Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Timmy will be played by a border collie. Wrong. Just so wrong.

157 replies

PretzelKnot · 01/08/2023 09:44

According to Wikipedia, Timmy will be played by a border collie in the new BBC Famous Five adaptation.

This is outrageous. I know some of the 80s editions of the books had Timmy on their cover as a border collie but he’s not. He’s a huge, fearsome, loyal protective mongrel who can hold back a bunch of bad guys in a tunnel allowing the kids to escape. Border collies are lovely and highly intelligent but no border collie could hold back a tunnel full of armed bad guys.

Here is the original description of Timmy-

“They sat up and looked to see what Timothy was like. They saw no
fisher-boy—but instead a big brown mongrel dog with an absurdly long
tail and a big wide mouth that really seemed to grin! He was bounding
all round George, mad with delight. She came running down to them.

‘This is Timothy,’ she said. ‘Don’t you think he is simply perfect?’

As a dog, Timothy was far from perfect. He was the wrong shape, his head
was too big, his ears were too pricked, his tail was too long and it was
quite impossible to say what kind of a dog he was supposed to be. But he
was such a mad, friendly, clumsy, laughable creature that every one of
the children adored him at once.”

Border collies already get a lot of glory in movies and TV shows. Now they are stealing a mongrel’s chance to shine.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 01/08/2023 10:38

Most of the suspense and jeopardy will be completely non-existent now, if instead of hoping beyond hope that Timmy will have found a random passer-by and got the message out to come and rescue them from the cave where they're being held hostage, they can just whip out their phones and wait for the police to speed along to the precise What Three Words address that they've supplied, with regular progress updates all the way.

And then, when the police have rescued them, they will send their parents on a mandatory childcare course for re-education, teaching them not to merrily send their kids off to chase dangerous smugglers or run off and join the circus when they should be doing their online homework nuggets (on devices with proper parental controls).

NeverDropYourMooncup · 01/08/2023 10:38

Saucery · 01/08/2023 09:54

He sounds more like a Bull Lurcher. That would Never Do.

Absolutely.

Anyhow, here's a flag for you all.

Timmy will be played by a border collie. Wrong. Just so wrong.
WeAreBorg · 01/08/2023 10:37

PretzelKnot · 01/08/2023 10:27

Look at this smug Border Collie in Babe. Never having to fight for roles. Always being the first dog on call.

#TeamMongrel

I really want to support you on this one - I would ordinarily always fight for the under’dog’…but
Sorry border collies are just the best dog. I swoon a little every time I see one. Sorry!!

Although surely this TV show is going to be terrible. The whole point is that they are posh white rich kids who hate poor people and are arseholes to all their servants, they have to run with this for the re-make otherwise make a different show

RitzyMcFitzy · 01/08/2023 10:34

Read all the Famous Five books a million times and would have sworn that old Tims was a border collie. I was clearly influenced by the late 70s TV show ( loved the theme tune. What a banger)

As long as all the working class characters that Julian and co patronise are authentically simple minded I won't mind too much that Timmy is being mis-pedigreed. And any Welsh kids must be barefoot and slightly feral. It's only right and proper.

CoachPiggyStardust · 01/08/2023 10:33

I always saw Timmy looking more like this.

Timmy will be played by a border collie. Wrong. Just so wrong.
LaviniasBigBloomers · 01/08/2023 10:32

I am 100% with you and hereby choose this as my hill to die upon. Is there a petition? (Not even joking).

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 01/08/2023 10:30

I still don't get why we need another adaptation, when we have perfectly good ones from the 70s and the 90s - unless there's a deliberate 'motive' to this.

Considering the books were very much of their time in the 40s, I don't see what authentic new info about that period we've learned now that we didn't already know 50 years later.

BBno4 · 01/08/2023 10:29

I thought you meant tiny Tim from A Christmas Carol. I was thinking wow, the BBC are really trying to be different.

Conqueeftador · 01/08/2023 10:29

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 01/08/2023 09:47

I thought he was a Red Setter? The illustrations in the books I had were in sure.

That’s what I remember too.

Theredjellybean · 01/08/2023 10:29

And strangely the pictures show George in clothes that would be sort of styles you can buy now and wearing trainers...the others all dressed in 1950's clothes...it's really jarring

PretzelKnot · 01/08/2023 10:27

homeforme · 01/08/2023 10:19

Border collies already get a lot of glory in movies and TV shows. Now they are stealing a mongrel’s chance to shine.

Good god OP I have read some hilarious stuff on MN but this is going into my top famous 5

Look at this smug Border Collie in Babe. Never having to fight for roles. Always being the first dog on call.

