Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be shocked that a man in his mid-twenties does not work for a living?

611 replies

queenofsheep · 01/08/2023 16:48

DD's boyfriend, older than DD by a year, does not work. He got his degree, now lives off rental income and an allowance through a family trust fund. AIBU to be shocked that there are men/boys in their twenties who are allowed to do this?

He and DD seem happy. DD isn't concerned at all. He insists that it is work because he has to manage his houses. He and DD go on nice holidays and attend parties.

OP posts:
Indigotree · 04/08/2023 00:22

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 03/08/2023 22:00

Who cares whether or not he has a job? Talk about misery wants company.

No one is obliged to use their assets "for the benefit of society." FFS, many people on this thread are living above bare subsistence, meaning you have room in your budget to pare down to rock-bottom and use the rest of your funds/assets/goods "for the benefit of society." Are you doing so? If not, why not?

He's a young man with perhaps 65 years of living ahead of him. More power to him if he can make it on his investment income, pay his taxes and actually enjoy life from day to day. He has plenty of time in future to "benefit society."

At least he's not ON benefits.

Actually I was brought up to live like that, yes, and I have friends who do so also. It's called living ethically rather than taking more than your share.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 04/08/2023 00:13

Kisskiss · 03/08/2023 21:22

because if you have loads of properties you normally get the agency to manage them and if you have only a handful you can do it on the side of your actual job. Lots of people do this!

Lots of people with loads of properties also manage them themselves like a job. Not everyone spends money on agents - especially if the have the time to do it.

Spinewars23 · 03/08/2023 23:01

I know a male, brought up three children in last 12 years, never done a day’s work, all you hear is them whinging about cold or flu.

Fibroid single woman seeing gynae if as it hasn’t quite ruined life 🤬never had to go for a sleep at 1pm before now, never had to worry urine output doesn’t meet input, this country is disgustingly unjust. (Whether that’s another thread Mumsnet promotes in hiding) but manhood supports.

Cosyblankets · 03/08/2023 22:28

pointythings · 03/08/2023 21:26

I worry about your obsession with the idea that young men should work. Why not young women?

As far as I'm concerned he's paying his way and he isn't taking a job someone else would need more. Fine by me.

Reverse snobbery is actually a thing.

Because it's not really about men in general it's about her daughter's boyfriend

WorldCuppa · 03/08/2023 22:22

The OP is obviously bitter because she’s got a sh1t job and wants everyone else to suffer too. Misery loves company eh? I say good luck to him.

LaDamaDeElche · 03/08/2023 22:21

But even those awful bank people have to show up and be accountable to someone in their day to day activities. There’s a difference between “having a private income” and “having a job”. Managing assets of your own, however acquired, is not a job, because the locus of control is not external I don't agree, otherwise anyone running their own business would fall into the category of not having a job, as at the end of the day they only have to be accountable to themselves. If he was getting an income just from his trust fund, I'd agree, but managing a portfolio of properties is a job. He has to pay taxes, ensure that the properties are maintained and profitable. My parents were property developers and landlords. They didn't inherit anything, they fixed up the properties themselves and managed them too and it was definitely a job, one that made them a shit ton of money.

Catsmere · 03/08/2023 22:08

Think of it this way, OP - he's one less person competing in the job market!

It's his own money, he's not sponging off anyone.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 03/08/2023 22:00

Who cares whether or not he has a job? Talk about misery wants company.

No one is obliged to use their assets "for the benefit of society." FFS, many people on this thread are living above bare subsistence, meaning you have room in your budget to pare down to rock-bottom and use the rest of your funds/assets/goods "for the benefit of society." Are you doing so? If not, why not?

He's a young man with perhaps 65 years of living ahead of him. More power to him if he can make it on his investment income, pay his taxes and actually enjoy life from day to day. He has plenty of time in future to "benefit society."

At least he's not ON benefits.

