Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Think less of my friend for reporting somebody for benefit fraud

133 replies

JimJams91 · 01/08/2023 19:50

My new-ish friend told me yesterday that she has reported her ex husbands new girlfriend for benefit fraud.

She doesn't know for certain that she's even committing benefit fraud but is feeling resentful about the small amount of CMS she receives from XH and doesn't like the thought of him spending money on another family (the girlfriend has children of her own that don't belong to the XH - children's father is deceased so the XH is likely spending a fair bit of time with/around them)

I felt quite uncomfortable when she told me about it and said I don't think it was the right thing to do because 1) there's no proof it's even happening and 2) if it is happening it'll impact her children more than it will her XH as he won't be the one in legal trouble or unable to feed his kids if his benefits are stopped.

Overall I don't like the idea of being spiteful to a woman who has done you no wrong just because you have a grudge against an ex. The ex seems like a complete waste of space but the girlfriend is a total stranger to her and has never done her any harm (and wasn't an OW)

I know benefit fraud is completely unacceptable but there's nothing to say it's even happening. Even if it was she has reported for the wrong reasons.

Do you think I'm being unreasonable for being against what she's done? If your friend told you this what would your reaction be?

OP posts:
SleepingStandingUp · 01/08/2023 20:26

Yeah, I'm with you . It isn't about the fraud claim, it's the making something up to be spiteful
Don't cross her eh?

JimJams91 · 01/08/2023 20:25

It makes me wonder what else she's capable of if somebody finds themselves in her bad books for whatever reason. Reports to social services? Fictitious reports for tax fraud? Etc.

It feels somewhat dangerous to know somebody who thinks it's acceptable to do things like that.

Unfortunately I don't think I'll be able to continue this friendship which is a shame for our children as that's how we met in the first place, my DS and her DS hit it off at a football club.

OP posts:
NettleTea · 01/08/2023 20:23

I was reported once, by a neighbour who wanted to put the kybosh on a business I was involved in, and to scupper a planning application by getting me out of the way.

She assumed I was unemployed, but I was actually self employed and had always kept meticulous records, but did recieve tax credits. Even so it was terrifying, and took months to sort out the mess that was made. It also came at a time when my eldest child was seriously ill in hospital. The investigating officer was very kind, but as people above said, all benefits get put on hold and they take one hell of a time to get going again - especially housing benefit - which can cause terrible cash flow problems / bills that cannot be paid / risks of evictions especially if you are close to the breadline.

She could have MH issues, and this could spiral her into a terrible state. She could already be in some financial difficulties, and this could cause her and her children to really suffer. And thats on a whim, to be spiteful, not even on any evidence

The other thing is that, if she WERE found guilty, there is a chance she could be imprisoned. And her children put into care. Thats a really nasty thing to do to another woman. Especially one who has lost her husband. Benefits arent exactly living the high life

Fallenangelofthenorth · 01/08/2023 20:23

I think it's a horrible thing to do, and no, I wouldn't be friends with someone like this.

Twilight7777 · 01/08/2023 20:23

YANBU, especially at this time when most people are struggling with the COL, it would be awful for someone to lose their benefits even temporarily whilst they are investigated for fraud. Hopefully HMRC will realise it’s just a case of ex jealousy.

Frankola · 01/08/2023 20:21

Considering she has no proof and it's due to her own vindictive opinions I agree OP, your new friend doesn't sound nice

JimJams91 · 01/08/2023 20:21

Dinopawus · 01/08/2023 20:18

Does she even know the ex's partner is claiming benefits? Her DH may have left a pension or life insurance.

I'm not condoning benefit fraud, but like you OP I'm not sure this was right.

She thinks the girlfriend is a SAHM and has automatically assumed that she must be claiming full benefits in order for that to be possible. I don't think she has any actual reason to suspect she's on benefits in the first place, other than that. It's alot of assumption.

OP posts:
gazpachosoupday · 01/08/2023 20:20

The thing is, she might have screwed herself.

If we say, Ex has moved into the house and she hasnt reported this, thanks to your friend's report, the benefits get switched and if she is claiming CMS, that goes down because of the new girlfriends children.

Kangarude · 01/08/2023 20:20

Again, apologies for my ignorance. It's ridiculous that lives could be so badly impacted by a spurious allegation.

JimJams91 · 01/08/2023 20:18

LovelyAutumndays · 01/08/2023 20:17

This is not the case. My benefits were stopped for 7 weeks because they though I had savings hidden.
Someone had reported it to them. I had no savings.
I have 4 children -2 with disabilities.
Those 7 weeks were the worst weeks ever. I couldn't pay my rent (private rent) and I had could not even apply for emergency payments because they had closed my universal claim.
I literally had no money. I had to put in a mandatory reconsideration which went in my favour and it was agreed I had no hidden savings.
I was overdrawn on my overdraft (got charged £5 a day for being over) so ended up with over £300 in charges. All my Direct debits bounced. More charges.
I got so ill with the stress - migraines and blood pressure Sky high.
The council gave me details of a food bank that I couldn't even get to as it was 4 miles away and I had no money for a bus fare!
I was making 5 calls a day to Universal credit (I couldn't put anything on my journal as they had closed it). I kept being given wrong information/ promised call backs that never happened.
Honestly don't report anyone for benefit fraud unless you are absolutely certain.