#TeamMongrel

Timmy will be played by a border collie. Wrong. Just so wrong.
OP posts:
HarrietJet · 01/08/2023 10:26

PretzelKnot · 01/08/2023 09:44

According to Wikipedia, Timmy will be played by a border collie in the new BBC Famous Five adaptation.

This is outrageous. I know some of the 80s editions of the books had Timmy on their cover as a border collie but he’s not. He’s a huge, fearsome, loyal protective mongrel who can hold back a bunch of bad guys in a tunnel allowing the kids to escape. Border collies are lovely and highly intelligent but no border collie could hold back a tunnel full of armed bad guys.

Here is the original description of Timmy-

“They sat up and looked to see what Timothy was like. They saw no
fisher-boy—but instead a big brown mongrel dog with an absurdly long
tail and a big wide mouth that really seemed to grin! He was bounding
all round George, mad with delight. She came running down to them.

‘This is Timothy,’ she said. ‘Don’t you think he is simply perfect?’

As a dog, Timothy was far from perfect. He was the wrong shape, his head
was too big, his ears were too pricked, his tail was too long and it was
quite impossible to say what kind of a dog he was supposed to be. But he
was such a mad, friendly, clumsy, laughable creature that every one of
the children adored him at once.”

Border collies already get a lot of glory in movies and TV shows. Now they are stealing a mongrel’s chance to shine.

There was a tv series in the 70's, I've seen a clip somewhere. He was a black and white collie in that, definitely.

Marblessolveeverything · 01/08/2023 10:25

Not sure how well the famous five will do if it set in the 2020s. Though George might be an interesting character. I have really fond memories of this I did offer my children them but they raise a few issues, you know like, neglect of parents, off in boats without life jackets etc - critics!

Theredjellybean · 01/08/2023 10:25

OP you're wrong..the dog playing Timmy is "a bearded collie cross called kip"
The pictures on BBC show a shaggy brown and white slightly collie shaped scruffy looking dog...while I agree Timmy should be brown !!!! Kip is definitely not a traditional black and white or red and white border collie

GasPanic · 01/08/2023 10:25

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 01/08/2023 10:23

It should be modernised IMO.

Timmy should be a pit bull.

The five can sit around smoking weed and when asked to solve a mystery say "do I look bothered" or "whatever".

Dressed like Goldie Looking Chain Grin

Maybe I'm easily pleased, but I'm just relieved that Timmy is going to be played by an actual canine dog and not by a (biological but not identifying) human in a costume.

I was thinking about some sort of robot or drone could be Timmy.

Or maybe ChatGTP. They could feed it clues from the mobiles and it could solve the mystery all by itself while they play video games or watch telly.

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 01/08/2023 10:23

It should be modernised IMO.

Timmy should be a pit bull.

The five can sit around smoking weed and when asked to solve a mystery say "do I look bothered" or "whatever".

Dressed like Goldie Looking Chain Grin

Maybe I'm easily pleased, but I'm just relieved that Timmy is going to be played by an actual canine dog and not by a (biological but not identifying) human in a costume.

Flapjacker48 · 01/08/2023 10:22

Dick = Rick
Fanny = Frannie

Worried1305 · 01/08/2023 10:21

George's mother*
Everybody else's aunt!

Worried1305 · 01/08/2023 10:20

Surely the key question is, will they rename George's aunt (as they did in the 1990s version. I was outraged and my poor mum had to explain why they had done it.)

homeforme · 01/08/2023 10:19

Border collies already get a lot of glory in movies and TV shows. Now they are stealing a mongrel’s chance to shine.

Good god OP I have read some hilarious stuff on MN but this is going into my top famous 5

Flapjacker48 · 01/08/2023 10:17

Other than Timmy and the odd terrier the dogs in Blyton stories are usually cocker spaniels and this was the type of dog she had (after her fox terrier died)

FlameGrilledSquirrel · 01/08/2023 10:16

GasPanic · 01/08/2023 09:57

It should be modernised IMO.

Timmy should be a pit bull.

The five can sit around smoking weed and when asked to solve a mystery say "do I look bothered" or "whatever".

And permanently on their mobile phones.

All on lashings of Crabbies alcoholic ginger beer.

longwayoff · 01/08/2023 10:16

My old and much missed Border Collie could have driven off a gang of robbers, tied them up and delivered them wrapped to the cop shop. Dont under estimate them. If they had thumbs they'd rule the world. My current dog would just shout loudly at them until they shouted back, then he'd run and hide.

tonyhawks23 · 01/08/2023 10:15

I feel like alan partridge when he says your getting bond wrong,reading this I'm 'your getting Enid blyton wrong!'

Scamper was a cocker spaniel.
I always saw Timmy as a border collie but know that's just my visualisation.
I thought the new one has Timmy as a bearded Collie??which is wrong imo but I will still watch it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread