Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Date got me to pay for expensive dinner - bin?

765 replies

Jonesjonsy · 01/08/2023 15:57

Met a guy online. First date, walk in the countryside near to where he lived. Seemed a really nice guy with great interests and gorgeous dog! Stopped at a cafe and had sandwich lunch about £8 each, no alcohol or anything. Very kindly he offered to pay and I accepted. no kiss or anything like that.

Second date he said he was going to be working near me and would I like to do something. I offered to book a pub dinner near to where he would clock off. Again it went well I thought, but conscious on seeing the prices on the menu I knew I wouldn’t want him to pay for me particularly as he had bought me the sandwich. At the end of the meal when he asked for the bill, I said you paid last time so I don’t want you paying again. He misconstrued this as me saying I would settle the whole thing (what I meant was we just had split it) and I guess I was so flummoxed that this had happened I just paid especially since the waitress was kind of hovering over us… I was embarrassed to talk about it. Bill was £110!

I guess I just wonder if this is a major red flag. I don’t know him well enough to determine and honestly it’s put me off I don’t think I want to meet up again. Yes I can afford it as I’ve worked really hard to build up my own business. I didn’t tell about money at all and am not flashy but I did talk about what I do and maybe he just made a assumption? AIBU?

OP posts:
DrSbaitso · 03/08/2023 20:25

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 03/08/2023 20:17

"the true purpose of etiquette is to make people feel comfortable and at ease in your company, "

Nope, not true. Though this gets trotted out a lot by people who are unclear on the concept.

Well I guess that's consistent with the idea that there's no good to be had in talking to people when trying to work out how best to treat them.

However, it shouldn't take 40 years of study to work out how to be pleasant company.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 03/08/2023 20:17

"the true purpose of etiquette is to make people feel comfortable and at ease in your company, "

Nope, not true. Though this gets trotted out a lot by people who are unclear on the concept.

DrSbaitso · 03/08/2023 20:02

ilyana · 03/08/2023 19:55

What good would that do? It would be much easier if everyone actually just followed social rules instead of expecting people to read their minds and saying things they don't actually mean. It's bizarre.

Social rules like not being abusive on the internet? Social rules that aren't actually universal and nowadays can even cause offence or hurt? Social rules that are exploited by a certain type of person to condescend rather than put people at ease? Social rules that clearly change with the times, or else we could just look at a guide from 1850 and have done with it? Social rules that, given the examples presented here, don't mean jack when it comes to actually treating people with mutual respect?

And if you truly don't mean it when you thank someone for buying you something because you don't think it cost enough to warrant it, it's in your own best interests not to make that known.

ilyana · 03/08/2023 19:55

WisherWood · 03/08/2023 19:52

I've collected and studied etiquette books for 40 years.

Have you tried speaking to actual humans? Just a thought.

What good would that do? It would be much easier if everyone actually just followed social rules instead of expecting people to read their minds and saying things they don't actually mean. It's bizarre.

WisherWood · 03/08/2023 19:52

I've collected and studied etiquette books for 40 years.

Have you tried speaking to actual humans? Just a thought.

willWillSmithsmith · 03/08/2023 18:25

Until she goes on a third date and gets more of an idea of his character it’s anyone’s guess what he’s really like. Maybe he’s sick of always footing the bill, maybe he thought OP was kind and generous, maybe he’s all for women’s equality and wanted to be wined and dined for a change or maybe he’s a just an idiot tight jerk. Hopefully OP will let us know, if she has another date with him. I’m getting quite curious 😁

DrSbaitso · 03/08/2023 17:45

Referring to the monetary value of a host's offering is beyond the pale.

This assumes that any thanks for generosity is a comment on the actual amount spent.

If you are under no obligation to give someone anything, then anything you do give them is generous. That's the point that people sneering at inexpensive drinks as not constituting generosity are missing.

At any rate, the true purpose of etiquette is to make people feel comfortable and at ease in your company, not to condescend and sneer. If one's version of it means not thanking someone for dinner but making repeated attacks on the Internet, I'd say it's not fit for purpose and I'm more than happy to eschew it.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 03/08/2023 17:19

@ilyana is correct.

I've collected and studied etiquette books for 40 years.

One thanks for the hospitality, not for the food or the amount spent. So gauche.

Referring to the monetary value of a host's offering is beyond the pale. Outings and visits are supposed to be primarily for companionship, with food or other amenities as incidental. Date Guy was perfectly correct to thank for a lovely evening without gushing over the amount that OP forked out. His manners sound quite good, actually.

CatMattress · 03/08/2023 16:40

If another date comes up set the expectations early: yes, I'd love to see you again. I'm free on x date and y date - just let me know when and where!

Then he's in charge and you can see what he plans and if he offers to pay etc etc. Should give you a better idea if he's a cheeky sod or a modern day feminist 😉

DrSbaitso · 03/08/2023 16:21

Curiouser and curiouser.

ilyana · 03/08/2023 16:14

DrSbaitso · 03/08/2023 16:03

And this is nonsense, because there's no way anyone would reference generosity unless the amount was what they considered high.

