Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be shocked that a man in his mid-twenties does not work for a living?

611 replies

queenofsheep · 01/08/2023 16:48

DD's boyfriend, older than DD by a year, does not work. He got his degree, now lives off rental income and an allowance through a family trust fund. AIBU to be shocked that there are men/boys in their twenties who are allowed to do this?

He and DD seem happy. DD isn't concerned at all. He insists that it is work because he has to manage his houses. He and DD go on nice holidays and attend parties.

OP posts:
Happyfluffball · 04/08/2023 12:58

5128gap · 04/08/2023 11:57

Id expect someone with that level of privilege to be giving something back, volunteering in some way, not spending his life in pleasure and idleness. I wouldn't want my DD to be in a relationship with a man who only took from life, possibly in this case from other people too, as private rents are frequently extortionate; as it indicates a flawed character, selfish, greedy, and hedonistic, traits that don't make for a great partner.

I have a number of family members who have never worked a day in their life. They don't pay taxes because they don't have income. They spend a lot of their time on hobbies, sports, learning new languages, travelling to new places, doing a post graduate degree now and then in an area they love. They take great care of themselves. They also do not take from the state because they are going to inherit enough to live well for the rest of their lives.

Why would they go and work in the city like me for a salary that won't make any difference to their lives. I am a top 2% earner in the UK and what I make is pocket change to my cousin. I have to deal with long hours, stress, not seeing my kids much all in the name of profit for a company and management who do not care about me. I am just another body to them. I picked my university degree based on what I thought was more employable not what I enjoyed.

They're not hurting anyone and they are more happy and fulfilled than me and all my colleagues. There's a lot of reverse snobbery going on from people who think that they are worthless just because they chose to live differently.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 04/08/2023 12:57

Ellyess · 04/08/2023 12:46

Blossomtoes ·

You complain that
"I’ve read some pretentious, pseudo intellectual twaddle "
and say JaukiVexnoydi is the worst.

Maybe you are simply not intelligent or sensible enough to think about what someone else says and to learn from a person who has knowledge from an advanced education and background.

You could gain a lot if you stopped posing and trying trying to sound clever, and instead took in what people with greater knowledge than you bother to pass on.

Because you are just showing yourself up for what you really are - ignorant and rude.

And now we know the education and background of another poster.

Amazing.

This thread really is something else

WorldCuppa · 04/08/2023 12:54

This is the best thread ever.

Ellyess · 04/08/2023 12:46

Blossomtoes ·

You complain that
"I’ve read some pretentious, pseudo intellectual twaddle "
and say JaukiVexnoydi is the worst.

Maybe you are simply not intelligent or sensible enough to think about what someone else says and to learn from a person who has knowledge from an advanced education and background.

You could gain a lot if you stopped posing and trying trying to sound clever, and instead took in what people with greater knowledge than you bother to pass on.

Because you are just showing yourself up for what you really are - ignorant and rude.

Ellyess · 04/08/2023 12:33

JaukiVexnoydi ·

Well said! Very well explained. Many thanks.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 04/08/2023 12:05

whatabeautifulwedding · 04/08/2023 11:57

@YetMoreNewBeginnings precisely.

The assumptions that people arrive at on MN are outstanding.

It’s brilliant.

That his family are influential in politics is my favourite one yet.

You’d have thought the OP repeatedly avoiding questions about how many properties he manages would lead to assumptions that maybe it does take a lot of time, but not at all…

Can’t wait to see what else he’s accused of by the end of the thread!

5128gap · 04/08/2023 11:57

Id expect someone with that level of privilege to be giving something back, volunteering in some way, not spending his life in pleasure and idleness. I wouldn't want my DD to be in a relationship with a man who only took from life, possibly in this case from other people too, as private rents are frequently extortionate; as it indicates a flawed character, selfish, greedy, and hedonistic, traits that don't make for a great partner.

whatabeautifulwedding · 04/08/2023 11:57

@YetMoreNewBeginnings precisely.