I'm sorry, that sounds like utter hell 💐

OP posts:
Dinopawus · 01/08/2023 20:18

Does she even know the ex's partner is claiming benefits? Her DH may have left a pension or life insurance.

I'm not condoning benefit fraud, but like you OP I'm not sure this was right.

Kangarude · 01/08/2023 20:17

abyssinianrosette · 01/08/2023 20:08

Not true. Benefits being sanctioned often means months or even years of financial insecurity , poverty. Suicides have occurred from innocent deserving people having their benefits stopped.

I'm claiming 100% honestly but I still have a huge fear of pissing someone off and then doing this to me. I can't work anymore, I've been very unwell. I realise I probably think about this way more than I should because of poor mental health but it is a real fear for many people, even those who don't deal with anxiety and paranoid ideation.

I didn't realise benefits would be stopped until someone pointed this out upthread.

I'm sorry to read that you are suffering so much Flowers

LovelyAutumndays · 01/08/2023 20:17

Kangarude · 01/08/2023 19:54

I wouldn't think anything of it. If she's not cheating the benefits system there won't be a problem.

This is not the case. My benefits were stopped for 7 weeks because they though I had savings hidden.
Someone had reported it to them. I had no savings.
I have 4 children -2 with disabilities.
Those 7 weeks were the worst weeks ever. I couldn't pay my rent (private rent) and I had could not even apply for emergency payments because they had closed my universal claim.
I literally had no money. I had to put in a mandatory reconsideration which went in my favour and it was agreed I had no hidden savings.
I was overdrawn on my overdraft (got charged £5 a day for being over) so ended up with over £300 in charges. All my Direct debits bounced. More charges.
I got so ill with the stress - migraines and blood pressure Sky high.
The council gave me details of a food bank that I couldn't even get to as it was 4 miles away and I had no money for a bus fare!
I was making 5 calls a day to Universal credit (I couldn't put anything on my journal as they had closed it). I kept being given wrong information/ promised call backs that never happened.
Honestly don't report anyone for benefit fraud unless you are absolutely certain.

Missingmyusername · 01/08/2023 20:13

Elsiebear90 · 01/08/2023 20:00

Why did she think his new girlfriend was the committing benefit fraud? Surely she would have to provide more info than “I think she might be” for them to bother investigating?

Exactly.

pointythings · 01/08/2023 20:09

Kangarude · 01/08/2023 19:54

I wouldn't think anything of it. If she's not cheating the benefits system there won't be a problem.

Except that of course there will be. She will be subjected to all the stress of an investigation and may well have her money stopped during that investigation, leaving her financially short. All because of pure spite. It's hateful behaviour and if any friend of mine did this, they would not be my friend any longer.

MrsTerryPratchett · 01/08/2023 20:08

Kangarude · 01/08/2023 19:54

I wouldn't think anything of it. If she's not cheating the benefits system there won't be a problem.

She's wasting the time and money of the benefits system on something she doesn't even know. Malicious reports are a massive issue in many areas.

abyssinianrosette · 01/08/2023 20:08

Kangarude · 01/08/2023 19:54

I wouldn't think anything of it. If she's not cheating the benefits system there won't be a problem.

Not true. Benefits being sanctioned often means months or even years of financial insecurity , poverty. Suicides have occurred from innocent deserving people having their benefits stopped.

I'm claiming 100% honestly but I still have a huge fear of pissing someone off and then doing this to me. I can't work anymore, I've been very unwell. I realise I probably think about this way more than I should because of poor mental health but it is a real fear for many people, even those who don't deal with anxiety and paranoid ideation.

Elsiebear90 · 01/08/2023 20:08

I think it’s unreasonable to punish his gf for him paying a shit amount of maintenance, her issue should be with him, not his partner. It does sound like it’s been done purely out of spite.

OhcantthInkofaname · 01/08/2023 20:07

I wouldn't be calling her friend. That type of pettiness is just unacceptable.

sparkleshin · 01/08/2023 20:06

Youre not being unreasonable
benefits are stopped while investigations are ongoing

JimJams91 · 01/08/2023 20:06

Posted too soon.

She's under the impression the girlfriend is a SAHM therefore in receipt of full benefits which she would be defrauding by not declaring a partner moving in.

OP posts:
Kangarude · 01/08/2023 20:05

Hopefully it would take more than one report, based on zero evidence, to stop someone's benefits.

JimJams91 · 01/08/2023 20:04

Elsiebear90 · 01/08/2023 20:00

Why did she think his new girlfriend was the committing benefit fraud? Surely she would have to provide more info than “I think she might be” for them to bother investigating?

She believes it's happening because much of the time her XH has their two children he has them at his girlfriends house (as told by the children)

She has taken that to mean he is living with the girlfriend full time and that she's "probably" not declaring it.

OP posts:
Thighdentitycrisis · 01/08/2023 20:03

I would feel the same as you too

Kangarude · 01/08/2023 20:03

homeforme · 01/08/2023 19:58

There will be. If an investigation takes place the person's benefits will be stopped whilst things are checked out.

Sorry, I didn't realise that.