Maybe you wouldn't. Some of us have a different idea of what it means to be generous.

Ok fellas (I know some of you are here)...if you do decide to pay for dinner, and the lady says "Thank you, that's very kind/generous"...are you offended?

Or the women here, for that matter. If you bought him dinner and he said that, would you think he was an ill-mannered oik?

The reason I made the point was that I was saying it wasn't rude not to explicitly reference the amount spent. The poster said something like "he could have at least said thanks for the generosity" given the size of the bill, and my point was that etiquette-wise, that's actually a faux pas, so I don't think it would be fair to judge someone for that. He did say thank you.

You're now pretending that the bill being (to OP and most others) high isn't pretty much the sole reason that this thread even exists, and that we'd all be hear going back and forth about him not thanking her properly for a £3 coffee...knock yourself out.

As I said, you're being goady and arguing in bad faith, and I don't have time for it.

DrSbaitso · 03/08/2023 16:03

And this is nonsense, because there's no way anyone would reference generosity unless the amount was what they considered high.

Maybe you wouldn't. Some of us have a different idea of what it means to be generous.

Ok fellas (I know some of you are here)...if you do decide to pay for dinner, and the lady says "Thank you, that's very kind/generous"...are you offended?

Or the women here, for that matter. If you bought him dinner and he said that, would you think he was an ill-mannered oik?

ilyana · 03/08/2023 15:58

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

AutumnCrow · 03/08/2023 15:58

Thank you for the etiquette lessons, ilyana. They have been inspirational.

ilyana · 03/08/2023 15:54

DrSbaitso · 03/08/2023 15:47

I agree that you can't bring it up later, but I think it's rude to accept someone's generosity, which they were under no obligation to give, without acknowledging it or thanking them for it. The very fact that you think "generous" must mean "expensive" is itself very telling. So presumably you wouldn't think it generous if someone didn't spend enough on you.

But it's clear we have different ideas of etiquette. I suppose yours must serve you well somewhere because of your ever so classy way of defending it. Personally I don't see how.

But I do thank them for it! I just don't reference the money part. Yes, using the word "generous" in reference to something someone has just paid for absolutely refers to the monetary expense. Anyone arguing against that is being goady. You wouldn't say 'thank you for your generosity' if someone paid for a Starbucks, would you?

And now here you go with the mental gymnastics about people not spending enough on me, when that's not at all what we're talking about. I would feel extremely awkward if I paid a bill and someone made a show of thanking me. A sincere thank you is enough.

You clearly have a massive insecurity about your lack of knowledge of etiquette. Go and read a book on it and stop complaining to me. Nothing I'm saying is remotely controversial. Someone said the bloke should have thanked her for her generosity - I'm saying that plenty of people wouldn't, because they consider that crass. It doesn't make them a user or rude, as long as they said thank you for the evening in general.

DrSbaitso · 03/08/2023 15:52

ilyana · 03/08/2023 15:48

I do thank people. I just don't reference the amount spent, because I was brought up not to be crass and gauche. I still don't think you're getting that what's gauche is using the word "generous" because that's subjective. To some people, £110 is nothing, and gushing over it makes it very clear you're poor, and that can make them feel awkward and then create issues where they feel they always have to pay. That's why you don't refer to the money part at all! You say a gracious thank you and move on.

You're just making yourself look pathetic with your personal digs.

You don't give an amount, you acknowledge the generosity. Since you don't think it's generosity unless it reaches a certain price point, I can see why this confuses you.

As I said, if you find this "etiquette" works for you (because your esteemed "etiquette" is certainly lacking elsewhere) then by all means keep doing it. However, from the way you say people treat you, and the way you seem to treat other people, I can't see any way it's working for anyone. It's throwing quite a few things into a very different light.

Stay happy.

ilyana · 03/08/2023 15:48

DrSbaitso · 03/08/2023 15:37

Is this your idea of etiquette too?

It's absolutely fine to thank someone for being generous. I'd say it's good manners not to act like it didn't happen.

You've talked before about people not responding well to you. I think we may be seeing why. Not thanking people for their generosity towards you would appear to be just the start of it. Stay happy!

I do thank people. I just don't reference the amount spent, because I was brought up not to be crass and gauche. I still don't think you're getting that what's gauche is using the word "generous" because that's subjective. To some people, £110 is nothing, and gushing over it makes it very clear you're poor, and that can make them feel awkward and then create issues where they feel they always have to pay. That's why you don't refer to the money part at all! You say a gracious thank you and move on.

You're just making yourself look pathetic with your personal digs.

DrSbaitso · 03/08/2023 15:47

ilyana · 03/08/2023 15:42

And by the way, I wasn't even thinking of dates when I made that comment, I meant in general. If I go out with a group and someone kindly pays the entire bill, I say thank you and make a mental note to get them back in the future. I don't gush over how much they spent on me or imply that it was a lot.

