Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Think less of my friend for reporting somebody for benefit fraud

133 replies

JimJams91 · 01/08/2023 19:50

My new-ish friend told me yesterday that she has reported her ex husbands new girlfriend for benefit fraud.

She doesn't know for certain that she's even committing benefit fraud but is feeling resentful about the small amount of CMS she receives from XH and doesn't like the thought of him spending money on another family (the girlfriend has children of her own that don't belong to the XH - children's father is deceased so the XH is likely spending a fair bit of time with/around them)

I felt quite uncomfortable when she told me about it and said I don't think it was the right thing to do because 1) there's no proof it's even happening and 2) if it is happening it'll impact her children more than it will her XH as he won't be the one in legal trouble or unable to feed his kids if his benefits are stopped.

Overall I don't like the idea of being spiteful to a woman who has done you no wrong just because you have a grudge against an ex. The ex seems like a complete waste of space but the girlfriend is a total stranger to her and has never done her any harm (and wasn't an OW)

I know benefit fraud is completely unacceptable but there's nothing to say it's even happening. Even if it was she has reported for the wrong reasons.

Do you think I'm being unreasonable for being against what she's done? If your friend told you this what would your reaction be?

OP posts:
abyssinianrosette · 01/08/2023 21:23

Kangarude · 01/08/2023 20:17

I didn't realise benefits would be stopped until someone pointed this out upthread.

I'm sorry to read that you are suffering so much Flowers

Thank you . Much appreciated .

JimJams91 · 01/08/2023 21:23

MyOtherCarisAFerrari · 01/08/2023 21:12

So, she knows the girlfriend's name and address at least, yes?
Otherwise this whole thing is a farce.
I agree with PP it's a spiteful thing to do but how can you report someone for benefit fraud if you don't even know that they claim benefits?

She got the surname by looking her up on social media. She must have the address otherwise she wouldn't have been able to make a report I wouldn't have thought.

OP posts:
SkylarSpirit · 01/08/2023 21:22

I actually wrote a newspaper article on this last year.

The government release statistics detailing the finances surrounding benefit fraud.

First, the amount of disability benefit fraud is negligible (you don't say what kind of benefit fraud she has reported, but cases like this usually are disability benefit - certainly Mumsnet is very keen on "disabled people committing benefit fraud" threads), yet disability benefit fraud receives an amount of attention that is hugely disproportionate.

The largest percentage of benefits fraud is actually pension fraud (meaning, people of pension age who lie about their personal circumstances to receive more state pension than they are entitled to), but you never hear a word about pensioners defrauding the state, you'd certainly never see a BBC TV show where a TV presenter goes around confronting elderly people who are stealing from the government by fiddling their pensions, even though pension fraud is eight times higher than DSA fraud.

Why? Because pensioners have the highest voter turnout, and no political party wants to risk pissing them off. So pension fraud continues, while disabled people are demonised.

Second, something like 89% of all reports of benefit fraud are found to be fraudulent and/or malicious reports. Ie the person claiming benefits is not committing any fraud, the person who reported them was either deliberately lying out of malice, or ignorantly assumed they weren't entitled to benefits due to stuff like "I saw my neighbour gardening once so they clearly must be pretending to be disabled to scam benefits" without realising the neighbour has a terminal diagnosis.

I don't have the exact stats to hand, but the government spends significantly more money investigating claims of benefit fraud, than they recover from genuine cases of benefit fraud.

People maliciously reporting people they dislike for benefit fraud costs our country millions.

If the government stopped investigating benefit fraud entirely, it would actually save the government money. That would never happen, because benefits claimants are a useful scapegoat who the government and the media have demonised to the point most people are extremely surprised to learn that disability benefit fraud is so extremely low, and that most allegations of benefit fraud are found to be false.

