Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Costa using Pride image of girl with breasts removed to support trans?

314 replies

Tryingmuchharder · 01/08/2023 09:17

"Costa Coffee was today accused of glamourising 'complex and dangerous surgery' by covering a van with a cartoon image featuring mastectomy scars.
The UK's largest coffee chain defended its use of the image to promote 'inclusivity and diversity' but was branded 'crass and irresponsible' and 'absolutely bonkers' – and there were calls for a boycott of the company on social media.
The image, depicting an androgynous-looking character wearing long shorts with scars below each nipple, is taken from a mural designed by the chain for Brighton and Hove Pride last year."

I find the attempt to 'normalise' the removal of perfectly healthy breasts because someone feels more masculine is wrong. AIBU

OP posts:
Thread gallery
16
Whatwouldscullydo · 01/08/2023 11:04

Tryingmuchharder · 01/08/2023 11:01

"And big brands like Costa fetishise their scars in a way that never lets them escape their essential femaleness. They are shouting out loud the part that's supposed to remain unspoken, and which is absolutely verboten to say about MtF transitioners. People can tell."

There are calls for SIMS a series of games aimed mainly at young people to include characters with surgery scars to show support and inclusivity to children who feel they are in the wrong body. It feels like a push to normalise surgery towards children. Surgery being promoted at the answer and normal and easy, it's anything but on all these counts. It's not the answer - you cannot change sex, it's not normal, and it's not easy.

Adults want the right to do nothing to themselves and be considered whatever they say they are whilst simultaneously pushing for kids to have access to all medical aspects of transition they themselves never wanted or had. Why?

Who benefits from a cohort of young people above the age of consent with the bodies of pre pubescent children ?

Tryingmuchharder · 01/08/2023 11:01

"And big brands like Costa fetishise their scars in a way that never lets them escape their essential femaleness. They are shouting out loud the part that's supposed to remain unspoken, and which is absolutely verboten to say about MtF transitioners. People can tell."

There are calls for SIMS a series of games aimed mainly at young people to include characters with surgery scars to show support and inclusivity to children who feel they are in the wrong body. It feels like a push to normalise surgery towards children. Surgery being promoted at the answer and normal and easy, it's anything but on all these counts. It's not the answer - you cannot change sex, it's not normal, and it's not easy.

OP posts:
Janiie · 01/08/2023 10:56

nonmerci99 · 01/08/2023 10:13

Appalling. Fortunately Costa Coffee is utter dross, so very easy to continue to avoid.

Indeed.

How dare they display such offensive imagery.

WinterTrees · 01/08/2023 10:53

I read the other day that female trans people are still discriminated against in the way they are presented in public. As women their breasts are used for the public gaze in advertising. As 'men' their breasts are used for public gaze in advertising.

I'm trying to clarify my thoughts around this too. Gender distressed girls and young women put themselves through this brutal, mutilating surgery in the vain hope of being perceived as masculine and read as men by a society in which women are always lesser. And big brands like Costa fetishise their scars in a way that never lets them escape their essential femaleness. They are shouting out loud the part that's supposed to remain unspoken, and which is absolutely verboten to say about MtF transitioners. People can tell.

SunnyEgg · 01/08/2023 10:50

Tryingmuchharder · 01/08/2023 10:46

Normalising mutilating surgery at such a young age.

One day society will look back at the damage caused. Hopefully you won't be a parent of a child grown into an adult that regrets the mutilating and messing with puberty that was assumed to be the answer without studies to show it actually helps.

Agree with what we are normalising. It’s so so bad

Tryingmuchharder · 01/08/2023 10:49

MumOfYoungTransAdult · 01/08/2023 10:46

And you'd want him to have the best professional advice as well? And not get suckered by adverts for other products which normalise penis removal as a cool thing to do?

Which is what this is thread about. Advertising is not direct force but it applies social pressure and not only for the product directly being sold (coffee in this case)

There are restrictions on advertising for cosmetic surgery, and that's for good reasons. These restrictions should apply to cosmetic surgery for transition too, and I think (though I'm not sure) they could apply to the promotion of cosmetic surgery in an advert for another product.

It's possible (and easy!) to complain to the ASA Even if there aren't immediate grounds to get the advert stopped they do count complaints to know about issues that concern people.

Thank you for saying this so much better than I could.

The gradual drip drip in society, coffee shops, schools, Penguin books, showing that mutilating surgery is normal and 'cool' as the Penguin book says. Drip, drip, drip, it's normal kids to physically mutilate your body, it's normal to take puberty blockers...drip drip drip.

OP posts:
Tryingmuchharder · 01/08/2023 10:46

ResisterRex · 01/08/2023 10:43

Normalising mutilating surgery at such a young age.

One day society will look back at the damage caused. Hopefully you won't be a parent of a child grown into an adult that regrets the mutilating and messing with puberty that was assumed to be the answer without studies to show it actually helps.

OP posts:
Whatwouldscullydo · 01/08/2023 10:46

applesandmares · 01/08/2023 10:27

OP do you believe that no one should ever be able to access gender reassignment surgeries, or that children should be protected from it? One I find a very reasonable stance, one not so much!

What benefits are there actually for adults though?

Open wounds that smell like colon. Tied to a dilation schedule that seems pretty incompatible with work/life certainly at first anyway. Disabilities, incontinence, loss of sexual function, inability to breast feed. All to achieve the impossible? The failure rates of phalloplasty are atrocious. Is this really something that should be done to perfectly healthy functioning bodies.if so why? What benefit is there?

MumOfYoungTransAdult · 01/08/2023 10:46

Beezknees · 01/08/2023 10:27

I don't have daughters but I can only do what's best to guide my DS. He's 15 so he's in the thick of all this debate. If he decides as an adult he wanted to chop off his penis then it's up to him. Obviously I'd advise him against it but I can't force him to do anything.

And you'd want him to have the best professional advice as well? And not get suckered by adverts for other products which normalise penis removal as a cool thing to do?

Which is what this is thread about. Advertising is not direct force but it applies social pressure and not only for the product directly being sold (coffee in this case)

There are restrictions on advertising for cosmetic surgery, and that's for good reasons. These restrictions should apply to cosmetic surgery for transition too, and I think (though I'm not sure) they could apply to the promotion of cosmetic surgery in an advert for another product.

It's possible (and easy!) to complain to the ASA Even if there aren't immediate grounds to get the advert stopped they do count complaints to know about issues that concern people.

Tryingmuchharder · 01/08/2023 10:44

[The Aggressive Research Intelligence Facility], which conducts reviews of health care treatments for the [National Health Service], concludes that none of the studies provides conclusive evidence that gender reassignment is beneficial for patients. It found that most research was poorly designed, which skewed the results in favor of physically changing sex. There was no evaluation of whether other treatments, such as long-term counseling, might help transsexuals, or whether their gender confusion might lessen over time.

Society is failing young girls

OP posts:
ResisterRex · 01/08/2023 10:43

Even Penguin Kids' books are at it:

twitter.com/penguinkids/status/1662051005356462081?s=46&t=WHoOZ_3Kv5G6-FyQuvE0LQ

Tryingmuchharder · 01/08/2023 10:42

viques · 01/08/2023 10:40

Pleased to see the good doctor is admitting that this is a mental health issue, not just confused , often autistic anxious teens misled by social media and pressure from people who should know better.

I wonder if Dr Webberley has considered if giving anorexic teens a gastric band would help another “debilitating mental health issue that sadly takes so many lives”. After all, didn’t doctors used to prescribe lobotomy as a cure for mental health issues like depression and schizophrenia, and hysterectomies for women suffering from anxiety and PND, I suppose she could argue she is simply continuing this medical tradition of using surgery to sort out mental illness. Radical stuff Dr W, though personally I wouldn’t trust you to lance a boil.

When you say it like that. Ouch. Surgery to try to resolve mental health issues

OP posts:
Helleofabore · 01/08/2023 10:42

The euphemisms 'top surgery' and 'bottom surgery' hide the very seriousness of all these procedures and normalises them.

viques · 01/08/2023 10:40

ArabeIIaScott · 01/08/2023 09:46

https://twitter.com/HelenWebberley/status/1686087509858467840

'Everyone shouting #BoycottCostaCoffee because it “promotes the mutilation of teenage girls” have completely missed the point. Top surgery is a completely routine and normal procedure that helps reduce gender dysphoria in trans men - a debilitating mental health issue that sadly takes so many lives every year. Top surgery doesn’t harm people - it saves lives.'

Pleased to see the good doctor is admitting that this is a mental health issue, not just confused , often autistic anxious teens misled by social media and pressure from people who should know better.

I wonder if Dr Webberley has considered if giving anorexic teens a gastric band would help another “debilitating mental health issue that sadly takes so many lives”. After all, didn’t doctors used to prescribe lobotomy as a cure for mental health issues like depression and schizophrenia, and hysterectomies for women suffering from anxiety and PND, I suppose she could argue she is simply continuing this medical tradition of using surgery to sort out mental illness. Radical stuff Dr W, though personally I wouldn’t trust you to lance a boil.

Tryingmuchharder · 01/08/2023 10:40

FOJN · 01/08/2023 10:33

Informed consent is almost impossible for this kind of surgery because there is a dearth of longitudinal studies, particularly since, in the last decade, we have seen a radically different cohort presenting at gender clinics.