The assumptions that people arrive at on MN are outstanding.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 04/08/2023 11:52

Kazzyhoward · 04/08/2023 11:01

He'll almost certainly have organised his affairs to pay less tax, because he has the flexibility to do so. That's flexibility that most people don't enjoy. He won't have been passive, there'll have been regular meetings between him (his parents etc) and various tax specialists, solicitors, etc. It, 100%, won't be an accident that there's a trust fund in place - the main reason for them being set up is tax avoidance. Pre-tax and post-tax returns will also have been a significant consideration when it came to deciding how to invest his money - he has chosen to invest in assets that give him a relatively low tax burden. He and his family won't have been passive in any of this - they'll have actively sought out tax exemptions, loopholes, reliefs, etc that simply aren't available to normal workers.

Yes, to a large extent, that's the fault of the politicians and vested interests, but I'd be happy to bet that some of his wider family are (or have been) influential in politics to some extent, to influence tax policy to their advantage.

So now not only do people on here know that he doesn’t have enough houses to make managing them a full time job, but that his family are influential in politics…

Thats actually hilarious

Tryingtokeepgoing · 04/08/2023 11:50

queenofsheep · 03/08/2023 14:37

It's surely a matter of principle as well as a genuine concern? Where I grew up, people worked unless they couldn't.

I'm not sure what you mean by matter of principle, unless its a baseless feeling that people should work. Surely people work either because they want to, or because they have to? Many people, at least when younger, are in the 'have to' category, but equally most people aspire to be, and work hard to ensure, that they are not in the 'have to' category. This guy doesn't have to work. He has time to enjoy his life, is able to do so without working and is involved in managing the income generating assets that provide income. I am not clear what the concern is?

whatabeautifulwedding · 04/08/2023 11:18

Spinewars23 · 03/08/2023 23:01

I know a male, brought up three children in last 12 years, never done a day’s work, all you hear is them whinging about cold or flu.

Fibroid single woman seeing gynae if as it hasn’t quite ruined life 🤬never had to go for a sleep at 1pm before now, never had to worry urine output doesn’t meet input, this country is disgustingly unjust. (Whether that’s another thread Mumsnet promotes in hiding) but manhood supports.

Eh?

Q2C4 · 04/08/2023 11:04

JaukiVexnoydi · 04/08/2023 02:39

The "protestant work ethic" has very much fallen out of fashion but it used to be that living an unproductive, non-useful and non-contributory life of leisure was seen as just as immoral as many more "active" forms of immorality.

But I approach it more as a physicist - in any system, entropy increases (that is, the world tends towards chaos and disorder) unless work is done to combat it. This is demonstrated in microcosm in every teenage bedroom on the planet. However, on a larger scale most jobs are in some way about creating order and rationality out of chaos in one form or another. People who do no work are creating chaos for some other bugger to clear up. It's intrinsically exploitative. Those with the fortune to not need a job to live can do their share of fighting against chaos by creating art, volunteering for charity, publicising good causes, all sorts of worthwhile things. Most of us have to do more work against chaos than the chaos we create because we have to in order to earn a living and run our households,so most of us are net forces against chaos. Some people are net creators of chaos through no fault of their own (especially kids) if they can't work. Those who could be a net contributor against chaos (which ultimately leads to destruction and collapse) but chose not to, are not on the side of good.

Entropy always increases, that's why it's called the arrow of time. The work done to remove disorder in one system creates more disorder in another.

Kazzyhoward · 04/08/2023 11:01

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 04/08/2023 08:09

That’s not down to an individual to change though.

you can’t seriously be suggesting he should be living a different life simply because the government have a taxation method in place that isn’t fair?

The ire for that should be aimed at the people that can change it. Though given he benefits from it and paid a smaller percentage of his income then many of us Mr Sunak is unlikely to be looking for it to change.

He'll almost certainly have organised his affairs to pay less tax, because he has the flexibility to do so. That's flexibility that most people don't enjoy. He won't have been passive, there'll have been regular meetings between him (his parents etc) and various tax specialists, solicitors, etc. It, 100%, won't be an accident that there's a trust fund in place - the main reason for them being set up is tax avoidance. Pre-tax and post-tax returns will also have been a significant consideration when it came to deciding how to invest his money - he has chosen to invest in assets that give him a relatively low tax burden. He and his family won't have been passive in any of this - they'll have actively sought out tax exemptions, loopholes, reliefs, etc that simply aren't available to normal workers.

Yes, to a large extent, that's the fault of the politicians and vested interests, but I'd be happy to bet that some of his wider family are (or have been) influential in politics to some extent, to influence tax policy to their advantage.

SmileyClare · 04/08/2023 08:15

We have no idea if he bought these properties himself

Seems likely he inherited them. But Yes maybe he saved up the money he earned doing a paper round in his teens to buy them with his own money.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 04/08/2023 08:09

Kazzyhoward · 04/08/2023 07:59

I don't care whether it's a "job" or not. What I care about is whether he's paying his "fair share" of tax. It's employed workers who are currently shouldering more than their fair share of the tax burden with student loan repayments, frozen tax thresholds, increases in NIC, workplace pensions, tapering away of child benefit, etc etc.

Those living on "unearned" income as defined by HMRC, such as rental income, dividends, interest, trust funds, etc pay less tax overall, because those "unearned" incomes aren't liable for NIC and those "unearned" incomes are more flexible and can be shared amongst family/spouses etc to save tax by using otherwise unused personal allowances, basic rate bands, etc., which an employed worker simply can't do.

So, yes, I would judge someone who's basically living on "investment" income, either from their own efforts or inherited or trust fund, because they're not paying as much tax as an employed worker. If the guy in question has an income of, say, £75k, his contribution to the country is a lot less than someone earning the same £75k as an employee. And that is completely wrong. It's almost a certainty that the guy in question (or whoever set up the trust fund for him) have taken steps to minimise the taxes payable - by lots of different ways that aren't open to an employed worker.

That’s not down to an individual to change though.

you can’t seriously be suggesting he should be living a different life simply because the government have a taxation method in place that isn’t fair?

The ire for that should be aimed at the people that can change it. Though given he benefits from it and paid a smaller percentage of his income then many of us Mr Sunak is unlikely to be looking for it to change.

Hungrycaterpillarsmummy · 04/08/2023 08:00

Sounds fantastic. Isnt that the dream?!

Kazzyhoward · 04/08/2023 07:59

I don't care whether it's a "job" or not. What I care about is whether he's paying his "fair share" of tax. It's employed workers who are currently shouldering more than their fair share of the tax burden with student loan repayments, frozen tax thresholds, increases in NIC, workplace pensions, tapering away of child benefit, etc etc.

Those living on "unearned" income as defined by HMRC, such as rental income, dividends, interest, trust funds, etc pay less tax overall, because those "unearned" incomes aren't liable for NIC and those "unearned" incomes are more flexible and can be shared amongst family/spouses etc to save tax by using otherwise unused personal allowances, basic rate bands, etc., which an employed worker simply can't do.

So, yes, I would judge someone who's basically living on "investment" income, either from their own efforts or inherited or trust fund, because they're not paying as much tax as an employed worker. If the guy in question has an income of, say, £75k, his contribution to the country is a lot less than someone earning the same £75k as an employee. And that is completely wrong. It's almost a certainty that the guy in question (or whoever set up the trust fund for him) have taken steps to minimise the taxes payable - by lots of different ways that aren't open to an employed worker.

Frogmila · 04/08/2023 07:56

Blossomtoes · 04/08/2023 07:36

I’ve read some pretentious, pseudo intellectual twaddle on MN but that wins the highest accolade. Top marks @JaukiVexnoydi.

I think it makes good sense.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 04/08/2023 07:49

I'm surprised that people are supporting a young man with a lifestyle of doing buggar all.

Given the OP has been very sparse with details about him, not even saying if he has one property or a few or loads we have no idea if he does bugger all at all.

People are just assuming. He says managing his properties is his job and the op has actually said nothing to contradict that. Just that they don’t agree.

Whether this young man needs to work or not is not really the issue; it's that his life has no purpose, aim or goal.

And that’s a massive assumption on your part made with very little information

Blossomtoes · 04/08/2023 07:36

I’ve read some pretentious, pseudo intellectual twaddle on MN but that wins the highest accolade. Top marks @JaukiVexnoydi.