Crimeismymiddlename · 01/08/2023 21:21

This is beyond, she has no proof or knowledge and has just done it to cause trouble.
I don’t hold the MN belief that hardly anyone commits benefit fraud, I think it’s far more widespread than people think. Your friend is not fighting for the tax payer she has done a nasty thing against some she doesn’t know out of jealousy-the girlfriend might work and own her home or rent without any UC help, how would she explain to her employer that she is being investigated for benefit fraud.
I would stay clear as she sounds awful, most people don’t admit stuff like that out loud.

JudgeAnderson · 01/08/2023 21:20

And she should be working.

Why? She may have life insurance or a pension from her late husband and is perfectly in her rights not to.
Assuming she actually doesn't, anyway.

MyOtherCarisAFerrari · 01/08/2023 21:13

Mariposista · 01/08/2023 21:12

The GF has got nothing to fear if she’s got nothing to hide.
And she should be working.

But her benefits might be stopped. That is, if she even claims any.
Guilty until proven innocent...

MyOtherCarisAFerrari · 01/08/2023 21:12

So, she knows the girlfriend's name and address at least, yes?
Otherwise this whole thing is a farce.
I agree with PP it's a spiteful thing to do but how can you report someone for benefit fraud if you don't even know that they claim benefits?

Mariposista · 01/08/2023 21:12

The GF has got nothing to fear if she’s got nothing to hide.
And she should be working.

DrManhattan · 01/08/2023 21:11

The whole system needs fixing. I know a couple of dads who pay nothing for their kids as they have their own businesses and don't declare their earnings correctly. I can see why your friend is annoyed but reporting fraud inaccurately won't help anyone.

Titicacacandle · 01/08/2023 21:05

I'd find it petty and spiteful and vengeful. Not traits I'd like in a friend.

MySugarBabyLove · 01/08/2023 21:00

I think anything done out of spite is wrong, even if it’s true.

I don’t believe that benefit fraud is nobody’s business, and I do think that there are situations where reports are deserved, But she’s not reported her because she believes she’s committing benefit fraud, she’s reported her because she doesn’t like the fact her husband is in a relationship with her.

TBH it’s very much luck of the draw as to whether benefit fraud is even investigated. There are people on here who have maliciously been reported, and then there will be people who are reported, who are genuinely committing benefit fraud and the DWP do nothing.

I know someone who was committing benefit fraud. I didn’t report her, but someone I know did, and nothing ever came of it. And yes, with absolute certainty she was committing benefit fraud - was claiming carer’s allowance for her mother who lived in a different part of the country. The mother was complicit, the individual was registered on the electoral role at the mother’s house, was on the council tax bill and receiving council tax benefit, and was quite open about it. Nothing was ever done.

WiddlinDiddlin · 01/08/2023 21:00

It's a pretty vicious thing to do, and spectacularly stupid.

If she loses her benefits, surely she's going to need more financial assistance from her partner, your friends ex - so he'll have LESS money to go around.

caringcarer · 01/08/2023 20:55

Missingmyusername · 01/08/2023 20:13

Exactly.

I think she would have to have some evidence that the gf had moved bf in. If there is no evidence because it hasn't happened then DWP will soon lose interest and move on to someone else.

abyssinianrosette · 01/08/2023 20:53

Indigotree · 01/08/2023 20:50

It's very hard on single disabled people or mothers if a partner moves in but doesn't pay any rent/bills...yet the claimant could be prosecuted for claiming benefits nevertheless.

I agree. I think the system needs sorting.

Indigotree · 01/08/2023 20:50

abyssinianrosette · 01/08/2023 20:41

That's a good question. I would guess it's if someone told you they the told the DWP that they're living alone when you know full well they living with their partner full time.
or claiming JSA but working cash in hand for more than 16 hours per week. But yeah obviously you would have to know these details about that persons life pretty well. And it's unlikely someone who is on the fiddle would tell anyone unless they very stupid.

It's very hard on single disabled people or mothers if a partner moves in but doesn't pay any rent/bills...yet the claimant could be prosecuted for claiming benefits nevertheless.

