Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Date got me to pay for expensive dinner - bin?

765 replies

Jonesjonsy · 01/08/2023 15:57

Met a guy online. First date, walk in the countryside near to where he lived. Seemed a really nice guy with great interests and gorgeous dog! Stopped at a cafe and had sandwich lunch about £8 each, no alcohol or anything. Very kindly he offered to pay and I accepted. no kiss or anything like that.

Second date he said he was going to be working near me and would I like to do something. I offered to book a pub dinner near to where he would clock off. Again it went well I thought, but conscious on seeing the prices on the menu I knew I wouldn’t want him to pay for me particularly as he had bought me the sandwich. At the end of the meal when he asked for the bill, I said you paid last time so I don’t want you paying again. He misconstrued this as me saying I would settle the whole thing (what I meant was we just had split it) and I guess I was so flummoxed that this had happened I just paid especially since the waitress was kind of hovering over us… I was embarrassed to talk about it. Bill was £110!

I guess I just wonder if this is a major red flag. I don’t know him well enough to determine and honestly it’s put me off I don’t think I want to meet up again. Yes I can afford it as I’ve worked really hard to build up my own business. I didn’t tell about money at all and am not flashy but I did talk about what I do and maybe he just made a assumption? AIBU?

OP posts:
DrSbaitso · 01/08/2023 19:30

Sirzy · 01/08/2023 19:24

But my response only turned around the genders from what another poster had said. My point was about how you can’t expect different both ways but I guess you do

Ok, since this means a lot to you and I hate for you to think your fantasy scenes prove anything...There would have been nothing wrong with him openly offering to treat OP to somewhere expensive. Equally, there would be nothing wrong with OP offering to do the same for him. It's an offer, freely made. It's fine. It's less fine to agree on an expensive dinner venue, without any agreement that it's all on one person, and then at the end let the other person cover the whole thing when it's a much more expensive meal than the sandwich you shouted. The sexes don't matter. It's gauche, whoever does it. It's almost as gauche as hearing the story, making up a completely different scenario that didn't happen and then deciding this made-up scenario confirms whatever silly prejudice caused you to invent it in the first place.

LakeTiticaca · 01/08/2023 19:29

He obviously misunderstood. You didn't really communicate it very clearly. The most unreasonable part of this post is paying 110 quid for 2 pub meals!!

IamSTARVING · 01/08/2023 19:29

Namechanger1002 · 01/08/2023 19:06

I muse like that too and don't disagree with you.

🤗

DNLove · 01/08/2023 19:27

You really need to work on how you represent yourself. You made out in the OP that you were Richard Branson with your own business. You're a secretary that cleans on the side. All credit to you creating opportunities but maybe you created an image with him that you are moneybags and £110 is a drop in the ocean for you.

DeliciouslyDecadent · 01/08/2023 19:26

I doubt that having a secretarial job and working as a cleaner at weekends means you are loaded.

Has he suggested a 3rd date?

How was it left at the end of the evening?

After your first date, who made contact for the 2nd date?

I'd let this bill issue go and see where it all leads.

It's very early days.

And your title of the post is very inaccurate. The reality is the complete opposite. He asked for the bill. You said he didn't have to pay all of it.
You didn't offer to pay for it all.

So- why did you?

Why didn't you say' Sorry, I mean we can go halves.'

You aren't explaining yourself well in your posts here so goodness knows what you said on the night.

creativeteapot · 01/08/2023 19:24

I think you need to cut him some slack....he might not have reacted quickly enough when he learned about the amount, but it can be a bit of a minefield. If you offer to pay (that was how he heard it) and he doesn't accept, this could easily be a red flag for some women....doesn't treat you as equal, etc. He might have felt as as well that this bill is too much, but was worried how to protest without it coming across the wrong way.

Sirzy · 01/08/2023 19:24

DrSbaitso · 01/08/2023 19:19

What way? The way where you get to have your prejudices confirmed by inventing scenarios that didn't happen?

He didn't offer to take OP out somewhere expensive, so why are you so invested in a fantasy situation where he did? And why does your fantasy prove anything?

It's literally a scene that you made up. Who cares?

But my response only turned around the genders from what another poster had said. My point was about how you can’t expect different both ways but I guess you do

CrazyArmadilloLady · 01/08/2023 19:22

Siouxiesiouxiesioux · 01/08/2023 19:20

He picked the 1st cheap venue - presumably because he might be going on a few dates and sensibly doesn’t want to be splashing out on anyone so soon. OP picked the 2nd more expensive venue. She could have also picked a cheaper place.

No, the OP picked the first venue as well - she has done all the organising.

