Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Timmy will be played by a border collie. Wrong. Just so wrong.

157 replies

PretzelKnot · 01/08/2023 09:44

According to Wikipedia, Timmy will be played by a border collie in the new BBC Famous Five adaptation.

This is outrageous. I know some of the 80s editions of the books had Timmy on their cover as a border collie but he’s not. He’s a huge, fearsome, loyal protective mongrel who can hold back a bunch of bad guys in a tunnel allowing the kids to escape. Border collies are lovely and highly intelligent but no border collie could hold back a tunnel full of armed bad guys.

Here is the original description of Timmy-

“They sat up and looked to see what Timothy was like. They saw no
fisher-boy—but instead a big brown mongrel dog with an absurdly long
tail and a big wide mouth that really seemed to grin! He was bounding
all round George, mad with delight. She came running down to them.

‘This is Timothy,’ she said. ‘Don’t you think he is simply perfect?’

As a dog, Timothy was far from perfect. He was the wrong shape, his head
was too big, his ears were too pricked, his tail was too long and it was
quite impossible to say what kind of a dog he was supposed to be. But he
was such a mad, friendly, clumsy, laughable creature that every one of
the children adored him at once.”

Border collies already get a lot of glory in movies and TV shows. Now they are stealing a mongrel’s chance to shine.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
PretzelKnot · 01/08/2023 10:59

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 01/08/2023 10:56

Secret Seven’s dog, Scamper, was a golden Cocker Spaniel I’m sure.

How come Timmy was one of the Famous Five, but Scamper was not one of the Secret Seven?

I hated the Secret Seven. The girls always got left behind which never happened in any of the other series.

Timmy was on of the five because he was active muscle. He bit bad guys, bailed up bad guys, stole a ham from bad guys when the kids were hungry. He stood van guard and rear guard.

Scamper didn’t do any of that. He was too small.

OP posts:
CosyKnits · 01/08/2023 10:59

spiderlight · 01/08/2023 10:04

Scamper was definitely a spaniel. He was described as a 'golden spaniel' so probably a cocker, although at a push he might have been a Sussex spaniel or a clumber.

Yes, definitely a spaniel of some kind in the Secret Seven.

I don't understand why we need another Famous Five adaption though, there are loads of more modern "kids solving crime" books they could turn into films/TV instead (Anisha, Accidental Detective by Serena Patel and the Mystery series by Helen Moss are favourites in our house)

HarrietJet · 01/08/2023 10:59

YesItsMeIDontCare · 01/08/2023 10:55

Found him! I'd say he's brown...

That's not from the original series. He was a black and white collie.

Flapjacker48 · 01/08/2023 10:58

@RitzyMcFitzy First four were good - the series was supposed to enid with "Rubadub" (i.e Barney finds his father) but publisher (and children) pressure ensured to much poorer books after (Rat-a-tat and Ragamuffin).

Many of the later book in the series are not as good (Famous five, Find-outers etc)

RitzyMcFitzy · 01/08/2023 10:58

YesItsMeIDontCare · 01/08/2023 10:55

Found him! I'd say he's brown...

He is bee-yooooooo-tiful 😍😍😍

RitzyMcFitzy · 01/08/2023 10:57

I was always a bit sus of the kids in the Fatty books and the Secret Seven. Most of them just attended a day school and I felt this meant they weren't quite top drawer.

(I of course was very much not top drawer myself)

Summerrainstorminagain · 01/08/2023 10:56

YesItsMeIDontCare · 01/08/2023 10:55

Found him! I'd say he's brown...

He's not what i think of as a border collie (even though he clearly is) and not what most would think of as one either! He's a beautiful dog!

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 01/08/2023 10:56

Has Julian escaped from Mumford & Sons?

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 01/08/2023 10:56

Secret Seven’s dog, Scamper, was a golden Cocker Spaniel I’m sure.

How come Timmy was one of the Famous Five, but Scamper was not one of the Secret Seven?

YesItsMeIDontCare · 01/08/2023 10:55

Found him! I'd say he's brown...

Timmy will be played by a border collie. Wrong. Just so wrong.
RitzyMcFitzy · 01/08/2023 10:54

The Barney mysteries were my absolute fave

Flapjacker48 · 01/08/2023 10:53

@siucra Nope, the dog (beloing to Fatty) in the "Mystery" series was a Scottish Terrier.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 01/08/2023 10:53

CoachPiggyStardust · 01/08/2023 10:33

I always saw Timmy looking more like this.

Same, actually. Which does correspond to some of the book (or audio books?🤔) covers we had, IIRC.

TheInterceptor · 01/08/2023 10:52

If they can race-swap the children they can certainly breed-swap old Tim.

Starlitexpress · 01/08/2023 10:51

Border collie in the 1970s adaption, I remember as I had my picture taken with him!

PretzelKnot · 01/08/2023 10:50

siucra · 01/08/2023 10:48

I think the dog in the Five Find-Outers - with Fatty, the detective - was a spaniel.

Loony was a black spaniel in the Mystery series.

OP posts:
YesItsMeIDontCare · 01/08/2023 10:50

He played by Kip, a bearded collie.

siucra · 01/08/2023 10:48

KimberleyClark · 01/08/2023 09:52

Secret Seven’s dog, Scamper, was a golden Cocker Spaniel I’m sure.

I think the dog in the Five Find-Outers - with Fatty, the detective - was a spaniel.

PretzelKnot · 01/08/2023 10:48

WeAreBorg · 01/08/2023 10:37

I really want to support you on this one - I would ordinarily always fight for the under’dog’…but
Sorry border collies are just the best dog. I swoon a little every time I see one. Sorry!!

Although surely this TV show is going to be terrible. The whole point is that they are posh white rich kids who hate poor people and are arseholes to all their servants, they have to run with this for the re-make otherwise make a different show

Yes they were posh rich white kids but they were never mean to servants.

They absolutely loved their live in cook and were devastated when she got quarantined with scarlet fever. The only servants they were mean to were the nasty ones who were actually thieves and kidnappears in disguise who took over Kirrin Cottage when Mrs Kirrin was in hospital and locked a kidnapped girl in the dark dungeons of Kirrin Castle. Dastardly.

They did however have a painfully naive “pull yourself up by your bootstraps” view of poorer people. Case in point- Jo the gypsy girl (think it was Jo- many Blyton series had an ubiquitous gypsy girl) trying to explain that they would steal if they were really hungry and the kids being shocked and saying they absolutely would not.

And I must disagree about border collies being the best dogs. Labradors are the best. However, I wouldn’t accept a lab playing Timmy either because just like border collies, they are not fearsome.

OP posts:
BrandonFlowersTurkeyTeeth · 01/08/2023 10:47

I always thought he was a border collie ?!

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 01/08/2023 10:46

Who the hell was Wentworth in the books???

I read that and I similarly have no idea at all.

To me, it's like when they advertise an 'all-star' version of a TV gameshow that I excitedly tune in for (sadsack, me), and it turns out that the 'celebs' are all off Love Island.

Summerrainstorminagain · 01/08/2023 10:45

It's being discussed as a "progressive" adaptation so I assume it's off the back of the rewrites. In which case Timmy could actually be a horse.

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 01/08/2023 10:43

I was clearly influenced by the late 70s TV show ( loved the theme tune. What a banger)

I was unreasonably gutted and felt betrayed when I discovered that it was sung by a children's choir and not by the Five (well, four of them, I guess) themselves.

The whole point is that they are posh white rich kids who hate poor people and are arseholes to all their servants

Come, come, now - they don't hate poor people, Gypsies and non-white folk: they just don't get what they are for. At least the ones getting jobs as their servants helpfully make it easy for them to grasp their purpose!

Housenoob · 01/08/2023 10:41

Just reading about the new adaptation and the cast. Jack Gleeson as Wentworth.

Who the hell was Wentworth in the books???