Indigotree · 01/08/2023 20:48

It's perfectly legal for her ex to stay at his girlfriend's and look after the children as much as they like, as long as he pays bills at his own address. It would only be benefit fraud if he were giving a regular income (e.g. paying her towards housekeeping) to his girlfriend and she didn't declare it.

Also, you can't just get single parent benefits — Labour phased those out and now you have to start looking for work when your youngest is tiny. There's no way she'll just be living on benefits without regular jobcentre meetings and proving she's spending 25-35 hours a week looking for work on top of looking after her children.

It sounds incredibly spiteful of your friend and I certainly wouldn't want to know someone who behaved in that way. I'd contact the benefits office and let them know it's a malicious hoax accusation as it could have very serious impacts indeed on the family concerned if they're unable to pay rent or buy food for an indefinite period of time.

LovelyAutumndays · 01/08/2023 20:44

@Exworkcoach what would it be down to?
I had no problems for 2 years and then all of a sudden they started going on about savings they thought had stashed somewhere from the sale of a property.
I asked what made them all of a sudden question this and they said the only way was if someone told them.
Honestly I went through hell.

abyssinianrosette · 01/08/2023 20:41

LifeIsGreatForUnicorns · 01/08/2023 20:29

Just wondering when it is “right” to report someone for benefit fraud then? As how would you fully know?🤔

That's a good question. I would guess it's if someone told you they the told the DWP that they're living alone when you know full well they living with their partner full time.
or claiming JSA but working cash in hand for more than 16 hours per week. But yeah obviously you would have to know these details about that persons life pretty well. And it's unlikely someone who is on the fiddle would tell anyone unless they very stupid.

Someoneonlyyouknow · 01/08/2023 20:40

She is nasty and vindictive and not someone you want to be friends with. She is also stupid - if the woman has any benefits stopped or reduced her household will be poorer and the XH may feel he wants to help. Your friends children may feel the impact, even if it's just dad having less money to buy treats for them. If your friend thinks XH CMS is calculated wrongly or he isn't paying then that is a separate issue.

Exworkcoach · 01/08/2023 20:38

homeforme · 01/08/2023 19:58

There will be. If an investigation takes place the person's benefits will be stopped whilst things are checked out.

Ex-DWP here. No they won’t. It’s actually pretty unlikely they’ll even investigate it, they’re so short staffed. The pp who said her benefits were stopped for 7 weeks - that wouldn’t have been down to a fraud tip-off.

LilyLemonade · 01/08/2023 20:34

Kangarude · 01/08/2023 20:20

Again, apologies for my ignorance. It's ridiculous that lives could be so badly impacted by a spurious allegation.

Your initial assumption was actually the common sense approach. You would think that 'innocent until proven guilty' would apply - but not under our punitive benefits system.

To the OP - I agree with everyone else. I actually don't think she should report even if she had some evidence. It's just not her business.

Arabels · 01/08/2023 20:33

Yanbu. What a spiteful, highly damaging thing to do to someone and their children for no better reason than jealousy.

Fallenangelofthenorth · 01/08/2023 20:30

LifeIsGreatForUnicorns · 01/08/2023 20:29

Just wondering when it is “right” to report someone for benefit fraud then? As how would you fully know?🤔

Probably never?

Why would you?

Fallenangelofthenorth · 01/08/2023 20:29

JimJams91 · 01/08/2023 20:25

It makes me wonder what else she's capable of if somebody finds themselves in her bad books for whatever reason. Reports to social services? Fictitious reports for tax fraud? Etc.

It feels somewhat dangerous to know somebody who thinks it's acceptable to do things like that.

Unfortunately I don't think I'll be able to continue this friendship which is a shame for our children as that's how we met in the first place, my DS and her DS hit it off at a football club.

Yes, that would be my worry too.

I just couldn't be friendly towards someone who'd do something so nasty and spiteful. We'd have nothing in common.

LifeIsGreatForUnicorns · 01/08/2023 20:29

Just wondering when it is “right” to report someone for benefit fraud then? As how would you fully know?🤔

Swipe left for the next trending thread