Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Costa using Pride image of girl with breasts removed to support trans?

314 replies

Tryingmuchharder · 01/08/2023 09:17

"Costa Coffee was today accused of glamourising 'complex and dangerous surgery' by covering a van with a cartoon image featuring mastectomy scars.
The UK's largest coffee chain defended its use of the image to promote 'inclusivity and diversity' but was branded 'crass and irresponsible' and 'absolutely bonkers' – and there were calls for a boycott of the company on social media.
The image, depicting an androgynous-looking character wearing long shorts with scars below each nipple, is taken from a mural designed by the chain for Brighton and Hove Pride last year."

I find the attempt to 'normalise' the removal of perfectly healthy breasts because someone feels more masculine is wrong. AIBU

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
16
SunnyEgg · 04/08/2023 12:40

Blatantlyfemale · 04/08/2023 12:38

I disagree with this. People should not legally be able to harm themselves. I disagree with any ultra free market position that says they should.

Maybe that’s where medical ethics should step in. We also don’t allow various things that are possible due to advances in medical science

Blatantlyfemale · 04/08/2023 12:38

captainmarvella · 03/08/2023 14:48

To be clear, I don't think kids under 18 should have any lasting surgeries, whether it is enhancing or cutting off any organs. But after they become a legal adult, say, early twenties, it's their wish. Their body, their agency.

I disagree with this. People should not legally be able to harm themselves. I disagree with any ultra free market position that says they should.

MumOfYoungTransAdult · 04/08/2023 12:37

You should pay privately if you want to unnecessarily m yourself.*

Sadly that's only too easy. And it's not just a private individual decision because the NHS picks up the pieces.

Normalising self-harm is a really REALLY bad idea. It's like "heroin chic" over again only no-one claimed that using images of skeletal bodies and scarred arms for publicity was being "inclusive".

Blatantlyfemale · 04/08/2023 12:33

FrancescaContini · 02/08/2023 13:01

This is absolutely disgraceful. Shame on Dr Zoe Williams for including BREAST BINDERS in a book she claims is “empowering” for girls aged 9+ 😡

I genuinely never realised what an absence of feminist analysis there is in our society until this movement came along.

Also I’m thinking that maybe there’s a good dollop of racist Western superiority going on here. Y’know, so followers of gender ideology think breast binding is not like breast ironing, or foot binding or anything like that because, y’know, we’re the West. Breast binding and aesthetic breast removal can’t possibly be the modern Western iteration of these misogynistic mutilations of women’s bodies. Because we are the West and too clever and progressive to fall for that!

dcbc1234 · 04/08/2023 12:15

captainmarvella · 03/08/2023 14:48

To be clear, I don't think kids under 18 should have any lasting surgeries, whether it is enhancing or cutting off any organs. But after they become a legal adult, say, early twenties, it's their wish. Their body, their agency.

Interesting you think early 20s is better but the current reality is the NHS does this stuff from 18 maybe even 17 plus. 21 used to be the age of coming of age but that was reduced to 18 at a time when there was no such thing as trans gender woo.
So rather than say 25 is ridiculous, it should be open for debate. The older someone is, the less chance of regret later. NHS should not fund it either way. You should pay privately if you want to unnecessarily m* yourself.

SunnyEgg · 04/08/2023 08:49

CaroleSinger · 04/08/2023 08:39

Does society think it's normal though? Surely the only ones who think that are the people themselves who are having it done?

A marketing initiative by a household coffee shop brand is about as accepted as things get

Well one way to do it. Another is children’s books, see Penguin example

Adults are failing children by normalising removal of body parts for gender ideology

CaroleSinger · 04/08/2023 08:39

Tryingmuchharder · 01/08/2023 09:22

I know it's crazy. What sort of society thinks it's ok to chop off girls breasts because they are struggling with their mental health?

Does society think it's normal though? Surely the only ones who think that are the people themselves who are having it done?

battymaggot · 04/08/2023 08:34

Oxfam included an image of a similarly mutilated female in its infamous pride (JKR) cartoon. Like Costa, Oxfam has history when it comes to misogyny. Remember how it's workers abused women and girls in Chad and Haiti. Costa thought that breastfeeding should be confined to the WC.
What will their PR geniuses dream up next?
Are they both in thrall to incels?

Florissante · 04/08/2023 07:20

jcyclops · 03/08/2023 23:52

Are they mastectomy scars though?
When I first saw the Costa cartoon, I thought the artist was copying the style of Pablo Picasso, so one "scar" is actually a nose, and the other is a big toe.

That's quite a stretch.

And one that failed to reach its grasp.