Jonesjonsy · 01/08/2023 19:21

DeliciouslyDecadent · 01/08/2023 19:19

the bill hadn’t arrived but he had asked for it as he needed to catch his train and I just said something like please don’t pay for the whole thing. I didn’t say I would pay. But I do see why it was confusing possibly.

That's not what you said in your first post.

Why didn't you give the full story then? It's very different to your first post.

i can’t remember the exact wording but I didn’t actually say I would pay for the whole thing. I was trying to ackownledge that he had paid and I didn’t want him to pay for everything again. It was something along those lines but i totally take the hit I was unclear. And should have said something. Totally agree with that!

OP posts:
CrazyArmadilloLady · 01/08/2023 19:21

It did sound like you were offering to pay, but only an idiot would have accepted and let you.

Of course he should have said, ‘this is way more than lunch was, let’s just split it’. Nobody would be offended by that.

What kind of clueless, tight idiot downs three drinks and two courses - on a second date! - and let’s the other person pay for all of it?

I’d be very put off, too.

I’m married to an Irishman though, and they fight over being the person to pay, whether they’re on a date or with friends. Generosity is a far more attractive quality.

ChampagneLassie · 01/08/2023 19:21

This is bonkers. You insisted on paying, how was he supposed to know what you really meant was let’s split it? Further you choose the establishment so presumably were happy with prices. I wouldn’t be put off by this, I’d chock it down as your error. I think you have set precedent that you want to pay your way / take it in turns to pay.

Siouxiesiouxiesioux · 01/08/2023 19:20

trifftrev · 01/08/2023 19:13

Well, you weren't clear with him but only an idiot would not realise they'd consumed a fair few quid's worth of food and drink and not offer to contribute so there is a sense of him taking advantage here. Especially as he'd only treated you to a tenner's worth. Does he think you're loaded? Also, the fact that he leaves the suggestions of where to go to you and doesn't take the initiative would bug me a bit. He really should thank you for your (unintended) generosity and take you out somewhere fairly nice in return.

He picked the 1st cheap venue - presumably because he might be going on a few dates and sensibly doesn’t want to be splashing out on anyone so soon. OP picked the 2nd more expensive venue. She could have also picked a cheaper place.

WombatChocolate · 01/08/2023 19:20

My only thought is that lots of people scupper potential relationships by over-analysing every little detail and talking themselves out of what might turn out to be a good relationship.

Give him the benefit of the doubt and fo on a third date if you enjoyed these other 2. Don’t let the fact that YOU said you’d pay and then did, or an over analysis of chivalry or the fact he had a cocktail, make you’d attribute characteristics or motives to him that might well not exist.

If you like him, give it a chance and go out with him again. If you don’t really like him, don’t bother. Forget about this bill and don’t let it define the way forward.

Dating costs money. If you go for a meal these days, unless you pick a very cheap location, if you have a couple of courses and some booze, you’re easily looking at £40+ per head and often more like £50 or much more. If you’re going to let someone ‘treat’ you, then you may well find yourself ‘treating’ to the tune of more than £100. If you don’t want to spend that kind of money, go for coffees or snack lunches. If you want to keep tighter control of your spending you need to choose the location based on price and are ahead of dates to split the bill. These things are all possible, but mean some potentially slightly awakward conversations ahead of dates. That’s fine and worth it if you don’t want surprise bills. But if you don’t want those upfront conversations because you think it’s not romantic, realise that him paying or not letting you pick up a bigger bill is much more likely. And have a think about why you feel what happened wasn’t right…is it reasonable to feel like that?

Go on a third date if you like him. Ask him to make the plans. All of these early dates are a chance to get to know each other. Sometimes it becomes clear really quickly if you’re in the same wave length or not, but often it can take longer for that to emerge. Hope you have some great dates.

DrSbaitso · 01/08/2023 19:19

Sirzy · 01/08/2023 19:13

So it does only work one way then

What way? The way where you get to have your prejudices confirmed by inventing scenarios that didn't happen?

He didn't offer to take OP out somewhere expensive, so why are you so invested in a fantasy situation where he did? And why does your fantasy prove anything?

It's literally a scene that you made up. Who cares?

DeliciouslyDecadent · 01/08/2023 19:19

the bill hadn’t arrived but he had asked for it as he needed to catch his train and I just said something like please don’t pay for the whole thing. I didn’t say I would pay. But I do see why it was confusing possibly.

That's not what you said in your first post.

Why didn't you give the full story then? It's very different to your first post.

Jonesjonsy · 01/08/2023 19:18

I guess he could think I’m well off - we talked a lot about what we did and I have a secretarial job but on top of that have started a weekend business where I do holiday let cleans at the weekend. It means that I work 2 jobs and the cleaning job is at a higher hourly rate because the people want reliable work and a quick turnaround. I also explained that I did it to try to create more opportunities for myself so it’s possible

OP posts:
SlipSlidinAway · 01/08/2023 19:18

Jonesjonsy · 01/08/2023 18:46

Amazing it has got this many responses! I never thought it would.