If adult women want to have their breasts removed for purely cosmetic purposes I could understand a bodily autonomy argument for that being allowed but when you are promising this surgery as a solution to mental and emotional problems when there is no evidence to support it then no, it should not be allowed.

Children should be protected from it. The studies show that more and more detransitioners say they made a mistake. Their stories are horrific. They believed a lie that their problems would be solved if they 'changed sex' no-one can actually change sex, it's a lie. Anyone can live as they want and if they wish to assume a different gender that's up to them. Suicides in adults sold the lie are high.

I've watched videos of girls sobbing because they thought becoming a 'man' would solve their problems, it doesn't and then they become a fake man because they can never really be a biological man or a man become a biological woman. The videos in their words show the damage, it's horrific and irreversible.

OP posts:
applesandmares · 01/08/2023 10:40

@FOJN adults mutilate their bodies by choice all the time through the route of plastic surgery. Women have been mutilating their breasts for decades but it wasn't a problem when they were getting bigger!

I don't think anyone under the age of 18 should be accessing anything that causes a permanent change to them unless it's medically necessary but it becomes more difficult for me to reason with once they are an adult.

LadyMary50 · 01/08/2023 10:38

LadyMary50 · 01/08/2023 10:33

Arrrg I was in a rage at reading about Costa and completely misinterpreted her post.Apologies I need more (not Costa)coffee..

I should have said this was in reply to Davros🤦‍♀️

FOJN · 01/08/2023 10:33

applesandmares · 01/08/2023 10:27

OP do you believe that no one should ever be able to access gender reassignment surgeries, or that children should be protected from it? One I find a very reasonable stance, one not so much!

Informed consent is almost impossible for this kind of surgery because there is a dearth of longitudinal studies, particularly since, in the last decade, we have seen a radically different cohort presenting at gender clinics.

If adult women want to have their breasts removed for purely cosmetic purposes I could understand a bodily autonomy argument for that being allowed but when you are promising this surgery as a solution to mental and emotional problems when there is no evidence to support it then no, it should not be allowed.

LadyMary50 · 01/08/2023 10:33

Arrrg I was in a rage at reading about Costa and completely misinterpreted her post.Apologies I need more (not Costa)coffee..

Tryingmuchharder · 01/08/2023 10:32

Helleofabore · 01/08/2023 10:27

Quite right LadyMary50. Helen Webberley, a doctor who specialises in gender dysphoria diagnosis SHOULD have those stats to hand. We know Webberley does not have those.

She should have the stats available to share. Apparently she is saving lives. Show the stats then.

Where are all the dead young girls who felt they were in the wrong body from before when doctors didn't offer puberty blockers or mutilating surgery?

There are stats to show that The most thorough follow-up of sex-reassigned people—extending over 30 years and conducted in Sweden, where the culture is strongly supportive of the transgendered—documents their lifelong mental unrest. Ten to 15 years after surgical reassignment, the suicide rate of those who had undergone sex-reassignment surgery rose to 20 times that of comparable peers.

OP posts:
Helleofabore · 01/08/2023 10:32

Hankunamatata · 01/08/2023 09:54

If trans men want to remove their breasts then it up to them. I do think totally inappropriate for costa to use the image, surely a trans person's journey is private?

I read the other day that female trans people are still discriminated against in the way they are presented in public. As women their breasts are used for the public gaze in advertising. As 'men' their breasts are used for public gaze in advertising.

gingerguineapig · 01/08/2023 10:32

Toadsnotfrogs · 01/08/2023 09:19

I think there is a cohort of marketeers who live in an echo chamber where no one ever says “erm hang on a minute…”

Yes. I often think this - not just in relation to this issue but eg the M&S thing where they gave away plastic toys or when Heinz decided that the recyclable tin was no longer suitable by itself for baked beans so they put them in a plastic tub as well.

Gateappreciation · 01/08/2023 10:30

What about women who have had breast cancer surgery? Not much empathy for them!

CriticalCondition · 01/08/2023 10:29

There's a petition. I won't put a link because MNHQ will delete it but it's findable if you search Costa scars petition.

Beezknees · 01/08/2023 10:28

Whatwouldscullydo · 01/08/2023 10:26

Would that also include 18+ adults who had their mental development stunted by puberty blockingcancer drugs medication who have been told for years that they need this to stay alive and everyone who lives them and wants them to keep their body healthy and whole is the enemy? Amd who have sadly reached the point of no return due to whats been done to them as children? A penis won't grow for example of puberty is blocked. Are they still capable of making these decisions?

I don't agree with puberty blocking medication.