Costa is very obviously celebrating, in the name of inclusivity and diversity, a transman who has had a double mastectomy.

jcyclops · 03/08/2023 23:52

Are they mastectomy scars though?
When I first saw the Costa cartoon, I thought the artist was copying the style of Pablo Picasso, so one "scar" is actually a nose, and the other is a big toe.

Costa using Pride image of girl with breasts removed to support trans?
twelly · 03/08/2023 22:21

captainmarvella · 03/08/2023 14:45

I was not going to comment because there is no point doing that in a (mostly) transph0bic thread, but this is just laughable. The 'Under 25 brains are not developed,' bull. "Young people" are allowed to procreate, vote, enlist in wars. Young people of 25 years old or under are heading businesses, performing surgeries, treating patients. But when it comes to certain polarising topics, suddenly they are "too immature" to take such decisions 😒

I find the notion of a late teenager or young adult with undeveloped brains being responsible for a tiny human being MORE terrifying than anything else. If we are going to use this 'undeveloped brains' argument, surely it should be about how teen parents should not be allowed sole care of their kids? Which would not go so well, now, would it, in a site called Mumsnet.

The allegation that posts and this thread is "phobic" is rather lazy - I would suggest that posts are stating facts and that perhaps the country view is "factphobic"

YouSetTheTone · 03/08/2023 21:06

If women think they don’t fit into the pink box for girls/ women it’s the ‘cage’ (society and gender stereotypes) that’s the problem, NOT the girl/ woman. You don’t need to cut bits off yourself because you’re the kind of girl who likes ‘boyish’ things or who feels uncomfortable with her developing body.
Going through puberty RESOLVES these issues in 90% of cases.

YouSetTheTone · 03/08/2023 21:02

It doesn’t seem relevant to me to compare teen parenting with irreversible radical cosmetic surgery, made at a time before the body and brain have stopped developing and maturing.

There have been many studies establishing the fact that the human brain fully matures at 25.

That isn’t to say that people under 25 can’t make decisions or function as sentient beings with autonomy but it does suggest that making decisions that potentially render one sterile, unable to have orgasms, with stunted emotional and physical development, and involve removing healthy body parts should not be made lightly, or indeed glamorised in cartoonish pictures in advertising material for major coffee chains.

If it’s ‘transphobic’ of me to think there should be rigorous safeguarding around significant irreversible medical decisions being made by minors then so be it.

Tryingmuchharder · 03/08/2023 17:09

captainmarvella · 03/08/2023 14:48

To be clear, I don't think kids under 18 should have any lasting surgeries, whether it is enhancing or cutting off any organs. But after they become a legal adult, say, early twenties, it's their wish. Their body, their agency.

It's not about transgender per se, it's about encouraging and promoting the chopping off of body bits as perfectly normal, it isn't. When someone is an adult and if they wish to modify their body in various ways so be it. However, the creeping normalisation of 'you feel a bit different then you are in the wrong body so change to another gender and take puberty blockers, chop bits off etc' bullshite fed to vulnerable young people convincing them by doing so all will be fine and dandy and all theirs worries, concerns and feeling 'odd/different' will just dissipate is BS. The books for very young children, the images of mutilated bodies, the sing song way that it's portrayed 'do this and makes your dreams come true crap.....

The reality and evidence is different. Longer term studies have shown increase in suicide in people that have gone down the trans route compared to peers - evidence shown earlier in thread. Also the growing numbers of young people who realise they were sold a lie and now regretting the decision and wanting to detransition. So caution and stop making it all hearts and easy fluffy to do this and normalising it.

Roll back 20 years and this wasn't normal..... there wasn't mass suicides of youngsters who felt odd in their bodies and didn't fit in, it feels and acts like a social contagion. It is particularly common now to see in young girls on the spectrum who are vulnerable, don't want to become young women and feel this is a way to avoid or escape the natural progression of their bodies! Society bullshite on what is a woman (pink and fluffy) and what is a man (tough and blue) doesn't help since most of us probably don't fit that out of date gender stereotypical rubbish anyway.

OP posts:
Tryingmuchharder · 03/08/2023 17:00

ResisterRex · 03/08/2023 15:17

The 'Under 25 brains are not developed,' bull.

Allow me to introduce to you, the Scottish sentencing guidelines in which a special case is made for - um - the under 25s:

www.scottishsentencingcouncil.org.uk/media/2171/sentencing-young-people-guideline-for-publication.pdf

Note that when it comes to crime, we are told:

"The character of a young person is not as fixed as the character of an older person"

As per the guidelines. But when it's minors and irreversible surgery, it's "empowering", "they know who they are", "listen to trans kids" etc etc.