One poster said that I was trying to act cutesy and when he didn’t pick me up on offering to pay I’m acting all offended. Do you know I think that is kind of right even though it’s embarrassing to admit - but I guess I was kind of waiting to see if there was a bit of chivalry. When I really analyse it I just feel that to me there feels like a bit of a lack of romance as actually I’ve also had to step in and organise everything rather than him making the effort to. So yes I do think I was unclear and maybe was being a bit outdated with expectations but my gut is that I kind of feel it’s part of romance that a guy steps forward a bit more. And maybe that’s built in to the biology of it… like if a woman has a child she becomes quite dependant by the nature of it, so the fact that a guy isn’t proactive with that aspect might be a red flag on a fundamental level and that all these equality arguments miss that key issue. Probably not being clear again but yes just a bit of food for thought.

I still don’t think I picked an expensive place….!

OMG. Shall I tell my adult sons that if they go on a date with a woman who chooses the venue and tells them they don't want them to pay ... they don't actually mean it?! It's just some sort of weird girlie test to see if they're going to become all manly and ignore the woman's feeble attempts to pay 🙄?

Personally I hate bill splitting. Much prefer taking turns to pay. You drew the short straw this time. You can sit back and expect him to pay next time.

GreekDogRescue · 01/08/2023 19:15

It would worry me that he is leaving the organising of dates to you. It’s tiring having to always be the one who has to make a plan.

trifftrev · 01/08/2023 19:13

Well, you weren't clear with him but only an idiot would not realise they'd consumed a fair few quid's worth of food and drink and not offer to contribute so there is a sense of him taking advantage here. Especially as he'd only treated you to a tenner's worth. Does he think you're loaded? Also, the fact that he leaves the suggestions of where to go to you and doesn't take the initiative would bug me a bit. He really should thank you for your (unintended) generosity and take you out somewhere fairly nice in return.

DeliciouslyDecadent · 01/08/2023 19:13

Hmmm!

There is a difference between an £8 sarnie/ drink and a meal for £55pp.

You communicated badly. Very badly.

He may have thought he'd offend you by offering to contribute (and think you are loaded.)

I guess some men may have said 'Look, that's a hefty bill and I want to pay for something, like the wine (if there was any)'

Presumably he had checked out the venue beforehand and £55 ish was within his budget.

If you eat out next time, I think you need to make it clear from the start that you split the bill.

Sirzy · 01/08/2023 19:13

DrSbaitso · 01/08/2023 19:02

He didn't, so who cares?

So it does only work one way then

Siouxiesiouxiesioux · 01/08/2023 19:12

You offered to pay and I think he had to say yes because a lot of men might be worried you’d think them sexist if they insisted on paying. Give him the benefit of the doubt this time and be much clearer next time. Good luck.

ModestMoon · 01/08/2023 19:09

And maybe that’s built in to the biology of it… like if a woman has a child she becomes quite dependant by the nature of it, so the fact that a guy isn’t proactive with that aspect might be a red flag on a fundamental level and that all these equality arguments miss that key issue.

Speak for yourself! I have a child and still earn way more than my kids dad does. Having a child hasn't made me dependent on a man, and I would be profoundly unimpressed by a second date who tried to suggest that I am dependent on account of my sex.

I think he misunderstood, and thought you were offering. Perhaps he was afraid of offending you. It is too early in the relationship for him to know if you are the type of woman to be offended by having your offer to pay challenged, the type to want a man to pay just because he's a man (eww) or somewhere in between. I do think he should have offered to split it - but maybe he was also caught in the moment and is regretting it. Third date will be the tell.

DrSbaitso · 01/08/2023 19:07

FloydPepper · 01/08/2023 19:04

There’s your answer. It only works one way…

No, the answer was "why is this non-existent situation that didn't happen relevant?"

Do you always go around trying to claim theoretical potential victimhood or is that only one way?

Namechanger1002 · 01/08/2023 19:06

IamSTARVING · 01/08/2023 18:46

I agree with you on that.

Equally - when did it become ok for the other senario.

I sometimes wonder of these things are much more important than they seem? As in - do they indicate in some periferal way a fture behaviour?

Modern guy - split bills 50/50. But society is not 50/50.

Do they expect to earn the smae as women or accept more for the same endeavour? Will his money be 50/50 in maternity? Will he participate 50/50 in child rearing? So on. Badly expressed thoughts but hopefully you can follow my meaning.

Like maybe, these things give a faint whif of the type of partner. Dunno - just musing!

I muse like that too and don't disagree with you.