ready to touch my own childhood issues, and I didn’t know about therapy as a place to approach them, and wouldn’t have had the money to, so my issues felt to me unresolvable except by having a great partner relationship. A very, very risky strategy that.

I also instinctively knew from my mums unresolved issues that it would be awful for any kids I had if I ploughed on with becoming a mum without something changing for me. And once I did have DC (which was before I had therapy despite all that) it was incredibly hard.

I’ll be honest that in motherhood I’ve also definitely used MN as a place to have regular conversations that were unavailable to me elsewhere whether ‘therapeutic’ or not. I have seen that in a lot of other posters too. I think becoming a parent for women or men is a life stage at which some universal therapy or debriefing would be very valuable too.

FruitTartlet · 03/08/2023 09:00

PermanentTemporary your post is so insightful and really resonated with me. I’m very sorry for your loss also.

Goatymum · 03/08/2023 08:34

It’s a very good question.
I had cbt recently and felt it didn’t really help although it did make me realise why I went down certain thought patterns/behaviours. By the end (was nhs so didn’t pay) I cba with it as was so repetitive.
My adult DD loves therapy and would be in it permanently (not in it atm)! But it has to be the right fit.
DS (v late teen) has had several goes at it, he’s prob neurodiverse but none of them have picked this up. He’s not keen on it and thinks talking to his friends is as good (but I think it’s over burdening and I’ve said as much - that goes both ways - he’s had friends who have done the same.
I think it’s too much to put heavy stuff on friends all the time, which is where therapy comes in. There are different types and cbt won’t suit everyone- and some conditions can be helped with effective therapeutic input alongside drugs, chsnge of lifestyle etc.
Also grief/bereavement counselling has its place and that’s something I wish I had had when younger.

VestaTilley · 03/08/2023 07:48

YABU. I had EBT when I had PND and anxiety. It helped me work out a lot of stuff, taught me coping behaviours and how to rationalize my thoughts, and helped me understand how much stemmed from my - at times - dysfunctional childhood, and where DH had let me down after DC was born.

Lamelie · 03/08/2023 07:12

Lots of interesting points. There are definitely some unhelpful modalities and practitioners. One thing that jumps out from the OP is all the protective factors and tools (resilience) you have. This comment leapt out, “after I was knifed ( quite gently!)”

Blatantlyfemale · 03/08/2023 07:07

PermanentTemporary · 03/08/2023 01:25

I've been in therapy for a while now since dh took his own life. Obviously I would feel a lot better some years after that event anyway. And I can't tell you exactly why it seems to help me. So it's not very convincing. All I can say is that when I have stopped, things get worse. Personal conflicts, illogical decisions, self destructive behaviours.

It is of course noticeable that therapy has grown in popularity in societies where religion is declining, and also where formal conversation is less common. Regular ethical and personal discussions are normal in most religions, and where there is a clerical class of people, that's their role. I am not going to talk to a vicar or a rabbi and find religion unhelpful now. But even thigs like regular visiting and deeper conversations or correspondence just aren't supported. Therapy is about the only place I have those conversations any more.

This is such an interesting point.

Blatantlyfemale · 03/08/2023 06:44

WildUnchartedWaters · 02/08/2023 18:34

The headline? People are talking about it more, and social media.

My dad claims nobody was gay in his youth. Ian mckellen does a phenomenal speech about nobody in the premier league or in schools being gay 🤥 nobody in my entire year was autistic.

And ob that note, I attribute this generations mental health to the earlier generations inability or unwillingness to address neurodivetsity, sexuality and male mental health.

We are just talking ahout it more.

Re, the physical thing I understand what you're saying. But it cant be measured in tbe same way , can it? People have treatment and still die. It's the same on the mental health world. The only difference is , terminal illness or cancer is protected in the sense that a similar
OP about someone just needing to get over it because their granny did would be vilified. Bar a couple or oppositions that shes ignored, people have jumped on to bash counselling. Which takes me back to why we have the rates we have.

It’s simply not true that there is more mental ill health as people are talking about it more. Measurements of rates of mental ill health in children and teenagers have shown year on year increases, across all the measures, particularly in the last 15 years and especially amongst teenage girls. It’s a real effect.