Thanks, that was the point I was making when I made the original comment. It appears sometimes under 25's brains are deemed developed (making decisions about being in wrong body, surgery, puberty blockers etc) and sometimes not (responsibility for crime etc as per your eg). Cannot have it both ways surely?

OP posts:
MumOfYoungTransAdult · 03/08/2023 15:40

And of course, context matters. If an artist makes a mural for Pride then they might put some dark or morally ambiguous images in it. Even in a mural celebrating gay or trans lives not every image will necessarily be simply positive and aspirational, images can show a darker or sadder side too, like mastectomy scars. But if that part of the mural is used to advertise another product or service then the artistic context is lost and the image becomes simply aspirational.

Costa chose the wrong bit of the mural. Unless they really do want to normalise and promote mastectomy for the physically healthy?

MumOfYoungTransAdult · 03/08/2023 15:24

after they become a legal adult, say, early twenties, it's their wish. Their body, their agency.

It is indeed. That doesn't mean we get to shrug off our own responsibility if we make false promises and promote risky medical interventions. Which that image does.

Debini · 03/08/2023 15:24

There are lots of bad reviews on their Facebook page about this. Surprised they haven’t removed them.

ResisterRex · 03/08/2023 15:17

The 'Under 25 brains are not developed,' bull.

Allow me to introduce to you, the Scottish sentencing guidelines in which a special case is made for - um - the under 25s:

www.scottishsentencingcouncil.org.uk/media/2171/sentencing-young-people-guideline-for-publication.pdf

Note that when it comes to crime, we are told:

"The character of a young person is not as fixed as the character of an older person"

As per the guidelines. But when it's minors and irreversible surgery, it's "empowering", "they know who they are", "listen to trans kids" etc etc.

Riverlee · 03/08/2023 15:03

@captainmarvella This isn’t a transphobic thread. However, it’s commenting on the in-appropriateness of a trans person showing mastectomy scars on an advert.

captainmarvella · 03/08/2023 14:48

To be clear, I don't think kids under 18 should have any lasting surgeries, whether it is enhancing or cutting off any organs. But after they become a legal adult, say, early twenties, it's their wish. Their body, their agency.

captainmarvella · 03/08/2023 14:45

Tryingmuchharder · 01/08/2023 10:07

Young people's brains are not fully developed until around 25 years old so imagine making such decisions that are irreversible so young.

I was not going to comment because there is no point doing that in a (mostly) transph0bic thread, but this is just laughable. The 'Under 25 brains are not developed,' bull. "Young people" are allowed to procreate, vote, enlist in wars. Young people of 25 years old or under are heading businesses, performing surgeries, treating patients. But when it comes to certain polarising topics, suddenly they are "too immature" to take such decisions 😒

I find the notion of a late teenager or young adult with undeveloped brains being responsible for a tiny human being MORE terrifying than anything else. If we are going to use this 'undeveloped brains' argument, surely it should be about how teen parents should not be allowed sole care of their kids? Which would not go so well, now, would it, in a site called Mumsnet.

Helleofabore · 03/08/2023 14:11

I wonder if this article is useful in explaining how some of the double mastectomy surgeons promote their services. Glamourising these surgeries is not restricted to coffee products, even the surgeons glamourise them.

I am cognisant of those who have suffered with seeing depictions of these images so I am putting a warning here. I hope that I have removed the preview picture.

*WARNING: photographs of double mastectomies in this article

https://www.jamesesses.com/p/the-butcher-of-louth

Gateappreciation · 03/08/2023 10:26

Thought I’d look up the latest regarding this situation, and came across this Costa response.

”In a statement, Costa Coffee told ITV News: "At Costa Coffee we celebrate the diversity of our customers, team members and partners.
"We want everyone that interacts with us to experience the inclusive environment that we create, to encourage people to feel welcomed, free and unashamedly proud to be themselves. The mural, in its entirety, showcases and celebrates inclusivity."

So they celebrate inclusivity, but there’s no apology that they have offended women, etc.

i plan to meet up with a friend tomorrow. costa in next was always our meeting place. I suggested the nearby M and S cafe instead!

lifeturnsonadime · 03/08/2023 10:26

How has society been so brainwashed to see this in any way as a positive thing?

It's absolutely disgusting. My daughter is autistic and so many of her peers are going for the boys names and their mothers are ordering breast binders.

It makes me want to scream.

But any kickback against this is met with cries of bigotry. There are swathes of people who don't care if girls, especially autistic girls end up removing their breasts and more.

Someone upthread said Eugenics and whilst that sounds like a conspiracy theory I'm beginning to wonder.

What happened to make this acceptable and normal? Was it covid when people were on the internet more? I can understand children being groomed but their parents have been groomed too. I think that they have lost their minds.