There's a certain section of the population who seem to think it's normal to go on about who pays the bill or make a song and dance out of paying or not paying. It's very awkward and crass. You accept something or you don't accept, but once you've done it, that's that.

I agree that you can't bring it up later, but I think it's rude to accept someone's generosity, which they were under no obligation to give, without acknowledging it or thanking them for it. The very fact that you think "generous" must mean "expensive" is itself very telling. So presumably you wouldn't think it generous if someone didn't spend enough on you.

But it's clear we have different ideas of etiquette. I suppose yours must serve you well somewhere because of your ever so classy way of defending it. Personally I don't see how.

jannier · 03/08/2023 15:44

DrSbaitso · 03/08/2023 15:41

No, I can't see how on earth she's a gold digger. She bought dinner! A gold digger would never have expected to pay for herself, nor paid for everything even if there was a moment of misunderstanding.

He wouldn't have known she was paying for dinner until the bill came and she finally said she was paying so up to that point he may well have thought what a cheeky mare after my money.

ilyana · 03/08/2023 15:42

DrSbaitso · 03/08/2023 14:49

What etiquette is that? That you literally can't mention what was bought for you when saying thank you for it? It's not "thank you for spending £110", it's "thank you for dinner, it was very generous of you". Do you not thank people for birthday gifts either?

Didn't you say the other day that men have treated you really badly? Does this etiquette work?

And by the way, I wasn't even thinking of dates when I made that comment, I meant in general. If I go out with a group and someone kindly pays the entire bill, I say thank you and make a mental note to get them back in the future. I don't gush over how much they spent on me or imply that it was a lot.

There's a certain section of the population who seem to think it's normal to go on about who pays the bill or make a song and dance out of paying or not paying. It's very awkward and crass. You accept something or you don't accept, but once you've done it, that's that.

jannier · 03/08/2023 15:42

Livelifelaughter · 03/08/2023 15:35

Honestly I really can't see how OP is a gold digger or anything thing similar. When I have been on dates and asked where I would like to go to I pick a restaurant that I have been to a few times before and enjoy. It might not be as high end as my date would normally go to or it may be more but it's giving him an idea of my life style. Money is relative £55 per head isn't cheap but she's not taken him to Claridges in the hope he's paying...

Neither is she taking him to an £8 lunch ...their lunch bill was more than many spend on a weekly family shop. Going £8 to £55 is masive

DrSbaitso · 03/08/2023 15:41

jannier · 03/08/2023 15:39

Because she let him pay first time then booked somewhere really expensive how's he to know she doesn't expect him to pay it all...then he's left in a dilemma of saying I can't afford this or letting it go...once she insisted on paying he must have been so relieved....why would he then argue with someone who says j insist on paying

She didn't intend for him to pay for her! How is it gold digging if you've no intention of having him pay for you?

DrSbaitso · 03/08/2023 15:41

Livelifelaughter · 03/08/2023 15:35

Honestly I really can't see how OP is a gold digger or anything thing similar. When I have been on dates and asked where I would like to go to I pick a restaurant that I have been to a few times before and enjoy. It might not be as high end as my date would normally go to or it may be more but it's giving him an idea of my life style. Money is relative £55 per head isn't cheap but she's not taken him to Claridges in the hope he's paying...

No, I can't see how on earth she's a gold digger. She bought dinner! A gold digger would never have expected to pay for herself, nor paid for everything even if there was a moment of misunderstanding.

Iwishmymumwouldbemymum · 03/08/2023 15:40

I'm with you OP, I'd be a little wary. I would go on the third date but I've have my eyes open for tightness as I can't abide it.

The facts are that no you weren't exactly clear but he went ahead with assuming you would pay..

Making assumptions about anybody's financial situation is inappropriate; even if you were wealthy then it's still not his money to spend.

There are three possibilities;

  1. he's a tightarse who leapt at the chance to take advantage (run)
  2. he's very free and easy with money and instead of squabbling over bills he works on the assumption people take turns
  3. he can't stand golddiggers and is subconsciously weeding them out in potential partners as he's naturally very generous in a relationship
  4. (whoops another option) genuinely doesn't know what's expected these days when it comes to paying as he has inadvertently offended women in the past.

4 is good, 3 and 2 alright, no.1 is awful. This is the assessment phase and you should be impressed. Personally I wouldn't be so far so I'd wait and see what happens on date 3.

I wouldn't be paying attention to any of this be clear about your expectations stuff either. The ball is in his court now to make sure he pays.

jannier · 03/08/2023 15:39

DrSbaitso · 03/08/2023 15:08

How can she be a gold digger if she's willing to pay at least for herself?

Because she let him pay first time then booked somewhere really expensive how's he to know she doesn't expect him to pay it all...then he's left in a dilemma of saying I can't afford this or letting it go...once she insisted on paying he must have been so relieved....why would he then argue with someone who says j insist on paying