Moomindroll · 03/08/2023 21:41

LaDamaDeElche · 03/08/2023 21:37

i mean, an income without effort, does not “a job” make We have no idea if he purchased these properties himself, whether he uses a management company or manages them himself, the number he has, whether he's bought properties and done them up etc etc. Plenty of people don't put in the effort for their income - I've got friends who are bankers who don't work particularly hard to earn an obscene salary. Difference is they're playing about with other people's money rather than a job which involves their own assets.

But even those awful bank people have to show up and be accountable to someone in their day to day activities. There’s a difference between “having a private income” and “having a job”. Managing assets of your own, however acquired, is not a job, because the locus of control is not external.

LaDamaDeElche · 03/08/2023 21:37

i mean, an income without effort, does not “a job” make We have no idea if he purchased these properties himself, whether he uses a management company or manages them himself, the number he has, whether he's bought properties and done them up etc etc. Plenty of people don't put in the effort for their income - I've got friends who are bankers who don't work particularly hard to earn an obscene salary. Difference is they're playing about with other people's money rather than a job which involves their own assets.

Moomindroll · 03/08/2023 21:28

LaDamaDeElche · 03/08/2023 21:09

Either way, it’s lovely for him that he’s able to be work shy, but I’m not required to respectful of it He has a property portfolio which he manages. He is working. This is a job.

Surely it depends on the scale - half a dozen flats managed by an agent, or the Duke of Westminster (with a £9bn property and investment portfolio), as to whether it constitutes “a job”?

i mean, an income without effort, does not “a job” make

Indigotree · 03/08/2023 21:27

ThatFraggle · 03/08/2023 21:21

Have you never watched Downtown Abbey, read Jane Austen?

There was a whole class of people who lived off rental income: the gentry. And in the UK we didn't guillotine them.

Some policies, such as inheritance tax, meant that we now have far fewer than there used to be. But some families were savvy and have retained that wealth.

In that world it was actually considered 'vulgar' to have a 9-5. Some have a hobby that keeps them occupied.

The 'gentry' still exist, and it sounds like you met one of them, OP.

This.
I'd worry as he doesn't seem to be using his wealth to do good for society, which I and most people I know certainly would, but otherwise I'd be glad if it potentially meant my grandchildren inherited wealth! ;)

pointythings · 03/08/2023 21:26

I worry about your obsession with the idea that young men should work. Why not young women?

As far as I'm concerned he's paying his way and he isn't taking a job someone else would need more. Fine by me.

Reverse snobbery is actually a thing.

Kisskiss · 03/08/2023 21:25

Moomindroll · 03/08/2023 21:01

I agree with OP that it’s weird. I know several people with private wealth. I know them through work. Yes, they don’t need to work, but they do because they gain something more than money from it or because they gain more money from it!

the thing that I find weird in all this, is that those people would generally side with the OP, making me wonder if the anti-OP outage is actually formed more from people who wish they didn’t have to, and so can’t see beyond their own ken, than people who have seen the possibility of not having to, and appreciate that work (in some respects) is its own reward- a concept that is maybe only available to those for whom it is a choice, not an obligation.

Either way, it’s lovely for him that he’s able to be work shy, but I’m not required to respectful of it.

Well said!

Kisskiss · 03/08/2023 21:22

LaDamaDeElche · 03/08/2023 21:05

But he is working! He’s in property management I don’t know why the OP and some other equally obtuse posters don’t understand this. Whether the properties are inherited or bought, done up and rented out, your job is in property management. It’s not a hard concept to grasp.

because if you have loads of properties you normally get the agency to manage them and if you have only a handful you can do it on the side of your actual job. Lots of people do this!

ThatFraggle · 03/08/2023 21:21

Have you never watched Downtown Abbey, read Jane Austen?

There was a whole class of people who lived off rental income: the gentry. And in the UK we didn't guillotine them.