THisbackwithavengeance · 04/08/2023 07:11

@JaukiVexnoydi

Hear hear.

No one is suggesting that the boyfriend - or indeed anyone with independent wealth - should go out and graft 50 hours a week in Asda and I'm surprised that people are supporting a young man with a lifestyle of doing buggar all.

Everyone should do something productive and meaningful otherwise what is the point?

How can you enjoy life's pleasurable experiences if that is all you experience? Surely if you spend your life yachting around the Caribbean and going to parties it just becomes meaningless and mundane. So then what?

I understand what the OP is saying totally. Whether this young man needs to work or not is not really the issue; it's that his life has no purpose, aim or goal.

JaukiVexnoydi · 04/08/2023 02:39

The "protestant work ethic" has very much fallen out of fashion but it used to be that living an unproductive, non-useful and non-contributory life of leisure was seen as just as immoral as many more "active" forms of immorality.

But I approach it more as a physicist - in any system, entropy increases (that is, the world tends towards chaos and disorder) unless work is done to combat it. This is demonstrated in microcosm in every teenage bedroom on the planet. However, on a larger scale most jobs are in some way about creating order and rationality out of chaos in one form or another. People who do no work are creating chaos for some other bugger to clear up. It's intrinsically exploitative. Those with the fortune to not need a job to live can do their share of fighting against chaos by creating art, volunteering for charity, publicising good causes, all sorts of worthwhile things. Most of us have to do more work against chaos than the chaos we create because we have to in order to earn a living and run our households,so most of us are net forces against chaos. Some people are net creators of chaos through no fault of their own (especially kids) if they can't work. Those who could be a net contributor against chaos (which ultimately leads to destruction and collapse) but chose not to, are not on the side of good.

Happyfluffball · 04/08/2023 02:38

queenofsheep · 01/08/2023 16:48

DD's boyfriend, older than DD by a year, does not work. He got his degree, now lives off rental income and an allowance through a family trust fund. AIBU to be shocked that there are men/boys in their twenties who are allowed to do this?

He and DD seem happy. DD isn't concerned at all. He insists that it is work because he has to manage his houses. He and DD go on nice holidays and attend parties.

Good for him. Why waste your life in corporate slavery if you don't need to. It is better to do something you enjoy with your life if you can afford it.

Anele22 · 04/08/2023 02:14

ConfusingTrousers · 04/08/2023 01:42

It's true no-one is obliged to use their assets for the benefit of society, but that's a legal question rather than a moral one. We will always exist in a world where there are rich people, and the rich will only ever exist because someone somewhere exploited the poor. The point is whether we just go along with that (as I've often done, I was born into privilege but I'm trying more not to waste it all on myself now) or try to change things. And we can change things and that's a good thing. Dismissing people as "jealous" for recognising that one person has a big pile of stuff while others are suffering, however many people you can get to agree with you and laugh at them, is a dark sign. You'll find it's not a wise concept to pass on to your kids. This planet is about to hit a point where we all get thrown back into depending on one another and your money won't matter. People will remember how you handled it, though, and that might make all the difference.
Tl;dr: THINK for God's sake, this isn't a game

Well put. A thoughtful and brave post. This has been a nasty thread and I couldn't put my finger on why but you've articulated it brilliantly.

ConfusingTrousers · 04/08/2023 01:42

It's true no-one is obliged to use their assets for the benefit of society, but that's a legal question rather than a moral one. We will always exist in a world where there are rich people, and the rich will only ever exist because someone somewhere exploited the poor. The point is whether we just go along with that (as I've often done, I was born into privilege but I'm trying more not to waste it all on myself now) or try to change things. And we can change things and that's a good thing. Dismissing people as "jealous" for recognising that one person has a big pile of stuff while others are suffering, however many people you can get to agree with you and laugh at them, is a dark sign. You'll find it's not a wise concept to pass on to your kids. This planet is about to hit a point where we all get thrown back into depending on one another and your money won't matter. People will remember how you handled it, though, and that might make all the difference.
Tl;dr: THINK for God's sake, this isn't a game

Swipe left for the next trending thread