Some policies, such as inheritance tax, meant that we now have far fewer than there used to be. But some families were savvy and have retained that wealth.

In that world it was actually considered 'vulgar' to have a 9-5. Some have a hobby that keeps them occupied.

The 'gentry' still exist, and it sounds like you met one of them, OP.

LSSG · 03/08/2023 21:20

Farmageddon · 01/08/2023 17:07

This is pretty standard for rich people OP, live off family money, inheritance, property etc. Then have a little side job/ hobby to keep them occupied.

He's not stealing and he's not scrounging so it's fair enough, but it probably would bother me in that he wouldn't necessarily have the same work ethic as your daughter.

I tend to think that never having to go out into the real world and earn your own money sort of ruins people...fair enough if people later in life decide to slow down and simplify their lives, but to be that young and never have really had a real job at all would be off-putting for me personally.

I agree with this.

immigrant002 · 03/08/2023 21:17

If you had enough money not to work why would you ? Isn't that the dream ? You sound bitter!

LaDamaDeElche · 03/08/2023 21:09

Either way, it’s lovely for him that he’s able to be work shy, but I’m not required to respectful of it He has a property portfolio which he manages. He is working. This is a job.

LaDamaDeElche · 03/08/2023 21:05

But he is working! He’s in property management I don’t know why the OP and some other equally obtuse posters don’t understand this. Whether the properties are inherited or bought, done up and rented out, your job is in property management. It’s not a hard concept to grasp.

Threenow · 03/08/2023 21:02

I'm not trying to shit talk him, yet I'm being called jealous and bitter by people who would rather side with wealth.

Oh don't be so ridiculous!!! What exactly is siding with wealth? I couldn't care less if people are wealthy or not, just as I couldn't care less if someone who doesn't have to work in a traditional job chooses not to.

You sound as though you are stuck in the good old class system which your country is entrenched in and are jealous of someone who has been born into wealth.

If my mother had come onto MN and started a thread like this about my boyfriend I would be furious - although my late DM was a lot less "shocked" about things than you appear to be.

Moomindroll · 03/08/2023 21:01

I agree with OP that it’s weird. I know several people with private wealth. I know them through work. Yes, they don’t need to work, but they do because they gain something more than money from it or because they gain more money from it!

the thing that I find weird in all this, is that those people would generally side with the OP, making me wonder if the anti-OP outage is actually formed more from people who wish they didn’t have to, and so can’t see beyond their own ken, than people who have seen the possibility of not having to, and appreciate that work (in some respects) is its own reward- a concept that is maybe only available to those for whom it is a choice, not an obligation.

Either way, it’s lovely for him that he’s able to be work shy, but I’m not required to respectful of it.

SmileyClare · 03/08/2023 20:58

There’s just not enough information to judge.

Maybe he parties most nights and doesn’t get up til 4 every day, maybe he pays an agent to manage the properties, maybe he and dd are forever jetting off on holidays and op is concerned that neither of them seem to have a work ethic or respect for people who have no choice but to work?

Can we have any more context op?

cartagenagina · 03/08/2023 20:51

queenofsheep · 03/08/2023 19:32

Odd don't you think that I'm being blasted for suggesting that young men should work? It's a completely normal path to take. I'm sure other privileged young men would make better use of their advantages, or am I mistaken? Hmm

But he is working! He’s in property management.

This thread is like banging your head against a brick wall.

OP, I don’t know what is wrong with you, but if you want to maintain a pleasant relationship with your DD you should probably keep your rather weird thoughts to yourself.

GoodChat · 03/08/2023 20:45

I'm not trying to shit talk him, yet I'm being called jealous and bitter by people who would rather side with wealth.

You are shit talking him though.

Nobody's siding with wealth. People are trying to explain that his life is just different to yours.

Why are you so worried?

Do you think DD will give up her studies to live off his money and be put in a vulnerable position?

Are you concerned that she'll enjoy the lavish lifestyle and forget her roots?